Dlaczego Rowling Nie Chciała Wydania Tej Biografii? Prawda O Mity O J.K. Rowling I Harrym Potterze

J. K. Rowling - the writer
1 follower
#JKRowling #HarryPotter #Biografierowling #StrefaCzytacza #Książki #SolomonSchmidt #RecenzjaKsiążki #Literatura #FantastyczneZwierzęta
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis review evaluates Solomon Schmidt's unauthorized biography of J.K. Rowling, *A Pen to Change the World*. The reviewer praises the work as the most reliable and meticulously researched biography to date, noting its ability to debunk myths about Rowling's success and its impartial handling of her modern ideological controversies, despite some omissions regarding her literary process.
Did we need a biography of J.K. Rowling, a book written conscientiously, impartially, avoiding the temptation of becoming a judge in a very controversial, ideologically charged, gender-related dispute in which Rowling found herself several years ago?
Of course it is. The only question is whether the highly publicized premiere of A Pen to Change the World, The Life of J.K. Rowling, by Solomon Schmidt, hides the truest truth, or merely the desire to make a substantial profit.
One thing is certain: the first solid biography of Rowling since 2001, which promised to be sensible, will sell like hotcakes, not only in the United States but around the world.
For the first time, I can evaluate the biography not only from the perspective of literary criticism, but also by verifying facts, which is very important to me.
Let's start by saying that over the years, a great many lies and myths have accumulated around Rowling.
If you started your journey with Harry Potter some 20 years ago or earlier, one thing is certain: you devoured those books like pelicans, just like all of us did.
That was the story of a little shoe, from zero to hero, from an idea through snail mail, international, a gigantic phenomenon.
The point is that this isn't true, because Rowling's journey, however dramatic, has been greatly exaggerated by sensationalist writers and has been colored over the years, right up to the present day.
The question is whether Schmidt managed to separate the wheat from the chaff. After all, we're talking about an unauthorized biography.
There's no reason to get upset about this, because Rowling has never authorized any text concerning her, as she guards her privacy like a lioness.
Moreover, the author of this book even received a warning from J. K. Rowling's associates to stay away from people connected with the author.
A sense of dread swept over us. Let's begin with the sensational.
This book is promoted as the most controversial biography of 2026, as the most censored biography.
In addition, the author is only 22 years old, and despite this, she already has 10 books to her name and, at the age of 13, was declared the youngest historian in the United States.
The question I had asked myself before reading this book, before reaching for it, was.
Can such a young person seriously approach this topic?
Is he capable of finding within himself the maturity that such work requires?
I may sound like a boomer, but now that I'm closer to forty than away from it, I can clearly see how immature I was just a few years ago, let alone fifteen or so years ago.
How easily I used to get excited about various things, how idealistically I used to approach many issues.
How fiercely I defended my tests, which time later proved—sorry for the expression—to be utter nonsense.
How passionately I defended my own arguments.
In short, in my early twenties I was an idiot who thought he had devoured all the intellects.
No, I'm not ashamed of it. That's just how things are; we call it growing up.
Frankly, I'm not particularly impressed by Donald's words of praise directed at the author—just give me Greenland or Trump's Foch.
I was afraid that in this book, opinions might prevail over facts.
No, how did that happen? I'll explain it to you right away.
As for Rowling's biography, if I recall correctly, it was supposed to be released last year, as I was already tracking it back then, but for some reason its release has kept getting postponed.
Were there legal issues behind it? Unknown.
But I do know this: the original version of the book is, at least according to what online bookstores state, eight pages longer than the British edition, which will not be published until the end of July.
I am not a supporter of conspiracy theories.
But I wonder where this difference comes from.
A light comes on at the back of the head—will this be a censored version, or not, or is it referring to blank pages that have appeared here but won't be present in the European version?
Unknown.
Now we come to the most important part.
Answers to the question of whether the biography written by Solomon Schmidt is anything more than a collection of nonsense from the internet, packaged with controversial marketing slogans to sell as effectively as possible.
Let us begin by stating that the book is divided into three parts.
Broken, polished, burning. Forgive me for giving you direct translations, but it is not my role to create a Polish version of this book.
I leave this to the person who will translate this book, since it is quite certain that they will translate it into Polish.
The first part concerns the history of Joanne Rowling.
Her family, her origins, her childhood, her mother's illness, her mother's death, her failed marriage, writing her first Potter book, and searching for a publisher for it.
The next part is essentially a story about the phenomenon of Harry Potter, about Queen Rowling, and about the great love of fans.
The third and final part essentially focuses on Rowling in the era of Twitter, or X.
Rowling openly expressing her views, engaging in an ideological battle.
I will call this war ideological, because that is precisely what it is to me.
A war of differing beliefs, a war of differing visions of the world, a war of differing directions.
No, this is still an ideology in its own way, by definition.
The best, and indeed one of the very few, if not the only, sensible biographies of Rowling to date.
a terribly dull and clumsy book by Shon Smith served up a story about J.K. Rowling,
Which ending was like a fairy tale about Little Red Riding Hood.
