Crique The Community Colorful Photos

Photo Camera Landscape Expert
201 followers
#PhotoCamera, #LandscapePhotography, #PhotographyExpert, #NatureShots, #ScenicViews, #OutdoorPhotography, #CameraGear, #LandscapeExpert, #TravelPhotography, #WideAngleShots, #PhotographySkills, #NaturalBeauty, #CameraTips, #PhotographyMastery, #LandscapeLovers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTAVA and Patrick Hall critique community photography submissions, analyzing lighting, composition, and color. The episode blends technical reviews of food, portrait, and wildlife photography with discussions on gear portability, the ethics of post-processing, and announcements regarding a year-end contest and tutorial sale.
Hey guys, welcome to the next Critique the Community.
I am here with Patrick Hall, who is across the world.
Where are you, Patrick?
I am all the way in Charleston, South Carolina.
We just delivered our baby girl like eight days ago
on the first, well, 10, 11 days exactly.
So I am in the thick of baby mode again.
Yeah, yeah, I'm sure things are a little busy.
Thanks for taking the time to do this critique.
If you guys would like to be a part of the next critique,
you can go to fstoppers.com slash contest.
It's open right now.
I know that we're starting
a little bit late here in December,
but the genre is going to be
your favorite image of the year.
And we will do this final critique of the year
towards the end of December, early January.
We just wanna see any genre of photograph,
but your favorite shot that you got this year.
And for prizes, we are going to give every single person
that we feature a free tutorial from the Fstoppers store.
And we are doing a gigantic sale on all of our tutorials
throughout the end of the year.
The more you purchase, the more you save.
I think if you purchase three tutorials, you save 60%.
And you would be wise to do that
because you can actually pay less for three tutorials
than you would for two.
That's how math works.
So check that out.
And if you buy any tutorials
and you happen to win this contest,
you happen to be featured in this next critique,
we will refund you anything that you've purchased.
So you can still take advantage of the sale right now,
fstoppers.com slash store.
And Patrick, let's get into this critique.
Let's start with this first one here by Christine Kennedy.
This is a very interesting food photograph.
I mean, right off the bat, I love this.
Okay, I do too.
And I think unless you have tried something like this,
trying to have pretty chaos like this
in any type of photograph,
but especially food is incredibly difficult.
It looks like, oh, she just threw stuff down on the table
and it looks good.
It is never that simple.
What do you think the background is?
Like, is it on real slate?
Or are they using those like,
I think they're called the duo boards
that you can get from the company
that makes the backdrops that fold up, you know?
So I would have guessed this is on some slate.
She specifically says here in her description
that she put everything on an old cookie sheet.
And that is very difficult for me to comprehend
because this does not look anything like any cookie sheet
I've ever seen before.
I mean, this literally looks like it's stone.
Yeah, sometimes you could have like cast iron.
I could see that being this sort of texture.
But a cookie sheet that looks like this?
I don't know.
I would have thought this is professional strobe lighting.
She says this is just window light.
And it doesn't feel like window light to me
because it's so soft.
Maybe there was a curtain or some sort of fabric
in between this food and the window.
But I mean, it definitely looks like a soft box
or an umbrella.
I mean, can't a soft box that's slightly shaped
like a window right above the frame,
you know, vertically coming down?
I mean, that's exactly what a soft box is supposed to do
is look like window lighting, right?
I guess.
I would just expect more directional light.
You know, I would expect harsher light
coming directly out of a window.
It feels like there's something flagging this window off.
And then there also feels like there's some sort
of fill going on as well.
I mean, if I'm looking at the shadow
that's underneath that fork,
that looks like a pretty deep shadow.
However, I don't see that deep of shadows
on the meat itself.
It feels like she has some sort of white foam core
on the left side bouncing light back into the food.
And I don't know, it just looks great.
The way she described it is like,
oh, I just threw some stuff down
and put it in front of a window and it looked good.
And the client was happy.
But it feels like more is going on here
or she was just incredibly lucky.
I want to step back away from the lighting
and the technicals of this and just the overall concept
because I feel like the colors,
if that's the theme of this critique, are incredible.
The texture and the moisture and all of that
is really selling this image.
But this photo in general,
if I saw this on Instacart or on Uber Eats or on a menu
or anything that's going to make me want to go
to that restaurant, it's immediately going to grab
my attention because I'm going to think
this is a very high-end restaurant
and their food's going to be great.
But if you ordered this
and this was what was actually given to you,
it's a little weird to like eat the food like this, right?
Like it kind of, it feels like a salad or something strange.
If you're spending $400,
then you would expect the food to come on a slate like this.
But yeah, she said specifically
she was working for a restaurant.
They wanted a shot of their lamb chops
just for social media.
I don't think, when I saw this,
I don't think that this is how it's delivered to each table.
I feel like it's just kind of, you know,
like with my hot sauce company,
I have lots of photos with the bottle on fire
or, you know, peppers, it's laying on peppers,
but when you buy it, it doesn't come on fire.
You know what I mean?
Sure, sure.
This just doesn't feel like a complete meal.
It feels like some kind of showcase image,
which serves a purpose too.
Yeah, yeah.
I think that's exactly what it is.
Are you ready to rate this?
I am ready.
All right, you're going to have to say out loud
because I can't look at the photo
and look at you at the exact same time, but here we go.
Three, two, one.
I'm giving it a four.
I'm going four too.
I don't think this is excellent for, we say,
it's an excellent professional photograph.
I'm giving it four for what it is, right?
I mean, most professional food photography
needs to be a little bit more polished than this,
but that's not the goal here.
And so I think for what it is
and for what she was trying to accomplish,
I think she did a great job.
Would you crop in anymore, just out of curiosity,
like make it to where the food extends
all the way to the edges?
