The Queen has held an audience with Harry Potter creator JK Rowling at the Palace of Holyroodhouse in Edinburgh.
Camilla was pictured smiling and standing side-by-side with the author as the pair met to discuss the importance of young people having access to books.
JK Rowling has become known for her outspoken views and previously been accused of transphobia for her views on gender identity, which she denies.
Speaking with Director of Advocacy at Sex Matters Helen Joyce, Talk's Mark Dolan says: "Are there any aspects to Rowling's remarks over the years that have been divisive or controversial? Do you think she's ever crossed a line?"
Queen Camilla's photo with J.K. Rowling has sparked debate due to Rowling's gender-critical views. Helen Joyce of Sex Matters argues the controversy is manufactured, asserting that Rowling is a defender of women's rights and biological reality. The discussion explores the harms of gender ideology, the evolution of Pride symbols, and the importance of maintaining sex-based protections.
Queen Camilla has sparked controversy by posting a photo with the Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling,
who is a gender-critical feminist. This was a photograph between the Queen and Rowling at
Buckingham Palace during Pride Month. So does she have a case to answer? Let's get the views
of Helen Joyce, Director of Advocacy at Sex Matters. Helen, lovely to see you again. Why
is this such a controversial photograph? I mean it's only controversial with people who want to
make it controversial. J.K. Rowling is a national treasure. Camilla is the Queen. Of course those
two people who both care a lot about getting children reading, and in the case of J.K. Rowling
has done more than anyone else in history to make that happen, can meet each other and post a
beautiful photograph about it. She's immensely popular but of course there are young people,
young women especially, who think that she's a bigot because she says that there are two sexes
and sex can't change and that matters for women's rights. So it's a confected controversy. I go
through King's Cross all the time and you know the model platform nine there? I have never seen it,
not with the long queue. She is not less popular than she was. Young people like to try to pretend
or some young people like to pretend that she is. Efforts to cancel J.K. Rowling have failed
spectacularly, Helen. Are there any aspects to Rowling's remarks over the years that have been
divisive or controversial? Do you think she's ever crossed a line? I mean she's a private
individual as well as a very well-known person. She can phrase things how she likes. I mean
sometimes I would say things more strongly than her, sometimes she would say things more strongly
than me. I think her compassion comes out in a great deal of what she says and especially in
the initial essay that she wrote setting out her opinion. If you read it fairly, as most of the
people who criticise her have never read it at all, let alone fairly, you can see that what she does
is animated by her care and concern for vulnerable people, in particular for women,
women who've been victimised by male violence, children and in particular lesbians. She has a
soft spot for lesbians who come under a great deal of pressure from gender ideology by men who say
that they're women and specifically that they're lesbians. Well that's right, I mean this is one
of the under-reported aspects of gender identity ideology, isn't it Helen, is how arguably homophobic
it is because you will have a little boy or a little girl that is non-gender conforming,
in other words the little boy is perhaps a little feminine in his persona or a girl
the opposite. Back in the day you'd think okay little Johnny's playing with dolls, no problem,
he may or may not go on to become gay. Now these children are being placed on a path to changing
their bodies and changing their identity. Yeah homophobic and sexist, I mean the ideology says
that if you are girly you are a girl, whichever sex you are, if you are boyish you are a boy,
whichever sex you are. I'm old enough to have been brought up in the time when we thought
you know girls can dress how they like and they can go on to go to the moon or be president or
whatever you know and the only things that one sex or the other couldn't do were just things
that were basic biology like a man can never get pregnant. Yeah so I mean gender non-conformity is
more common in children who are going to grow up gay so they have been targeted more than other
children by this but overall it's just super sexist. Yeah I mean it's quite shocking isn't it
and Queen Camilla has been an advocate for women who are victims of emotional abuse, domestic
violence, it's one of her passion projects and really this infringement of women's hard-won
sex-based rights is a very very problematic issue and therefore she's right to stand
shoulder to shoulder with Rowling. I would completely agree and I would also say that
in my experience far fewer young people actually think that J.K. Rowling is a bigot than you would
think when you read pieces like there was a piece in the Daily Mail yesterday talking about how
you know only old people think this as a youngish woman I think 25 saying something like
literally everybody my age agrees with me. Well the polling shows she's wrong there. Most young
people like most old people do not agree with her. I mean there is an age gradient but actually and
the more people know about gender ideology the more they know about how it harms people the more
they see men stealing women's sporting achievements, rapists in women's jails and so on the less they
like it and that is true at every age. And J.K. Rowling has used her financial power and her
platform and her fame to speak up for women's hard-won sex-based rights and for common sense
and for human biology. In the absence of J.K. Rowling this battle for common sense would not
be where it is right now would it? I think that's completely true I mean she makes the news whatever
she does like there isn't another person I don't think who could have a photograph taken with the
Queen and have this the days of discussion in newspapers and opinion pieces and you know shows
like this. So she puts this back on the agenda over and over again and at first people may think
to themselves oh I heard something about her didn't she go a bit bigoted or a bit crazy
and then finally they look into it and they're like oh my goodness is that what's being called
bigoted but I completely agree with that. So she is our absolutely our best ally in this fight and
you know other people are rich enough that they can cope with being cancelled but she's the only
person who really has done this somebody at that global a-list level who has decided that she is
going to use the fact that she is literally uncancellable to stand up against this idiotic
ideology. And Helen it's difficult isn't it because as you say people have a caricature in their mind
of J.K. Rowling partly because how she's been portrayed in the media and in other quarters.
