Supreme Court strikes down State gun law in massive Second Amendment win

Facts Matter
2.9K followers
🇺🇸 Try The Epoch Times 👉 https://ept.ms/ReadEpochTimes
🟡 Up to $20,000 of Free Silver: https://ept.ms/3biH9MN
In what amounts to a major win for the 2nd amendment, the US Supreme Court just struck down one of the most restrictive state-level gun laws--a law that required gun owners to get express permission to carry their weapons in stores and hotels.
Let's go through the backstory of this law, the unique rationale behind it (Aloha-Spirit~), as well as what the new ruling means for the country as a whole.
Episode Resources:
🔵 PDF of Court Ruling:
https://ept.ms/4v2j2Hp
====
#supremecourt #secondamendment #factsmatter
© All Rights Reserved.
In what amounts to a major win for the Second Amendment, the U.S. Supreme Court just struck
down one of the most restrictive gun laws in all 50 states. It was a law that required gun owners
to get express permission to carry their weapons in stores and hotels. And if the prospect of trying
to get a hold of someone in the Hilton family to get a permission slip for you to carry your gun
seemed unrealistic, well it also seemed unrealistic to the U.S. Supreme Court who just struck it down.
Let me give you the backstory on this law, the very unique rationale behind it, as well as what the new
ruling means not just for the state but for the entire country as a whole. So to start with, let
me give you a super quick primer on three recent gun-related rulings at the U.S. Supreme Court
that are relevant to our discussion today. Firstly, in the year 2008, in a case titled
District of Columbia v. Heller, the U.S. Supreme Court explicitly stated that the Second Amendment
protects an individual's right to bear arms. Up until then, people were making the argument that
because of the wording of the Second Amendment, it only applied to state militias. But in 2008,
the U.S. Supreme Court struck down that interpretation and ruled that no, actually,
the right to gun ownership is an individual right afforded to all American citizens.
Then, two years later in 2010, in a case called McDonald v. Chicago, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled
that it's not just the federal government, also state governments have to recognize the Second
Amendment as well. The rationale was that the 14th Amendment, it extended the protections of
the Bill of Rights to the states, and it made them apply to state governments as well. And so a state
was not able to violate your Second Amendment rights separately from the federal government.
And then lastly, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a case relevant to our discussion in the year 2022,
and that case was called New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruin. Now, we've covered
that case many times before, and there were many things that came out of that ruling,
but relevant to our discussion today was that firstly, the Bruin decision determined that the
right of the people to keep and bear arms extended beyond the home. And then secondly,
the Bruin decision set up a new test, a new legal test that courts have to apply when deciding
whether or not a certain anti-gun law violates the U.S. Constitution. Here was the relevant part
in the majority opinion of the Bruin case that basically set up this test. Quote,
the burden falls on the defendants, meaning the state governments, to show that New York's proper
cause requirement is consistent with this nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
Constitutional rights are enshrined with the scope they were understood to have when the people
adopted them. With these principles in mind, the court concludes that respondents have failed to
meet their burden to identify an American tradition justifying New York's proper cause requirement.
And so that was obviously more related to that specific New York case, but starting in the year
2022, because of this decision, they established this new legal precedent that's colloquially
called the Bruin test. It's a two-step process to determine whether a given law violates the
Amendment. Firstly, the court must determine whether the Second Amendment's plain text
covers the conduct in a given case. And then secondly, whether or not the anti-gun law
is consistent with this nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. And so that
was the legal backdrop in the year 2022 when the case in Hawaii played out. All right, just to pause
here for a super quick moment. If you've watched our program, Facts Matter, then you know that we
focus on one thing, which is the facts, not speculation, not narratives, just what the data
shows. And right now, the data globally is pointing in a direction people should really be paying
attention to, which is the fact that global conflicts are fueling market uncertainty. That's
why I believe in owning something real, something physical, something that the government can't just
inflate away, which is physical gold and physical silver from today's sponsor, which is American
Hartford Gold, the company that I trust and who I've been personally buying from for many years
now. These are tangible assets. They're not tied to policy decisions or shifting narratives. Gold
has held its value for thousands of years through inflation, currency changes, the rise and fall of
empires, as well as general global instability. In a certain sense, gold actually thrives in
periods of global instability. And American Hartford Gold is a good company. They have an A-plus rating
with a better business bureau, thousands of five-star reviews. They can deliver your gold
and your silver directly to your doorstep, or they can help you set up a gold IRA if you're trying
