A small civilian plane crashes into Beijing's tallest skyscraper. The pilot dies. Then the real mystery begins. Why did Beijing wait nearly 24 hours before speaking? Why did the official statement avoid key details? Who was the pilot? Why did the aircraft suddenly disappear from public flight tracking? And why did one of China's biggest state-owned companies rush to issue what many saw as an indirect denial? In this livestream, we separate confirmed facts from rumors and examine the five biggest mysteries behind one of the most unusual aviation incidents Beijing has ever seen.
Hi, everyone. Hi. All right. Greetings from Toronto, Canada.
Okay. How's everyone? How's everyone's weekend so far? Good? Okay. All right. Let's I'm trying
to maneuver this new system here. All right. We have I have I'm wearing American flag inspired
earrings because we have our team produced a song to celebrate the 2250th birthday of
the United States of America. I want to play the song for you at the end of this live stream.
So stay with us. Okay. Let's talk about the the accident that happened in Beijing. That's all over
the press. So Friday, just after six o'clock Beijing time, a small civilian aircraft flew
into the tallest building in Beijing. Now under normal circumstances, that alone would have been
one of the biggest stories in China. Think about it, a manned aircraft flying into the tallest
skyscraper in the capital. In broad daylight, hundreds if not thousands of eyewitnesses,
videos everywhere, you would expect wall to wall coverage. Instead, within hours,
videos began disappearing, photos disappeared. Searches on China's social media stopped
returning results. So for nearly 24 hours, Beijing remained quiet until about I think in the
afternoon of Saturday, Beijing finally broke its silence. It didn't answer the biggest questions.
Instead, it raised even more of them. So who was the pilot? Why has the pilot's identity become so
covered up or controversial? Why did one of China's largest state-owned companies rushed
out to issue what many people interpreted as a strange indirect denial? Why did the aircraft's
transponder suddenly disappear before the crash? And perhaps the biggest question of all,
was this really an aviation accident or are we looking at something much more like a deliberate
attack? So today I want to examine what almost every new piece of information surrounding the
incident or I should say why every piece of information surrounding this incident makes
it feel stranger than the one before it. So let's start with what the eyewitnesses said.
So shortly after six o'clock, a small light aircraft entered Beijing's Chaoyang district
at very low altitude. Actually, I have a video. Let me play that for you.
Um, where's the video? Here is the video.
All right, what am I doing? Um, wrong video. Here we go. Okay, here we go.
So I'm going to mute it so I can keep talking. So this is the video compiled based on
eyewitnesses, what they captured. It was during rush hour and now Chaoyang district isn't just
any business district. It's the political and financial heart of modern Beijing.
The aircraft that smashed into the city headquarters hit the 83rd floor. The aircraft
didn't explode on impact. Instead, it broke apart. A large hole was left on the side of
the building while pieces fell from hundreds of feet onto the streets below. Because it was still
daylight and the weather condition was excellent, many people witnessed the collision and people
immediately recorded the crash. The video spread rapidly online and then they were removed.
Now let's turn to the aircraft itself. Flight tracking data published by Flightradar24
indicates that the aircraft was a Chinese-built Aurora SA-60L light sport aircraft and its
registration is B-12PP. And as you can see at the end of this video, there's an image.
Yeah, that's the aircraft. So let's just stop it there. This is the aircraft.
And can you guys see? Yeah. It was a two-seat single-engine recreational aircraft commonly
used for flight training and private flying. In fact, it's one of the aircraft most associated
with China's so-called low-altitude economy, which is part of the National Comprehensive
Transportation Network Plan. It's a new initiative introduced by Beijing in 2024
with the goal to build a modern industrial ecosystem operating in airspace below 1,000 meters,
utilizing drones and small flying objects for commercial purposes.
Okay, with that said, let's turn our attention to what Beijing finally told us yesterday
and perhaps more importantly, what they chose not to tell us. So mystery number one,
why did Beijing's first statement create more questions than answers? So after nearly 24 hours
of silence, the Chaoyang District Government finally released its first official report.