And you almost don't even need the spoon
and the fork and everything.
Yeah, maybe that is a good idea.
I definitely don't want to crop the silverware though.
So if you're going to crop into this food,
I feel like you got to move the silverware in tighter
or take it out like you said.
Next up, this was taken by Snagsby.
What a name.
This was actually the highest rated image by the community
and certainly an interesting image.
What is this?
Do you have any idea what this is?
I don't, but it looks more like art that they're installing
versus a crop that they're picking.
Right?
I mean, it looks like some kind of reeds that they've dyed
and now they're putting them to make this field
versus it naturally grows like this and they're picking it.
So I have no idea.
Does she tell us what we're looking at here?
Can I also say, not only is this person's name Snagsby,
but their last name is Chuzzlewit?
This can't be a real name, right?
This has got to be some sort of alias, online alias.
Is anyone on earth named Snagsby Chuzzlewit?
She does, she or he, I don't even know who Snagsby is,
but they say that this is an incense factory in Vietnam.
So these are incense that have been dyed
or the perfume or the scent has been embedded into it,
I guess.
I don't know anything.
I mean, you're the incense expert here.
I have no idea how incense are even made,
but every time I go in the other room,
every time I go in the other room,
I have to smell your incense in the cupboard there
and it does smell pretty good.
It smells pretty rich.
Yeah, in case you guys didn't know,
I am the face of a high-end incense brand.
Patrick and I did stock, micro stock photography
of each other like 25 years ago
and some company paid a whopping 25 cents
for some strange image of me holding cash
and it ended up on an incense box
and we made a funny video about it.
I think the video's called Dawn of Money, D-O-N of Money.
Type in Dawn of Money, F-stoppers, it should come right up.
It's a good video.
Yeah, so are you ready to rate this image, Patrick?
Three, two, one.
I'm gonna go four again.
Four.
This is a really cool image.
It definitely feels like the post-processing,
I mean, they have completely blown the red channel out
to get this effect, I would imagine,
especially when you look at the pink-red incense
on their side, they're not nearly as bright,
it feels like, you know, they're just like a few,
like 10 points lower to where they're not blowing out,
but I think that's what gives this the flavor.
You really want the reds to be
on the edge of completely blowing out, right?
I guess so, I certainly don't have a problem with it,
it doesn't, I mean, you know,
I'm looking at a low-res image here,
but it doesn't look like it's been saturated to 1,000,
it just looks, to me, like it's real.
I mean, even the blue has this, though, too.
The blue straight blue. Yeah, it does.
It also feels like it's been pushed so far,
but they've done a really good job
of then letting the natural, you know,
kind of bamboo-brown colors, and maybe his shirt,
this person's shirt is starting to get a little crazy
with the pinks and the, it's hard to tell
what that pattern is, it's, that's starting to feel
a little, I wanna say, feels unnatural,
I mean, the whole image feels unnatural,
but when the clothing starts to bloom,
I feel like maybe that's going a little too over the top,
but I love this image.
Very interesting shot, all right,
let's move on to the next one.
Now, what is going on here?
This is like the color run in India or something?
I think so.
This was taken in 2019 during the Holi in Nandagan,
I'm sorry, I'm butchering all of these words.
Yeah, it seems like that painting festival
where they're throwing, like, the dyes in the air,
and he says, this young boy caught my eye
standing quietly and watching the sunset
as if the world around him had paused,
the warm evening light fell perfectly on his face,
creating a calm little moment amid all
the chaotic celebration.
Man, this is just like, it reminds me of that,
is it Steve Curry image of the woman,
you know, the Afghan woman?
Yeah.
It's just like a classic portraiture style
of something exotic that Westerners aren't used to seeing
with the colors, it almost feels like a stock image
that, like, Nikon would use to represent, you know,
how their new camera can capture color.
It does, yeah, it does, it feels like it would be
on the back of the box or something.
I have a little problem with the pose of this child,
I feel like their faces turned a little more
than I would like, and I am absolutely nitpicking,
I love this shot, but it just, instead of feeling
like this world-class image to me,
it kind of feels like, oh, like, show me the one
right before this, or the five after this,
I just want to see if there's something
a little bit better than this.
I love that dark background, which I guess
is the kid's parents, potentially,
and then just this beam of light kind of piercing
through all of the people just to illuminate this child,
I find it very interesting.
And the facial expression, like, you know,
usually I'd say something like this is,
ah, I want a little bit more out of the face,
but there's something solemn about this kid's expression
that kind of works, like he says, amid the chaos.
But man, I just wish the kid's face would turn
a little bit more towards the camera
and continue looking away where he is,
or the face stays just where it is
and the eyes lock onto the camera.
That is being pretty nitpicky, I would say.
What's interesting about the color,
well, just the color of this, you know,
I feel like all the hues are falling
in a very narrow band, which to get contrast
with your yellows and your reds
can be very, very difficult.
I think the previous image was a great example
where everything was red and that blue line
really helped divide everything out.
I think images like this are tricky because, you know,
it would be so easy to oversaturate
or have no separation in colors with the, you know,
the color scheme all falling really close to each other.
And yet there still is a lot of separation.
You know, it's like the yellow on the face
is perfectly separating it from the darker magentas
right behind the child, you know what I mean?
Yeah, here's another nitpick,
and I usually never care about this sort of thing.
What do you think about the color of this child's eyes?
I think, you know, they stand out.
Are you saying they're dodged too much or something?
Like, they definitely have this, like.
No, no, something about the color of the eyes
feels like it's clashing, this sounds insane.
It feels like it's clashing with all the red colors.
It's like this greenish-brown color in the eyes,
and I just feel like I just want a little color shift
on those eyes to make them a little more complementary.
