What Makerfield means for Labour, Reform and Restore | spiked podcast

World News Updates
7 followers
Julia Hartley-Brewer and Claire Fox join Tom Slater to discuss why Andy Burnham won’t bring ‘change’ to Labour, why Reform UK fell short, and whether Restore Britain will continue to nip at Farage’s heels
#Gjwnews #WorldNewsUpdates #Neutral #worldnews
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis episode of The Spiked Podcast examines Andy Burnham's victory in the Makerfield by-election. The discussion explores whether the result signals genuine support for Burnham or a strategic rejection of Keir Starmer, while analyzing the current standing of Reform UK and the broader realignment of the UK's working-class electorate.
Hello and welcome back to The Spiked Podcast. I'm Tom Slater, editor of Spiked, filling in
in the hot seat this week for Fraser Myers, who is away. But what a story he's missed. It's the
day after the Makerfield by-election, a truly historic vote, which has raised all kinds of
questions about the state of our politics. I'm delighted to be joined by two brilliant people
to discuss this. Claire Phopps from the Academy of Ideas. How are you doing, Claire?
Very well, thank you.
And Julia Hartley Brewer from TalkTV. So the headline results, as people will have seen,
Andy Burnham winning this seat very comfortably, 55% of the vote, Reform UK coming a pretty distant
second with 35%. And in third place, Restore Britain, the challenger party to Reform on the
right, sweeping up around 7% of the vote. So just to kick things off, Claire, what do you think this
vote means? And do you think it's striking that the margin by which Andy Burnham won in this case?
That's a very existential question. What does this vote mean? But anyway, I suppose the first
thing to say is that the vote is likely to have an impact on the future of the country for all
the reasons that everybody has already said, so I won't be unoriginal. But it's one of the reasons
why the vote was so large, in my opinion. Because, you know, if you're in the Makerfield constituency,
no disrespect to the people of Wigan and Surrounds, but you know, it's like suddenly
the whole world says you're responsible for something big happening, right? And they then say
that you could vote the future Prime Minister of the country. So it's not just like a local
by-election anymore, and it's attractive for a number of reasons. You might have the Prime
Minister as your local MP, never, you know, a bit glamorous. And secondly, they quite like him,
right? They don't associate him with Labour. In fact, he's done his everything to disassociate
himself from Labour. Everybody in the area, absolutely everybody, hates Keir Starmer.
So this is the kick Keir Starmer out vote. And so that's, you can sort of see how they won. I'm
delighted, by the way, that the turnout was so high, because that's what we should all want as
Democrats. We don't want this decided by a kind of lacklustre, unengaged electorate. And they
were well and truly engaged. But why it was odd was because we associate that whole area
and with a very recent, just at the local elections, massive humiliation of Labour
by reform. And so it's a kind of weird one, because reform stood, and they undoubtedly
didn't perform as well as people anticipated. I never, over recent weeks, I'm not saying I
called it, I just knew they, I guess they weren't going to win. I didn't think it was close
from people I was talking to, both people in the Labour Party and people in reform. So I was kind
of getting both crowds confirming what I thought. But the gap was much bigger than I'd anticipated.
I mean, it really is a kind of resounding victory for Burnham. You know, that's it. And I suppose
the only other thing to say at this point is just that, you know, despite that, for me,
Burnham is a hologram, you know, just a kind of empty... I mean, the disappointment that I have
is that all these hopes and this sort of big, almost international discussion about what's
happening in Makeville is about Andy Burnham. And then you have to go, oh God, Andy Burnham.
Who's Andy Burnham? Oh, I know who Andy Burnham is. He's that guy who is, he's got nothing going,
you know, doesn't say anything politically. I consider him to be a kind of nice local chap who's
not done a bad job as mayor, but is actually, should be, held to account for a wide range of
things that he didn't do, whether it was the grooming gang stuff that he failed to act on,
the fact that he took credit for other people's work in relation to both housing and transport,
all sorts of things I can say about him, which I won't bother now. And we're meant to be excited
by it. But I don't want to undermine the democratic rights of those voters who think, well,
you know, we'll make our little mark on history by getting the Prime Minister elected.