It's very short, only has six sentences. It said, at 5.55 on June 26, a single-engine, two-seat
light sport flying object collided with a high-rise building near Beijing's East
Third Ring Road. The pilot was killed. 13 people on the ground were injured.
The relevant authorities are investigating. Now at first glance, that sounds normal. But if you
really read between the lines, several things immediately caught my attention. First, the
statement avoided the word aircraft or airplane. Instead, it repeatedly used the technical term
light sport aviation object. Now, that may simply reflect official aviation terminology,
but here's what struck me even more. The statement says the aircraft collided with a high-rise
building. It did not mention the tallest building in Beijing. It did not mention the headquarters
of the city group. It did not mention the landmark building known as the China Zun
because this building resembled a Chinese shape, a particular shape. So people gave this building
a name. It's called the China Zun. And instead, it just said a high-rise building. And it didn't
say an aircraft. It said a light sport flying object. Now think about that for a moment.
If a civilian aircraft flew into the tallest skyscraper in Washington, London, Beijing,
I mean not Beijing, Tokyo or New York, would the official statement from those countries simply
say it struck a building? And there's another detail. The statement used the word collided.
Now to be fair, investigators had not yet completed their investigation or they have,
they just decide not to tell us. So the choice of wording has another effect. It presents the
incident as an aviation accident rather than focusing attention on the possibility of deliberate
intent. Whether that possibility ultimately proves true or false is a separate question.
The statement confirms that there was only one person on board. It confirms that the pilot is
dead. It confirms 13 people on the ground were injured. But it never tells whether the pilot
was a man or a woman. That's another point that people find interesting. In China, official
statements following major incidents usually include at least some basic information or
description of the individuals involved. They often withhold the name. Sometimes they withhold
their background or occupation. But usually they will say whether the person was a male or female.
But this statement doesn't. Why? Well, I think the authorities are trying to avoid to reveal the
identity of the pilot. And I'll explain that later. But considering the rumors about the
pilot's identity were already spreading across the internet before the statement was released,
that omission immediately became part of the story. And then almost exactly at the same time,
another very interesting thing happened. Citigroup appeared to respond. Their headquarters
was hit by a plane. One of its employees was rumored to be the pilot. But there was
no press conference. There was no press statement. There was no spokesperson involved.
But with something much more unusual. And that brings us to mystery number two.
So who was the pilot? Who was actually flying this plane? You might think that should be one
of the easiest questions to answer because he or she is already dead. You can easily identify the
But that's not what happened. Instead, almost immediately after the crash,
social media in China was flooded with guessing. But there was one name that came up. A woman
named Liu Junhua. And internet users started digging through public records. And they showed
that a woman named Liu Junhua had worked as a senior executive within Citig's financial business.
I think she's in the private wealth management unit. According to public biographies,
she had more than 16 years of experience in financial markets and had held management
positions within one of Citig's financial wealth management companies. So naturally,
speculation spread quickly. Because you know the pilot is Liu Junhua. And then
the plane hit the Citig building. And within Citig, there's a person called Liu Junhua.
Let me actually show you a picture of her. Where is it? Here we go. Oh, there she is.
That's according to her social media profile. So people began asking, well, is that the same
person? Is that the same person? Now, under normal circumstances, that would be very easy
to clear up. The authorities could easily identify the pilot. Or at the very least,
tell the public whether the pilot was male or female. Instead, they did neither.
They did not tell us who the pilot was. They did not review the pilot's gender. And that's
exactly why the rumors continued. People believed that it was exactly because the pilot was a woman
that the authorities avoided mentioning the gender. Then came Citig's strange statement.
Almost at the same time the government released its statement, one of Citig Group's official
WeChat accounts published an article featuring a senior executive named Liu Junhua. And the title
said, Building Spirit with Culture and Advancing Steadily. And then column, Liu Junhua of Citig
Wealth Management talks about how culture empowers high-quality company development.
Now, here's the note. The article was dated June 27, the day after the crash. So many people
immediately interpreted this as an indirect denial. In other words, if Liu Junhua was giving
interviews and discussing company strategy today or Saturday, then she obviously couldn't have
been the pilot that got killed in the incident. But here's the problem. The article contained
no pictures, no videos, no public appearance. So that doesn't prove anything. It's not convincing.