This is probably insane that I'm saying this.
People are like, you're suggesting ruining the photo
and making it fake, but do you feel this at all?
If the kid had bright blue eyes,
I think it would be a more impactful,
colorful image that would pop more,
but that is kind of insane if this kid's eyes
are hazel color, and you're saying that you should
bump it over into green or bright blue or something.
Okay, no, no, so I'm not saying that.
I'm not saying, like, let's make them vibrant blue.
I'm just saying, like, potentially,
like, a white balance shift.
It just feels like a strange, conflicting color right now
it's like brown or something,
and if brown's where you want to go with it, fine.
I have brown eyes.
Pull just a little bit of that green out of it
or something, something about it feels, like,
unnatural to me, especially against the red paint.
I think they're just, that's the hazel color
of this kid's eyes.
I mean, so my son Hudson's got very blue eyes
that are almost gray, which is an interesting color.
I've never really, when I talk to people,
I look at their mouth.
I don't look them in the eye.
I look at people's mouths 100% of the time.
I feel like I have to, to hear them.
Maybe I'm deaf.
Well, yeah, I think you and I are both deaf,
but I just, I don't know.
I don't know if it's because I wanted to be a dentist
or because it's the most animated part of their face
or what it is, but I rarely look at people in their eyes
unless I'm so close that I have to, you know?
Like, if you're five feet away from me,
you could look at the mouth or the eyes
and you can't tell the difference, but anyway,
the point is, is I don't recognize most people's eye color.
And so I can't tell you the color of most people's eyes
after, you know, spending a lot of time with them.
And so my son's eyes are this really strange
kind of gray, blue color that I have not seen very often
because I don't look at people's eyes.
And then now with my daughter, her eyes are like black.
It's like the craziest thing.
Like these baby eyes, it's like, it could go towards brown
or it could go towards dark blue,
but they haven't really decided
which way they're going yet.
And so it's just like the whole eye is black,
which sometimes freaks me out late at night
when I look in her eyes.
I'm like, whoa, cute little baby,
but it's like the eyes are so dark.
Now, is it true?
I think somebody told me that all Caucasian babies
are born with blue eyes and then they shift.
Is that true or did I just make that up?
I don't know, because my baby's black.
That's why I'm bringing it up.
You have a ethnic baby and so I don't know.
It's funny because Hudson is the,
he's whiter than me, right?
And so it's kind of funny to be like,
he's half black, half white, and then he's got blue eyes.
Like he breaks the mold.
But my daughter at the moment is darker
and I don't know what color her eyes are going to be.
Sometimes they look blue, sometimes they look black.
So anyway, I think you're crazy for thinking
that this kid's eyes needs to be changed in this photo.
No, not all Caucasian babies are born with blue eyes,
but it's common because they often have less melanin
at birth, making their eyes appear blue or gray,
which can darken later.
However, some Caucasian newborns are born with brown eyes.
Oh, interesting.
Three, two, one.
I'm going four again.
Is it, are we biased towards really just
bright, colorful images?
Is that what's happening here?
Maybe I'm just in a good mood.
I don't know.
But yeah, usually we're giving people threes.
And so a four is good.
If this child had more pretty eyes
and was looking a little bit more at the camera,
maybe I would have given a five.
Next up, a very different image.
Before we get into this image, I gotta ask you,
have you watched the 50 Cents documentary on P. Diddy?
That photo of that innocent child,
just, it's on my, I just like watched it the other,
like the last couple of days, I've been,
I got Kristen a Peloton for,
she's been wanting a Peloton,
and then I found myself using it.
And so I ride on this bike with this projector
and I can just watch Netflix.
It's like the greatest thing.
It's the greatest way to work out ever.
And I was like, let me watch the P. Diddy special.
And it's on my mind all the time
because I feel like it's just so well done
and it's so crazy.
And I was just curious if you'd seen it,
but it sounds like maybe you haven't.
And where do you watch it, where is it?
It's on Netflix.
Okay, I keep hearing about it,
I read headlines about it, I hear that like,
You gotta watch it.
It's good, huh?
Yeah, so what's really wild about this documentary,
because I, you know, you and I both watch
these true crime documentaries
and we're really fascinated on how they
were filming it at the right time
and they got the footage
while the new discovery was happening
and you're like, as if you were to be a filmmaker,
you'd say like, how were you there
at the moment that that happened?
And what's interesting about this documentary
is Puff Daddy was trying to get it removed
for using copyrighted footage that he owned, right?
But what happened was, is he's had somebody
on his team for like the last 20 years
filming behind the scenes of his entire life
for some like grand documentary that he's wanted to make.
But he has a history of not paying people
for all of the production that they do
on his music and all this stuff.
So when he was arrested and goes to jail for his trial,
the videographer was like, well, he never paid me.
So I guess he goes to 50 Cent
and gives them all of this incredible
behind the scenes footage where he's explaining
how he's trying to get out of this indictment by the FBI.
And you're just like, it keeps cutting.
You keep watching this documentary and you keep thinking,
if you were to cut this footage out
that's recorded by P. Diddy's team,
it would just, it would be a completely different documentary
and so I find it really fascinating to watch this
because at the pivotal moment, it'll cut to the now
and you're like, I can't believe
he's saying stuff like this on camera,
but it's because he never anticipated
that this would be like used against him, you know?
Well, I've seen this clip for years of 50 Cent.
He's on some, you know, radio show or whatever
and he's like, man, P. Diddy tried to take me shopping.
What the hell?
You know, and then they asked P. Diddy,
they're like, hey, last time 50 was here,
he said you tried to buy him clothes
and he was like, I thought he would like some clothes, man.
