For decades, companies moved manufacturing overseas in search of lower costs. Now that equation is changing. Labor costs in China have risen, tariffs and geopolitical tensions have added new risks, and companies are rethinking where products should be made. Yet bringing production back to the United States is proving far more complicated than many expected.
As manufacturers look for alternatives, countries like Mexico, India, and Vietnam are attracting new investment. At the same time, advances in automation are changing what modern factories look like and where they can operate. The result is a global manufacturing landscape that is becoming more diversified, with businesses weighing cost, resilience, market access, and long-term risk all at once.
In this episode, we speak with Rosemary Coates, Executive Director of the Reshoring Institute and a veteran supply chain consultant with decades of experience helping companies evaluate global manufacturing strategies. She explains why many firms are exploring alternatives to China, why Mexico has emerged as a major manufacturing destination, and what it would take for more production to return to the United States. Along the way, she discusses automation, supply chain resilience, labor economics, and the future of global manufacturing. ----- 02:18 The Manufacturing Evolution 03:44 Where Manufacturing Is Moving 06:46 China's Lost Cost Advantage 10:13 What Drives Factory Location? 13:16 Xinjiang Cotton and Supply Chains 14:36 Why Automation Has Limits 16:36 The Reality of U.S. Reshoring 18:30 Why Leaving China Is Hard 22:43 When Workers Block a Factory Exit 26:18 Supply Chains in a New Era 30:14 A Reshoring Conversion Story 33:17 The New Global Manufacturing Map 36:59 Why Manufacturing Still Matters 40:54 Inside Mexico's Factory Boom 44:57 America's Next Manufacturing Wave ----- Let's Stay in Contact: • Substack - https://substack.com/@themarketinsidershow • X (Twitter) - https://twitter.com/MktInsiderShow • Linkedin - https://www.linkedin.com/company/market-insider-show/ ----- 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘷𝘪𝘦𝘸𝘴 𝘦𝘹𝘱𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘦𝘥 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘷𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘰 𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘨𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘥𝘰 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘯𝘦𝘤𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘢𝘳𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘳𝘦𝘧𝘭𝘦𝘤𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘷𝘪𝘦𝘸𝘴 𝘰𝘧 𝘔𝘢𝘳𝘬𝘦𝘵 𝘐𝘯𝘴𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘳. 𝘛𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘯𝘵 𝘪𝘴 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘦𝘥𝘶𝘤𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘭 𝘱𝘶𝘳𝘱𝘰𝘴𝘦𝘴 𝘰𝘯𝘭𝘺 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘴𝘩𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘣𝘦 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘴𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘪𝘢𝘭, 𝘪𝘯𝘷𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘮𝘦𝘯𝘵, 𝘰𝘳 𝘭𝘦𝘨𝘢𝘭 𝘢𝘥𝘷𝘪𝘤𝘦. 𝘈𝘭𝘸𝘢𝘺𝘴 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘴𝘶𝘭𝘵 𝘢 𝘲𝘶𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘧𝘪𝘦𝘥 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘧𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘭 𝘣𝘦𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘦 𝘮𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘪𝘢𝘭 𝘥𝘦𝘤𝘪𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴. 𝘚𝘰𝘮𝘦 𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘬𝘴 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘥𝘦𝘴𝘤𝘳𝘪𝘱𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘮𝘢𝘺 𝘣𝘦 𝘢𝘧𝘧𝘪𝘭𝘪𝘢𝘵𝘦 𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘬𝘴.
There is a lot of talk about manufacturing coming back to the U.S.
Is it coming back? And what's happening with China? Today we sit down with Rosemary Coates,
who was involved with outsourcing to China, but now she wants to bring companies back
to the U.S. and other parts of the world. Exiting China can be very challenging. You have to apply
for permits. You can't just close up the factory and leave. I mean, if you're building some kind
of technology that they think is really important, they may not permit you to leave. So that's one
thing. If you have supplied equipment or a machine made in China that's used in a production factory,
you think you own it. And that's not the way the Chinese are going to look at it.
She also will tell us which regions are prospering from manufacturing and what
lowest cost labor areas are. I'm Siamak. Welcome to Market Insider.
Rosemary, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you. I'm happy to be here. We want to
talk to you about manufacturing. And there are some big shifts globally in the supply chain
system and the manufacturing. What are you seeing out there right now? Big changes in manufacturing
for sure. So I've had a long career in manufacturing over about 40 years and have seen
manufacturing leave America to go overseas, particularly throughout Asia and then
specifically into China from the late 90s to today, but also mostly through about 2015 or so.