Now I found this article particularly unusual because it has a very obvious timeline problem.
When Citig Wealth Management, or one of its WeChat accounts, published this indirect denial,
the article included a note at the top saying that it had reprinted from
jrj.com, which is a Chinese financial portal. It's called 金融界 in Chinese. In English,
it means financial world. Let me show you the image of the post. Yeah, this is the article.
Maybe I can make this bigger so you can see better. So we circle the time. Oh, this is the
original time of the article that the WeChat account of Citig quoted. This was the original
source. However, and let me show you the other image. And this is the Citig's WeChat account
that reposted the article from jrj. Okay, but we got a problem here with the timing.
And it's not a small problem. The article on Citig's official WeChat account was published
at 3.15am. But when you look at the original article on jrj.com, it shows a publication time
of 1.03pm the same day, almost 10 hours later. So here's the question. If the jrj.com article
didn't appear until the afternoon, how could Citig have reprinted it at 3 o'clock in the morning?
Shouldn't it be the other way around? Shouldn't jrj.com be reposting Citig's article? I don't
know how to explain that discrepancy. But it's a very obvious contradiction. And at the very least,
it raises more questions about the credibility of Citig's so-called denial. It looks like
it just put up a note at 3 o'clock in the morning and then backed it up with an article 10 hours
later from jrj.com. So if the pilot was indeed someone else, someone who has nothing to do with
Citig, it would have been so easy for Citig to deny it. Get her to issue a statement, get on
news or issue a video clip. Why deny it in such a convoluted way? So this denial made more people
believe that the pilot was indeed the woman tied to Citig, and that would have been the woman
working in the wealth management unit. Then came another piece of information. Reporters from the
According to their reporting, they saw police searching a vehicle parked near the airport.
Using publicly available registration records, they found that the vehicle was registered to
someone named Liu Junhua. Again, same name. Now the Financial Times is being very careful here.
It does not say the police confirmed that this Liu Junhua was indeed the pilot,
or this Liu Junhua was indeed the one working at Citig.
But think about where that leaves us. We have an unidentified pilot. We have a government
statement that omits the pilot's gender. We have widespread online speculation centered on a woman
named Liu Junhua who was an executive working for Citig. And then we have a very weird denial
from Citig, both in terms of the timing and also in terms of the style of the article.
And then we have police searching a vehicle registered to someone with that same name.
None of those facts by themselves proves anything directly, but together they explain why the
authorities and Citig tried very hard to avoid identifying the pilot. Because if they did,
it could be devastating, possibly. However, these unexplained discrepancies immediately
connect the dots, connect the mysterious pilot to the female executive working for Citig.
Now, I don't think that's even the biggest mystery, because once you look at how this aircraft
actually flew, the story becomes even harder to explain. So now let me move on to mystery number
three. Why did the aircraft fly this way? Okay, let's forget about the pilot's identity for a
moment. Let's forget about Citig. Let's look at only the flight itself, because flight data
doesn't have political opinions. It simply shows what happened. So according to available flight
data from flight tracking services, this was supposed to be an ordinary training flight.
The aircraft took off from Shifuosi airport at around 5.30 in the afternoon. It spent several
minutes flying normally while practicing local traffic pattern. Everything appeared routine.
Then something happened. Instead of turning back toward the airport land, the aircraft continued
flying due west, straight toward downtown Beijing, the heart of Beijing. And that
was the first unusual detail. The second came only a few minutes later.
According to available flight data, the aircraft's ADS-B transponder stopped transmitting near
From that point onward or forward, public flight tracking services could no longer see where the
aircraft was. In other words, part of the flight simply disappeared from the public record.
And also radio communication also went silent. Again by itself, none of this proves anything.
Equipment could have failed. The pilot could have become incapacitated.
Investigations exist exact for that reason. But here's what I found difficult to explain.
According to the available information, everything was functioning normally until
the time when the aircraft left its planned landing pattern. Only after it headed toward
central Beijing did the transponder disappear. Only then did the radio fall silent. Only then
did the aircraft stop responding to air traffic control. That sequence immediately raises questions.