It's the weirdest situation where like 50 Cent is like,
he was coming on to me and then P. Diddy's like,
nah, man, I was just trying to be nice and buy some clothes
and I always watch that
just because I thought it was hilarious,
but I never thought like,
was he really trying to have sex with him?
Maybe so.
Watch the documentary, man.
Episode three, it gets crazy.
All right, this next shot here, very different,
much more polished, obviously shot in the studio.
I love this shot.
Okay, I'm gonna try not to read.
Let me just make this full screen
and not read the right hand side
and try to think of how this image was shot.
So there's a gelled light behind her,
firing down on her legs and on the tutu and all of that.
There must also be a red or orange gel on the left
that's doing the hair and the underside of her arm.
So you have two like backlight gelled lights.
You have some kind of fill that's blue
that's giving the highlight down her leg.
And then you have some kind of key light
that's coming from above down
that's warming up the majority of her body on the top part.
Like, is that four lights?
Do you think I have that right?
Is there a fifth light?
So Patrick, I think you got that exactly right.
Two straight boxes behind her, yes, with orange gels,
one white light above her,
and then one fill light with a teal gel, camera right.
Very impressive, Patrick.
Now there is still a shadow coming from her hand
that's supporting her,
that's going back towards the backdrop.
And is that the red gel or is that the white light?
Like, that's the one shadow where I'm kind of like,
that light feels like it's coming from camera left.
But what light is causing that?
Is that the white light that's doing it?
Because the white light feels like
it's come from up above down, but I don't know.
Yeah, I mean, I see exactly what you're saying.
There is a chance that the key light
that he says is above firing down
could be slightly towards the camera
and maybe like slightly left,
just like kind of over her face a little bit more.
Yeah.
And maybe that light is casting a shadow down under her arm
and it looks-
It's being filled by the red.
Yeah.
It just looks like it's being shot to the side,
but I don't know.
Have you done any photography yourself
where you've used big key lights
that are gelled blue and like crazy stuff
to give this kind of look?
I mean, it feels like I would have had.
Yeah, yeah.
I think my profile picture on Facebook is me blue, right?
It is, yeah.
I wasn't there when you took that image, so I forgot.
And just to talk about like the level of detail
that this photographer has reached on this image,
like obviously fantastic model, talented model,
perfect hair and makeup,
at least from this distance, it looks perfect.
The pose is fantastic.
The outfit is perfect.
And then after that,
he's dialed in the lighting to get that perfect.
It's just like every element of this is excellent.
Yes.
I'm in a good mood, Patrick.
I'm going all the way.
Three, two, one.
I'm going five stars on this one.
I love this shot.
Five stars, okay.
I'm going four.
I don't know.
I don't know this is so memorable that I'm like,
wow, like five, I'll never forget it.
But I think her pose,
I mean, everything about this is great.
The thing that I keep thinking about looking at this image
is how much of the pose was the photographer's doing
versus she's a real dancer and has this pose nailed down.
Because if you're not a photographer
who photographs dancers all the time, like me,
I would get this girl in the studio.
I would get her to do something that's like,
it just feels unnatural.
I'm like, your arm that's holding you up needs to be bent,
but I don't know how to explain it to her.
And then the hand, it's like, it's so close,
but I'm not able to like fine tune it.
I'm going to give it 100% credit to the model.
I mean, I don't want to take away from this photographer.
And I know some photographers are great at posing.
I'm going to say,
no matter how good you are at posing your models,
no man could come up with this.
Maybe he saw another picture of another person doing this
and he held it up and said, can you do this?
But no man could explain this to a woman
and it make any sense.
Like, this is why good models are so great,
is they can look in the mirror
and they can tweak their body to where they know
when that mirror is the camera, it's going to look great.
But when you're a dancer, you're kind of dependent.
It reminds me of like line dancing.
You know, when you have like 10 girls
and they're all doing the Britney Spears line dance,
there's got to be somebody outside telling them that like,
you're a great dancer, but you're off a little bit.
We need to tighten it up.
Like you need somebody else's eyes
from the outside looking in to tweak it.
And I guess that's what I'm trying to say is,
she probably got there 75%,
but was the photographer able to take it over and say,
hey, this weird thing with your chin,
you actually need to be looking more to the ceiling.
You know what I mean?
He's tweaking it or she's tweaking it,
or is this person just, boom, nails this pose
and it's just perfect?
I don't know.
The world may never know.
Well, Leonard, killer photo.
Next shot.
This is a weird one.
I want you to try to guess what this is by James F.
I keep seeing a leaf in water
and all of the crazy colors makes me think of like,
salt flats that we've been to,
or like, it's not oil, I don't think,
because there's so many little sharp veins in the colors
that makes me think it's not liquid or fluid.
Although it could be,
the bottom left looks kind of like an oil spill,
but I'm gonna say this is some kind of weird leaf
that has been solidified in a salt flat.
Once again, you've done a pretty amazing job.
So James says he was in New Zealand
and he learned that this certain type of tree,
when a tree branch falls, it releases natural oils.
And so he was just looking around for these oils
and he found a leaf.
I don't think I could guess this was a leaf.
I don't know what I thought it was.
And yeah, so he just took a macro shot
of a leaf in these oils.
So this is a liquid.
This isn't dry, salty, aged something.
So I looked around and found this leaf
with this color surrounding it.
He doesn't mention liquid,
but it was definitely created by oils,
but I see what you're saying.
There's cracks, which makes it seem like it's not a liquid.
It's also got this like pop art sort of thing
where it feels like maybe it's a double exposure
of paper mache or something on top of something else,
you know, and that's what's giving it this effect.
But if this is truly just a leaf
that's embedded in water with oils
and you just took a macro shot of it,
like that's pretty crazy that this is the resulting image.
Let's rate it.
Three, two, one.