The slipper is found, the shoe fitted to the correct foot,
And they got married, and lived happily ever after.
Although I appreciate Smith's work, for years I have been expecting something more comprehensive and less clumsy in the Witcher.
But it's still very cumbersome.
Did Solomon Schmidt fulfill my dream?
Yes, and no.
That means, compared to Smith, yes, but generally...
Let's start by saying that this is undoubtedly a better-written book than Smith's biography.
Reading her is not like rubbing sandpaper over one's backside, which in itself is a major plus for me.
Let's be clear, I'm not reaching for J.K. Rowling's biography because of her artistic merits.
I reach out as a creature hungry for the expansion of knowledge, seeking answers to the questions that trouble me.
I want blood, I want marrow, I want shark.
Actually, the first chapter largely repeats what Sean Smith wrote in his biography.
However, it is repeatedly supplemented by adding something to it.
I would like to point out here that Schmidt did not base his work solely on press interviews or other similar materials.
He also spoke with many people connected to J.K. Rowling, including members of her family.
It was precisely the contacts with J.K. Rowling's family that so unsettled the author.
Schmidt received a letter from Rowling's lawyers, who clearly objected to the methods Schmidt used to obtain information.
The author, in fact, included this letter in the preface.
And pay attention, it followed from that that it had happened to him, well, that doesn't sound particularly good,
Wait outside people's homes to talk with them.
Ouch.
No, in any case, it's already evident in the first part of this book that Schmidt has filled in the knowledge.
There's a lot here about the Rowling family, and a lot about the relationships within it.
We learn about many fascinating facts regarding her grandparents, including the legendary Kathleen.
What is the name that Rowling adopted as her second name, so that Joanne Rowling became J.K. Rowling?
We have quite a few family anecdotes and other people's remarks about Rowling in this book.
That is why we receive an answer, even to the question of why the writer does not maintain contact with her father.
Yes, that's just the kind of food for people interested in others' lives.
There's also a bit of dirty laundry here.
Exclusion, violence, lack of acceptance.
We see a person who was soon to become one of the most famous writers in the world.
and we see the world in which reality revolved
sometimes more, sometimes less colorful.
No, Rowling is also characterized in this way in many respects.
Schmidt, somewhat interestingly, points out in his book the prototypes of the characters from Rowling's books.
What's most fascinating about him in this field are his discoveries regarding accurate selection.
which turns out to be a surprisingly powerful novel firmly rooted in Rowling's biography,
members of her family, people she knew.
At the author's request, with whom I am in contact and from whom I receive a digital copy of the book,
He didn't have to wait a month for it to be delivered in paper form,
I will not tell you the details today, I will not provide specifics.
It sent him to one of the most fascinating parts of the book's biography,
where it was described.
Although it is a book strongly grounded in facts
and often not only exclude lies but also precisely target them,
Although they grew from the legend of J.K. Rowling, flaws and mistakes are not absent.
Even at the moment when Schmidt states,
that Rowling had wanted to name Harry just Harry Potter from the beginning,
what is not true, because J.K. Rowling herself stated years ago,
She had previously considered other names, such as the name Bat for her character.
Anyway, those are just details, because what matters most to me is...
the fact that aside from the bibliography written by Philippa Arrington,
This biography is the first book to reveal the truth about the publication of Harry Potter.
But it's not true that Harry Potter reached the first print run.
In a quantity of 500 copies, 200 in hardcover, 300 in paperback
and how it had been served for long, long years.
The fact is that 500 copies were issued in hardcover.
But in soft, almost 6,000, Philipp Arrington reached such data.
And if someone asks, where such a high print run for the first edition of the children's book comes from
When was it, when children's books weren't read?
Truth is very little fairy-tale-like.
Before Harry Potter was sold, it was already widely talked about.
I don't want to spoil your fun in discovering this truth,
On the other hand, to put it briefly, yes, it was very skillfully orchestrated by someone.
And very unconventional marketing.
At the moment Harry Potter made his debut in Great Britain,
People were curious about the book that was sold for a record amount of money to the United States.
They were curious about the little coat that enchanted America.
Sorry, there was no magic here, and I appreciate that Solomon Schmidt revealed this truth in his book.
The truth stripped of the rather clumsy packaging surrounding the Harry Potter phenomenon.
Generally, it smiled at me only moderately, and it smiles in one-third of this biography.
which is practically entirely devoted to the controversies surrounding J.K. Rowling.
So many details, quotations here.
And I understand where the decision comes from to show the conflicts from both sides as accurately as possible.
What one should appreciate is Schmidt's impartiality.
who does not utter a word in favor of anyone's side,
allowing us to form our own opinion.
If, therefore, you wish to understand the genesis of the conflict concerning transgender people
and to understand his reality, not from sensational headlines
the idiotic comments posted online,
It's worth at least reaching for this biography.
