Leave a 🇺🇸 in the comments FOR THE ALGORITHM! The Supreme Court has reaffirmed birthright citizenship as the law of the land. Trump is furious - but he may just have an ace up his sleeve.
Join our fight to expose what powerful people want to keep covered up—regardless of political affiliation: http://americauncovered.tv
The Supreme Court struck down an executive order attempting to end birthright citizenship, ruling 6-3 that those born on US soil are citizens regardless of parental status. While the ruling maintains the status quo, the Trump administration is pursuing legislative changes and aggressive immigration enforcement to limit the practice.
The Supreme Court has reaffirmed birthright citizenship as the law of the land.
Trump is furious, but he may just have an ace up his sleeve.
Welcome to America Uncovered, I'm Chris Chappell.
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court finally made its decision on Trump v. Barbara,
the case challenging President Trump's executive order to end birthright citizenship
for the children of illegal immigrants and temporary visitors.
The final vote was 6-3, striking down the executive order.
Chief Justice Roberts wrote the majority opinion,
joined by Sotomayor, Kagan, Barrett, and Jackson.
Justice Kavanaugh agreed with the outcome, though for different reasons,
while Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch dissented.
In essence, the court reaffirmed birthright citizenship.
If you're born on US soil, you are a citizen.
It doesn't matter who your parents are, how they got here, or how long they were planning to stay.
So let's just take a minute to look at what the justices actually said about the case.
Roberts leaned on history.
US soli, the right of the soil, goes back to English common law.
And it's been a more or less settled issue since the 1898 case of Wong Kim Ark,
where the court held the Citizenship Clause incorporated the common law
and granted citizenship to nearly all children born in the United States.
He also rejected the Trump administration's argument that
citizenship should depend on your parents having
primary allegiance or domicile within the US, as dramatically revisionist.
Justice Clarence Thomas, meanwhile, wrote the dissent.
A whole 91 pages of it.
His argument was that the 14th Amendment was never meant to be universal.
Rather, it was specifically meant to give citizenship to freed slaves and their children—
people who never knew any home besides America.
To quote Justice Thomas,
Blacks were entitled to citizenship because they were Americans.
They had no other homeland, owed no allegiance to any foreign power,
and were subject to no other authority.
And he continues by adding that the court's decision
adds to the sad history of the 14th Amendment,
which was designed and understood to secure equal rights for the freed Blacks,
but has instead been repurposed for political projects
that the Reconstruction Congress did not support.
Now, I mentioned Justice Kavanaugh,
and how he agreed with the majority's opinion that the executive order should be struck down,
though for slightly different reasons.
In his view, the order wasn't unconstitutional,
but rather it violated a federal statute.
Which means technically,
Congress could change the statute without touching the Constitution.
We'll come back to that, because Trump definitely took notice.
Ok, so all things considered,
very little has changed as a result of this case.
Legally speaking, we're living in the same world as we were the day before the ruling.
Though I suppose if you checked the discussion happening on X,
you'd think we're on the brink of a civil war.
But is all the panic and outrage justified?
Probably not.
Though critics of the decision do make some valid points.
You see, unrestricted birthright citizenship is pretty rare.
Countries that have it are concentrated almost entirely in the Americas.
And that's not a coincidence.
A good portion of why comes down to a holdover from the early colonial period.
A bunch of underpopulated New World territories desperately needed people—
to explore, to settle, to farm.
So they made citizenship as easy as showing up and having a baby.
This used to be the policy back in Europe, too.
But as these countries developed, and all the empty space was filled up,
the rule of the land was replaced by the rule of blood.
Basically, to become a citizen, at least one of your parents also has to be a citizen.
The UK dropped the rule of the land in 1983.
Ireland got rid of it in 2004.
Australia, New Zealand, France, India, and most of the world go by rule of blood.
So the US is kind of a strange outlier among the more developed nations.
And this has a real impact on the country's demographics,
its economy, its culture, and its politics.
Let me give you some numbers that may actually shock you.
According to Pew Research, about 9% of US births in 2023
were to unauthorized or temporary legal immigrant mothers.
That's roughly 320,000 babies in a single year.
And about 260,000 of those specifically
wouldn't have qualified for citizenship under Trump's executive order.
Just to give you a sense of scale,
2014 saw around 297,000 births to undocumented parents,
7.5% of the country's total births.
