The purchase of gold and investment in bullion is not FCA regulated nor do they benefit from the protections of the Financial Services Compensation Scheme or the Financial Ombudsman Service. The value of your investment can go down as well as up. Consider the risks involved before choosing to invest. This card is issued by Transact Payments Limited pursuant to licence by Mastercard International Incorporated
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Following Keir Starmer's resignation as leader of the Labour Party, this discussion explores the constitutional argument that a change in Prime Minister should trigger a general election. The speakers argue that modern mandates are personal rather than just party-based, suggesting that an unelected successor lacks the democratic authority to govern.
Well, welcome back to State of the Nation and let's have a look, a reminder of what
Starmer had to say earlier on today.
The question my party is asking now is whether I am best placed to lead us into the next
general election. I have heard the answer of my parliamentary party to that question.
That is why I will resign as leader of the Labour Party. I have spoken to His Majesty
the King this morning to inform him of my decision.
Well, Sir Keir Starmer spoke to the King and whoever becomes Prime Minister will be appointed
by the King. But it seems to me a change of Prime Minister needs a new election. The mandate
is personal. We may not strictly have a presidential system, but nonetheless people vote for a
leader and a party, not thinking of who the individual MP is. And I've been saying this
for a long time. This isn't just a convenient soundbite for today. Listen to this.
There's one way that it was beginning to evolve that the electorate seemed to want. And that
was that if a Prime Minister resigned partway through a parliament, that should lead to
a general election. When I knocked on doors in North East Somerset, people didn't say
to me that they wanted fixed term parliaments or AV or any of that. They asked who had elected
him to be Prime Minister. And although the constitution is clear that we can change Prime
Minister as often as Her Majesty sees fit, the mood of the country is for that constitutional
evolution. The mood of the country is for that constitutional evolution. And one Andrew
Burnham used to believe exactly the same thing. He regularly called for general elections.
You can see his tweets on the page saying in 2022 we needed a general election. We'll
see if he sticks to that. But only yesterday, a Labour MP, a serving minister, tweeted the
same. So this isn't a marginal view. This is a view that is gaining currency, not as
a matter of political opportunism, but as a constitutional evolution. Now, people will
say that we have a parliamentary system and the Prime Minister needs to command a majority
in the House of Commons. But bear in mind that in itself is a constitutional evolution,
that the role of Prime Minister is one that is not defined in statute, is not defined
in any foundational constitutional document. It has come from what happened in the reign
of George I, when the title of Prime Minister was used as a term of abuse against Robert
Walpole. I mean, you may think it is a term of abuse once again, because our Prime Minister
has been so hopeless, but that's not the main intention. And from that term of abuse, it
became a regular position. But the powers of the Prime Minister have evolved. In the
18th century, the Cabinet was not appointed by the Prime Minister, but by the King. There
was no concept of collective responsibility until about the 1830s. Our system of government
is not some written document. It is an evolution depending upon circumstance. And it seems
to me the circumstance has in recent decades changed. When people went out to vote, up
until relatively recently, a few decades ago, the party names weren't even listed on the
ballot paper. At that point, you really could argue that it was a personal vote for a known
candidate. But once the party names appeared, and the leaders became more prominent, perhaps
from the time of Margaret Thatcher, certainly by the time of Tony Blair, definitely with
David Cameron and Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer, people were voting for a new leader, not for
the individual standing as the Member of Parliament. And that mandate is therefore personal, and
if the person goes, the mandate needs to be renewed, reallocated, because the people
may decide that the new person coming in isn't their choice, particularly if it's a coronation
without even a vote amongst the Labour Party itself. I think this is a very important constitutional
evolution. It's why I opposed the Fixed-Term Parliament Act. And it seems to me that whoever
comes in will have no validity, no mandate, no real authority, without that general election.
As always, let me know what you think, mail them on gnews.com, but now I'm very pleased
to be joined by Richard Tice, the Deputy Leader of Reform. Richard, thank you for coming in.
I mean, I suppose I could just say to you, do you agree, which I have a feeling it is
the Reform position, but do you agree out of a constitutional change that you think
is more general, or do you just think it's convenient now?
You've worked hard for your money, so why does it feel like your pounds are constantly
losing value? Your savings should grow and be safe. It's common sense, isn't it? But
here's the truth. Policy impacts inflation, which silently erodes your purchasing power.
Don't let inflation decide what your money is worth. And when your money is with your
bank, the bank uses it for their purposes. They lend it, they profit from it. Your money
works hard for your bank, when it should be working hard for you. This is why people are
seeking alternatives to traditional bank savings accounts. With a tally money account, your
pounds are automatically converted into real physical gold, held securely in your name.
