In this video, I’m breaking down why some Dallas homebuyers need to not be buying a home right now, especially new construction. Big builder price cuts can look exciting. A home may be reduced by $100,000 or even close to $200,000, and it can feel like the deal is obvious. But the real question is not how much the builder says they dropped the price. The real question is whether the house is actually worth the new price.
We look at real examples in McKinney and Celina where new construction homes had massive advertised discounts, then compare those prices to nearby sold homes. This is where a lot of buyers get misled. A builder can cut the price and still be overpriced. A discount does not tell you market value.
We also talk about builder lender incentives, closing cost credits, special interest rates, and why buyers need to understand where the money is really coming from. If the builder owns the lender, the numbers may not be as simple as they sound. A credit only matters if the costs, loan terms, escrow numbers, and final cash needed at closing actually make sense.
The point is not that nobody should buy a home in Dallas right now. The point is that you need to know what you are walking into before you sign. In this market, smart buyers are not just asking what the builder is offering. They are asking what the home is worth, what the loan really costs, what the contract allows, and what risks they may still be carrying years from now.
This video warns homebuyers, especially in Texas, about deceptive pricing and lending tactics used by new construction builders. It exposes how \"massive discounts\" and builder-affiliated lenders can mislead buyers, emphasizing the necessity of professional representation to determine actual market value and avoid financial pitfalls.
This is a contract to buy a home in Dallas,
and honestly, for a lot of buyers,
this is exactly what should happen to it.
We think we're in this buyer's market
where we have a strong advantage.
You know, you can get an inspection.
You don't have to feel rushed or pressured,
but I want you to think about this.
Anytime you have one side that gets an advantage,
the opposing side always has to get smarter
and more tactical.
Back in 2021, when sellers had all the power,
some buyers got so desperate that their realtors
would pull the key out of the lockbox and not put it back.
You know, hide it, take it home, whatever it took
so the next buyer couldn't get inside the house
that their client wanted.
That's what happens when one side of a deal is losing.
Buyers had to be strategic
and sometimes a little underhanded.
Now sellers are the ones on the losing side.
They're the ones who have to be clever, tactical,
you know, make you think their home is better
than every other home out there.
That means as a buyer, you can have the upper hand,
but still be in a complicated game
where it's easy to get manipulated.
I'm gonna tell you right now,
nowhere is this easier to see than a new construction.
Most buyers think a price cut means they're getting a deal.
You know, the builder drops the price by 50,
maybe $100,000.
Buyers see the new number and start feeling
like they just scored big.
You know, it feels like finding a 70 inch TV
on clearance for half price.
Like you don't spend much time wondering what it's worth.
You're too busy looking at the discount.
Now I wanna show you this playing out
in real time with houses.
We were out with buyers recently looking
in McKinney and Salina.
They wanted new construction, great schools,
and a budget under 700,000.
So after touring a lot of homes,
we narrowed everything down to two finalists.
The first home was in Willowwood in McKinney.
It fed into Melissa ISD, which checked our school box.
The buyer had originally priced the home at 749,000
and the current price was 637,000.
That's a reduction of more than $100,000.
Now our second home was in Mosaic in Salina.
This one fed into Prosper ISD.
So again, we've got our good schools there.
The original price was 880,900.
And then the current price was 684,900.
So the builder had cut almost $200,000 from the price.
Think about what that feels like as a buyer.
These are massive discounts.
It's not a question of whether you're getting a deal.
It's a question of which one is the best deal.
So you start comparing.
Mathematically, we could come at this
from a few different angles.
We could compare the upgrades in each home.
The McKinney home had cedar garage doors,
quartz countertops, dual vanities.
Then the Salina home had a three-car garage,
wood floors, and a larger covered patio.
You could spend all day comparing features
and trying to decide which home gave you more for the money.
Then there were the monthly costs,
property taxes, HOA dues, PIDs, MUDs.
If one house costs less to own every month,
that's absolutely relevant.
You could even look at the builders themselves.
Which builder has more exposure?
Which sales rep sounds desperate for a deal?
So depending on what part you focus on,
you could make a case for either home.
The problem is that none of those things
tell you what the actual price should be.
If we're trying to figure out
which of these homes is a better deal,
eventually we have to look at the one thing
that determines value more than anything else.
We have to look at what the neighbor next door
just paid for the same house.
And here's where we run into a problem.
Texas is what we call a non-disclosure state.
So you can't actually look up the neighbor next door
to see what he paid.
And builders know this.
