Outrageous photo edit

Photo Camera Landscape Expert
201 followers
#PhotoCamera, #LandscapePhotography, #PhotographyExpert, #NatureShots, #ScenicViews, #OutdoorPhotography, #CameraGear, #LandscapeExpert, #TravelPhotography, #WideAngleShots, #PhotographySkills, #NaturalBeauty, #CameraTips, #PhotographyMastery, #LandscapeLovers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTwo photography experts critique community-submitted photos to determine their \"print-worthiness,\" debating the balance between technical perfection and artistic authenticity. The session covers various genres, the impact of AI on modern aesthetics, the technicalities of physical printing, and the announcement of contest winners.
I got a little story to tell you.
An Uber driver had a gun on him
and he didn't have his ID with him.
And so he was like, if I get pulled over,
probably going to jail.
He told me his whole life story.
Really cool guy.
Three days later, I'm scrolling through Facebook
and I see his picture pop up.
He has been arrested for trying to murder, murder, murder,
murder his 20 year old daughter.
He threatened her.
He didn't try to murder her.
I'm not trying to take his side here.
But he was a responsible gun owner
when it was time to take somebody out.
He didn't pull the gun on his daughter.
He didn't pull the gun.
I hadn't told my wife this.
Oh, you didn't tell her.
No, I was like, I'm not going to freak her out.
She'll never get an Uber again.
You just never know who your Uber driver is.
Hey guys, welcome to the next Critique the Community.
Today, we're going to be critiquing
your best print worthy photos.
If you would like to join the next critique,
you can do that right now at fstoppers.com slash contest.
And we want to see your most emotional photos.
I'm going to keep that vague and ambiguous.
You let us know what you think
your most emotional photos are
and we will rip them apart next month.
Let's get into this one.
So you said this is a contest that we've done
on print worthy images.
Now there's been a big debate in the comments
of are we judging these based on should they be printed?
Or are we judging these on are they great photos
that maybe people would want to print?
What's the difference?
There could be a product shot that's a five
and you're like, I don't really know that I'd print this.
But then there could be other images
that are great for print.
It could be really abstract.
But you could be like, it's still a three.
So I feel like-
I'm rating this for me personally,
which ones would I like on my walls?
Okay, I was telling the audience that I like to rate them
whether or not they're still a good photo.
We can talk about that too.
And then it just happens to also be a good print.
Sure, sure, sure.
Some debate in there and I want to acknowledge it
because a lot of people fell on one side of the coin.
Before we get into that real quick, guys,
I just want to let you know,
we're going to do probably the biggest sale we've ever done
during one of these critiques.
We're not going to publicize this coupon code,
but if you use the coupon code CTC50,
you can save 50% off any tutorial in the fstoppers store.
Check it out at fstoppers.com slash store.
Have we ever done 50% off?
Maybe if you did a bundle.
Yeah, if you bought a bunch together.
Four or five of them, but not on a single item
or a single cart.
Right, right.
So this will be the lowest price that you can get
a relatively new tutorial for.
All right, let's get to it.
All right, here is the first image.
And the first thing my mind goes to
is this a composite with the same people in it?
That's what I thought at first, yeah.
I mean, we got like Eli Lacardi up here, up in the corner.
He's taking some photos.
But then we have a couple surfers that it feels like,
I mean, I guess this is a surf spot.
There could be a bunch of people.
But it also kind of feels like maybe the two upper guys
could be the same guy.
I don't know.
I'm looking at their footprints
to see if they all lead to the person.
And they do, which makes me think
that they are actually there.
Or it's just a very good composited image.
I love this image.
I think this is, you know, we're gonna debate
whether or not this is print worthy
and you'd want this on your wall.
But I keep thinking as a thumbnail
for an editorial news article or something like that,
or even in a lobby or in a, you know, maybe a surf shop.
I think it's a very cool image.
It's not so over the top where, you know,
crazy color and splashes
and it's one guy doing the surf activity.
This feels a little more like fine art.
I like it.
I like it a lot.
I'm the one that chose the pictures for this critique.
I'm going to say something a little blasphemous.
What do you think about editing out every single person
except for the guy on the far right?
And I-
Take all the people out?
Yeah, like everything that you like about this photo,
what if you just got rid of all that?
And it was, because I feel like
I don't really like the pose of any person
except for that guy on the far right.
And if you remove all the other people,
you definitely need to zoom in a little bit more,
change the composition
so that that guy's not just like on the edge of the frame.
But I understand this is cool
because it has all the surfers.
That's why I chose it.
But now that I'm looking at it,
the water and the reflection and, you know,
the pattern of the water
in each of those little sand dune areas
is incredible looking.
That surfer on the right, super cool looking.
Everyone else kind of frumpy looking.
So I see what you're saying.
And it is kind of strange to think that
they almost look like they're AI generated
because they're in these weird shapes.