Even I found in this section a lot of things I didn't know about.
which greatly enriched my knowledge and helped solidify my conclusions,
I'd already had that somewhere, so it's the perfect explanation for the entire dispute.
The only thing I regret is the fact that this third part essentially replaced
What interested me most in Rowling's biography.
Or perhaps this may sound strange, but Rowling's privacy doesn't really concern me much.
and their Twitter or X handles.
What interests me more are the foundations that enabled her to create Harry Potter.
Trafny Wybór, the series about the strike, and all its other books.
Indeed, regarding the history of the creation of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone,
I am quite content.
One could write a completely separate book about Potter alone.
on several hundred pages concerning its origin,
On the other hand, I'm not entirely satisfied with the series' storyline about the strike.
I know a number of anecdotes and stories related to its creation,
Which could truly become an interesting and important element of this book.
What is unforgivable to me, however, is that Schmidt did not dedicate
even just a word for the starry little beggar.
That's just my opinion.
But we're talking about an author who, aside from the Potter-related works, doesn't have many books to her name.
And in my opinion, each of them should find its place in a biography dedicated to the author.
So from this perspective, I feel great disappointment,
Rowling's privacy has lost out to her creativity—and it's simply sad.
For that, I can say that the biography written by Schmidt
She opened my eyes regarding the downfall of the Fantastic Beasts series.
Indeed, the author here presents further reasons,
which inevitably led to the downfall of Fantastic Beasts.
And if you're curious about what those reasons are, take a look at Potterownia,
Where exactly am I explaining it to you.
In the end, I can say that I am satisfied with this biography.
I consider it the best in terms of both research and language.
Indeed, one can see moments in it when the author, perhaps due to age,
He may have gotten a bit too excited, thus flooding us with irrelevant details.
I think that even in the most critical moments
does not match Patricio Tarantino, who in the pages of his publication
He even provided, attention, the identification numbers from the wristband of the newly born Joan Rowling.
Seriously, this isn't a joke. He actually listed it in the book.
What matters most to me is how diligently Schmidt approached it.
to make their work credible, which is confirmed by a 90-page,
a very detailed bibliography placed at the end of the book
thanks to which we can trace every source,
From which author did the writer draw knowledge for this biography?
In the era of AI, media duplication across borders,
To is something particularly valuable and deserving of the highest respect for me.
This underscores that the author worked on something real.
As a long-time fan of J. K. Rowling, closely studying her life,
I can confidently recommend this biography to you, with its career and achievements.
Perhaps not as sensational as suggested by the announcement.
But let's remember that this book was written by a historian here, not by Rita Skeeter.
Moreover, which is a major advantage for me,
The author remained neutral, refraining from expressing their own opinions or views.
This makes it so that after reading this biography, everyone will be able to judge,
especially in the context of ideological disputes,
Who is right based on their own beliefs or their own experiences.
I consider this to be a truly significant advantage of this book.
It is also important that I did not find any glaring deficiencies or distortions here.
One can see extensive research, one can see factual verification.
Perhaps this is not the ideal biography for me,
It also lacks much to become a beautiful biographical story.
What are Agatha Christie's or Daphne du Maurier's biographies to me, anyway?
which I consider masterpieces of biography,
It is a solid and very good book.
ready to publish it to the world
I became the most important publication of its kind in the world.
As for the photos I had the chance to see for the first time only today
And also, due to the author's request, I am not showing them here,
There are indeed very many of them.
Moreover, they are on additional, unnumbered pages.
So you don't need to worry that instead of content, you'll find only pictures in the book.
As for their quantity, we have a truly private portion.
family photos, unique items, some photos of individual places or buildings
a few photos that can be found online
such as promotional photos from various events or premieres.
I don't actually need photos for my biography, but it's nice when there are some.
so overall, that's a plus, especially if someone ever wanted to visit those places someday
related to J. K. Rowling, but there's also no such frenzy here,
What I would have expected from those announcements.
Meanwhile, we're waiting for the announcement of the Polish edition,
and I'm especially rooting hard here for one of our publishing houses,
to whom I suggested this book with the proposal of its publication in Poland.
Let's keep our fingers crossed for them.
And at this occasion, I also warmly discourage you from doing so,
You would buy this book through Amazon.
They do not secure their shipments.
This book, like every other one I've had the luck to buy through Amazon,
Regardless of which one, regardless of which Amazon,
She's just lived, worn down, looks as if she's truly been through a lot.
Therefore, I suggest waiting for the European or Polish release.
I'll buy this book from another source that cares more about its customers.
Let me know if you intend to read it, and I'll just add,
that my opinion is completely independent.
I have no collaboration on the book.
I bought it myself, and the only conversations I had with the author were
In essence, it was about whether I could count on a digital edition.
He could have just read it to himself earlier.
I'll record this material for you as soon as the paper finally arrives.
He arrived... Oh, very, very late,
That would already be a story for an entirely different topic.
Biography of Salomon Schmidt, the best currently available biography
What did J.K. Rowling achieve?
And moreover, a very good biography.
Hold on, hey!