And then there's another detail, the weather. At the time of the crash,
conditions over Beijing was clear. Visibility was excellent. So there were no reports of
severe weather. Even if the aircraft had experienced some kind of technical or mechanical
problems, an experienced pilot flying under visual conditions would normally be expected to avoid
colliding with the tallest and the most recognizable building in Beijing.
And by the way, this pilot is said to be a member of the aviation club at that airport.
So she is obviously experienced. And then came the aircraft's flight path. According to people
familiar with the investigation, the aircraft continued flying at roughly normal cruising
speed. Its heading remained remarkably steady. So there were no obvious attempts to return to
the airport. No visible signs of uncontrollable aircraft. Instead, it continued toward the city.
It looks like it was not experiencing mechanical problems.
And then here's another very interesting detail that came from someone with a professional
aviation background in China. According to this aviation expert, the very aircraft,
Aurora SA-60L, the model involved in the crash, is equipped with a whole aircraft ballistic parachute.
In other words, it's not just the pilot. This entire aircraft has a parachute. If the aircraft
had suffered a serious mechanical failure, or if the pilot had suddenly lost control,
the standard emergency procedure would have been to shut down the engine,
cut off the fuel supply, and deploy the ballistic parachute. The system is specifically designed
to bring the entire aircraft down safely. Now, if that's true, then it's difficult
to explain why the aircraft would continue flying at high speed into the heart of Beijing
before striking one of the city's most famous landmarks. That's why people find it very
difficult to believe that this was simply the result of a mechanical failure or a health crisis
related to the pilot. So based on everything we've discussed, the flight path, the loss of
radio communication, the transponder going offline, and now the aircraft's emergency recovery
system, I believe the evidence strongly suggests that a deliberate act took place instead of an
ordinary accident. Then another claim appeared online. There's a political commentator named
Liu Junning, based outside of China, said he had received information from sources familiar with
the matter. He said that he had not been able to verify what he got, but according to his contact,
after the aircraft disappeared from public tracking, it might have circled Beijing's
second ring road before eventually turning back and striking the city tower.
At first, that seems inconsistent with the publicly available flight path. But remember
something important. The public flight path ends when the transponder stopped transmitting.
Everything after that is invisible to the radar. So if the transponder was
intentionally switched off, then the public simply has no way of knowing
where the aircraft flew during those final minutes. So could it have circled the second
ring road and flown over Zhongnanhai? Because the second ring road is really the heart of Beijing.
So could it have flown over Zhongnanhai? Technically, yes. Could it have flown over
Tiananmen Square? Also yes. Right now, nobody outside the investigation or nobody can really
answer that question with certainty. But if Mr. Liu's source is correct, then the implications
become much more significant. Because it would suggest that the pilot may have been searching
for another destination before ultimately striking the city tower. Whether that destination was
Zhongnanhai, Tiananmen Square, or somewhere else entirely, we simply don't know. At this point,
it's speculation. But one thing is certain. The missing minutes before the loss of the
transponder signal and the impact remain one of the biggest unanswered questions in this entire
case. And that brings us to what may be the most important mystery of all. That is,
mystery number four. Was the city tower really the target? Or was it something else?
Well, let's start with what we know. The city tower, known in China as the China Zun,
isn't just another office tower. It stands at 528 meters tall. It's the tallest building in Beijing.
It's one of the most recognizable landmarks in the city. It's also the headquarters of the
One of China's largest state-owned enterprises. So even if it had been a random accident,
it happened at one of the most politically and symbolically significant locations in Beijing.
And people notice that. There's another interesting detail. Because the name China Zun
is only 6.5 kilometers away from Zhongnanhai, the headquarters of CCP leadership.
