Europe's automotive industry is facing a historic crisis as Volkswagen weighs unprecedented factory closures and massive job cuts. However, the root of the problem isn't just high energy costs or European bureaucracy—it's China Shock 2.0. With Chinese electric vehicle (EV) manufacturers building cars significantly faster and for thousands of euros less, traditional German automakers are rapidly losing market share both at home and abroad. This video analyzes the structural trade imbalances flooding the market with subsidized EVs, explains why laying off workers won't solve Volkswagen's €6,000 per-car cost gap, and examines whether new European Union tariffs will protect domestic manufacturing or simply trigger a costly global trade war.
AI Generated·May contain errors
If you look at Volkswagen's stock chart over the last five years, it doesn't really look like a
90-year-old industrial titan. It looks more like an altcoin that got rug pulled by its own founding
team. The stock is down more than 65%, trading at its lowest level since 2010. Which means,
and I want you to sit with this, it's now cheaper than it was during Dieselgate,
the scandal where Volkswagen got caught building cars that lied to government regulators for a
living. Somehow, the current situation is worse. Volkswagen is, according to two people who are
definitely going to be having an uncomfortable conversation with HR, considering breaking a
taboo that it's held for the entire corporate history, cutting up to 100,000 jobs and closing
four factories in Germany. I say considering because nothing has actually been signed yet.
The supervisory board doesn't officially meet to look at the proposal until July 9th.
But when three different newspapers all report the exact same number in the same week, you can safely
assume that someone in Wolfsburg has already started drafting the corporate euphemisms.
Personally, I'm waiting to see whether they call it streamlining operations
or right-sizing the corporate footprint. I've got some money on right-sizing.
Either way, we're talking about roughly one-sixth of their entire global workforce
at a company that as recently as late 2024 promised its own unions in writing that there
would be absolutely no planned closures until 2030 at the earliest. We've now learned that a
corporate guarantee from a car manufacturer has a shelf life of about 80 months. They're not alone,
which I suppose is meant to be reassuring in the way that it's reassuring to know that other people
are also falling off the same cliff as you are. BMW says it'll spend up to a billion euros on
restructuring, which analysts translate as another 10,000 job cuts and a 15% cut to European car
production. Mercedes-Benz has postponed a summer bonus worth nearly a fifth of a month's salary
for 90,000 workers and is asking everyone else to go back to working a 40-hour week for 35 hours
worth of pay. And it's not just the German brands either. Peugeot managed to deliver just 373 cars
in Australia in the first five months of this year. To put that in perspective, Ferrari sells
more cars in Australia than that. Their local distributor has now decided that it no longer
wants to be in the Peugeot business. Ask a European official why any of this is happening
and you'll get the same three culprits every time. High energy costs, an aging workforce,
and red tape from Brussels. Notice what's missing from that list. It's a bit like asking a man why
his house burnt down and getting a very detailed lecture about the flammability of his curtains.
It might be true, but it completely ignores the guy standing on the lawn with an empty gas can.
There is of course something to all of those issues. Germany and Europe as a whole have
major structural problems and trying to do business in the EU can feel like being trapped
in a Kafka novel. The decision to rely solely on cheap Russian energy was a monumental mistake
and then suddenly not having any was an energy shock of historic proportions, made even worse
by the military disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz. But if you actually look at the numbers,
red tape and demographics doesn't really explain what's happened.
Bloomberg research puts about 40% of Germany's recent GDP shortfall down to the energy shock
and another 40% down to lost export markets. The remaining 20% is weak domestic demand and
bureaucracy. So, German politicians have taken the 80-20 rule and confidently applied it backwards.
Countries right next door like the Netherlands and Denmark deal with exactly the same EU paperwork,
yet somehow their economies keep growing. The real problem isn't a sudden increase in forms,
it's a sudden lack of anyone willing to buy what Germany makes. For decades, Germany ran the
textbook trade surplus economy. Build extremely complicated expensive machines, sell them to the
rest of the world and repeat. But today, the rest of the world, and specifically China, is no longer
buying. The trade chief in Brussels knows the relationship has flipped so hard that the EU is
now running a trade deficit with China of roughly a billion euros a day. The economist Adam Tooze
has described what's happening between Germany and China as mercantilist on mercantilist violence,
which is both a wonderful phrase and an accurate description. According to Tooze,
60% of the massive 27 billion euro swing in Germany's trade balance with China between
2021 and 2025 was accounted for entirely by vehicles. For a hundred years, German car makers
assumed their advantage. The ability to build a flawless combustion engine was permanent,
but the forced transition to building electric vehicles changed the rules of the game entirely.
The Chinese didn't just catch up with battery chemistry and software, they lapped everyone else.