Today's environment, we're seeing a lot of manufacturing being developed in Mexico.
So companies are interested in reshoring, but if they can't make the economic case for that,
then they're shifting their priorities to other places in the world and basically out of China.
So yeah, manufacturing has not only developed in terms of its strategy, but the technology is
really advanced. If you go into a manufacturing shop today, it's full of computers and machine
tools and robots and sophisticated equipment that was never there before. And is it like that in
Asia and other places or the manufacturing here? It's very automated. Manufacturing has a curve to
it. And the low level manufacturing, like assembly work that's done with a lot of people or a lot of
handwork, a lot of content, labor content in it. We see that in developing countries all over the
world. Even China is shedding a lot of that low level kind of manufacturing to other countries
where it's less expensive and where people are desperate for jobs. So the developing countries,
third world countries take on that kind of manufacturing. But then manufacturing is a
curve. So as you move up the curve, it gets more sophisticated. You might go from those kind of
assembly jobs to more of a factory environment where you've got some machine tools, but you
sell people and so forth, all the way up to very sophisticated manufacturing. Tesla, for example,
if you go to a Tesla factory, it's full of robots. There really aren't any people there.
It's all machinery and robots that are manufacturing the goods. So it's a curve over
time. And as manufacturers develop, as economies develop, you'll see there's more and more
sophistication in manufacturing. Now, when you're saying that manufacturing is pulling out of China,
is any of it coming to the U.S. or is it all going to Mexico? And what is coming to U.S.,
what is going to Mexico? Yeah, that's a great question. So, you know, I run the Reshoring
Institute. So for many years, I helped companies offshore to China and find sources in China.
And then after the 2012 election, where Mitt Romney and Barack Obama were China bashing,
telling Americans that it was all China's fault and China was stealing our jobs and all of that.
And at that point, I think a lot of executives that I was working with would say to me,
get me to China or get me home. And there was a lot of change, I think, and turbulence during
that time as people were rethinking their global strategy. And as a result of that,
we developed the Reshoring Institute. But we developed a process that you can go through
to determine where in the world you could manufacture, sort of a total cost of ownership,
but more sophisticated than that. So, you know, you can evaluate your costs and where it's
appropriate, where your markets are. I mean, all of a sudden, it got more complicated. So it used
to be, you know, my clients would say to me, just get me to China. I know it's cheaper. Let's go,
you know, just get me there, make it happen. But today, that same decision is very complicated.
You know, it's can we manufacture in the US for the US market? Can we, you know, move some
manufacturing to Asia? How do we mitigate our worldwide risk? Can we go to Eastern Europe?
Is there risk because of the Ukraine war? You know, there's all sort of geopolitical factors,
as well as cost factors, as well as growth in customer base. So what what happened
over the last few years, what we're seeing is because of the geopolitics,
and, and some about the tariffs, although I don't think the tariffs have really
driven a lot of manufacturing back to the US. But at any rate, companies are now rethinking
that global strategy, so that they're pulling out of China. One of the studies that we did was
really quite interesting is we looked at 12 countries, and 10 job categories. So we looked
at jobs like machinists, or machine tool operator, or manufacturing supervisor, or manufacturing
engineer. And we compared the labor rates for those 10 categories, in 12 different countries,
China is no longer the cheapest alternative. China is like right in the middle, and the labor rates
have gone up there. On the low end is Mexico. So Mexico is cheaper than China. Mexico is fairly
significantly cheaper than China. Yes. So on the low end is Mexico, India, and Vietnam. So
and we're actually seeing the growth of manufacturing in those places. Vietnam became
very popular for a while as companies were moving out of China. But Vietnam only has 95 million
people, and their factories are full. It's really hard to find capacity in Vietnam. Mexico has lots
of advantages because proximity to the US. So you don't have to put anything in a container,
you can just drive across the border. We have USMCA, which is a trade deal between Canada,
Mexico, and the US, that if you are manufacturing, and the growth, and labor, and everything involved
in manufacturing in Mexico, it originates in Mexico, you essentially can bring items in duty
free into the US. So you're looking at comparisons like that. If you have a, you know, a 60 or 80%
tariff rate, combined tariff rate on products coming from China versus zero from Mexico,
the labor rates lower, and the infrastructure is pretty good. And their new president,
Claudia Scheinbaum, is very focused on developing business in Mexico. So if you look at these
comparisons, a lot of companies are very interested in Mexico for that reason. So I would
say that's reassuring and nearshoring. So if companies come to Mexico, what about the transportation?