I'm going three stars on this one.
I feel like it's a solid image, but it's so weird.
Like my mind keeps going back and forth
from I'm looking at a image out of a helicopter
at a mountain to a leaf in a puddle.
Here is a staircase in Spain.
This is where the original Illuminati originated.
I can see like, I can see P. Diddy
walking up these stairs right now.
Like this is-
Maybe this is inside P. Diddy's home, yeah.
Yeah.
I have one potential problem with this,
but it also might be the reason why I like it.
You're saying it's like off center a little bit.
It's got this perspective shift.
That's not what I'm thinking.
I keep thinking about the white balance.
Does this look like it's 3000 Kelvin in the wrong direction?
I mean, it does,
but that's what gives it the cool color scheme there.
Right, right, right.
So if you start pulling this to the blue side
and add a little bit of magenta to it,
does it just become a dull triangle
and you lose all the interesting color?
I wonder if you could put or tweak the white balance
to put a little bit more pure white here and there
and still leave the yellow
to where it makes you feel like the paneling is this color.
But like say right down the middle,
if you took the middle furthest point and you made that,
there is almost, if I zoom in,
there is an area that almost has
a correct white highlight down there.
But if you just added something else
to where the white balance felt a little bit more correct,
your eye would start to think that this isn't an error,
that it's just actually this color.
You know what I think could do that?
I think if you selected that metal railing
and you desaturated that metal railing all the way down,
I think that would do it.
Or would that kind of ruin it, you know?
You've taken pictures, especially with your iPhone,
you take pictures with mixed lighting.
You're near window light and then you're in a restaurant
and it's got crazy lighting and you take the picture
and you're just like, this looks too crazy.
Like it's capturing all of the white balance correctly,
but because the lighting is on such opposite sides,
it starts to just feel like really, really wrong.
Your mind has a hard time accepting it.
Three, two, one.
Three stars.
On a three, what are you?
Three as well?
Three.
Yeah, I feel like it's interesting, it's okay,
but the colors are interesting,
but it also feels like an error to me.
It's like a white balance error.
I can see this going into like a fine art direction
because I keep thinking that this is a little hidden room
at the top of like some cabin
and that the bottom panel is actually ground level
that you're not looking down towards the ground,
but you're actually like the top of the triangle is up.
So if you could like suspend some furniture
or put a bed flat, you know what I mean?
It would be this crazy optical illusion
to where it would look like those Escher images
or something where it makes you just wonder what is up
and what is down and it has that fun house
kind of feel to it.
I know that's not the intention of this image,
but I keep going to that thinking that is a roof line
and the peak is the top of the roof.
Yeah, I see that as well.
Real quick guys, let's talk about the prizes
for this contest that we're doing right now.
Third place is going to get a tutorial
from the F-Stopper store.
Second place is going to get
ACDC's Photo Studio Ultimate 2026.
If you're like me, you probably give Adobe
a ton of money every single month.
You can either pay per month with this software
for way less, or you can just buy it outright
and no more subscriptions.
That is my dream, but right now
I'm going to be editing this video on Adobe Premiere.
So Adobe's going to get my money for a little bit longer.
And first place is going to get the Tamron
25 to 200 millimeter F 2.8 to 5.6 lens.
I just did a big roundup comparison video
of every all-in-one lens for Sony full frame cameras
and this lens did fantastic.
So first place is going to get this.
Stay tuned for the end of this video
where we will figure out who all three winners are.
Can you guess how this image was taken?
I mean, it reminds me when I was in like biology class
and you could like, you know, see what a protein looks like
and you'd have this 3D render of the protein
unfolding and binding and, or, you know,
like we just went through the COVID stuff.
We saw all those pictures of coronaviruses
and how they dock and bind
and we all became experts at that.
Clearly this is like paint that's being thrown
and splashed in some way.
I'm going to guess that it's a, is it like a,
I'm thinking like a balloon that's like blown up
and it has somehow,
somehow you get the paint inside the balloon
and then you pop it.
But then there's also no shield.
There's no sheath of the balloon itself.
So I don't know if that's been edited out.
It looks like something that's been like blown up
and then popped and then it's expanded, you know.
But yeah.
So once again, great job.
You're doing a good job of guessing.
The only difference, and I did,
I did not guess this myself.
He did not put paint in the balloon.
He put paint on the balloon and then popped it.
That would be the easier way, yeah.
But then did he just mask out the balloon itself?
Or it's hidden behind?
He doesn't mention it.
Yeah, he doesn't, he doesn't mention that.
But I don't know.
There's something really weird about the lighting on this.
It feels like it's fake CGI.
It's like there's no deep shadows
in all the waves of the paint.
And so it just, it doesn't feel real at all to me,
but it's interesting.
It almost feels like it's your favorite lighting,
like the 45, 45 lighting,
or the lights are on opposite sides
and then maybe like a fill card
to like even fill more of the shadows.
But it feels like every side, top, left, bottom, down,
they all have so much detail
that it feels like it would be the worst,
most boring lighting style for a face
or a person or a product.
But in this context,
it makes everything really pop against that black.
If you look in the hole where, you know,
like in the middle where there's the opening
in the orange paint,
you would expect there to be shadows being cast
on the paint that's on that blue on the left.
And I just don't see any big shadows anywhere.
I don't know if it was shot with a ring light or something,
but it's a very confusing image for me to look at.
I have a hard time with this
because I just don't know what kind of portfolio
this goes in.
You know, it's like maybe fine art
or, you know, exploratory portfolios or something,
but it's one of those where you just,
you print it and put it in a series on the wall
is the only thing I could, like,
I don't know what art buyer is hired.
I mean, maybe if you could put a product in here
or somebody needs this sort of splash effect
and that's exactly what they're envisioning
and you know how to do it and photograph it.
