A controversial play in a Mets vs. Cubs game led to a runner being called out on a walk after a replay review. Despite the manager's protests and subsequent ejection, the ruling was correct based on MLB rules regarding live balls during a walk. The video explains why the ball remains live and provides historical examples of similar \"ticky-tack\" calls.
This play in the Mets and Cubs game had everyone talking,
everyone talking about the rules, the situation,
what's going on.
We've got PCA on first base.
The Mets are aware.
They're trying to keep them close.
This one's brought to you by Create.
Try to back pick him.
He's safe.
They thought they were gonna have him.
The catcher's like, ah, thought we had him.
But first base and the Mets aren't getting along right now,
nor any of the other infield positions.
Anyway, PCA, looking to steal.
1-1 pitch, high.
2-1 pitch, check on him, pitcher.
Yep, yep, okay.
They're worried about him getting second base.
We got a foul ball.
We've got a 2-2.
Now it's 3-2 and he's off and running on the 3-2.
It's ball four.
He slides in and the umpire doesn't say anything
because it's ball four, right?
He gets the bag and he's like, can you check it?
Yeah, can you check it?
Yeah, he's gotta put his hand up, you know?
We wanna review things.
Umpire, put your hand up to let us review things.
Umpires get together and they're chatting.
They're like, yeah, well, I guess we can review it
because, yeah, he slid and then he was tagged.
Then he had the base.
They're all talking and PCA's like, what?
Guy in the crowd's like, you're out, dog.
Umpire is gonna address the crowd
and let them know what's going on.
New York is challenging the safe call at second base.
It's a loss.
You see PCA's confused.
The announcer's like, it's a walk.
What are they talking about?
Well, here it is.
He's out, he slides in, he's safe.
What matters, what does?
He says, he literally told me ball four, it's dead.
That's what he said.
PCA's like, what?
He's watching the replay, he's looking up.
He's like, pfft, what are you talking about?
I'm going to second base.
Umpire says, nah.
After the review, the runner initially contacts second base,
loses possession of the base,
and is tagged while losing possession.
Therefore, the runner is out, the call is overturned.
Look at Simeon's face.
He's on the other team, but even he's like, oh, dog.
I don't know, man.
What are these guys doing?
Turns out they're doing just fine.
There's a lot of examples that make this
make a ton of sense, but before I show you those,
let's just watch counsel, because he is mad.
He's just, you just told me that, you said it was dead.
You said it was out at first, then you said it was dead.
What's going on?
Jordan Baker, tallest umpire in the league,
he's looking on, overseeing, overlooking,
and he's like, oh, that's ******* ridiculous.
That's ******* ridiculous.
That is ******* terrible.
That's ridiculous, that is ******* terrible.
And now he's ejected.
He's like, what?
You gotta be shitting me.
That is ******* terrible.
That's not the ******* rule.
He's out?
What did you call him?
He's out?
The ball is dead.
**** you, **** you, **** you.
And he's ejected, and he's gone.
All right, let's take a look at examples.
We poured through game footage from the past
to find out what's going on here,
and this is an example of how you can't get tagged out
on ball four.
You are entitled to second base.
So here's just one example.
It was ball four.
There was a base runner was stealing.
They threw down to second, tagged him out.
No, that's easy.
Everyone understands that rule.
Now, why is it not a dead ball?
Because this happens quite a lot.
The ball gets thrown,
and the runner gets to stand up and run to third.
If you want it to be a dead ball,
then you wouldn't have this,
and this is pretty common.
Like, this doesn't look foreign to anyone,
even though it's ball four.
Sometimes the catcher hears ball four,
and they get a little jarred, and they sail that thing.
Now, because it's not a dead ball, and it's a live ball,
if you were to see this happen,
your brain wouldn't blink.
You would go, uh-huh, Elvis Andrews, where are you going?
It's a live ball, and even he's like, damn, okay?
And he gets tagged out, even though it was ball four.
So that makes sense.
That's why the rule exists.
Sometimes rules exist,
and then they get applied in ticky-tacky ways.
And in 2023, in this Cubs-Giants game,
Madrigal gets tagged in the dick,
and they say, you're out.
And he's like, what?
And then they say, no, we're gonna challenge it,
because they overruled it.
They said, no, he's safe.
And then they challenged it,
and this looks like it was ball four.
He slid past, and then he went back.
Same thing.
Same exact play.
Same exact thing.
He gets tagged in the nuts, and then he's off the bag,
and then he gets tagged on the hand right there,
and it's as if he touched second base
and continued running,
just like what Elvis Andrews did
in that one I showed a second ago
where he gets in a rundown.
So it's the same thing.
Now, when it happened in 2023,
it didn't even make it to my radar
or anyone's radar, I don't think.
They said, yeah, we checked it.
He's out.
And they explained it to the manager,
and he was like, so because he ran past,
then, okay, okay, I get it.
I'm not gonna yell and scream.
So this one didn't make headlines.
But I was like, wait, 2023 Cubs,
2026 Cubs, there's gotta be the same players
on the same team.
So we took a look at the starting nine,
and we've got three guys, Ian Happ, my dude,
Danzy Swanson, Saya Suzuki.
You guys were all on the field
when this happened last time.
I wonder if Happer was like,
yo, Craig, this happened to us already.
Chill, they're right.
They're right.
I tried to call Happ,
but he's playing professional baseball,
so he didn't answer.
Maybe he'll text me.
And say, I did tell Craig that.
Or he'll say, I forgot,
because no one made a big deal out of it.
So when you really boil it down,
it's a ticky-tack call.
All the calls where you touch
and barely bounce off second base
are ticky-tack calls.
But the rule exists for a reason,
and they applied the rule properly.
And this has happened a lot before,
and no one seems to care.
So there you go.
That's the breakdown.
Thanks to Create for sponsoring today's video.
There's two things athletes
have always benefited from,
creatine and electrolytes,
and Create has put both in one stick, one pack.
Code JOMBOY for up to 44% off.
Link in the description.