Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/2wufkc • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
A woman seeks advice on whether to continue financially supporting her 84-year-old father-in-law, who lost his savings to bad investments and divorce. Despite the couple's stable finances, the ongoing requests for money—including recent requests for hearing aids—are causing marital strain and budget tightening.
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
I'm calling up regarding my father-in-law. My father-in-law lost his retirement money due to
bad investments and a divorce. Now he's barely scraping by with social security. My husband comes
from a family of three other siblings. My father-in-law has told us that he's in, or my
and is barely scraping by between the credit card debt, food, living expenses, etc. He has about
a hundred dollars left over a month. He has started asking us to buy him things after a
knee surgery he had. We bought him a recliner, also redid his shower to help him get in and out
easier. That's great. And then he asked us for a thousand dollars more to help with some other
expenses. Now he's asking us to buy him hearing aids. My husband and I haven't talked to any of
the other siblings to help with their dad. He doesn't think they can afford it. When do we stop?
Wow. How old is the father-in-law?
84.
Okay. Okay. Gosh, I'm so sorry that that took place. And it sounds like he just
didn't have the financial literacy to invest correctly.
And then it sounds like the divorce was kind of a double whammy there.
Did he get divorced very late in life?
Well, he's divorced twice. So this one, yeah, he was a second marriage.
What I want to know first, before I talk about him, I want to know about you guys.
What's your financial situation?
We're doing, you know, well, we do have two children that are still in school.
So we are paying for them to finish school. They'll be here done in about a year or so.
College?
College. So financially wise, I mean, we're doing good.
In the way of there's no debt. You guys have plenty of retirement. I should be clear by that
question. Any debt?
No. We pay off our credit cards every month. We're doing well with retirement. We're putting
away with money with that. I mean, we are, I mean, to pay stuff for him. I mean, yes. I mean,
we have to tighten the budget a little bit to pay whatever the father-in-law needs.
So that does put like some kind of strain on us just because we aren't able to do the things that
we would like to do.
Right. Because this is costing you, this has cost you a lot so far. And I mean,
hearing aids are not cheap. I mean, we're talking a couple of thousand dollars. How much?
Well, he's anywhere between, you can get them from $1,500 to $5,000.
Right. Right. What does your husband think about all this? Does he want to continue?
You know, those free samples at the store that are up for grabs for anyone? Well,
that's basically what's happening with your personal information online. Data broker sites
collect stuff like your address, phone number, email, even your family's information and just
post it online for anyone to grab. And that's why I use Delete Me. They remove your personal info
from hundreds of data broker websites and keep it gone. So stop letting random websites treat
your data like it's free samples. Get 20% off your annual plan at joindeleteme.com slash Ramsey.
What does your husband think about all this? Does he want to continue
helping dad financially? Does he want to put a stop to it, a limit to it?
Well, he's now, you know, after this is like the fourth time he's asked us for things,
he's like, OK, when is this going to end? Like what is next? Like if the car breaks down?
Yeah. Well, the truth is, it won't end until you end it.
Yeah, because, you know, life keeps lifing and things keep popping up. So I agree with George.
It's not going to end. I mean, I don't I don't know what his health is like at this point. Is
he able to take care of himself? Does he live alone? Yeah, he lives alone. He's able to take
care of himself. He lives in a small apartment. It's so, you know, I mean, that's health wise.
He's he's OK. So there's there's two realities here. And I don't think I need to say this to
you. I think you've thought of this, but it's worth saying out loud for the call.
We're very around here. We're very much self starters. Autonomy is good. Be in charge of
your own life, that sort of thing. And so for that reason, I don't think that you have a moral
obligation to take care of this person. So hear me say that. However, the two things that you're
holding in your hand are I have my life going over here. I have money that I want to spend on
my life and my family, what have you. And then you have this guy over here who the truth is
he's not going to work. He's 84 years old. He's not going to bring in any income.
And so what you're balancing is his quality of life and how that is affecting your quality of
life. And this is not a selfish statement, but it is kind of like a a mental calorie soul tax
statement, which is, is it going to drain you more to know he's over here? He needs hearing aids. He
doesn't have them. His car is broke down. He's having trouble eating like those sorts of things.
Are those going to bother you to the extent to where you go? You know what? Maybe it's just
worth it for me to help out. Maybe that actually does improve my quality of life. And I'm not over
here worried about it all the time. There is something to be said for that. And I think that
you've probably weighed that out mentally. And I think only you know, is this something that
really is a need or is this something that there are measures that he can take to lower his
lifestyle? Can he sell his home and downgrade to an apartment? Are there things that he can do
to kind of fund this out for another 10 years if he's healthy? So does I mean, does he live in a
house? Is there things that you can sell off that can kind of stave this off from you guys fitting
the bill? Not really. No. Because when he did lose his house through the divorce and they had to
sell it, they were already deep in debt at that time. So he didn't make any money from selling
the house. So he basically has, you know, he lives, like I said, in a small apartment and stuff.
What's his rent? I'm not exactly sure what it is, to tell you the truth. I don't know.
If you're going to give him a single dollar more, you're going to be very involved with his finances
and understand exactly how much is coming in and how much is going out. Because that controls how
much you're going to end up having to give every month. And it gives you a very clear picture about
the future of this. Is he even making the minimum credit card payment? Is it in collections and
they're coming after him? You guys need to get clear on that as you step further into his financial
life. And I would have your husband talk to the siblings. Right now, we're assuming that nobody
can chip in and nobody wants to help. I would have a come to Jesus meeting with them going,
hey, listen, here's what's going on with dad. Not doing well financially. Are you guys willing and
able to chip in a certain amount per month? Put a limit on it, even a time limit and a number limit
so that they know this is not an eternal funding of dad's life.
That's right.
Because he could live another 15 years, right?
Right, right, right. And if he has no assets, truly, I wouldn't even worry too much about this
credit card debt. If they sue him, there's nothing they can take.
It's unsecured.
And it's not going to pass to you guys. So that would not be something I would jump in and say,
well, we've got to pay off the credit card debt. No, you can keep paying minimums if you want to.
And if they do come after him, if he does miss a payment, I would be contacting Guardian
Litigation. They're a nationwide law firm that can help with this debt settlement collection
issues. They'll assign him an attorney to help with all this. And you can reach out to them
at GuardianLit.com slash Ramsey. But right now, we need a game plan with some timelines.
We need limits to all of this. Otherwise, it will never end. It is Bank of Susan forever.
And he's going to come for $1,000, then $2,000, then $5,000.
And you guys need, for your own marriage and sanity, this needs to stop or it needs limits.
Create your free every dollar budget today. The simplest way to budget for your life.