NEW vs OLD Toyota HiLux Comparison Review: SHOCKING RESULTS!!

POP Cars
24 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
It's been a long time coming. This is the old Hilux, but this one here is the new Hilux. Today
I'm going to compare the two. We're going to take a look at the old Hilux, compare that to the new
Hilux. I'll tell you everything good about the new Hilux, but also some of the things I think
maybe Toyota have been a little bit too conservative on for the new Toyota Hilux.
We'll compare things like the exterior, the interior, how they drive, because I can finally
tell you about that as well. And of course, whether or not you should be rushing out to buy
the new Hilux, or whether you should just purchase the old one. Well, it's still on sale.
Let's get into it. Okay, let's talk about pricing now for the Hilux. It's about two months later
since I filmed this comparison, so now I've actually got the prices in front of me. And
because they've deleted the 2.7 litre petrol engine and the 2.4 litre turbo diesel, and you
can only get the 2.8 turbo diesel, which is a better engine, but boy oh boy does that raise
up the price of entry for a Hilux. It now starts at $33,990 Australian dollars before on-road
costs, and that is for a workmate single cab. That means that if you want to buy a Hilux,
it will cost you $7,515 more than before. What if you want a 4x4 Hilux, and you want the cheapest
4x4 Hilux? Well, because they have deleted those engines, it starts at $45,990 Australian dollars,
which is up over $5,000. And across the rest of the range, prices are up by about $4,000 for each
spec, which is actually kind of reasonable-ish for an all-new, all-new generation. But like I've said
before, under the skin, this really is the same Hilux as before. Interestingly, the Rogue and
Rugged X are both $71,990 Australian dollars. It's the same price as before, and how I think
they've managed to do that is because you don't get the wider track anymore, and so that was the
extra cost. So even though you're technically paying the same amount as before, you are actually
getting less for your money because you don't get the better engineering of having that wider track.
So yeah, pricing is up. If you want to read more about it, I'll leave a link down below. But across
the range, you are spending about $4,000 more on average for a Hilux. What do you guys think about
that? All right, I wanted to wait to talk about how the car looks because I wanted to see what
you guys thought when we released our video on it. So I'm actually filming this on the day that
this video was releasing. You guys do not like the way that the new Hilux looks, and that's kind of
fair enough. I understand it to an extent. However, me personally, I actually think it looks better
than before, especially that front end. It just looks more modern, and I think that Toyota are
actually nailing their designs for their new cars. You're going to get roasted for that. I'm okay
with that. Please let me know in the comments section if you don't agree with me. It is 100
millimeters taller at the front. They've actually increased the front fascia size for crash
regulations, they told us. So apparently this is safer when you crash, or at least crash into
someone. Hopefully you don't do. And by this, he means the Hilux, not the Chinese car behind him.
No. Yeah, don't even think about that one. The sides clearly are exactly the same because the
metal, everything down to the door handles and the cabin specs have remained entirely the same. But
the tub is new, and I really like the tub of the new Hilux. I like the fact you now get a foot
insert. Sure, it copies the Ranger and heaps of other utes, but whatever. It's a good thing. Please
do copy that. I love how the Toyota lettering is embossed and embossed at the back. I love the
Toyota heritage badging at the front of the new Hilux. And even the new taillights, even though
they still are halogen in some parts, which is crazy to me. And by the way, because so many of
you have been like, who cares that it's the same tub dimensions as before? A lot of people actually
care because you can't fit a pallet between the wheel arches. Mic drop. So honestly, I prefer the
of the new Hilux. Let me know what you guys think down in the comment section below. Which do you
like more, the old Toyota Hilux or the new Toyota Hilux? Let's get back to the video.
All right. What about the interior of the new Hilux versus the old Hilux? Well, it is a massive,
massive step up. Technology in here is a hundred thousand times better than before. The layout is
still logical. It makes sense, but it just looks and feels so much better. They've made the interior
quieter. So you have this nice soft touch in so many parts of the cabin that is really important
for stopping sound wave reflection. And it is a quieter interior, not the best in the world,
but it's still good. The seats as well are fantastic too. And the steering wheel,
massive, massive upgrade versus before, except for the wireless charger. That is still not great.
What about back seats? And then there are the back seats of the new Hilux. And here I am a lot
more disappointed. There have not been very many changes at all. And as you'll see with the old
Hilux, just not all that great. Here I am at five foot 11, really not a lot of leg room at all.