Is that a big advantage when you're shipping something across the globe? Is the shipping cost
very little when it comes to products, or is that a big factor for people? Depends on what
commodity you're shipping. And the other thing is, you know, most companies now have sustainability
as part of their executive orders. So they want to develop green manufacturing and focus on
sustainability in their business. So when you look at the carbon footprint around the world,
bringing things from proximity, that are in proximity from Mexico, has much less carbon
footprint than bringing something from Asia. So it could be slightly cheaper because you're
going over the road traffic and it has a smaller carbon footprint from Mexico.
So what we're finding is, I mean, we would love, we're the reshoring institute, so we
love to bring manufacturing back to the U.S. And we try that as the first alternative. But often
we can't make the economic case for it. It's just too expensive here. Our labor rates are too
expensive. The regulatory environment is difficult to navigate. The overall cost of operations is
generally higher. So, you know, we look at the economics of that. The other thing that I would
say is very, very important, and that's their costed bill of materials. And that means everything that
goes into building a product. So what's the cost of the, you know, the components,
the cost of the metal, the cost of all that, and the cost of labor. And so when you look at a costed
bill of material and you understand how much is related to labor, let's say 50% of the cost to
build a product is labor related, versus a product that is made in an automated environment and
there's very little labor. Then you look at the labor rates around the world and you can see that
if you can automate production, take all that labor out, and make things by machines, you can really
produce anywhere, including the U.S. So when we're working with clients, if they have a lot of labor
in the product that they're making, you know, it's kind of a no-brainer to say you need to find a
low-cost labor country like Mexico, right, or India. These are places where the labor
cost is very low and there's a lot of assembly work and so forth. But if you can automate that same
production and have capital investment in machinery, you can locate in the U.S. You know, there are lots
of places in the U.S. where the labor rates are lower than other places and, you know, lands
available and so forth. Let me give you an example. If you are a company that makes men's shirts,
there's a lot of sewing in making a men's shirt. You have to sew on the collar and the sleeves and,
right, so there's a lot of people at sewing machines that are making men's shirts. They're not
made by a machine somewhere. They're people at sewing machines. So there's a lot of labor content
to it. But if you are a company that makes the fabric that goes into the shirt, textile production
is fully automated. I don't know if you've ever been into a textile factory, but you walk
in there and it's all machines. There's no people. You know, there's some engineers that maybe are
walking around tweaking some machines from time to time, but mostly they're in a control room
watching what the machines are doing and the fabrics are made in a very automated way.
So as a result, you can see there's textile production in North Carolina and South Carolina
and Alabama and Mississippi because it's an automated process. It doesn't require that high
that high cost of labor. If you're making men's shirts, on the other hand, those are typically in
Bangladesh and lots of places in China still, places where India, places where the labor costs
are relatively low, also Central America. So it's different looking at it. So does the textile go
from the U.S. to those countries? Yeah. And so it's worth to produce them there even though the
shipping costs across the world? Yeah, I mean, lots of textiles are made all over the world
and depending on like silks and so forth. So you can get them in local? Yeah. So, you know,
depends on what you're making, but it gets really complicated with some regulations also. So for
example, there's import regulations on forced labor, the Uyghurs. In China, there are a lot
of labor camps. Yeah. Yes. And in particularly in Xinjiang province, in far Western China,
they grow a lot of cotton and that cotton and because it's made or grown and the use of forced
labor is there, the U.S. restricts imports of any cotton from Xinjiang province. So think about
supply chains, right? So you've got cotton that then gets processed, that then gets woven into
fabric, the fabric gets sewn and so forth. You know, this is the supply chain, right?
On the U.S. side, if we look at a men's shirt that has cotton content that originated in Xinjiang
province, that's restricted. You cannot import it into the U.S. How do they know, right? I mean,
it just seems like you're looking at a shirt, how are you going to know where the cotton was?