It's part of why we see all this pricing confusion.
Now, fortunately, realtors can see those sales.
So we started looking up sales
and we started with the McKinney home.
We found three similar homes built by the same builder.
You know, similar size, layout, bedroom, all of that.
When we averaged those sales together,
they came out to about $173 a square foot.
So we applied that number to the McKinney home.
The result was about $615,000.
So the asking price was $637,000.
Okay, so hold on here.
The builder had already cut
more than $100,000 from the price.
Okay, not 10,000, more than 100,000.
And somehow the house was still priced above
what the neighbor down the street paid for his.
So you would think a six-figure discount
would solve that problem, but it didn't.
Then we moved on to the Salina house.
This was the heavyweight champion of discounts, right?
Nearly $200,000 off the original price.
If you showed that number to most buyers,
they wouldn't just be interested.
They'd be loading boxes into a moving truck.
Well, we ran the exact same analysis.
Same builder, you know, similar size, layout,
homes that had already sold.
Well, those homes averaged about $212 per square foot.
So we applied that number to the home.
The result was roughly $635,000.
The asking price was almost $685,000.
Okay, hear that again.
The builder cut almost $200,000 from the price.
And after a discount that large,
the home was still priced about $50,000 above
what the neighbor paid for it last month.
Now, I wanna show you one more thing,
and this is what you're gonna be telling your friends
about at work tomorrow, okay?
So get ready to have your mind blown.
In fact, absolutely share this video
so we can get the word out on what's happening here.
Okay, you'll hear plenty of people saying
this is the market crashing
and it just needs to keep on crashing.
Well, let's take a closer look.
If you look at the pricing history
from our home in McKinney, on May 13,
it was listed for $749,724.
The very next day, the price dropped to $637,582.
The very next day, the price dropped by over $100,000.
This had nothing to do with market pressure.
This wasn't about the home languishing
on the market for months, you know,
and then they finally lowered the price.
This was, from day one, meant to make you think
you were getting the home at a discount.
And lest you think it was entered by mistake,
check out this other listing.
In Salina, where on March 4, the home was listed
at $817,259, and the very next day,
it was lowered to $689,000.
They lowered the price by over $128,000 within 24 hours.
Okay, or how about another example,
where the home was listed in March for $843,052,
and the price lowered the very next day to $732,990.
Or yet another house on January 7,
where the list price is $799, and the very next day,
it's $749,000.
When buyers have the upper hand,
seller-builders have to be resourceful,
or whatever you want to call that.
One builder cut over $100,000.
The other cut almost $200,000.
All right, new construction all over the place,
starting their price ridiculously high,
and then slashing it the very next day.
All right, that's a trap.
The builder wants your attention
on how much the price came down.
They want you thinking about what you're saving.
What they don't want you asking
is how much is this house actually worth?
This is exactly why I started this video
by lighting a contract on fire.
If your entire definition of a good deal
is a giant discount sticker,
this is not the time for you to be signing a contract.
Burn that thing and walk away.
And guess what?
That's only the first place
buyers are getting blindsided right now.
The second one has to do with how you pay for the house.
So I'm talking about your loan.
If you've looked at new construction recently,
you have probably seen offers that sound incredible.
$20,000 toward closing costs, special interest rates,
you know, maybe all of the above.
The sales consultant says it with a smile.
Everybody wants you looking at that $20,000.
But I want you to stop and think about something.
Where exactly is that money coming from?
Most buyers picture the builder reaching into their pocket
and handing the lender $20,000
towards their closing costs.
All right, that's not what's happening.
In many cases, the builder also owns the lender.
One part of the company builds the house.
Another part of the same company makes the loan.
So when the builder says,
use our lender and we'll give you $20,000 towards closing,
you're not looking at two separate companies
who decided to work together.
You're looking at different parts of the same company.
That's important because the first question shouldn't be
how much are they giving me?
The first question should be, what are the actual costs?
If somebody tells you they're paying $20,000
towards your costs,
but closing costs are $20,000 higher than they should be,
did they really pay your closing costs?
Or did they just move money from one pocket to the other
and hope no one else noticed?
That's the part most buyers never really think about.
You know who's told me I'm right about this
more than anyone else?
And this is gonna surprise you.
It's sales reps working for builders.
There was this one particular sales rep
who texted me off and on for about a year.
I would put out a video about new construction
and a few days later, she would text me
and say that everything I said in the video is true.
You know, a few months would go by,
another video, another text, you know,
like my builder has absolutely done this.