The same issue exists around the pride flag it's pride month now and I think a lot of people that
don't have the detail just think well this is about letting people be gay and live their lives
as they wish but that's not really what the latest incarnation of pride is. That's right I mean the
original pride flag which is just the rainbow was the rainbow symbol which includes everybody
so everybody has a sexuality everybody's included and then they started to add elements to it so
there's a sort of chevron in it now and it's got the trans bit like it's like a sort of a
spearhead coming in and taking over the rainbow and then there's all sorts of other bits to it too
and what it makes is a political statement and a counterfactual statement as well. It's a symbol
of allegiance to the idea that somebody can change sex that that somebody who is girly is a girl and
somebody who is boyish is a boy you know which is completely the reverse of be who you are be
free to love who you love. It's saying if you act a certain way you should probably think of yourself
as something that you aren't and perhaps you know get yourself through some pretty gruesome and
medical treatments as well that end up with sterility and also by the way start destroying
women's rights so yeah so it's it but people don't know that they just think oh it's the
same as you know the old pride. It's a real problem isn't it the public a lot of people
just think you know if I support the pride flag I support pride month corporations are doing it
I'm just being a nice person live and let live which is of course how you feel and how I feel
Helen they don't realize the divisive ideas contained within pride 2.0 which effectively
supports the concept of biological males in female spaces in female prisons and participating
in female sport that's the problem with pride 2.0. Oh I agree but I really think that we are
getting the message out there I mean we see from opinion polling like almost unprecedented shifts
away from agreeing with all this right and we have done ourselves some focus groups and we've heard
people at every age including very young people like 18 to 24 saying things like but why do I have
a pride month when we have only one day for people who died for their country and I mean I completely
agree with that so yes I don't feel pessimistic at all I think that every person who knows more
about this is likely to move towards our position so it's just a question of getting the message
out and JK Rowling is our best help on that. And Helen you know you're not left-wing or right-wing
you're not political you're ultra liberal live and let live you couldn't care less who sleeps with
who else and that's important to put it out there this shouldn't be political do you think we will
look back on this era in let's say 10-15 years time and we'll scratch our head will this war
on the madness of gender identity ideology be won do you think? I'm hopeful but we can't give up
because you know my analogy for it is that it's like bindweed or some you know some awful weed
in your garden that you really have to keep on top to get rid of if you just cut it off the top
it just grows back again you've got to rip it out of the roots it's in all our institutions it's in
the NHS it's in the government all the regulators have got captured by it as you said most big
businesses already say it you know we're seeing that in the very very very slow response to a
supreme court judgment that said sex means sex inequality law and that's well over a year ago
and still government and private sector are mostly not obeying it I think that's unprecedented that
supreme court judgment is being so widely ignored so we can't let up we have to keep going. Helen
always a deep privilege to have you on the show my thanks to Helen choice director of advocacy
at sex matters and a fantastic best-selling author on this issue it's going to be a long battle but
it will be one in the end but we need to keep talking about it and use this platform to do just that.