But maybe the human body does weird shapes
when it's not perfectly timed.
I keep going to this guy here
and thinking he looks really bad.
And then I keep going to the runner
and thinking she looks kind of off too.
But then you're right.
I kind of like this guy over here.
He looks pretty good.
Yep, yep.
Photographer, he's looking a little frumpy.
I think I don't mind the girl on the,
I think it's a girl on the bottom
who's kind of playing with her hair.
Yeah.
I don't like the photographer.
I think he kind of throws,
I just keep seeing one of our featured images
that we did of Aliyah LaCarty,
I think on the cliff of someplace in like Moab.
Oh, I was thinking him in Iceland
when we first went to Iceland
and he like walks out on that pool of water.
Yeah, it's funny how only you and I
are probably going in that direction.
And there's also this weird shape
where I feel like the people aren't randomly dispersed.
It's almost like a T or a cross,
like straight down and then straight across.
Yeah.
And maybe some people would say,
oh, those brilliant leading lines,
like they all line up.
But in my mind, I think I want them scattered more.
I was kind of knocking this image at the beginning,
thinking, is this a composite of the same guy?
But I think this needs to be a composite.
I think you need to photograph each one of these people
walking and then pick out the perfect stride
so that if you go this route,
people like you aren't complaining
that they all look frumpy.
You've actually gotten the perfect silhouette of each person.
To answer your question, I don't know.
I think it would be missing something
if it was just one guy.
I mean, I could probably throw this into Photoshop
and remove all these people
and show it to you guys on the screen
if I want to take the time to do that.
Do it, do it.
And then we could see if you're right or wrong.
I think a little bit of water
needs to be added on the right.
That's easy to do too.
I know, but I think it could be a more compelling image.
This was taken by Brandon Bailey
and he says he actually sold a 40 by 60 inch print.
And the other thing to consider
is that a lot of people who buy fine art,
they want it to be real, you know?
Especially now, you can generate anything in two seconds.
And so the value lies in it being real.
And so me telling you to go in
and Photoshop the hell out of this
and then generate a whole quadrant of it,
it's lame, but it could be better.
There's a middle ground there though.
I don't know.
Like I think of music production or something
where the performance was done
and then in the studio,
they had the studio magic to make the hit sound huge,
but it was actually done.
Now it's harder to say that today.
But if you look at songs in the 70s and 80s and 90s,
before Pro Tools existed,
you actually did have to do the performance.
And then you could like make it all smooth and clean.
I think there's a difference
where you have an image like this
and you clone a person out
or you make it a little wider using AI.
I think the base of the image is still there
to where I don't view it as completely the same
as totally generated with AI.
Sure, it's not the same as totally generated.
Like if I removed, I keep thinking,
should you remove some of the footprints on the left?
Yeah, we're just literally rebuilding this entire image.
Let's remove all the people, all the footprints,
and then let's add like a dolphin jumping out of the water.
I mean, it's a critique.
So we're trying to come up with ways
that you could improve the image.
You think the image would be better with less people.
I don't know.
I also think it's super cool
the way it is with all these people.
I mean, that's the whole reason I clicked on it.
Well, this is the first image.
Let's go ahead and rate it.
I think we both like this.
Three, two, one.
I'm between a three and a four.
I'll go four.
I'm being nice.
I'm between a three and a four as well.
All right, next image.
I love the tonality, the color.
Yeah, it's nice.
And we've gone completely in a different direction here
with a very cool kind of green white balance.
Yes.
Now, this is a little hard for me to see,
and people always get mad when I say this,
but we don't have the highest resolution shots
submitted to us, right?
Our website kind of downsizes stuff.
And it kind of feels like this lion
that's in the front with the open eyes
is a little blurry to me.
And I just wonder if you put this through
like a Topaz gigapixel, whatever it's called,
where it upscales.
I just wonder if you could fix that.
You can also do the sharpening too,
where not only does it make it more resolution,
but it tightens the sharpening as well.
I don't know, so growing up,
like I grew up in Alaska and my mom and dad,
I assume, I don't know that my dad
was really the one doing it,
but they bought a lot of prints like this
that they would put in our house.
And they were always of like foxes or penguins
or things that you, maybe not penguins, puffins,
things that you would see in Alaska, you know,
like wildlife.
And there is a vibe that this sort of image
gives your house when you print something like that
and put it in there.
It kind of starts to get into the like wilderness
or hunter sort of vibe, you know,
and it really sets the mood
more than just an abstract image.
And so I've always wondered,
because, you know, I look at these pictures
and I think at some point I'm going to inherit these.
What do I do with them?
I don't know that I ever really personally
would want these images that I grew up with
hanging in my wall that are of puffins
and, you know, of moose and bear, maybe lions, you know.
I think this would fit really well in a,
like a man cave or a trophy room
if you had like a bunch of wildlife
that you've done taxidermy or something,
I don't know, or a cabin.