That number was larger than the total number of births
in any state other than California and Texas.
It was larger than the total number of births
in 16 states plus the District of Columbia combined.
And keep in mind, these are just snapshots.
The number of these births tend to ebb and flow
with how well the border is being enforced.
So in a scenario where you have massive influxes of people,
like we saw under the Biden administration,
the numbers tend to be much higher.
So yeah, you can see how this kind of thing could be destabilizing.
And this is to say nothing of the whole industry of birth tourism.
That term is usually defined super narrowly.
It basically just means someone who traveled here specifically to give birth.
In terms of raw numbers, it's pretty rare.
But the mere fact that it's even legal
tells you a lot about how broken the underlying system is.
Take for example, Xu Bo.
He's a Chinese billionaire, the founder of a gaming company called Duoyin Network.
According to a Weibo post from his account,
he was seeking to have 50 high-quality sons via American surrogates,
fantasizing that his American-born kids would marry Elon Musk's children.
And this isn't some one-off case.
The owner of one California surrogacy agency
said he personally helped fill an order for a single Chinese parent for 100 children.
So we have Chinese billionaires buying citizenship for children
who may never even set foot in this country unless it's to collect a passport.
Wonderful.
Trump made sure to congratulate President Xi and the great country of China
on their massive birthright citizenship win.
Alright, so what happens now?
The law is the law, at least for the foreseeable future.
What's Trump's response to the ruling, besides the usual sarcasm?
I guess I have to accept it's the Supreme Court, so I'll accept.
I don't know, it's up to them.
Uh, that's...weirdly humble, especially from him.
Mr. President, are you feeling alright?
Don't worry, he was back to his usual self-on-truth social,
where he said,
The Supreme Court upheld birthright citizenship,
which is too bad for our country,
but we can easily make it up in Congress through legislation,
with the support of the President,
that now has been determined during this process.
No long unwieldy constitutional amendment is necessary.
Remember what I said about Kavanaugh's opinion,
and how he saw the problem with Trump's executive order
as a violation of statutes, not the Constitution?
This is basically what Trump's talking about.
Within hours of the Supreme Court's ruling,
Tennessee Congressman Andy Augles introduced something called,
and I promise I'm not making this up,
the Anchors Away Act.
The bill would redefine federal law so that a kid only counts as a citizen
if at least one parent is already a citizen or legal resident.
And it would also let border officials
turn away pregnant travelers outright.
Speaker Mike Johnson said Republican leadership is already looking at it.
Lindsey Graham says he's making it a top priority.
And Senator Eric Schmidt said Kavanaugh may have left Congress a door.
He's filing legislation to walk through it.
Now, I'd be doing you a disservice if I didn't give you an honest read here.
Kavanaugh's actual theory is narrower than these bills are treating it.
He thinks Congress can carve out limited exceptions
similar to existing ones like diplomats' kids,
not rewrite the whole rule.
But getting that done is far from certain.
Which is probably why the administration isn't putting all its chips on Congress.
Because there's a second lever
they don't need anybody's permission to pull.
Immigration enforcement.
On the same day as the ruling,
the Justice Department sent a memo to every US attorney's office in the country
ordering them to prioritize the investigation and prosecution of birth tourism schemes.
Visa fraud, wire fraud, money laundering, identity theft, healthcare fraud—
it's all on the table now for anyone connected to these operations.
And that's really just the leading edge of a process that's been building over a year.
Legal immigration overall is already down more than 600,000 people under this administration.
H-1B visas got hit with a $100,000 fee.
And eligible applications dropped 27%.
Refugee admissions are capped at 17,500 for the entire year.
Visas have been fully or partially paused for nationals of 39 countries,
and immigrant visas specifically paused for 75 more.
If Trump can't end birthright citizenship,
he'll settle for making sure as few people as possible
can get here to give birth in the first place.
The legislative path is slow and uncertain,
and would likely end up right back in the hands of the same Supreme Court.
But enforcement is already underway.
It doesn't need to wait on Congress.
The door to enter the US will get narrower and narrower until it slams shut.
Or at least until another president reverses course.
But what do you think?
Leave a comment below.
I read as many as I can.
But I read every comment on AmericaUncovered.tv,
where you'll get access to thousands of episodes ad-free,
plus a community chat, live streams, and more.
Once again, I'm Chris Chappell.
Thanks for watching America Uncovered.