It's so historically unique, that. And Julia, to bring you in here, what do you think this says
about reform, how they're shaping up? Because as has already been the case, people have sort of
declared that their rise is over. This has shown that the wheels are coming off, all the usual
cliches deployed. But what do you think this says about how reform will do? It's the usual Westminster
bubble, completely overreacting to everything. And absolutely any single vote, whatever it's a
general election or by-election, this tells us 20,000 things, when it doesn't. Remember the end
of two-party politics, the return of two-party politics, they're always predicting things based
on one particular vote. Look, this was a pre-Beth Clare, you can't deny, this was an amazing victory
for Andy Burnham, the size of the actual vote, people turning out, the size of his vote, the size
of his majority, the fact he increased it by, what, 10 percentage points or 20 percentage points,
I think, on the last guy. I mean, look, there's no question at all. But was this a vote for Andy
Burnham or was this a vote against Keir Starmer? Because I'm thinking, if I lived in Makefield,
I'm not a, these days, I'm a floating dota of years, but would I, not necessarily a natural
Labour voter at the current time, given their policies and their track record, would I have
voted for Andy Burnham just to get rid of that god-awful man Keir Starmer from number 10? You
know what? I think I probably would have. An extra reform MP isn't going to make a difference.
Andy Burnham does make a difference. But this is where we're in the same situation as we were in,
in July 2024, almost two years ago, where there's this message of Keir Starmer's won this amazing
majority, as we know, incredibly shallow majority. Basically, it was a rejection of the Tories.
People either didn't vote Tory or they turned to vote reform. They split the right-wing vote
and Labour got in. And I think this is what's happened now. Now, it wasn't Restore that was
taking enough votes for reform that meant the reform didn't get in. It was, you know,
not necessarily the best choice and most well-vetted candidate from reform. But the point
is, as you say, Clare, you've got a moment as a voter in Makefield to actually have a major impact
getting rid of one of the most hated people in the country. You're going to take your chance,
aren't you? And when a lot of the commentators, I mean, you can virtually see the supposedly
politically neutral news presenters and political editors on the telly and hear them on the radio,
virtually, I mean, oozing with excitement. This is what they were like about Keir Starmer,
the Great White of Hope, you know, this knight on shining armour and how, you know,
all these quotes from all these people on the left saying, these are the people of Makefield
standing up against hate and division. By the way, a load of those people voted for reform
in the local elections just a few weeks ago. Suddenly, they're now acceptable people. They're
no longer bigots and hateful people. Very difficult to square that one. But fundamentally,
this isn't, you know, high water for reform that's been reached and now they're going to ebb away.
This was a very, very unique situation where you got a chance to oust a hated, useless sitting
prime minister and you'll take you ever as an option. Do I think that Andy Burnham is going
to be any better than Keir Starmer? He's more fun. He's got more charisma, not a high bar,
admittedly. But I mean, let's be honest, he can communicate much better. But at the end of the
day, he's as untried and untested realistically as the prime minister. And I'm afraid, I think all
the people who are very excited today about change, because we had a lot of that talk, didn't
they? Change in July 24. I think they're going to be sorely disappointed by A, what change he can
deliver and B, the change he does deliver, how useless that change is. I think that's fair. I
mean, the only distinction between them seems to be that he does have a pulse in contrast to Keir
Starmer. And he wears t-shirts. Exactly, he wears t-shirts, which is really, really interesting.
When people think about an independent publication like Spiked, they think about the writing, the
debates, the ideas. But there's a lot more happening behind the scenes. It's subscriptions,
events, books, emails, reader relationships, all the practical things that help turn a publication
into a community. And those practical things really shape how people experience a brand.
I know that as a customer myself. When I've bought from a Shopify powered store, the experience
feels simple and seamless. Browse, buy, get updates, done. You don't notice the technology
because it just works. For a team like us at Spiked, that ease can make a real difference,
helping us spend less time managing systems and more time growing our audience. That's where
Shopify comes in. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world
and 10% of all e-commerce in the US, helping everyone from well-known brands like Penguin
Books and Huel to small independent organizations selling directly to their audiences. If you're
selling online, Shopify helps you get up and running quickly with hundreds of ready-to-use
templates that let you build a professional looking store without needing a team of developers.
It's also packed with AI powered tools that can help with everything from product descriptions
and page headlines to enhancing your product photography. And when it's time to spread the
word, Shopify makes it easy to create email and social media campaigns, helping you reach
customers wherever they are. Best of all, Shopify gives you expert support on the practical side of
running a business too, from inventory management and shipping to returns and payments. So if you're
ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Start your business today with the industry's best
business partner, Shopify, and start hearing this noise. Sign up for your £1 per month trial
today at shopify.co.uk slash spiked. Go to shopify.co.uk slash spiked. Once again, that's
shopify.co.uk slash spiked. Claire, on the point of reform, because there has been this
response amongst the media to say that this proves that they're sort of running aground,
I often find this so strange because the fact that, you know, the last election,
it's only a couple of years ago, they had all the five MPs. So the fact that they're
even being talked about as being in contention at the next election to be the largest or second
largest party would be in its own terms a historic political achievement. But any setback, it seems,
is used as proof that the whole populist wave is over. What do you make of all of those claims?