But I'm just trying to think like,
what do you do with this sort of image?
I feel the exact same way.
I could definitely see this being some sort of modern art,
but it feels a little bit too messy to me.
I feel like I want you to do a hundred more balloon pops
and get something that's a little bit more artistic
for lack of a better word.
Let's go ahead and rate this.
Three, two, one.
I'll give three, but again,
I don't really know what this is for.
It's not quite interesting enough for me
that I could imagine this being printed and hung somewhere.
Next image, once again, very, very different.
And so obviously this image stood out to me immediately,
just the thumbnail, I had to click on it.
I feel like this is done incredibly well.
However, now that I really take a second
to think about what I'm looking at here,
what are these flowers?
Like, do you just feel like all of these are fake?
Like these flowers look unbelievable.
Well, I was thinking the same thing.
They're either fake and it makes this more obtainable
or you have spent, I mean, could I say thousands of dollars?
I mean, I think of how insane flowers are now.
Like you can go to Publix
and buy a small bouquet of flowers for your wife
and it's like 40 bucks.
I'm like, when did flowers get so expensive?
That's for the cheapest, crappiest one.
A lot of times they're a hundred.
So yeah, so I'm thinking like this is a ton of money
and hopefully you've teamed up with a florist
and that's been copped
and that's their contribution to this.
Or they're the most incredible fake flowers ever
because they don't look cheap and ugly and, you know,
made of fabric.
But they also don't look real.
They look like something from Avatar.
It almost looks like AI generated flowers or something.
Or it looks like a macro shot of a rose
that's now larger than life next to her head.
You know, like it would be the biggest single rose.
Right, I just, I don't think this is a real thing.
And like, look, here's a giant one right here too.
We are buying our wives the wrong flowers,
I'll tell you that.
This is what's, this is a possibility.
The other thing I'm wondering is like,
you immediately think she's laying on a bed of flowers,
but the lighting is the clamshell lighting
where you have like one below and one above.
This is clearly the model standing, right,
with a wall behind her.
Or is she standing-
Oh, that's interesting.
Yeah, I guess you're right, I didn't even think about that.
Otherwise she would be, I mean, one,
if she's laying down and she's on,
she's laying down like three feet off the ground
because she would be smashing all the flowers
or the flowers would be up past her face, right?
They'd be closer to the camera.
Yeah.
So I feel like it's gotta be a wall.
And then if she's standing, it kind of makes me wonder,
is it just the flowers below her that are real?
And then AI has filled in the rest or something?
I don't know.
It'd be interesting to know, do they give more?
No, he gives nothing.
I probably shouldn't have allowed this image
because there's not a good description.
Remember, guys, yeah, you must have a good description
so when we debate stuff like this, we have the answer.
At the bottom, he says, no, all these flowers are real.
No AI in this image.
What?
Oh, wow.
Goodness.
All right, now, what is your biggest problem with this image?
I mean, she just seems like she's blank
and she's giving me like a resting bitch face
with no like, no smirk, no evilness, no,
like I'm not being pushed in any direction.
It's just a girl who's there.
That's maybe what I-
To me, it's just the mouth.
I feel like her eyes look fine.
It's just the lips.
I mean, can you just highlight the mouth
and just make that go through AI and give it a smirk?
I mean, you can do that now with a lot of AI software.
I think you could even liquefy the mouth
and just put a little bit of pressure
on one side of the lips
and it would just look like she's got something
going on in the mouth.
And I feel like this image is unbelievable.
Right now, it just, it looks like,
her eyes look fine.
Usually when you get the, you know,
as Peter Hurley says, the out to lunch face,
the eyes look bad and the mouth looks bad.
They're like daydreaming about something.
I'm not getting this from this image.
I feel like her eyes look fantastic,
but her mouth, man, the way that it's going down,
I just need a little something coming from her mouth.
It reminds me of like a movie cover on Netflix
or like the Real Housewives of LA or something.
And like, this is what they're doing.
The Bravo is now putting this much production
into, you know, the casts, you know, profile photos.
And for this season,
they're all in front of these crazy flowers.
But I think she, yeah,
she just needs a little something in there
to push it over the top, you know?
All right, let's rate it.
Three, two, one.
I'm still giving this a four though.
I'm giving it a four too.
I mean, I feel like this could potentially be a five,
but liquefy that mouth or just go, dude,
like if you're going to do this much work on this image,
he probably has 500 shots.
There's got to be a better mouth in one of those pictures.
Just Photoshop it on this image
and you have won at photography.
I want to know what the full budget was for this.
How much did this cost to produce this image?
Because that's insane if that's all real.
All right, next shot by Dave Gallagher.
And not only did he get one hummingbird,
he got two hummingbirds going to battle.
And what was the micro four thirds camera
you recently shot with?
The OM systems.
He says he shot this on the OM1 Mark II.
Yeah, that's the camera.
That's what I just said.
Yeah, the Mark II is the newer one,
but that's what I had.
Man, I love that camera.
I know you've been shooting a lot of wildlife
with the biggest cameras and the full frame
and all that stuff.
I wish you had gotten to use that camera
before I shipped it back
because it just was so fun to shoot with.
I suck as a wildlife photographer.
I think you would have produced
way better pictures than me,
but I was doing a lot more sports.
I was shooting live sports with it
more than I was wildlife,
but it just was so lightweight.
It felt like a 70 to 200 on a full frame
and it would just make you want to go out and do things.
And the depth of field was a little bit wider.
It was a little deeper,
but the enjoyment that I had
compared to carrying the full frame lenses around,
I didn't want to shoot anything with those lenses.
It just stopped me in my path.
And I was like, man, I don't,
do you have another one?
What do you mean?