But the sophistication is pretty good. They now can do DNA testing. They can test them.
DNA testing and they know the origin almost down to the field of where the product was grown.
Now, in terms of that kind of manufacturing, you said when you were making shirts, men's shirts,
you have to have sewing. Can that get automated? You know, some. I mean, so another example is
athletic shoes. So, you know, running shoes, right?
There's been a number of companies that have tried to automate that process. Adidas, for example,
German manufacturer tried to automate the production of shoes and it was not successful.
There's just too much labor requirements and so forth. I've been to, I work for a big running
shoe company. They asked me to go and visit all their factories in China and Vietnam. A couple
years ago, they were having some quality issues and they wanted me to go and evaluate what was
happening. And I was astonished. I, you know, I've seen a lot of things, but boy, you walk into a
factory and there are people, a lot of people sitting at sewing machines that are sewing the
uppers part of the fabric. And so, you know, there was a lot of sewing, but then there were also
these people who were gluing the little squares on the back of your, on the bottom of your shoe,
you know, how there are patterns and different colors and stuff. Each one of those squares is
individually glued by a person sitting at a workstation in China or Vietnam. And then they
go through a heat treat process. So all kinds of melds together, but there's so much labor
involved there that some parts of it can be automated, but a lot of it cannot. It's just,
it just requires labor. So the answer to your question, can't we automate things like that?
Maybe, and some of the production might be able to be automated in a way, like a heat treat
machine, for example, but a lot of it is still going to have labor content that's really difficult
to automate. Now your clients you're talking to, companies you're talking to that they want to
come back and they want to reshore, are there big challenges for them to come back to the U.S.?
I would say instead of a challenge, it's really thinking through that strategy. There are like so
many variables now. Certainly, you know, there's a challenge with the cost related to it. So we
looked at labor rates all across the U.S. So there are places in the South and in like Texas where
the labor rate, the minimum wage is like seven dollars an hour. I mean, it's really astonishing.
I live in Silicon Valley in San Francisco. The minimum wage is over twenty-five dollars an hour.
So, you know, you can look around the world at labor rates. In Mexico, for example, the average
labor rate is three dollars and twelve cents. So even the lowest rate in the U.S. at seven dollars
and something an hour versus three dollars in Mexico, you can see if you have a lot of labor
content, it makes sense to go there. So there's these kind of variables, you know, when I'm
working with executives that you have to decide where in the world do you want to go? What makes
economic sense to do it? What are the geopolitics? I mean, are we going to be in a fight with that
country in a year or two? Is that country going to be in a war? Is this country in a
low-lying area where you got to worry about hurricanes and wildfires? You know, we're here
in California, right? And we're always worried about wildfires and factories burning down.
That makes the decision really complicated because there are so many of these variables.
And is it hard for companies to exit China? And are a lot of companies looking at that?
Exiting China can be very challenging also. So this is, you know, part of how I work with a lot
companies is talking them through the difficulties in extracting yourself from China. So first of all,
you have to apply for permits. You can't just close up the factory and leave. You have to
apply to be able to leave. And the Chinese government may have reasons to slow walk that
permit or not allow it or whatever. I mean, if you're building some kind of technology that they
think is really important, then they're going to try to keep you there, right? They may not permit
you to leave. So that's one thing. Another thing is that most Chinese workers in factories are on
labor contracts. So they have, they'll go to work in a factory and they sign a contract for a year
or two. And if you leave the factory or close it down, you have to pay out. You have to pay out
the entire. Yeah. Yeah. Had to have a few tough conversations with CFOs about the cost of leaving
because of that. So they have to pay out all these contracts and you know, that can be quite expensive
to do that. That's another issue to deal with. If you have supplied equipment, right? So you've
sent a machine tool or you've had a mold or made in China or a machine made in China that's used
in production factory. You think you own it and that's not the way the Chinese are going to look
at it, right? So once you have a machine that you've delivered to their factory or has been
made in China or a mold that was made in China, it sort of becomes part of their infrastructure.
Well, it's hard. It's hard. It depends on how you've written the contract and if you have
done it properly so that the Chinese factory will respect that contract. That's, you know,
a lot of Westerners make that mistake. They think they can apply a Western contractor.