At cruising speed of this aircraft, that's roughly one or two minutes away. And I'm not suggesting
the aircraft was headed for Zhongnanhai. But the proximity helps explain why this incident
would have immediately been treated as extraordinarily sensitive. Actually,
I think another source, it could have been Mr. Liu himself, said that Zhongnanhai has already
designated this incident as a terrorist threat. Maybe it's a domestic terrorist threat. That's
from some insiders. Now let's turn to his report. So Mr. Liu's source said that this aircraft
might have spent several minutes circling near Beijing's second ring road, which is the very
heart of Beijing, before turning back toward China Zun, the civic tower. That naturally
raises another question. Why? Was the pilot searching for another destination? We don't know.
There's another interesting detail. Now in China, Xi Jinping was given the political nickname Yi
Zun, the number one Zun, that means the one supreme authority. That's widely associated
with Xi Jinping. The building is called the China Zun, same Zun. Does that symbolism matter?
Maybe? Maybe not? Okay. But people inadvertently linked the two. Now Hong Kong's Minbao or
Minbao Daily, which many people now view as largely aligned with Beijing, reported something
very interesting. Citing sources familiar with the aviation industry, the Hong Kong newspaper
said that before the aircraft crashed into the building, multiple air traffic control units
were trying to contact it. That included the departure controller, the approach controller,
and the regional control center responsible for Beijing's airspace. Every one of them
repeatedly called the aircraft, and there was no response. Minbao also reported that the military
eventually dispatched a helicopter to search for the aircraft. But by the time the helicopter
reached the area, it was already too late. The plane has already struck the building.
And then here comes the interesting part of the interesting insight. The newspaper interviewed
aviation professionals from Beijing, and they pointed out an interesting detail. They believe
the pilot most likely deliberately switched off both the aircraft's transponder and its radio.
And they noted that the area around Beijing's third ring road, or the second ring road,
is so politically sensitive that there are no publicly available visual flight charts
for the pilots navigating by landmarks. Because of that, these experts believe that the pilot
may have used the Jingqing expressway as a visual reference, following it from Tongzhou
all the way towards the civic tower, and eventually hit it there. So what's particularly
noteworthy is that these observations weren't coming from overseas media or people like me.
They were reported by Minbao, a Hong Kong newspaper that is generally viewed as operating
under Beijing's influence. And they made that point very clear. So taken together,
this report and other information we just discussed suggests one scenario,
and one very likely scenario. The pilot may have been searching for a different target
than the civic tower. Perhaps Tiananmen Square, perhaps Zhongnanhai, or perhaps something else
entirely. But without visual flight charts in such a highly restricted area, it may have been
easy for a pilot, or it might have been too difficult for the pilot to pinpoint
her target. So it's easier for her, flying a small aircraft at low altitude,
to identify a more visually recognizable landmark. So it was impossible for her
to identify a specific government compound from the air. So she has used the highway as a reference,
and ultimately went to the civic tower, the tallest and most recognizable landmark in
central Beijing. Of course, that's just one possible interpretation. At this point,
no one outside the investigation team knows exactly what happened. And we may never know
what went through the pilot's mind during those final minutes. But regardless of the motives,
the incident touched on several of Beijing's most sensitive concerns at the time.
One is security. This happened in one of the most heavily protected districts in China.
A manned civilian aircraft reached the heart of Beijing, might have crossed some of the
country's most sensitive airspace, and ultimately struck the tallest building in the capital.
Whether the flight was accidental or intentional is almost beside the point. The uncomfortable
question is, what happened to Beijing's air defense system? What happened to the protective
shield surrounding Zhongnanhai? Was it really as impenetrable as people had been led to believe?
That's question number one, or concern number one. Concern number two is motive. If this crash
ultimately proves to have been deliberate, it will be fundamentally different from the
knife attacks and the vehicle attacks that China has witnessed in recent years.
Think about it. Learning to fly is not something most people can afford, especially not in China.
It takes money, it takes time, it takes training, and it takes certain professional skills.
Whoever the pilot was, this was almost certainly someone from a rather privileged background with
significant financial wealth. This was definitely not someone struggling to survive,
and this was not someone who is, is not, she's not even middle class, just trying to,
you know, make a living in Beijing. This is someone who is doing very well in the capital
city. So that alone makes the story deeply unsettling. Now there are also unverified
reports circulating online claiming that Ms. Liu suffered substantial, should I put,
should I put her picture back on? Where is she? There she is. Let me put her back.