Tone is also not great. Headroom is not great. And by the way, this seat is a bit forward of
where I would normally sit. So you don't actually get a huge amount of room. And because it's built
on the old bones, well, you just, you have compromises. So let's talk about the old one.
So all of that is great. You know, the fact that the interior is so much nicer is a massive
improvement. However, it's also based on this Hilux, which is not necessarily a good thing
because there are inherent compromises. Yes, this does feel so much older in comparison.
This digital instrument cluster up in front of you, you could barely call it that. Like it shows
enough information, but it's stuck in the early 2000s. This infotainment display, terrible.
Seriously, one of the worst on any new cars. So I'm glad it's gone. Storage space, interestingly,
is kind of better in this one. There's just a bit more room going on, but it definitely
just feels so much cheaper than the new one. But like I said, it's the same cabin. As a result,
my legs in the new one are at the same angle as this one, which is bad. It's like I'm in an
F1 driver's position. They're really far up. If I was to pretend I'm sitting on a normal chair,
I just can't. My legs are at just such a poor angle because that floor is so high.
This is an old platform. This IMV platform has been around for a long, long time. That's why
they don't use it in the new Prado or Land Cruiser 300 series. And really, if they did use that new
platform, I think we'd be getting way better ergonomics. Because frankly, even these leather
seats, they feel really nice. And it's the same situation with the back seats. Again, this is the
old Hilux, but the same cabin space. It's just not enough. This is my driving position. My legs are
pushing into the seat in front. I don't often see that in modern day cars. Legs are just not at a
great angle. Toes not at a great angle. And again, it's a limitation of this platform. And the fact
that they share the same cabin is just not great. Also, things are pretty carryover. Same air vents,
same USB-C ports, same center fold-down armrests. In fact, to me, the seats feel almost identical.
So I'm not sure how much they've changed in the back seats, despite saying it is all new. Maybe
it is, it just doesn't feel it. Which begs the question, what about driving experience? Let's
drive it. Okay, driving the Hilux. But you might be wondering, Matt, isn't that the old Hilux?
And the honest answer is yes. Yes, it is the old Hilux. You see, Toyota are a mega conservative
company, as you may know, as you can probably tell. And so even though I have driven the new Hilux,
and I can show you footage of driving the Hilux, I wasn't able to film, which is really unfortunate.
But I literally just got out of it. So let me tell you about it. And it's both a good and a bit of a
disappointing story. So under the skin, these two cars are almost identical. But as you can probably
hear by my voice, kind of shaking here, there is one huge benefit for the new Hilux. You see,
both Hiluxes are powered by the same engine. It is, of course, the 2.8 liter turbo diesel 1GD engine.
It is a really beloved engine, frankly, it's extremely reliable, and it puts out enough power
and torque. 150 kilowatt of power, 500 newton meters of torque. I say enough, because really,
I think that the power should have been improved for the new Hilux. It is new after all,
but it's the exact same drivetrain, down to the six-speed Azen Torque Converter transmission.
That means that this also gets the V-Active mild hybrid system. So if we come to a stop,
even here on this terrible gravel, you can see that the car turns off. But it's a really seamless
start. It's not like the Ranger. It's actually much better than the Ranger's start-stop system.
So yeah, that's really good. So I guess a little bit of a red flag that they haven't really done
anything to the engine. But also, the kind of buyer who buys a Hilux probably doesn't really
care about having more power and more torque, even though it is absolutely useful for things like
towing. However, that also means that this thing still has a part-time four-wheel drive system,
which I think is just totally unacceptable. And this is a great example. I'm currently
on a gravel road, and we are kind of scrambling for traction. But I can put this thing into
four-high on an unsealed surface. Do not do this on a sealed surface. You will destroy
your center differential. And hey, at least now we have four-wheel drive, but part-time four-wheel
drive. Massive no-no. This thing should have gotten the Prado system and had—my voice is shaking so
much—and should have had a permanent four-wheel drive. That aside, the major benefit of the new
Hilux is its new suspension. It gets new dampers. It's got new valves within those new dampers.
