A small civilian aircraft flew through the heart of Beijing and exposed far more than an air-defense failure. The incident may have revealed two of Xi Jinping's biggest political vulnerabilities: a stalled power struggle inside the PLA surrounding Zhang Youxia and Liu Zhenli, and a growing security crisis for Xi's closest ally, Cai Qi. Could one plane have exposed cracks in both Xi's military control and his inner circle?
Interestingly, just a few hours after Friday's aircraft incident, another political development
quietly unfolded. At 11.12 that evening, that's five hours after the crash, Xinhua released an
announcement stating that 14 officials had been stripped of their status as National People's
Congress deputies. Among them were three full generals and three lieutenant generals.
All 14 are widely believed to have belonged to Xi Jinping's political group or political camp.
The most prominent names were Politburo member Ma Xinrui and Guangdong Provincial CPPCC Vice
Chairman Guo Yonghang. Guo Yonghang was placed under investigation on March 27th,
remember the date, and Ma Xinrui followed on April 3rd. These two individuals are tied.
Guo Yonghang was Ma Xinrui's longtime associate in Guangdong. He was his
chief administrative aide when Ma Xinrui was running Shenzhen. These two are brought down
together because one worked for Ma Xinrui. Guo Yonghang is widely perceived to be removed
because of his tie to Ma Xinrui. But here's where the story becomes much more interesting,
because if the military really is experiencing this level of internal dysfunction,
then what happened politically just a few hours after the crash deserves our attention.
Let's compare those two newly announced cases with those two names, Ma Xinrui and Guo Yonghang,
the two names that I just talked about. Let's compare them with the other two names that I've
talked about many times before, Zhang Youxia and Liu Zhenli. According to official announcements,
Zhang Youxia and Liu Zhenli became under investigation on January 24th, 2026. Yet
as of today, neither of them has been stripped of their status as National People's Congress
deputies. If you visit the MPC's official website today, both men, both generals are still listed
among the 230 or so representatives from the PLA and the People's Armed Police delegation.
Now think about the timeline. Since Zhang and Liu were officially announced under investigation,
the MPC Standing Committee has convened four separate times, February the 4th,
February the 25th to the 26th, April the 27th to the 30th, and then June 23rd to 26th.
Every one of those meetings removed other officials from the MPC, yet Zhang Youxia and
Liu Zhenli remain untouched. Now compare that with Ma Xinrui and Guo Yonghang.
His chief administrative aide was investigated on March 27th, and the Ma followed on April the 3rd.
Less than three months later, both men have already entered the next stage of the disciplinary
process with their MPC delegate status removed. In other words, the newer cases have advanced
ahead of the older ones. Meanwhile, Zhang Youxia and Liu Zhenli have been under investigation for
more than five months, yet their legal status has barely changed. Because as long as they maintain
MPC delegate status, their case cannot enter formal prosecution because MPC delegates cannot
be prosecuted. So viewed together, that timing is difficult to ignore. It suggests Xi Jinping
may be encountering significant internal resistance in trying to remove the two generals,
I mean, in trying to move the two generals' cases forward. And if those two cases continue to stall,
the political consequences for Xi Jinping could become increasingly serious. But the military
may not be the only place where Xi Jinping suddenly finds himself under pressure. Another
person who may have been an even more direct political hit from last Friday's aviation
incident is Xi Jinping's closest political ally, Cai Qi. So why Cai Qi? Because as director of the
CCP General Office and the official responsible for the Central Security Bureau, the very agency
that protects CCP leadership, Cai Qi ultimately oversees the security of Zhongnanhai and the
personal protection of China's top leadership. Simply put, that's his job. And according to
the reports we've just discussed, after the aircraft left its assigned flight path,
it remained airborne for nearly 20 minutes before crashing into the city tower. During the entire
period, during that 20 minutes, neither the military nor civilian authorities
mounted any effective interception. Politically, someone has to answer for it. And inside the
party, that responsibility almost inevitably falls on Cai Qi. So there's really no way for
him to avoid it. Remember, Cai isn't just Xi Jinping's chief of staff. He oversees Beijing's
entire security apparatus. He's responsible for protecting the top leadership. He oversees
the Central Security Bureau. He also heads the office of the National Security Commission,
coordinating national security affairs at the highest level. That means protecting Zhongnanhai,
protecting senior party leaders, coordinating nationwide security operations, even monitoring
the movements and activities of certain senior officials. All of that falls within Cai Qi's
portfolio. So if a small civilian aircraft can wander through Beijing's most sensitive airspace
before striking the city's tallest building, it inevitably raises serious questions about
Beijing's security system. And politically, the blame almost certainly lands on Cai Qi.
But his problem may not stop just there. His son could also find himself caught in the political
storm. I have a picture of his son. It's tiny. The young man circled in orange is Cai Erjing.
So Cai Erjing is deeply involved in one of Beijing's newest strategic industries. I told
was one of Xi Jinping's strategic industries. Now, according to public information,
Cai Erjing currently serves as deputy director of the National Development and Reform Commission's
Department of Low Altitude Economy Development. Although the department has an official director,
reports say that Cai Erjing, the junior Cai, serves as the executive deputy overseeing
the department's day-to-day operations. From a political perspective, this has always been
viewed as an extremely important appointment. The low altitude economy has been promoted
as one of China's future economic growth engines. Had everything gone according to plan,
Cai junior might well have positioned himself for rapid promotion over the next several years.
But then came last Friday's aircraft incident, which many people say has turned against the
low altitude economy. It's going to be killed. There's no way central government or provincial
governments are going to promote this because it's at the cost of their safety. When that happens,
the executive official overseeing the sector, meaning Cai Erjing, could easily become the
person held responsible. The accusation writes itself, you focused on economic development
while neglecting national security. You promoted low altitude aviation, and now let's look at what
happened. Politically, it would be an extremely convenient narrative for Cai's opponent.
And that's where the irony becomes especially striking. Xi Jinping has repeatedly argued that
political security and national security must always take priority over economic development.
For years, he has insisted that security comes first. Now, Xi Jinping's opponents inside the
system can simply turn his own political logic against one of his closest allies. If Beijing
has just experienced its biggest security embarrassment in years under Cai Qi's watch,
and if Cai Qi's own son happens to oversee one of the sectors most closely associated with low
altitude aviation, then Xi Jinping has very little room to defend either of them. After all,
they would simply be applying Xi Jinping's own standard and logic. So politically speaking,
that may be exactly what makes this incident so dangerous for both Cai Qi and Xi Jinping.
From that perspective, one could argue that Friday's aircraft incident is,
at least indirectly, connected to the unresolved Zhang Youxia-Liu Zhenli cases.