They say that this woman suffered a tremendous financial loss after a margin call,
a failed margin call, a collapsed margin call related to an investment.
Whether those reports are accurate or whether they had anything to do with this incident
remains unverifiable at this point. But this story is no longer just about an airplane
crashing into a building. It has become a story about some very uncomfortable questions,
questions about Zhongnanhai's security, questions about the sentiment in CCP's elite class,
questions about China's financial market, questions about China's falling economy,
and perhaps most importantly, questions about what could drive someone with the means to become
a licensed pilot to the point of carrying out such an extreme act. So those are questions that
no official statement wants to answer. But those, that's precisely the reason
that Beijing and CITIC downplayed the incident tremendously. But that's precisely the reason why
people can't stop talking about it. So that's what I have for you. This is what I have gathered
so far in the last two days, one and a half days about the incident. I think it's dramatic because
like I said, we've seen knife attacks, we've seen auto vehicle attacks. Now we've seen aviation
attacks. And I think this will be the end of Beijing's low altitude economy because I think
it spells security risk. And I think Beijing might just suspend that initiative altogether
because it could be deadly. All right. With all that said, I want to share with you
the song that our team produced. We wrote a song for July 4th, the 250th anniversary of the founding
of the United States of America. And we wrote a song. We talked about how we want to write a song
because I'm an immigrant, I'm from China, and I want to write a song to reflect
the sentiment of someone who is in China. I asked myself, how would I feel about
the founding of the United States after 250 years if I had been stuck in China?
What would I say or what would I express if I had never left China? And so this is a song written
from that perspective. It's written from the perspective of someone who has never visited
the US. And how would a Chinese living in a totally closed society feel about
the 250th anniversary? So here's the song. And it hasn't been released yet. I'm wearing the earring
for the occasion. So we'll release that shortly. So here's the song.
Can you guys hear it? Yeah? I don't hear anything. Nicole, can you hear it? No? I just
want to make sure. I just want to make sure people can actually hear it. Tell me if you can. I'm going
to play it. Can you tell me? Because I'm using my laptop and the audio setup is all different.
I just want to play it and see if you guys can hear it. I grew up hearing stories on an old TV
screen. They said America was a giant, losing faith inside a dream. They spoke of endless conflicts,
of greed and broken trust. A nation built on power, a kingdom built on dust.
I watched classmates disappear, bound for California,
for places I couldn't pronounce back when I was young.
And I kept asking softly, a question no one liked. If the house is really burning,
why is everyone running inside?
I've seen your mountains. I've never seen your plains. But your name still travels farther
than power ever could. For those denied their freedom, for those still seeking hope,
for those searching for a future they cannot find at home. America,
maybe that's why the world still calls your name.
The years turned into decades. My hair began to gray. The answers weren't in headlines.
They found me anyway. I found them in a sentence written long ago that all men are created equal.
Simple words powerful enough to frighten tyrants still today.
For 250 years, you've carried more than your own dreams. You've carried the hopes of strangers
you'll never know or meet. They look westward, toward a distant light. The land of the free
and the home of the brave. Not because you're perfect, not because you're stronger,
but because you remind the world what free people can become. Now I understand why we call you
May beautiful, leap prosperous, dream strong.
America, may you remain beautiful. May you stay strong.
Who has never seen your shores, yet still believes in what you mean.
All right. I watched the sun in silence because I couldn't hear it, but I've watched it many times.
For those of you who are bilingual, you know, in Chinese, we call the United States of America
Mei. So people never realize what it means, right? Mei means beautiful,
Li means prosperous, and Jian means strong. So yeah, so that's what the name
America means in Chinese. All right. That's how I would feel if I had never come to this country.
That would be the song that I would sing today if I lived in China now. So happy birthday.
And that's it for today. I hope you enjoyed the song and I won't take any questions because I'm
in a hotel room. They'll probably kick me out very soon. Enjoy the rest of your weekend and
I'll be back. I'll see you back when I'm back to the US. Okay. Bye. Bye.