Goats Or Sheep - Which Animal Is Better For Your Farm Or Homestead.

Cattle farm
8 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 2, 2026
Thinking of adding some goats or sheep to your farm or homestead? Learn some of the main differences between sheep and goats, and let us help you decide which one is better suited for your land and for your needs.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedJulie explains the fundamental differences between sheep and goats to help homesteaders choose the right animal. While both are ruminants, they differ significantly in eating habits, personality, maintenance, and utility. The choice depends on the land available, the desired products (meat, milk, or fiber), and the owner's preference for animal temperament.
Hi friends! My name is Julie and welcome back to my farm. In this video I'm going to help you
decide whether sheep or goats would be the right animal for your farm or homestead.
Now most people don't even know that there's a difference between sheep or goats. They may think
that goats are just a horned version of a sheep, but that couldn't be farther from the truth.
They're actually very different. Now while they're both ruminants, which means they have
a four-chamber digestive system including a rumen that helps them to ferment and digest
grass and other forage. Each species is more specialized to eat different types of forage.
Sheep are known as grazers and that means they're more suited to eat grass off the ground,
whereas goats are known as browsers, which means they're more suited to eat taller weeds or leafy
greens that are more eye level. They actually have very different anatomy of the muscles in
their neck where it takes much less effort for a sheep to have its nose to the ground
than it does for a goat who is more suited to have their head up high.
And while both sheep and goats can subsist on pretty much the same sort of forage, for example
goats will eat some grass and sheep will eat some weeds and leafy greens, but they are specialized
to eat one or the other. And they do have different mineral needs. For example, goats have a high need
for copper, whereas anything over a trace amount for sheep can be actually lethal. One of the
biggest differences in my mind is the personality of the two. Goats tend to be much friendlier and
more social with humans. They're also more trainable. They really follow routine very well
and that can make them very easy to handle. Where sheep on the other hand are very skittish and have
much more of a prey mentality, even when I've raised bottle baby lambs and handled them quite
a bit when they're young, they really don't want to interact with me much once they get older.
Whereas even a skittish goat I could win over with just some treats. Another big difference is that
in general most goats have horns, whereas in sheep most breeds don't have horns. And there
are definitely exceptions to both rules. Now the presence of horns on your animals
offer some unique challenges. It can make them a little more dangerous. You definitely don't
want an animal to use those against you. And you have to be a little more careful about fencing.
For both our sheep and goats we primarily use the electric netting fence powered by a solar
energizer. And that allows us to rotationally graze in any area we need to on this property.
But we do have some areas, especially our main pasture, which is fenced in welded wire or field
fence. And this large square field fence can be really dangerous for goats that have horns.
They can stick their head through and then when they go to retract their head their horns will
catch like a barb. It can cause them to panic. It can cause them to actually strangle themselves.
And they definitely are more likely to jump or duck under a fence than a sheep would be. Now
that's not to say that sheep won't get out of your fence too, but in my experience they're
much more docile and more likely to stay in. Now you may have heard that goats can be naughty and
that's definitely true. Goats are naturally very curious and they like to jump on things,
including you. But this also means they can be rough on your barns and your equipment.
They are much more likely to jump on their hay bale and waste all their hay or destroy the nice
hay feeder that you built them. So goats tend to get bored and they're more playful. They want to
jump up on stuff and you just have to be aware of that. You have to be a little more vigilant
making sure your areas are goat safe. If you're going to have your animals around trees,
goats are much more likely to strip the bark off of them than sheep. If you were thinking about
raising these animals on a property that's not yours, you want to make sure that there's not
something there they're going to destroy. For example, you can raise sheep on a solar panel
field and it's a great way to access free grazing. You're definitely going to want to
have sheep out there because goats are much more likely to jump on the panels and damage them.
Sheep are more gentle with their environment. I've even seen them used in vineyards to trim the grape
leaves. Another difference can be in the maintenance of these animals. In my experience,
my flock of sheep needs their hooves maintained a lot less frequently than my goats. Some of my
goats need as often as a monthly trim, whereas I can get away with not trimming my sheep hooves for
sometimes a year, sometimes more. Now we raise a hair sheep on this farm, but many breeds grow
wool and that needs to be sheared every year, so that's a consideration if you're going to
raise a wool breed of sheep. Both are fairly susceptible to parasites. I think goats are
easier to detect when they do get sick and when they need treatment just because of their social
nature, whereas sheep are much more likely to hide the symptoms of disease until it is far more
progressed. And if you're thinking about getting dairy goats, especially high producing dairy goats,
you're going to have to be much more vigilant about the health of their udder. Those goats
will be producing a larger volume of milk and will have a larger udder, which is going to have more
contact with the ground, versus a sheep's udder, which is quite small usually and tucked up under
their body. That contact with the ground is going to make a goat more susceptible to infection
through her teeth, especially if the ground is poopy or dirty. So keeping these differences in
mind, your next consideration should be, why do you want these animals? What are your goals in adding
these animals to your farm or homestead? The first question I would ask is, which is better suited to
my land? So if you have more forest, more weeds and brush that you need to clear, then goats are
definitely the better choice. If you have big open pastures or just a lawn that you're tired of mowing,
then sheep are a better way to go. Now while you can keep a small number of animals in a fixed area
or a barn, it's good to remember that it is much better for their health to have them outside and
moving around and eating fresh natural forage. Maybe you simply want a pet or a companion for
say your horse or donkey, then I think a goat would be a much better choice just because of their
social nature. And of course the big three reasons that people would be interested in small livestock
like sheep or goats is for meat, milk or fiber. And for each of these purposes, there are really breeds
in each species that would fit. But in general, you're going to have an easier time finding a nice
dairy goat. There are several dairy breeds that produce a lot of milk, whereas in sheep there are
only a few, namely the East Frisian. And the volume a sheep is going to produce is never really going
to compare with a high producing goat. Although the milk does have different quality, sheep milk
is much higher in fat. And there are certain cheeses that you make specifically with sheep's
milk. When it comes to meat, I would pick whichever one that you like to eat better. Now lamb tends to
be a little bit fattier than goat, but in my opinion goat has a richer flavor. If you're looking
to sell that meat, then lamb is definitely an easier sell, but there are some markets for goat
as well. It's just a matter of what is popular in your area and what sort of marketing that you want
to do for those products. And then there's fiber. There are several really nice wool breeds that you
could choose from, whereas in goats it's really limited to the angoras and those can be difficult
to find. So as you can see, the purpose for the animal is going to really determine which one is
right for you. I really enjoy raising both of these species and I hope this video helped you
if you're trying to decide which one is right for your farm or homestead. If you'd like to learn more
about how we raise our sheep, you can click right here. And if you'd like to learn more about how we
raise our goats, click over here. Thanks for watching, guys, and we'll see you next time.