to diversify your retirement. And right now, when you call and mention my name, Roman, you can get up
to $20,000 in free silver with your first qualifying purchase. So give them a call 866-242-2352,
or just text Roman to 65532. That's again, 866-242-2352, or text Roman to 65532. I'll also
throw all their details. You'll be able to find them down in the description box below. By that
point, the U.S. Supreme Court had already determined in 2008 that U.S. citizens had the individual right
to keep and bear arms. In 2010, that the state government had to honor that right. And then in 2022,
that the right naturally extended outside of people's homes. However, the state legislature
of Hawaii, they still pass something known as Act 52, which was a sweeping ban on gun owners to be
able to carry their guns almost anywhere outside their home. Quote, Hawaii's Act 52 banned handguns
on private property unless the permit holder had received express authorization to carry a firearm
on the property by the owner, lessee, operator, or manager of the property. It also banned firearms in
bars, beaches, parks, and sensitive places such as hospitals, schools, and government buildings. The law
placed the onus on private property owners who wish to allow concealed carry on their property
to communicate their policy to the public. And so in the U.S. state of Hawaii, you theoretically
have the right to carry your firearm outside your home, just not in a park, in a beach, anywhere near
or on school or government or a hospital property. And then on top of that, if you were to enter some
sort of a private establishment, there would have to be an explicit sign, let's say on the window,
or as soon as you come in, saying something like, conceal carry is welcome here. Meaning essentially
that even though you technically had the right to carry outside your home, you really did not have
that right. Hawaiian lawmakers, they call this the default rule, meaning that the default in terms of
the private businesses is that everyone is banning guns in their establishment unless they say
otherwise. In a funny twist of language, the critics of that law, they called it the vampire rule,
because as we all know, vampires can't go into somewhere unless they're explicitly invited in.
And so gun owners, they were saying that they were being treated like vampires under this law.
Also, it's worth mentioning that similar laws have gone into effect in the states of New York, California,
Maryland, and New Jersey. I don't know so much about the latter three, but I know in New York,
the language is almost identical to what was passed in Hawaii. But we'll get to that in a moment.
Circling back to the case of Hawaii, though, lawsuits were brought forth by three local gun
owners there alongside the Hawaii Firearms Coalition, saying that their rights were
being infringed by this state law. However, after it got to the appellate level, the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, they reviewed the Hawaiian law and they said that even under the
strict Bruin test, the one that we described earlier, the Hawaii law was fine since, quote,
The restrictions that it imposed fell well within the historical tradition.
And realistically, in the unique case of Hawaii, that is true going back to the time not so long
ago when Hawaii was not a state, but rather its own kingdom. Quote,
The state of Hawaii then argued that this historical backdrop led to the development
of what they termed the Aloha spirit, which then basically clashed with the U.S. Supreme
Court's interpretation of the Second Amendment. Quote,
should not be allowed into businesses at all. These attitudes appear to reflect the state's
Aloha spirit, which, as explained by the Supreme Court of Hawaii, clashes with a federally mandated
lifestyle that lets citizens walk around with deadly weapons during day to day activities.
Also, on top of the kingdom of Hawaii historical argument, the state also argued that even though
within the Hawaii state constitution, they have language that almost exactly mirrors the Second
Amendment in the federal constitution. The Hawaii state constitution was written in the 1950s at a
time when the general understanding was that that language limited gun ownership to militias rather
than it being an individual right. And so basically they were arguing that the people who wrote the
Hawaii state constitution, they understood that what they were writing meant that only militias
can gain access to guns rather than bob down the street. However, the local gun owners, they
appealed the decision of the appellate court all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court, who wound
up taking up the case. And after hearing the oral arguments from both sides, from both the state
government as well as the local gun owners, late last week, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor
of the gun owners, specifically in a, I guess, very typical six to three split decision. You
had justices Brett Kavanaugh, Neil Gorsuch, Amy Coney Barrett, Clarence Thomas, Sam Alito, and John
Roberts all vote against the Hawaiian law. Writing for the majority of the court, you had Sam Alito
write the following, quote, The Second Amendment has the same meaning in all parts of the United
States. It cannot give way to the spirit of Aloha in Hawaii any more than it can yield to the spirit
of the Big Apple or the Windy City. It applies in the same way to our 50th state, where about 8%
of adults possess guns, and our 49th state, where the figure is roughly 59%. Now, that was, of course,
a reference to Alaska, which became a U.S. state just a few months before Hawaii did.