Before we dig into how that happened, let me tell you about this week's video sponsor ZocDoc.
If you're based in the US, healthcare administration can involve a baffling amount
of friction, bureaucracy and waiting. If you try and book a non-emergency appointment with your
doctor, you're often put on hold and after an endless loop of annoying music are told that
the next available appointment is in six weeks time. You often give up at this point, tell
yourself you'll try again later and don't. ZocDoc is designed to short circuit that annoying process.
It's a free platform where you can search for local in-network doctors across more than 200
specialties, GPs, dermatologists, physios and instead of calling anyone you can see
real appointment availability and book instantly online. Most appointments happen within 24 to 72
hours. There are over 150,000 providers across all 50 states with verified patient reviews and
full profiles so you can make an informed choice without the guesswork. It is, in short, what
booking anything else online has looked like for the past 20 years, finally applied to the one area
where it really matters. Head to ZocDoc.com forward slash Patrick Boyle or click the link
in the description to try it out. Your future self will be considerably less annoyed.
To understand how Chinese manufacturers managed to sidestep a century of European engineering
dominance, you need to understand something the industry is now calling China Speed. European
and American car makers typically run product development cycles of 40 to 80 months. Chinese
firms, on the other hand, can get a brand new model out the door in under 24 months. That's
a lot faster. They manage this with flat management structures, punishing work hours,
and by applying a software industry attitude towards quality control. Where they first ship
the car and if there are any problems, fix them later with an over-the-air update once people
start complaining on social media. This is a very different approach to running a car company,
not one that I would have picked, but here we are. China Speed explains how they are developing and
building cars so fast, but it doesn't explain the wave currently hitting Europe. That's a separate
thing, and economists have started calling it China Shock 2.0. The first China Shock, or China
Shock 1.0, hit after China's entry into the WTO in 2001. It mostly wiped out low-wage manufacturing,
things like toys, furniture, and basic electronics – industries that were never going to define
any country's long-term economic future. And these industries were a much smaller slice
of the global economy at the time. It hit the American Rust Belt hard, but Germany did just
fine because a rapidly industrializing China needed enormous amounts of heavy machinery,
chemicals, and vehicles. And Germany happened to make exactly those types of goods,
and could sell them to China. China Shock 2.0 is a very different animal. China's economy today is
about 18% of global GDP, so any growth in its exports is growing from a vastly larger base.
And that export growth is now concentrated in precisely the capital and technology-intensive
sectors Europe used to have to itself. China doesn't need German machine tools anymore.
In fact, that relationship has now flipped. Since mid-2025, according to the Center for
European Reform, Germany has been buying more capital goods from China than it sells them.
It's a bit like selling a man a complete set of precision tools, only to look out your front
window a few years later and realize that he's used them to take the wheels off your car.
The scale of this is hard to overstate. China's auto exports are expected to approach 10 million
vehicles this year. A lot of the exports are being driven by weakness at home. Domestic car sales
fell 22.3% in China year on year in May, according to Reuters. Manufacturers who are stuck
in a brutal domestic price war are dumping their surplus production onto the rest of the world,
instead of trying to sell them to buyers in China. In a normal functioning economy,
a surge in exports would come with some offsetting correction. According to the
Michael Pettis, rising production should mean rising wages. Rising wages should mean rising
domestic consumption. Rising domestic consumption should mean rising imports. Or, failing that,
the resulting trade surplus should push the currency up, making exports more expensive
and closing the gap on its own. Neither of those things is happening. Adjusted for inflation,
the renminbi has actually depreciated by around 15% over the last five years or so.
This is not a coincidence. Brad Setzer and Sander Tordwar have written that Chinese
state banks routinely intervene in currency markets, buying dollars to keep the renminbi
cheap. The IMF puts the undervaluation at around 16%. Setzer and Tordwar think that the real number
is considerably higher. They note that Beijing even changed how it calculates its own trade
surplus back in 2022. Foreign firms operating inside China now get classified as running a
trade deficit against China, which conveniently makes the real surplus harder for anyone outside
the country to see. So, China isn't just competing hard, it's working its way around all of the
mechanisms that would usually correct for these problems, and exporting the imbalance directly
onto everyone else's books instead, which leaves Europe's car makers staring at a problem that
doesn't actually have a solution on their end. The traditional corporate response to shrinking
profits is simple. You fire people. If the business model is under siege, you call a
press conference, explain to shareholders that you are streamlining operations to achieve lean
agile efficiency. If you are feeling ambitious, you blame the headcount reduction on AI.