They go on AI and they develop a contract they think is good and it's going to protect them. And
that's not really the case. So, you know, so leaving China, so you may have trouble getting
your machinery back. Also, occasionally the Chinese government will restrict used equipment
from coming from being exported. So you're going to have a problem there. And then the last thing
to consider, well, not the last thing, there are lots of things to consider, but one of the big
other things is you have taught this factory how to make your product. You've given them
the schematics, the engineering drawings, the blueprints. You have, they know who all the
sources are. So who are sending products and components and so forth to the factory to build
this product for you. You've taught them how to do it. You've taught them the quality standards.
They have your drawings. And so you're going to leave and you think that they're going to just
go to sleep at night and forget all that. You know, they're going to come back to work the
next day and continue to make that product just under a different name. So you're, you know,
And they're going to compete with you probably at half the price.
Oh yeah. There are stories of people going to like a trade show in Europe and they find
their own product that they didn't make sitting there, you know, being sold. And it's because
they left the factory in China. So even though you own the factory or is this for cases where
you're outsourcing to a factory or both? It could be a number of things. I mean,
it sort of depends on the situation, but yeah, I mean, it's, it's not easy to just, you know,
you could, you know, lock the door and turn off the lights and get on a plane and leave China.
Right. A few years ago, there was a good example of a guy, a guy from Florida who was running a
medical consumable. So throw away stuff like bandages and things like that. So consumables
that you throw away. And he determined it was cheaper to, to make that product in India and
decided he was going to move the factory from China to India. And so he started packing things
up and so forth and his employees got wind of what was happening in China and they captured him
essentially. And they held him prisoner in his office for two weeks. And so, I mean, they fed
him and everything wasn't, you know, horrible, but he couldn't leave. They wouldn't let him leave.
And it was because they expected a payout of all their wages. They were under contract. You know,
interestingly, the authorities, the police in China are not there to handle civil disputes
like you would expect in the West. So police are there to enforce the laws of the government,
that it's a different idea. And so they're not going to come and try to resolve this issue.
So he was kind of stuck there trying to figure out what to do. And he had phone access and so
forth. And he found out there was a NBC TV crew that was nearby filming something else. And so
he got in touch with them somehow or another and asked them to come and they did. They came and
filmed at the place and showed him in his office, you know, waving through the window.
And eventually the employees, you know, they negotiated with the employees and he had to pay
them and then they let him go. So he had to pay future wages. Yeah. Essentially like,
kind of like we do severance, like you get to pay a loan. You know, this guy thought he'd just,
you know, lock up the factory and lay everybody off and leave. And it's not that easy. Right. So,
and that's an example. I've heard other examples similar to that, where the employees got
far in advance about a factory leaving and they were not happy about it. And they either, you
know, sabotage production or they slowed things down or whatever. So, you know, that's, you know,
we coach clients about leaving. We always tell them, don't, don't announce it. You know, this
is not a good idea. And you have to think about all these things in advance. Like, are you going
to have to pay out people? How do you get your drawings and your molds and so forth, you know,
moved and that sort of thing. So planning for it in advance and sort of in secret until you're
ready to go. But then you may never be allowed back in. Chinese government's going to say,
no, you can't get a visa to come back. And the other thing is, you know, the Chinese economy is
vibrant. I mean, they're growing, even though there are issues with employment and so forth.
But, you know, last year they grew at five percent. So you don't want to, and the market is
enormous in China. So if you don't want to give up the market. Yeah. If you're building a product,
you don't want to shoot yourself in the foot and say, we can't, you know, we can't sell it in China.
So thinking through these kind of strategic decisions in terms of where you're manufacturing
can be daunting, you know, and difficult for executives that are not used to making those
kind of decisions. Are people looking in concern about China and they want to pull out or what are
people doing right now? The ReSharing Institute is nonprofit and nonpartisan. So I hate to make,
you know, statements about politics, but the Trump administration has made it difficult
in terms of dealing with China. You know, we're not that friendly with other countries around
the world because of the Trump administration policies. So, you know, it's not that the
factories aren't there. Factories are fabulous in China. I mean, man, I've seen some things
that are just incredible in terms of capability and, you know, sophistication. And I mean,
just, you know, there's a lot of infrastructure in China. If I'm going to move or extract myself,
how do I deal with the geopolitics that sort of overlay all this? So it isn't necessarily the
factory doesn't want to deal with you, but now they've got to worry about their government.