Not a promise, not just a number on a computer screen, real gold in a vault. And the clever
bit? You still have instant access for transfers and payments. Through the Tally Money app
and Tally Debit Mastercard, you can transfer funds or spend it in any currency. Gold has
been trusted for thousands of years. Now with Tally, it works more like everyday money.
So if you're tired of your savings not keeping up with the cost of living, and you'd rather
own something real, take a look at Tally Money. To find out more and to get an exclusive GB
News offer, simply scan the QR code or click the link in the description.
Well, if he is, then he's making a big mistake, because I think the country will be furious.
Firstly, at the point of having a change of Prime Minister without the country having
say. Secondly, someone just rocking up from outside, I think will double the anger, particularly
at a time when the country is broken. And everybody knows the quality of life and the
money they have in their pocket at the end of the week and the month is reducing. I think
that rage will grow. And if Mr Burnham thinks he can get to a November budget where he's
going to have to increase taxes a lot without any form of mandate, you might find he's even
more unpopular than Keir Starmer very quickly.
Well, I think that's a very important point, because as he wasn't elected last time round,
he did not stand and can repudiate the Labour Manifesto. That wasn't how he got into Parliament.
And I think you're right. I think the country would be furious if an unelected Prime Minister
broke manifesto commitments on tax rises without having renewed his mandate.
You see how unpopular Keir Starmer has been with Rachel Reeves increasing taxes, which
they said they weren't going to do. You know, this chap, he seems to be from a sort of,
well, you don't quite know where he is. But at the moment, he seems to be heading way
left to sort of what I call hard socialism. And that's not what the country voted for.
So there has to be a general election.
From a narrow party political point of view, both your party and mine, do we really want
a general election now? Are either of our parties ready? And mayn't Burnham get a bounce,
as Gordon Brown did, that would put him in quite a strong position?
Oh, he's bound to get a bounce as he takes votes mainly from the Green Party, who seem
to have disappeared into a submarine. But as far as we're concerned, we will be ready
and we're looking forward to it. And we think that every party should look forward to it.
I do think the Conservatives have been slightly prevaricating today. They seem to want one
only if he doesn't fund the defence investment plan. Well, either you want one on principle
and constitutional priorities and good behaviour or not.
Well, I definitely want one regardless, though I'm not speaking formally for the Conservative
party. And David Cameron said very clearly when Gordon Brown took over that we needed
one. So it's quite a consistent Tory position, though. I'm afraid we didn't do it. Well,
we didn't, we didn't. May and Boris both had elections in fairly short order. That's the
other thing. From the political vantage of Burnham, he'd be well advised to have one,
wouldn't he? Because it's his best opportunity to win.
It's the only chance when he's going to have some form of popularity. As I say, I think
by Christmas, if he doesn't seek a mandate for his form of governing the country, then
he will be very, very unpopular indeed. And the country will become almost ungovernable
under that sort of regime. I really do think so. And yeah, I think the country wants an
election. The country doesn't know Andy Who, Burnham Who. I mean, no one outside Greater
Manchester really knows who this chap is. He hasn't been in the House of Commons for
nine years. He tried and failed twice in a leadership contest, which is why he doesn't
want a contest this time. Interested to see what happens there.
Well, that's also interesting because we're streetings backing him and we wonder what
backroom deals have been done. But if Burnham's the only candidate in the next 48 hours, no
one else comes forward, what on earth are we waiting for? They do seem to be just mucking
around with the government of the country for internal party political reasons.
Well, it's interesting the Prime Minister set the 9th of July as the opening time for
nominations to close just a week later. Let's talk about Darren Jones. I'd keep a very close
eye on Al Khan's, but there should be a contest. But I think when they have a contest, if they
have a contest, then Mr Burnham might suddenly be found greatly wanting because he doesn't,
you know, what's he ever said about the defence? What's he ever said about the economy? What's
he ever said about the boats? What's he ever said about foreign policy? We've not a clue.
Put him under a bit of pressure in a contest, he'll be all over the place.
And he's very often said things that are convenient for the moment and changes his view a few
months later. You saw at the party conference, Labour's conference last year, he said he
wanted to rejoin the European Union. To the voters of Maccafield, he said that he didn't.
He really does seem to be one of those politicians who changes his coat according to the audience
he's addressing.
And I think that, you know, the public is grumpy at best at the moment. And I just think
that that concern, that anxiety, that anger will grow if there's no contest to be Labour
leader. Just a complete outsider shows up and takes control of the country. I mean,
it's a bit of a coup. That's actually what we're looking at here. We're looking at a
coup of the United Kingdom by potentially the hard left with no democratic mandate whatsoever.
But the one thing that was clear from Maccafield was that voters wanted to get rid of Starmer.
Yes. And we had reform voters who had voted for us in the local elections on May the 7th
telling us we voted reform to get Starmer out. Now we're voting Burnham to guarantee
to get Starmer out. All right. That's what happened.