Car executives are discovering that this particular trick doesn't work. Take Volkswagen's
restructuring plan. The average VW employee in Germany costs the company roughly €70,000 a
year in wages and benefits, according to the FT. Cut €100,000 of them and you save about €7B a
year. Close those factories and you shave another €3B off capital spending. All in, that's €10B a
year. Spread that across the 9 million cars Volkswagen sells annually and you get a saving
of roughly €1,000 per car. Assuming you can still build the cars without the workers in the
factories. This would be a great plan if you weren't competing against people who can build the
same car for €6,000 less. McKinsey puts the Chinese cost advantage on EV production at 20-50%.
On a Volkswagen that costs roughly €30,000 to build, that's a gap of at least €6,000 per car.
So Volkswagen's historic once in 90 years layoff proposal is designed to claw back €1,000 per car.
The competition is already ahead by €6,000 per car or more. It just doesn't add up. Firing the
isn't curing the disease, it's just a fairly dramatic way of treating one symptom of it.
European car makers can't even count on a slow market to buy them more time to figure out
software. For a while, it looked like the real story here was just EV fatigue, that after getting
burned on depreciation, consumers had gone off electric cars altogether. If you only look at
America, you'd believe that. Since the Trump administration phased out the federal EV tax
credit at the end of 2025 and rolled back Biden-era emissions rules, US EV sales have
dropped by roughly 27% in the first quarter of this year. Off a cliff more or less.
Europe is a very different story. European car makers operate under strict fleet emission
targets. Miss the EV quota and Brussels fines you into the ground. So selling EVs isn't optional.
European drivers don't get cheap domestic fuel the way Americans do either.
Gasoline in Europe costs almost 70% more than in the United States.
When the war in Iran escalated and the Strait of Hormuz closed,
European drivers ran towards electric cars to get away from high prices.
Tesla, which had been in a multi-year European slump, saw sales jump in the first half of the
year. The problem was never that Europeans stopped buying electric cars, it's that they
stopped buying European electric cars. They are buying the flood of cheaper Chinese alternatives
instead. Cars that come with voice controlled AI and charging speeds that make European EVs
look like they are running on a phone charger. One of BYD's new Denza models can apparently go
from empty to 70% charged in just 5 minutes. Good luck selling a European EV that takes 40 minutes
to charge when the car next to it at the station leaves before you've finished your coffee.
Since traditional manufacturers can't compete on price, the EV subsidies EU governments hand out
often just function as a taxpayer-funded discount on Chinese cars.
Brussels' response to this criticism is something called the Industrial Accelerator Act,
which tries to restrict those subsidies to vehicles actually assembled in Europe,
with local content requirements attached. The Chinese manufacturers found the loophole
almost immediately. They are moving into the exact factories the western car makers are abandoning.
Because their EV divisions are losing money, Ford and Nissan have been cutting production
and leaving huge plants sitting half empty. If you're a Chinese EV brand, the playwrights
don't export the car and eat the tariff. You take over the empty plant, do final assembly there,
and then the car officially qualifies for European subsidies, paid for by European taxpayers
to build cars that are putting European workers out of the job.
The furniture is being swapped out in real time.
Cherry is moving into a former Nissan factory in Barcelona later this year,
and is in advanced talks to take over freed up lines at Nissan's plant in Sunderland.
Geely is taking an idle haul at a Ford plant near Valencia in Spain.
BYD is in talks to take over half of Volkswagen's Dresden factory, the glass-walled one that
Volkswagen used to show off to customers who liked to watch their car being built.
Stellantis has entered a joint venture to build vehicles for China's Dongfeng
inside its own historic post-war plant in Rhein.
On paper, European executives are calling this a win-win. Someone pays rent on the
empty real estate. Local politicians get to save a few thousand jobs. Everyone claps.
Rest of World quoted an industrial consultant, Babak Hazfei,
who pointed out the actual long-term cost.
The issue is that these deals hand rivals instant local legitimacy,
access to local supplier networks, and a clean way around EU import tariffs all at once.
Philippe Guilleron, a union rep at Stellantis, put it better than I can when he told Bloomberg,
when your tech know-how is gone, it becomes nearly impossible to make a comeback down the road.
It's as if somebody started cooking your meals for you all the time.
In the end, you no longer know how to cook for yourself.
Once a manufacturer is running on Chinese batteries, Chinese software, and Chinese
vehicle architecture, it isn't really a manufacturer anymore. It's a marketing
department putting a familiar badge on someone else's car.
Which leaves Western leaders with an actual question to answer. What do you do about an
export shock that's turning your industrial base into a chain of very well-branded distribution
centers? When an industrial foundation starts to crack, the immediate political instinct
is to panic and start pouring concrete. If foreign goods are arriving too fast and too cheap,
you simply build a giant wall. But as economists like Brad Setzer and Michael Pettis have pointed
out, a modern trade war isn't a simple masonry job, it's a complex architecture problem.