You feel like it was inconvenient using this lens?
Yes, it's like a thing of the past, man.
It's like for all those photo nerds
that just want the most shallow depth of field
and they want that extra like five or 10% image quality.
And I buy into that too.
Like I see that lens and I'm like, man, that's what I want.
But when you have to carry that around,
like I can't imagine taking it on a plane
or you've got to go to the Olympics
and you've got to like travel with that stuff.
Like it's just not a genre for me.
But this image, now that you've mentioned
that that's what this is shot on,
my critique of this would be that
it's got a little extra depth of field
that makes it look not quite as separate.
You know, the separation isn't quite as much
as I would have thought, but.
That is also my issue with this photograph.
I feel like the birds themselves, super interesting.
Light on them is decent.
I found, you know, when I shoot people,
I want soft light on them.
I really don't like shooting people in direct sunlight.
I was really preferring all of the images
I got of wildlife with direct sunlight.
Early sunlight or late sunlight,
like, you know, directional sidelight.
But even still, these birds look fantastic,
but man, I really just want that background
to go out of focus.
And it just kind of looks cheaper
because it has a deeper depth of field.
If this image had a much shallower depth of field,
maybe he tells us what millimeter
and what f-stop it was shot at.
But even with a full frame camera,
this depth of field would only be like,
it's hard to say what a stop
of more shallow depth of field looks like
because it's not really measured in that way.
But if you could make this a little bit blurrier,
part of me just thinks that the birds,
they have color and leaves behind them
and they're just not positioned.
Like, I understand how tricky it is
to capture an image of these two birds
in the frame, all in focus, all frozen.
But I just kind of feel like
even if it had super shallow depth of field,
would the birds look that much better
or would they still kind of be lost in the color scheme?
You know what I mean?
I do agree with you.
And there's some weirdness going on with the background.
I don't know if you can see,
like around the left side of the flower up here.
I don't know if he cut this out.
Oh, that's interesting.
It just doesn't look like a real background to me.
And then you've got this gray wall or something
that's kind of the same color as the bird.
So it's not the best background.
But these hummingbirds, man,
they only hang around trees and bushes and stuff.
Like, it would literally be impossible
for you to capture one just out in the open
with tons of distance between them and the background.
But still, very cool.
Three, two, one.
I'm between a two and a three.
I'm gonna be mean on this one.
I'm gonna go two.
Oh, wow, two.
I think, I mean,
I am definitely giving this a higher score than a two
because that it's two hummingbirds, right?
So maybe that's unfair.
But at the same time,
I like to imagine I have gone
to a professional photographer's website,
or let's just say a photographer's website.
I see one image, and this is the image I see.
And I have to guess everything about this photographer.
I have to guess, are they a hobbyist?
Do they do this professionally?
Are they ultra talented?
Do they charge a lot of money?
Or is he just some guy
who likes to take pictures on his off time?
And this image specifically
kind of feels like a hobbyist to me.
I see the image up close here on the tablet,
but I'm also seeing it further away on this monitor.
And when I see it far away, there's nothing about it.
Everything's so blurred together that I just,
I'm not like stopping and being like,
whoa, let me see what that is.
And I feel like that's the first thing
that I need with an image.
And all the other images so far have had that, you know?
So this is, sorry,
I just feel like this is the weakest image of the group,
but I understand how much time
and effort went into creating this.
Like it's, you probably shot thousands of images
and got this one, and here I am giving it to you.
So it's funny because the second I saw this,
I was like, he shot this in his yard.
I just thought that.
Because you have to have so much freaking patience
with these birds.
And if you just learn, if they come around your house,
you just learn, oh, they like these three plants.
They usually come in the mornings.
So I'm just gonna sit outside in my lawn chair
and wait for them to come.
But if you were on a hike somewhere or whatever,
and you see a hummingbird,
you don't have time to like grab your camera
and change the settings and take a picture.
It's gone already, right?
And then I read in his description,
yep, he took it in his backyard.
Same with me.
I just got what I think is a really lucky, lucky shot
of a hummingbird sitting on a branch.
These things sit on branches for like three seconds
and then fly away.
And the only reason I was able to get it,
I was sitting on my couch watching TV
and it sat on a branch near my window.
And I happened to have my 600 millimeter camera
sitting in front of me.
And I just grab it and pick it up
and start taking pictures as I walk towards it.
And then as I got right to the edge of my minimum
focusing distance, the thing flies away.
But I love the shot that I got.
I feel like, oh my gosh,
it's like the detail in the shot's unbelievable.
The lighting's unbelievable.
There's no way I could capture that in the real world.
You know, like it was just straight luck.
Next, we've been here.
Whoa, I wish it looked like this when we went there.
This looks like something out of the Lord of the Rings.
It doesn't even look like the same spot.
Yeah, and I'm wondering how much funny business
has been done to this image because it's unbelievable.
I love the lighting here, but it doesn't feel possible.
It doesn't feel possible that the sun
could hit that mountain the way it is
and then also hit the tips of the cliff
clouds without hitting all the clouds.
Something about the angle of the light,
it just, maybe the sun is further to the right
than I think it is.
But what do you think about that?
I don't know this location well enough
to know where the sun's rising and falling.
It feels like to me,
the sun might not have even come up over the horizon yet.
And therefore, everything below a certain altitude
is still experiencing like morning blue hour.
And the sun is just angled up
to where it's hitting the peaks
and it's hitting the light in the clouds in a certain way.
And you can even see up in the top right left corner,
the sky above this cloud is the brightest part of the image.
So to me, it makes sense that somehow the light
is really low on the horizon firing upwards.
It's lighting the furthest sky.
It's lighting the clouds in a crazy dramatic way.
But then all of the foreground is kind of going black.
I think it's possible.