You know, what's the government going to say? The Chinese government hasn't just
sat back and done nothing when we put sanctions on them or tariffs on them.
They've retaliated with tariffs of their own and their own sanctions.
I was dealing the other day with a company that asked me about the new
restrictions the Chinese government has placed on supply chain mapping. So most companies now
in supply chain map all of their suppliers. So, you know, we've got tier one suppliers,
then you've got the suppliers to the suppliers and the suppliers to the suppliers. So tier one,
tier two and tier three, all the way down to mining or growing or, you know, all the way down
there. They will they will map it. Right. And that that became very popular, especially after
the pandemic. So you want to know exactly where everything is coming from, where it's coming from
and also to identify risks. So if you say, oh, man, you know, this factory burned down their
level three, a tier three supplier, but it's going to affect my whole supply chain, right?
Because you can't get parts now. So, you know, identifying risks like that. So there's been
a lot of movement towards supply chain mapping over the last few years. And that's particularly
important with the UFLPA, which is the Uyghur, the Uyghur regulations in the U.S.
So the U.S. Customs Service is going to say, prove to me that your stuff doesn't come from
Xinjiang province and it wasn't labor. Yeah. So you have to map your supply chain to determine that
you need to know every level of suppliers to be able to prove to the U.S. government, U.S. Customs,
that this is not a product from from forced labor. But the Chinese government has retaliated
recently in the last few months and put restrictions on that. So they consider that
extraterritorial. And that means a foreign country is coming in and meddling in local laws.
So they've said, you can't do that. You cannot, you know, go and try to investigate all the way
down in your supply chain. So here you got a company in the U.S. trying to import goods,
trying to deal with U.S. customs laws that says map your supply chain. And the Chinese government
saying, no, you can't. So, you know, there's there's it's stuck between a rock and a hard spot.
And I think that's a good example of how, you know, geopolitics and the overlay of that
affects global supply chain management. You were involved with with outsourcing to China.
And how did you go from that to reshoring? Because you're running a nonprofit that's
advocating for reshoring. Yeah, we did a lot of outsourcing. I worked for some big consulting
firms and then went out on my own and was helping companies offshore to China. That was I got really
good at it. And I wrote a book about it. It was a bestseller and all this stuff. And I was doing a
lot of that. And, you know, in the process of doing that, we we shut down a lot of factories
in America. I knew we were putting people out of work. I mean, it was really starting to get to me.
I was not that excited about all this that was going on, even though that was my job. Right. But
you know, I was beginning to feel it wasn't the right thing. And then along came the 2012
presidential election. And Barack Obama and Mitt Romney were both saying, you know, this is a big
problem with China and all that. And I'm like, oh, man, I can't tell anybody what I do for a
living. You know, this is bad. But I think, you know, that election triggered a lot of executives
to start thinking about the process and thinking about whether it was a good idea to outsource
everything to China. And so we, you know, out of that, we developed a methodology for evaluating
where in the world to manufacture and could we actually bring some manufacturing back.
And I would say, you know, there was some steady growth, kind of minor, but some steady growth in
jobs coming back to the U.S. and manufacturing coming back until the pandemic. And then all
of a sudden, you know, everybody kind of sat up and said, holy cow, we're vulnerable. You know,
our supply chains are all over the world. We don't know where the risks are. You know, we
can't get parts from China that we had depended on. If you look at a pharmaceutical industry,
for example, the basic building blocks to a lot of pharmaceuticals like aspirin, for example,
Tylenol, antibiotics, the basic building blocks are all made in China. The fundamental building
blocks of those, China and India. And so, I mean, just think about what would happen in the U.S.
if we couldn't get antibiotics because there was some sort of supply chain disruption or
the Chinese government restricted the exports from China. And so, you know, this idea that we
are very vulnerable and you really need to rethink those supply chains came of age and
reshoring became much more popular after that. Right now, there's a lot of talk about bringing
investment to the U.S. and we are hearing about data centers, factories. Is this mainly the
activity that's going to start in the U.S.? Do you think it's mainly the people that are starting new
or is it that some of these existing manufacturing that's getting done other places is going to come
here? I think my view is that manufacturing is evolving. It isn't so much something has stopped
and something has started. It's more, you know, changes over time. Businesses evolve over time.
