4 Major Taboos Containing Profound Classical Philosophy That No One Realizes In Water Margin

History & Culture of East
10 followers
40 Video Views·Aug 7, 2026
Who Are The 5 Characters Forced To Arrow In Liangshan Who Hated Song Jiang To The Bone?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video analyzes the Chinese classic *Water Margin*, contrasting it with *Three Kingdoms* to highlight its celebration of reckless heroism. It explores four critical \"taboos\" or character flaws—timidity, impulsiveness, arrogance, and slyness—using specific figures from the novel to provide timeless life lessons on the dangers of these traits.
Welcome back to Battlecry.
There's an old Chinese saying, don't read Water Margin when young,
don't read Three Kingdoms when old. It speaks to the core essence of these two literary classics.
Three Kingdoms is a masterpiece on the struggles for power.
Filled with complex characters, cunning schemes, and deep calculations.
That's why when people reach old age, they have life experience.
They've matured and gained deeper insight.
Making them easily drawn to the sinister intrigue of Three Kingdoms.
Water Margin, however, is the opposite. It celebrates the heroics of outlaws.
It encourages a reckless spirit, doing whatever one desires without restraint.
Wu Song, fueled by rage, could slay dozens of men.
Li Kuei, blindly following orders, would kill an innocent boy without hesitation.
That's why young people reading Water Margin are easily incited,
often seduced by its unrestrained and wild style.
Here are four major taboos hidden in Water Margin that any reader should recognize.
The first taboo, timidity.
They say Lin Chong is unbeatable on horseback, Wu Song on foot.
Meaning Lin Chong is the ultimate cavalryman, while Wu Song is the best infantryman.
In Water Margin, Lin Chong is one of Liangshan's five tiger generals.
His reputation and martial skill are well-earned.
Yet, Sher Nian created a truly unique image of Lin Chong,
where his will and spirit seem to contrast with his martial talent.
Through this, the author sends a valuable message for us to reflect upon.
Blindly enduring things with cowardice only leads to worse outcomes.
Or as the youths say today, one moment of weakness lets people walk all over you.
Upon hearing his wife was harassed, Lin Chong charged to the scene,
intending to teach them a lesson.
Yet upon learning the harasser was Gao's son, Lin Chong relaxed his fists,
unable to even curse, choosing to swallow his rage and walk away.
Though Lin Chong was fearful of offending the powerful,
his friend Lu Zhixian was a man who feared neither heaven nor earth.
Hearing of the incident, Lu Zhixian went to confront the harasser,
but Lin Chong, ironically, ran to stop him.
Despite such humiliation, Lin Chong remained obsessed with preserving his superior status.
He was simply cowardly.
You must realize that forbearance has its limits, if you only know how to yield,
you simply invite others to exploit you.
Lin Chong yielded time and again, and one step back led to his downfall,
framed for entering the White Tiger Hall and charged with treason,
only to be hounded by Lu Zhixian and lose everything.
Lin Chong's life was spent compromising for the sake of the big picture,
which stripped away his heroic spirit.
Despite his martial prowess, his entire life was ultimately shackled by fear.
Throughout our lives, our most pathetic displays of cowardice often occur right
before those who despise us most.
Everyone aspires to be a Wu Song, but in reality, most end up like Lin Chong.
Temporary peace leads to a lifetime of regret, sometimes you must act.
Rather than endure the torture of the soul, take a stand.
The Second Taboo, Impulsiveness
Li Kuei, known as the Black Whirlwind,
a whirlwind that swirls without regard for direction, much like his own reckless,
impulsive nature.
When Li Kuei first met Song Jiang, the latter simply wanted some fish soup,
and Li Kuei rushed to the riverbank to get it.
In his haste for fresh fish, Li Kuei started a fight with the fishermen
and the merchants along the riverbank.
This triggered a series of unnecessary troubles and endless conflicts.
Song Jiang was a cautious and composed man,
and though Li Kuei was his closest brother,
he failed to learn even a shred of patience from him.
Once, Li Kuei was sent to gather supplies and heard rumors that Song Jiang had kidnapped a girl,
so he charged forward to confront the accusers.
They described Song Jiang as about 40, with dark skin, not too tall, and so on.
Before they could finish, Li Kuei erupted in rage,
shouting that he didn't need to hear more, it was definitely him.
He rushed back to Liangshan, ignored the truth,
confronted Song Jiang, and even defiled the heavenly justice banner.