I mean, I would have like ---- my pants
if I, I think I did almost ---- my pants
on this hike at one point.
But-
You actually did, yes.
I was, we were climbing somewhere else over here.
Maybe this was in Argentina.
I think this is in Chile, but yeah.
Anyway, watch the behind the scenes videos
if you want to experience that.
But our experience here was, you know,
rainy, overcast, getting soaking wet.
I think we ran into somebody who recognized
Aliyah Locardi, you know,
and that was the highlight of the day because nothing,
the weather was so bad, but this is beautiful.
The critique I have with this is,
I guess I just want it zoomed out a little maybe
to give it a little, like the foreground,
I feel like is kind of lacking a little bit.
Maybe that's unfair because the lighting event
in this is just so over the top
that everything is right here focused.
I don't know, I just know there's water
right in front of the person
and you don't get to see any of that.
So after reading his description,
I do think this is real.
He says, you know, early morning,
this is one of the most spectacular sunrises he's ever seen.
He's never seen clouds with red spots like that anywhere.
And he says the only editing he did
was a little bit of post-processing in Lightroom.
So I guess it's real.
And I mean, look at that red on the middle right,
all the way to the right, like that's like neon red
hitting that mountain peak over there, that's wild.
The lens that this photographer uses is a 70 to 300 lens,
which is not like one of those crazy,
you know, professional 2.8 lenses.
It's one of those lenses that's made to take hiking
and you're still, it just goes to show
that if you have a great lighting event
and you're capturing beautiful things,
the lens kind of takes a backseat to that, you know,
unless you're shooting those hummingbirds
and you need something that actually gets you that close,
then I feel like it's, you know,
there's a point of diminishing returns,
but this is, you know, once in a lifetime experience
to see something like this.
We were there how many days?
Like we probably saw this mountain like five days in a row
and never once saw anything like this.
Wow, we didn't see anything like this,
but I think at least at one point
we got to see the peaks of the mountain.
But yeah, this is an unbelievable lighting event.
Three, two, one, four stars.
Yeah, I gave it four.
I complained about no foreground,
but the more I look at this,
the little V shapes that are occurring both at the bottom
and between the tops of the mountains,
like I feel like there are some really nice leading lines
here that, you know, if you didn't know
that there was water and maybe something else
to kind of give it a little bit more weight at the bottom,
I think they've done a good,
I think the photographer's done a good job
with the leading lines to make it kind of sit well
in this frame.
Do you look at images like this and feel like, man,
there's a very good chance that you will never ever go back
to this location in your life again?
And maybe you feel like you don't need to go back again.
Sometimes you're like,
I don't need to go to that place again,
but you do feel like I'd love my son
or my wife to have experienced it.
And the only person,
it's like you and I are the only two people
that were there to experience it.
And it's in such a crazy part of the world
that it's like, I see images like this,
I get a little sad because I'm like, man,
I'd been there.
I didn't get to experience it to its fullest.
There were so many amazing hikes we could have gone on,
but we just didn't have time.
And, or do you have like no regrets?
You're like excited that you have been there
and it's your memories, your memory,
and you don't need to go back there again.
I don't know that I feel with Iceland.
I feel like I need to go back to Iceland.
That was so incredible.
With this place, I wouldn't be upset if I went back.
And for some reason, it feels like I will go back there.
But-
That hotel was one of the greatest hotels
like I've ever experienced for sure.
Yeah, I think that might have been
the coolest hotel I've ever been in in my life.
I can't remember the name of it offhand,
but watch the photographing the world behind the scenes
and you can see us in that incredible hotel.
Yeah, I guess I am more worried
that we're not doing as cool of stuff
with F-stoppers anymore, right?
I don't feel sad that I may not ever get to go back
and see that mountain.
I feel sad that what if there's just not a market
for photography tutorials anymore?
And those photography tutorials are literally,
filming them have been the highlights of my life.
Getting to travel around the world and film,
even the stuff that would be boring,
filming architectural photography with Mike Kelly,
some of the highlights of my life.
And so that makes me sad
if I'm not able to do something like that again.
But I have all these other things that I wanna do.
I really wanna make a documentary.
I would love to make a feature film
that's fiction one day,
but I gotta get my ass in order, man.
I just feel like I'm becoming lazier day by day.
And so I gotta just get on it.
All right, guys, we have deliberated.
Here are the winners of this contest.
Third place in the winner of a free tutorial
from fstoppers.com slash store.
We're going with the child with paint all over them
by AJ Maharjan.
Awesome image.
Second place and the winner of ACDC's Photo Studio Ultimate.
My favorite photography name of all time,
Snagsby Chuzzlewit.
Congratulations.
Both of you guys send me a private message,
Lee Morris on fstoppers.com
and either let me know which tutorial you want
for third place and give me your contact info
so I can get you the software for number two.
And first prize, it wasn't just me who chose this.
Patrick agreed with me.
We are going with the Ballerina by Lenart Bowering.
Congratulations, you have won the Tamron 25-200 lens.
I love fixed aperture, expensive pro lenses,
but sometimes they get really heavy
and carrying multiple lenses is a pain in the butt.
So if you can get a lens that does everything,
it can be very convenient.
I think too, with cameras just being so much better
at high ISO and just giving you so much more image quality
and dynamic range, I think these lenses
just are able to perform better
than some of those first cameras that we had,
you know, the D200 with a lens like that.
At the time, it just wasn't able
to produce the same image quality.
If I can carry around something that weighs a lot less
at my age, that's probably what I'm actually gonna go for.
All right, guys.
Again, fstoppers.com slash contest.
Show us your best images of 2025.
Every single person that we feature
is gonna get a free tutorial from the Fstoppers store.
We will see you in a few weeks.