So it was really kind of funny hearing this from an insider.
Then earlier this year, she actually called me.
She told me she was done with being a sales rep
and she wanted to become a realtor
and specifically that she wanted to work with us.
She said she liked that we were the whistleblowers.
I didn't see that one coming.
Her exact words were that she was tired
of seeing buyers being taken advantage of.
One of the stories she told me has always stuck.
A buyer was getting close to closing
when they were suddenly told they needed
about $8,000 more than they expected.
The lender explained the increase in lender language.
The buyer listened.
The problem wasn't that the buyer disagreed.
The problem was that the buyer had no way to tell
whether the explanation made sense.
Think about taking your car to a mechanic.
The mechanic calls and says,
we found something else wrong.
It's gonna be another $2,000.
Then they start talking about sensors and modules,
parts you've never heard of before.
You know, most people aren't mechanics.
They don't know which questions to ask.
They don't know which details matter.
They just know the bill got bigger.
That's exactly where a lot of buyers find themselves
when lender paperwork starts changing near closing.
Suddenly people are talking about fees and credits
and escrow accounts, all this paperwork.
You can usually get the lender
to give you some kind of answer.
Knowing what in the world they're talking about
is a whole lot harder.
Okay, remember when I burned that contract?
If somebody can change the numbers by thousands of dollars
and you don't know how to make sense of what they're saying
or why the numbers changed, slow down for now,
at least until you have the tools you need.
And that leads directly into the next problem.
The builder wants to sell the house.
The lender wants to close the loan.
So who is helping the buyer figure out
whether all of this actually makes sense?
Most people would immediately answer a realtor.
Well, that's not necessarily the right answer.
Over the past year, I've had several homeowners reach out
because they wanted to sell their house.
So we sit down together, look at what they own
and compare it to what the house is worth today.
And I have to tell them they're upside down.
They owe more than the house is worth.
Now, here's the part that sticks with me.
Every single one of those homeowners used a realtor
when they bought the house, every single one.
So just having a realtor is not the solution here.
It is not enough.
One thing I've noticed over the years
is that most buyers don't actually know how to tell
if a realtor's doing a good job.
They don't know how to tell if a realtor's telling them
what they need to know.
You can't ask a question
if you don't know the question exists.
In fact, just recently,
I had been chatting with a first-time home buyer
who wanted to buy a new construction home.
We had a few Google Meets together
talking about her timeline, the market,
new construction, all of that.
Then I followed up with her a little bit later
and she told me she'd already gone
to a D.R. Horton community
and put down a deposit the same day.
She said once she met with the sales rep,
she realized buying really wasn't that complicated
and she had a cousin realtor
who would rebate the commission back to her.
That right there is why I started this video
by lighting a contract on fire.
From her perspective, it was a friendly sales rep
and she trusted him.
From my perspective,
I was thinking about everything that could go wrong,
not just what we talked about in this video,
but also how D.R. Horton is a budget builder
who sells a lot of their homes to investors.
Now, I'm over here thinking about exit liquidity
and how poorly maintained rental neighborhoods tend to be.
And when I got off the call,
I couldn't stop thinking about those homeowners
I'd already met with.
You know, I've already seen the ending to this story.
I've been the person explaining
why an owner can't sell their house
in a neighborhood they hate.
What worried me wasn't whether
she had an experienced realtor.
It was that she thought the process was simple
and she blindly trusted the sales rep.
But I can't fix everything, okay?
So just know this,
the people who end up in trouble usually aren't reckless.
They just don't know what they don't know.
They oversimplify.
I mean, sometimes I think the most important job
a realtor has is helping buyers answer the questions
they never knew existed and give them the information
they didn't know they needed.
Here's just a few of them.
They should help you understand
how the house should be priced,
help you understand the financing, the contract, the risks,
and help you understand the costs
you'll still be paying years from now.
Now, if you like the sounds of how we work
and you're planning to buy a home in Dallas,
check out our Let's Find Home questionnaire.
You can scan the QR code.
We'll have a short discovery meeting
where we can learn more about your situation,
answer your questions,
and help you figure out the smartest next step for you.
I mean, maybe that means buying now.
Maybe it means waiting.
Maybe it's changing your strategy completely.
But whatever you decide,
you'll be making that decision
with a lot more information than you have right now.
Now, if you're specifically thinking about building a home,
that's a whole different animal,
and I definitely recommend checking out
this video right here.
In the meantime, this is Wendy Pinnell,
your Dallas realtor and broker,
and I'll see you on the next video.