Later, Li Kuei learned that someone had been impersonating Song Jiang to commit atrocities.
Lu Sun once remarked that he despised rash characters like Zhang Fei and Li Kuei.
They never bothered to discern right from wrong, simply grabbing their axes to lash out.
True wisdom is often hidden within calm and composure.
While great misfortune lies in impulsiveness and rashness,
only with a calm mind can one see the truth of a situation
and resolve problems in a rational manner.
If you only approach tasks with a hot-headed, chaotic mindset,
you will only make matters significantly worse.
In life, it is essential to keep a steady heart and avoid acting in haste.
The Third Taboo, Arrogance
Lu Junyi is a prominent figure in Water Margin,
who, despite few appearances, leaves a lasting impression.
Before joining Liangshan, he was a hero of his region,
known as the Hebei Triple Excellence with unmatched spear skills.
After joining Liangshan, he captured Sherwen Gong and immediately took the second-in-command seat.
Yet, for such a legendary figure as Lu Junyi,
in the eyes of Jin Xingtan, the renowned Chinese critic,
celebrated by later generations as the master of vernacular literature,
he was nothing more than utterly foolish,
appearing to be a major character, but ultimately lacking any true talent.
The reason Jin Xingtan disliked Lu Junyi so much
was primarily due to his intense arrogance.
As a wealthy merchant, Lu led a life of comfort and privilege,
but fell for Wu Yong's schemes, losing his home and wealth, ultimately forced into outlawry.
Song Jian spared no effort in his attempt to bring Lu Junyi to Liangshan.
He had Wu Yong pose as a fortune teller and visit Lu's estate,
claiming that Lu faced a death omen and must flee to Tian in Shandong to avoid it.
Believing it to be true, Lu Junyi immediately packed his belongings to leave.
To reach Tian, he was forced to pass through Liangshan.
Lu's loyal servant, Yan Qing, sensed that something was amiss.
He warned Lu against being reckless, fearing Liangshan outlaws might ambush them.
Yet Lu, always self-righteous and arrogant, cared for no one's opinion.
In his eyes, the famed Liangshan heroes were nothing more than mere bandits.
With this mindset, Lu Junyi set out on his journey.
He fell into Liangshan's trap, lost his home, and was forced to join them.
A gentleman should not boast of his deeds or accomplishments, for ego invites failure.
No matter how brilliant one's achievements, arrogance will surely destroy them.
One must rationally face their flaws, overcome obstacles, and never lose faith.
Even in times of glory, one must never forget the struggles of the past.
The reckless will never succeed, the arrogant will only court disaster.
Lu Junyi serves as the perfect example of this truth.
The fourth taboo, slyness.
Some say Wu Yong is the Zhuge Liang of Liangshan.
In reality, Wu Yong cannot be compared to Zhuge Liang at all.
Most of Wu Yong's schemes were spiteful plots that harmed others for his own gain.
He gained his reputation as the resourceful star simply by being a self-serving, manipulative
opportunist. Before Song Jiang took the lead, Cao Gai was the leader of Liangshan.
Yet shortly after Song Jiang arrived, Wu Yong defected to his side.
Wu chose Song over Cao because he knew Cao sought rebellion, while Song sought amnesty.
Ultimately, Wu Yong and Song Jiang were cut from the same cloth,
both lacked grand vision, craving only rank and status.
They were nothing like Cao Gai, who truly sought to rule and carve out his own kingdom.
Starting your own venture or business is commendable.
Yet a scholar like Wu Yong craved stability and the prestige of an official career.
Thus, Song Jiang was clearly a better fit than Cao Gai.
When everyone felt like rebelling but lacked Song Jiang's approval,
they turned to Wu Yong, the strategist, to plot their insurrection.
Trapped in this agitation, the sly Wu Yong claimed that
a group cannot function without a leader, pushing for a new one.
This, however, required the brother's decision before moving forward.
At this critical moment, Wu Yong used Song Jiang as his shield,
solving the problem while avoiding offending anyone.
It is fair to say that Wu Yong was truly devious.
This sly nature brought him status and military power.
But it ultimately cost him his own life and identity.
Wu Yong's existence revolved entirely around Song Jiang.
After Song Jiang was poisoned, Wu Yong lost his center.
And perhaps suicide was the only logical end for him.
These are the four invaluable lessons Sher Nian embedded in his characters.
What is your perspective on this?