And a new suspension tune, though they haven't told us exactly what that is yet. Still under
wraps. But all I can tell you is that the improvement is massive. Do I think it's best
in class? No. It rides firm, but it is so much more comfortable, particularly for backseat
passengers as well. And the rear ride just does not feel as fidgety as it feels right now, which
is just a poor ride. These have had a poor ride for a long time, and people put up with it, but
you shouldn't have to. And I'm happy to say that they've fixed it. The other thing as well is the
steering. Now, here you feel everything through the steering wheel because it is still hydraulic
steering wheel. In the new Hilux, that new electronic power steering is so much better.
You have much better control of the car. It potentially feels a little bit more vague versus
this. Still quite heavy. Get into this Hilux versus that. You will notice the difference night
and day. Again, it's something that should have come earlier, but hey, at least they've addressed
that now. Oh, the ride in this is bad. The other thing as well is it's quite loud in here. You can
really hear the engine. It's noisy. It's unrefined. The new Hilux is far better at that
too. They've added a bunch of NVH stuff and chassis stiffening, even though it shares the
same ladder frame. It's got more spot welds. It's got better engine mounts. It is an improved
experience on the inside, and that is definitely welcome. So even though it retains this 2.8 litre
turbo diesel, and by the way, every other engine option has been deleted from the new Hilux. You
only get it as a 2.8 litre turbo diesel now. Apparently, customers don't care. I don't know.
You can let me know your thoughts down in the comment section below. Fuel economy too is just
okay for the class, even with this hybrid technology. A Triton demolishes this in terms
of its engine refinement, frankly, but also fuel economy. I'm averaging 9.1 litres per 100
kilometres driving this thing around, mostly on highway. A Triton, you'd be getting low sevens,
but at the same time, the ride quality is beyond better, because this thing is rough as guts.
But what about off-roading? Let's talk about that. So what about off-roading? How do these compare?
Well, as you'll see, this Rogue has a nice and wide track, because the Hilux was fitted with a
wider track than some other variants like the GR Sport. However, the track width has now been
re-narrowed. Essentially, it's been put back to whatever a regular Hilux was, which in some
instances is good. If you're going through some really narrow off-roading course, having a narrower
track is actually a really good thing. However, it does come at the cost of some stability when
you are off-road, or sometimes you don't want to be within the narrow track. I will say though,
whether you go for an old one or you have a new one, they're really, really good off-road. In fact,
the new one has upgraded multi-terrain select. What is that? Well, it's different traction
control systems. You can use, for example, rock or mud, and it will modulate the brakes and the
traction control system to essentially keep you going. It can almost get rid of having a lockable
rear differential. By the way, because it is all carryover, you can only lock that rear differential
when you are in four low, using the low range transfer case, which for most people isn't a
bother, but I just hate the fact that you do have to do that anyway. It's old and it's archaic, but
we did some relatively gnarly off-roading today. Some really steep hills, heaps of rain, heaps of
I've got to say, the new Hilux performs so well. In fact, I think because of those traction control
systems, the multi-terrain select, it really is just better at off-roading even than this.
It's also got updated hill descent control that will now hold you at three to four kilometres an
hour. You can't set it, you can't change it, which again, is silly, I think. Apparently,
customer feedback was that people didn't care, but really, the more customisability you can have
with your off-roader, the better. That aside, the Hilux is a fantastic off-roader and I think
the new one, particularly with its really smart software that has been recalibrated,
yeah, it's a bit of a winner. All right, so final thoughts on this comparison. Should you just go
and buy the old Hilux or rush forward to the new Hilux? Well, look, there's a lot of improvements
with the new Hilux. I think the ride quality alone is enough for me to be like, go out and
purchase the new Hilux. I gotta say, it does still feel in a lot of ways like the old Hilux.
Once you're sitting inside of it, apart from that really, really nice new interior, it drives quite
similarly as you would expect. So, I really would have hoped that they would have done more of a
generational leap, frankly, between the old versus new. This doesn't feel like old Ranger
versus new Ranger. This feels like Hilux versus Hilux. That's maybe 25% better. But let me know
what you guys think down in the comments section below. Would you rush out and buy the old or the
new Hilux? And of course, if you want to buy any new car like a Hilux, you want the best price
possible, scan the QR code on your screen now or just Google CarSource Buy. Our team of car buyers
will help you get the best price possible. Join thousands of happy customers. Oh, and subscribe.
That really helps the channel out too. Ciao for now.