Well, that's the thing is, I mean, I've heard the announcement that the populist wave is over,
you know, once a month for years. I mean, it's like every time anything happens, it's like,
oh, great, that's the end of that. And it can be in France, it can be in Germany, it can be in
Hungary, it can be wherever, right? It's always over. But they misunderstand the spirit of
populism. And the spirit of populism has been, you know, chosen the vehicle of reform by and large,
right? You know, but it's the idea that a vote for Andy Benham means that people aren't populist
anymore. I mean, populist is an old phrase, but you know, that that spirit of wanting to
shake things up, the political realignment, I mean, this is a bit of a political realignment
in it, in and of itself, which is, is that the Labour Party collapsed within two years, right?
This is the mainstream party. And it's collapsed, and it's collapsed because its own voters,
working class voters in particular, and we do have to remember that the Labour Party was a
working class, by the way, to represent. I mean, they might well have, they might well have betrayed
that many a time, but now there's not even a pretence, right? And that Labour Party was
humiliated in the local elections. I do want to say something about reform, though. I mean,
a couple of observations. One is Rob Kenyon, right? If I can just do a bit of an in defence
of Rob Kenyon. I've never met him. And I mean by that, he thought that he had another three years,
or not just he, the local reform group thought that they had another three years till the general
election. They could select their candidate and all the rest of it, right? So talk about somebody
thrown into the hole, I'm like, right? And the reason why I think they selected Rob Kenyon,
because I know that you can say, and you're right, of course, you know, maybe, you know,
a bit weak on the betting. But actually, he was the local guy who didn't do bad in the last general
election, and was very popular with local activists on reform. And it would have been
a real slap across the face of that local group. And after all, you know, the leadership does have
to take into account that they can't just go around, as it were, and parachuting in, you know,
slick alternatives. They've tried it, it doesn't work. But also, they had a genuine local popular
guy who might well have benefited from the three years of getting thinking about standing as an MP,
and he suddenly had to do it all. So that was because, why? It was because the Labour Party
is so anti-democratic that they orchestrated to use the constituency, create a coup situation
to get rid of their own leaders. That was a disgusting attack on democracy in many ways,
right? I mean, you know, why did Josh Damon stand out? I decided to stand down in order for us
to internally sort out our problems, because we don't know how else to do it,
right? So I really resent that. Having said that, it's also the case that I didn't think
that reform had a great campaign, which is not the same as saying that I blame
Kenyon. I didn't think they had a great campaign, because I think on occasion,
they sounded as though they had an entitlement to the win. And they kept that, you know, it's
our territory, we just won here. And it's the only thing that I agreed with Rupert Low on,
when he said last night, and he said it a couple of weeks ago as well, which is nobody owns voters
votes. Every single one of them should be fought for in a democracy. So this idea of going on and
on about Restore splitting the vote, though that was, you know, based on an exaggerated sense of
and kind of didn't feel to me a very positive case for. I also thought they should have made
more positive case for reform. And they're actually getting a good policy team together
now they've got some good arguments, but I never really heard them. And I don't know that the
doorsteps heard them either. So I just think it was too anti-Labour or anti-Restore.
But that's where this is unique by election, isn't it? That it just became about Andy Burnham,
both sides based reforming Nigel Farage paid this point this morning in a video basically,
their campaign was, you know, vote for us to get rid of Starmer. That was Burnham's campaign.
So I don't think it's the end of reform at all. But reform should learn the lessons that don't
be complacent and, you know, be better prepared. And, you know, you're going to have local
candidates who won't necessarily slick operators, but they should at least be familiar with what
the party's big issues are other than just being local. And just on the Restore stuff,
and I know that Spites have been doing things on this. I mean, I am concerned about the
ethno-nationalism, downright racism, to call it what it is, of some
people around Restore, you know, who they seem to regard well, and some very unpleasant
anti-Semitism from some of the people that they haven't denounced. And let alone the fact that,
you know, we've actually got the equivalent of BNP joining their ranks without any criticism,
right? You got a lot going on. I'm very worried about all that. I mean, I worry about it
politically. I think we have to take into consideration the fact there's a group of young
people who think that this is the appropriate way of behaving. But I suppose I want to,
you know, I want to also say that they have a lot of people who will have voted for them,
even if it was only 3,000 in the end, but they won't have all been going around going,
I'm putting my, you know, tick next to an ethno-nationalist new party who got a particular
weakness on, you know, Jew hatred, right? I don't think so anyway. I think that it's much more that
they're the challenger party, that there is this problem for reform, which I don't know how they
resolve, which is, if they were to become the government and they hadn't done any work on policy
and then got anyone who knows how to run government, we'd all be going, you irresponsible
idiots, how immature. You can't just play student politics. But because they're trying to be all
grown up and do all the grown up things and look like they can run the country, then there starts
being a little bit like, I want to be in the rebel party. And so there's a little bit of that.