You know, what we were doing three years ago looks different from what we're doing today.
So I think there's, you know, companies that are rethinking those decisions, trying to decide.
When I, you know, like one executive I talked to in the last week or so, originally the company
established in the U.S. from the 1960s and they were making products here. Then in the late 90s
or early 2000s, they moved all of that production to China. It was much cheaper, right? And so they
didn't have anything left here except management and, you know, sort of a shell company in the U.S.
Today, that same manager is saying, now what do we do? You know, the tariffs have made it
expensive. The geopolitics is a problem. You know, how do we rethink our global manufacturing
so that we don't necessarily leave, completely leave China, but can we re-establish the
manufacturing in the U.S.? Can we establish the manufacturing in Mexico? So we have like
now three centers, right? Or, you know, other options. Do we move some to Vietnam or, you know,
there are all different kinds of approaches for that. Is there a number you put on for your
clients in terms of the risk of China? Is there a certain percentage of cost that you say
you're manufacturing in China, there is X amount of risk for you? Not a specific number. I would
say it sort of depends on the industry. So if you're making electronics, I mean, you know,
the Pearl River Valley, Guangzhou, Dongguan, Shenzhen are, you know, that's the factory of
the world for electronics. There's no question about that. It's still there. Components mostly
come from there. It's, you know, that's going to be standard. And even though there are tariffs
and restrictions and so forth, there's still a massive amount of activity there. But if you're
making something else, you know, you're making pharmaceuticals, then, you know, that's a little,
that's a different business model. So you might consider moving out of China and into more into
India or, you know, some other Central America, for example, is up and coming. If you're making
semiconductors, we're seeing a lot of semiconductor movement around the world and development in
certain places. I know Costa Rica has got a very aggressive strategy for bringing semiconductor
production to Costa Rica. So, you know, there's all these different things that are happening
around the world now. And we didn't have to deal with 25 years ago. It was much simpler.
It was all China.
Yeah, it was all China. And before that, in the 60s, it was all America. You know,
America was the manufacturing hub of the world.
What's the value of that?
Well, you know, manufacturing is the backbone of a lot of economies, including China. You know,
really, the development of the Chinese economy was on the back of manufacturing. But in the U.S.,
even though manufacturing is only about 11 or 12 percent of our economy,
structurally, it's really important for us to have manufacturing here. It has a higher value,
economic value, for one. If you put somebody to work at a manufacturing plant and they earn
an average wage of, say, $85,000 a year, $65,000 to $85,000 a year, for a factory worker,
it's pretty average. In most places in the country, not California, California is too expensive,
but most places in the country, that's middle class. That's squarely middle class. And what
we know about middle class people is they buy homes and they buy cars and they go to the beauty
shop and they shop in the local grocery store. And, you know, it has this economic magnifier
effect on the economy. It's very, very important. So structurally, you know, to make the economy
stable and consistent, manufacturing is very important for that part of it.
And then the other thing is, you know, there's risk. I mean, we don't necessarily want to
manufacture, say, weapons or, you know, some of our defense equipment overseas somewhere.
I mean, you know, that needs to be manufactured here. And so those kind of, you know,
considerations, depending on the industry, are what we're seeing in terms of those strategic
decisions. You mentioned that at some point you were in the process of outsourcing and you saw
people losing their jobs. You felt bad. Can you tell us, what was those moments like?
Yeah, I was not the person that was laying people off, but, you know, I was involved in projects
where factories would close. And, you know, just I've been all over the country. I've seen,
you know, the small towns where there was a factory that employed most of the people and
it closed. And so, you know, a lot of people out of work and that creates this terrible economic
effect. And I think, you know, a lot of our presidents over the last 25 years or so have
tried to address that in different policies by creating innovation hubs and, you know,
trying to move manufacturing along in terms of sophistication. And it's because of that economic
magnifier effect. It's really important. And then, you know, Trump's approach is to put tariffs on
everything. And what that does is make foreign goods look more expensive. It's not that they
are more expensive. It just makes them look more expensive because you're taxing them, right?