Start with the structural power dynamics. Michael Pettis has long argued that in any
trade dispute, it's actually the importing countries, the deficit economies, holding
the good cards. An export-driven economy like China depends entirely on foreign consumers to
absorb its enormous state-subsidized overcapacity. Cut off a major market and the domestic engine
hits a wall. Surplus nations like Germany used to resist this logic because they thought of
themselves as part of the same exporters club. That gets harder to maintain once China's
manufactured goods surplus reaches roughly 2 trillion euros, a number that matches the
entire national income of Italy. The trouble, according to Setzer, is that Europe's existing
toolkit was built for a much smaller problem. The European Commission currently relies on
product-by-product trade investigations, slow, bureaucratic, and trivially easy to route around.
Case in point, when the EU slapped countervailing duties on Chinese battery EVs,
manufacturers simply changed lanes, monthly battery EV sales slowed, and imports of Chinese
hybrids into Europe surged 155% almost overnight. Tordwar and Setzer say that the result is a leaky
bucket of product-by-product duties, for instance on Chinese truck tires but not electric trucks,
and on EVs but not hybrids. Trying to defend an entire industrial economy one product line at a
time is like bailing out a flooded basement with a teaspoon, which has led to a fight over how high
the wall should go. France's national planning office has floated a flat 30% tariff on all
Chinese imports, a truly drastic proposal, and one that comes with a real risk of triggering a
beggar-thy-neighbor spiral where everyone scrambles to protect their own slice of an increasingly
shrinking pie. History shows how that tends to work out. In the run-up to the Great Depression,
the United States passed the Smoot-Hawley tariff act. At the time, America was the dominant economic
power on the planet, running huge surpluses and responsible for nearly 16% of global exports.
The tariffs were meant to protect American farmers and factories. The timing was, in retrospect,
not great. Trading partners around the world retaliated immediately. Global trade seized up
and American exports fell by more than 65% within three years. The wall didn't keep the trouble out,
it locked everyone in with it, and made the Great Depression much worse than it needed to be.
To avoid repeating that particular mistake, Tordoir and Setzer have proposed something
closer to a scalpel. They want Brussels to build a European version of America's Section 301.
The 1974 trade law that lets Washington investigate economy-wide unfair practices
rather than suing over one product at a time. They argue that a European 301 type instrument
would allow Brussels to respond to systemic distortions that fall outside traditional trade
defense, notably China's persistent currency undervaluation and macroeconomic policies
that generate demand externally while suppressing it at home. A 301 does not imply indiscriminate
tariffs on all Chinese imports, but flexibility to apply a remedy on key sectors. This type of
tool, they say, would let Brussels flexibly target the sectors that matter most – autos, machinery,
chemicals, batteries, cleantech, and the semiconductors – to build them.
Emmanuel Macron put the underlying complaint about as bluntly as it can be put. He's told
the Chinese more or less that a trade surplus built on importing almost nothing isn't sustainable
because it slowly kills off your own customers. Even a perfectly targeted tariff, though,
can't override basic accounting. A trade deficit simply means that a country is consuming more than
it produces and saving too little. If you use a tariff wall to shift production from an efficient
foreign factory to a slightly less efficient one in another country, you haven't touched that
underlying macroeconomic imbalance. You've just forced the local consumer to pay more to sustain
it. What all of this really marks is the end of a 30-year design rule for global trade – efficiency
first. Western economies didn't outsource their manufacturing base by accident or because
they weren't paying attention. They did it because in a stable world with open sea lanes,
optimizing for immediate cost efficiency was the entirely rational choice. Stretching a supply
chain across an ocean to save a few cents on a component makes perfect economic sense
right up until the moment where it doesn't. That era appears to be over. As trust between
the major trading blocks runs out, the global economy is splitting into something closer to
autarky – a self-sufficiency motivated mostly by fear. Governments and boardrooms are looking at
how exposed their delivery routes actually are and deciding that the efficiency of global
integration isn't worth the strategic risk anymore. We seem to be moving from free markets into a
higher cost and less efficient one where businesses pay a premium for the comfort of redundancy,
building duplicate plans and trading mainly with countries they trust politically. It means higher
prices for consumers and thinner margins for businesses. The old rules of global trade were
designed to reward the most efficient operator on the planet. The new ones are being designed to
make sure everyone pays a permanent premium just to keep the gates closed. If you found this video
interesting, you should watch my video on Brexit 10 years later – what it actually cost Britain
next. Don't forget to check out our sponsor ZocDoc using the link in the description.
Have a great day and see you in the next video. Bye.