But don't you think that, and Burnham is facing a problem with that as well, which is, of course,
you know, he's Mr. Cool King of the North. He's the one, and he played the blinder. He was on my
talk show regularly during lockdown. He was trying to get extra funding for, you know,
not just Manchester, the people of the North, when they were in tier four or whatever,
when the Westminster central, you know, centric government was not thinking about that.
I mean, he's played the blinder and he's been able to completely distance himself from everything
that Keir Starmer's done, all of the U-turns and all the mishaps and all of the failure to
deliver this mythical change that we hear so much about all over the manifesto in 2024.
But watching Burnham's speech today after he won, yet he was talking about people have voted for
change. Change to what? From what? To what? When? How? How are you paying for it? What are you
going to do? And then there's just no detail. Exactly the same problem we have with Keir
Starmer. They were the alternative. Burnham was the alternative. Well, any moment now,
whether or not cabinet ministers talk the prime minister into resigning or whether there's a
leadership contest, a coronation, whatever happens, very, very likely, I mean, you'd be
crazy not to put money on him to be the next prime minister and pretty soon. At that point,
he is the establishment. He is the person, you know, he's the person who governs and therefore
to govern is to choose. He's the person who will then have those difficult 400 MPs,
many of whom are backbenchers, never worked in the real world, have no idea. I mean,
no evidence, by the way, that Andy Burnham himself knows what Rachel Reeves fiscal rules are,
given that you wouldn't actually tell an interviewer the other day what they were,
even though he's saying he's going to stick to them. He's got no money, no room for manoeuvre,
no evidence whatsoever. He has grasped the really big issues about needing to spend on defence,
cutting net zero, bursting the welfare bubble and slashing that in massively.
There is no evidence he has grasped any of those big issues. Cheaper bus fares,
renationalise an industry here or there is not going to make enough difference to people's
lives. It's not going to grow the economy. So he's going to be Mr Change who can't, won't,
will not deliver change. In two years' time, he's going to just be Keir Starmer,
but with a slightly nicer personality and a T-shirt. And people think that the charisma
and the personality is what is going to keep him above where Labour languishing at 19 points in
the polls right now. But, you know, Boris Johnson had heaps of charisma. People who would never vote
Tory in their lives and voted for him. People follow him down the street. Weird, weird attraction
for women. Don't even understand that. But you know what? That charisma kept him in post
for two years. I just I think I've got to be honest with you. I woke up this morning to the
result. I think it's hilarious. I love the fact that you've got a whole load of people
basically absolutely convinced this is the guy he's going to deliver.
Everything is going to change now. We're going to get the government we voted for.
None of this is going to happen. He'll have a bounce in the polls for a few months. Of course,
he will. But at the end of the day, he's going to be another lame duck.
I think that's as optimistic a note to end on as we could possibly hope for. Julia and
Claire, thank you both very much. There's no Spiked podcast unlocked this week, but we've
got something even more special for you. There is an exclusive Q&A with our own Brendan O'Neill,
which is up now exclusively for Spiked supporters. So there'll be a link in the
description. Click on that after you've watched this and go and enjoy that and enjoy your weekend.
Thank you so much for watching the Spiked podcast. We'll be back next week. So make sure
you subscribe to the channel and click the bell so you never miss an episode. If you enjoyed the
Spiked podcast, then why not check out what else our channel has to offer from our documentaries
to our weekly interviews and podcasts like the Brendan O'Neill show. And if you're a Spiked
supporter, you can watch the second half of this episode by logging in on the Spiked website.
If you're not yet a Spiked supporter, then why not sign up now? You'll get unlimited access to
the website, add free reading, discounted tickets to our events and so much more. So
become a Spiked supporter today by going to spiked-online.com forward slash support.
That's spiked-online.com forward slash support.