And that's supposed to generate more work for U.S. factories because it looks like the
foreign goods are more expensive. It hasn't had much of an effect. It's been more of just
increasing costs in the factories. But, you know, there are different strategies like that that
presidents have tried to apply to help strengthen manufacturing in America because it's the backbone
of our economy, because it's very solid and, you know, it's different than, say,
you know, a service economy. What is coming to Mexico? Interestingly, Mexico has a new president,
a woman, Claudia Scheinbaum. She was elected about two years ago now, and she promised to
develop business centers and kind of industrial parks, 100 industrial parks.
And she's been very active in promoting manufacturing in Mexico. And it's for that
same reason we were talking about before. It's got this economic magnifier effect.
It's very good for economies to have manufacturing.
Because it will create more jobs, or is it?
Yes.
It will pull people to the middle class.
And basically, manufacturing jobs pay better than almost anything else. So it's very,
very effective in creating a middle class.
Do they also last longer? Is that once they come?
Well, yeah. I mean, there's big investments.
So people will have these jobs for longer.
Yeah. They pay better. You learn some skills. You may learn how to operate a robot or, you know,
things that are going to be good skills and better paying jobs and so forth.
So Claudia Scheinbaum is really focused on the development of manufacturing in Mexico.
And so they're developing industrial parks. They're building new roads.
Now, they've got problems, too. I mean, they have to deal with crime at the border, the cartels,
drug traffic. And, you know, there are still lots of issues like that, that it's not all perfect.
But it's very attractive. And so you're seeing, like, the development of automotive.
Boy, Tesla just built a mega factory near Monterey.
And it's a, you know, they're making Teslas.
There's a lot of automotive. All the big brands are there,
either for final assembly or for some traffic parts and so forth.
I was down at the Port of Laredo. I took one of our interns with me down to Laredo.
And we went to see the activity because I'd heard there was, you know, so much going on there.
And it was absolutely astonishing. I mean, the Port of Laredo is now the largest land port
in America. It's just a little sleepy Texas town, you know, at the border.
But they have enormous amount of cross-border traffic.
They told us that they process 14,000 trucks per day that cross the border in Laredo.
You know, the way they've done this, the way they can handle it is they have these technology
corridors. The trucks drive down these corridors and the truck is automatically weighed.
There are barcodes on the truck that are red, so they're scanned.
They have facial recognition for the driver. So if you have import-export documentation,
it's been preloaded into a computer system. And if that matches with the driver and the truck and
the weight and everything, they never slow down. They get a green light and they just drive across
the border. So actually they slow down to about 20 miles an hour, but they don't stop.
And so that's the way they facilitate this growth across the border. And they're building a new
international bridge and there's all kinds of activity there. They told us that the import-export
traffic in Laredo increased by 230% last year. I mean, just think about that. 230% of commercial
traffic. That means you've got to have roads and bridges. There's construction everywhere and
there's warehouses everywhere. It's just really, really amazing. And the biggest product that's
moving across the border there is automotive. Now, what about the U.S.? What is coming here
or what is starting here? I keep saying I think the manufacturing is evolving. What we're seeing
here being manufactured is a lot of automated product. So any product that is using robots and
advanced machine tools, that kind of thing. I was down at a machine shop in Morgan Hill,
which is at the very south end of Silicon Valley the other day. And it was a fantastic machine shop
that is fully automated. I mean, they have really sophisticated machinery and sensors.
The whole place was full of sensors so they know what's happening with each machine. They control
it and they can see what machine is down or when it's about to need maintenance or
what pace it's working at. And so for them, it was really very sophisticated.
That kind of manufacturing will stay here because you need parts. They happen to be building parts
for SpaceX, for example. And there's rapid engineering development. So they're always
putting a new part in place or SpaceX will call up and say they need 10,000 of these parts next
week. And so they're scrambling for that. So I think there's a lot of development and sophistication
and certainly in machining. Robotics is big. Manufacturing through the use of robotics.
So old fashioned jobs in the U.S. where you used to put a peg in a hole, that was your job all day
long. In today's environment, you run the robot and you have to fix the robot and repair it and
reposition it and so forth that puts the peg in the hole. So it's a different kind of job.
Rosemary Coates with Reshoring Institute. It was great to have you on Marketing Insider.
Tell us what you think about this discussion with Rosemary.
Do you think a bunch of manufacturing will pull out of China and come to the U.S. and Mexico?
Or do you think this might be harder than it seems?
You can always comment. I'm Siamak, this is Marketing Insider. We'll see you next time.