And the majority opinion then goes on to write the following, quote, Nearly local attitudes can
neither shrink nor inflate the meaning of fundamental Bill of Rights guarantees that
apply to the states through the 14th Amendment. The state law departs sharply from the standard
common law rule and access to private property held open to the public under which everyone,
including lawful carriers of firearms, may enter unless specifically forbidden to do so. The Hawaii
law hobbles what the Second Amendment protects, preventing everyone from carrying a gun without
express consent by the property owner, while it imposes severe restrictions on the daily activities
of residents who have satisfied the state's rigorous requirements for the issuance of a
carry permit. When these permit holders leave home in the morning, not only must they take care to
avoid all the territory where the possession of a gun is prohibited outright, but they may also
be barred from entering many places that people routinely visit. And then in a separate but
concurring opinion, Justice Amy Coney Barrett added the following analogy to make her point,
quote, According to Hawaii's logic, if a state made it a crime to wear religious head garb,
such as a hijab, on private property open to the public, that law could evade constitutional
scrutiny because the state has merely adjusted the default to require permission to be clear.
That is plainly wrong. Property laws, no less than other laws, are subject to constitutional limits.
So when a property law restricts the bearing of arms, the state must prove that the law abides
by the limits of the Second Amendment. And so there you have it. Hawaii's Act 52, which is
basically a workaround against the Bruin decision, has been determined to be unconstitutional. Which
naturally, as you can imagine, the executive director of the NRA's Institute for Legislative
Action hailed as a major victory for gun rights across the whole country. Quote, Law-abiding gun
owners will no longer be forced to beg for special permission simply to exercise their constitutional
right to bear arms in public places. And so there you have it. Moving forward, Hawaii is no longer a
default can't-bring-your-gun-to-any-private-establishment state. Then for the other 75 million
Americans who live in one of the other four states with nearly identical laws in the books
about where you can and can't bring your guns, specifically in New York, California, New Jersey,
Maryland, those are probably done as well. The Supreme Court ruling, it directly undermines
California, New Jersey, Maryland, and New York's similar default bans on guns in private property
establishments that are open to the public. I mean, ultimately, someone will have to do the
work of going through the motions and suing those individual states one by one. But given the fact
that, for instance, again, New York state's law is pretty much identical to the one in Hawaii,
it's most likely unenforceable. I mean, in fact, out of all the different states, Hawaii, really,
if you think about it, had the strongest claim because they were a sovereign kingdom prior to
becoming a U.S. territory and then later a U.S. state. And even that claim did not stand legal
scrutiny, even though they had that historical record of gun and other weapon restrictions.
So you can imagine that anything that the New York Solicitor General might argue in court
will probably have very little sway. But we'll have to see ultimately how that plays itself out.
But there you have it, a victory for the Second Amendment. And if you want to read the decision
for yourself, I'll throw it down into the description box below. You can click on that
link. It'll take you to the PDF version where you can read through it. As any Supreme Court ruling,
the top line is always interesting. If you get too deep into it, it gets into, I guess,
realm of legalese. But Sam Alito writes well. It's very logically organized. So if you want to
check it out, the link is down there. Also, also, if you're interested in general Supreme Court
rulings, I would highly recommend this other link down in the description box below. It's a
subscription link to The Epoch Times. And by subscribing through that link, we'll also send
you this magazine that we put together with all the rulings of the previous term, what they are,
what the background was of the ruling, and what it means for both the plaintiffs in the case,
but also for all of us moving forward. Because the Supreme Court, every single session,
they have so many rulings. And a lot of them might be technical or very specific to a very,
very niche set of circumstances. But a lot of them are very broad in their application. And
they apply to you, me, and almost everybody else. And what we were able to do is compile them
together, distill out the facts, distill out the meaning, like the true meaning,
strip out all the legalese language, and present it to you in a fun, concise way. So check it out.
If you subscribe to The Epoch Times using that link, you'll get that magazine. And also, besides
that magazine, moving forward with a subscription to The Epoch Times, you'll get all the reports
moving forward as all these new Supreme Court rulings are coming out. You will stay informed
of them as they're coming out. So check it out. You'll be supporting our work here, but also
staying informed yourself. So it's a win-win. Check it out. Subscribe to The Epoch Times.
And then until next time, I'm your host, Roman from The Epoch Times.
Stay informed. And most importantly, stay free.