Or if you took it yourself.
Yeah, but even if you took it yourself,
like, I don't know,
wildlife just really changes the mood,
this kind of wildlife, you know.
Like you have a bunch of wildlife in Puerto Rico
and I think that gives a totally different vibe.
But I don't know, there's something to think about there
where this type of shot, it's for, you know,
the wildlife outdoor enthusiast for sure, you know.
I don't know that everyone's gonna put this
and put it on their wall.
Just like the last one, I mean, you know,
not everyone's gonna put surfing pictures on their wall.
Sure, I really love the lighting on this
and I keep looking at it and thinking,
does it need a little more contrast or something?
And I'm like, maybe not, maybe it's kind of perfect
the way it's, I don't know if muted is the right word,
but it's like a very even exposure
throughout the entire picture,
which normally I wouldn't like,
but it feels more artistic because of that.
One challenge I've always had with printing any images
is that you can get into the, you know,
the calibration of your monitor and all of that stuff,
but you always print it and it never looks the same
on a monitor that it does on paper.
And then another one that no one ever talks about
is how you light it.
So in a lot of prints that I've installed,
especially in the studio back in Charleston,
is I like to print, you know, print them large,
put them on the wall, but then have like little pin lights
where the lights are hitting
and accentuating parts of the picture.
So you could potentially print this really muted like this,
but then with the lighting,
you could kind of have it pop out a little bit more
because if it's not lit well,
this could really get too gray, too middle.
You know, the middle tones are too similar.
And then when you walk in a room,
it doesn't pop the way that you want it,
but you also don't want to do it in post
to where the blacks are crushed and all this contrast is,
it starts to look fake, right?
So I don't know, there's something going on
with lighting too when you consider all of these images.
You know what I can do?
I was just doing an ad for a ink poster,
this e-ink display.
I did a big review of this thing.
All right, so move over so people can see.
So obviously it's blurry right now
because we're in focus,
but that's a painting I have set up right there.
I'm gonna steal this dude's photo of these lions
and it's gonna take a little bit to generate,
but this is an e-ink display.
So it's not a normal LCD frame
that has like a backlight and everything.
It's like an e-ink reader.
It has a battery in it, but the battery lasts a year
and it only uses the battery power to change the image.
So even when it runs out of battery,
it'll have that image forever until you change it.
It's sitting over right now.
But it's not the best for photography.
It's not like the colors aren't the best,
the resolution's not the best,
but for black and white photography,
I think it does a pretty decent job,
but you can see it's going to town now.
It has to do this whole wiping thing
and it'll start flickering
and then it'll generate the image here.
See, I have not gone this route of the digital frame.
I like the idea of changing it all the time,
you know, or changing it enough
to where it kind of keeps things fresh.
Instead, what I've been doing
is I've been printing these massive prints on canvas,
like really high in canvas,
which I didn't think was a thing,
but you could print on like,
you can go to like a company that prints on fabric
and you can get it to look really good.
And then I build them and stretch them on these huge frames
where I wind up with prints
that are like seven feet by five feet.
I mean, they're massive.
You never get that printed for a reasonable price
and then shipped.
And once you build that though,
you are permanently locked into that picture.
So here in Puerto Rico,
I've tried to like do one or two prints
that really always kind of fit the flow of my house,
but then they never change.
But again, you probably can't do a print that large
the way you're doing it either
because you'd need a screen that would be massive.
So there's kind of a benefit to each one of these.
And I love this picture.
I mean, I know we haven't rated this.
I love that the main lion is looking out
and then the other one's looking down.
I try to get couples to do this a lot
where I'm like, let the guy not look at the camera,
but let him look off.
And then maybe the girl is looking down or something.
I feel like this is, they naturally know how to pose,
which is interesting.
Yeah.
There's something really, really nice about this shot.
I'm not a huge fan of African safari pictures,
but this one stands.
I mean, how rugged these lions look, it's wild.
And he said very soon after he took this,
both of these lions were killed by other lions.
So this was in Tanzania in the Serengeti National Park.
I've always wanted to go to Africa and go to the parks.
Like part of me thinks that it might ruin it for me
because when you see what the park's really like,
maybe you realize that everything you've ever seen
of Africa is like not what it really is.
It's kind of like when we went to those slot canyons,
you've always seen those pictures and you're like,
I think they're so cool.
But then when you experience it,
it's like completely ruined that whole thing for me.
100 photographers fighting for the exact same photo.
You know, it's just so lame.
Every time I see those photos, that's what I think of.
I never see it and say, what a beautiful photograph.
I immediately go to the experience.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
All right, you ready to rate this?
Yeah, three, two, one.
Four stars, a solid four stars.
I feel strongly about that four.
Yeah, I do too.
So this shot, you know, an animal,
but totally different vibe.
Like you said, when you have lions hanging on your wall,
those don't fit in many places,
but an artistic shot of a horse,
that can fit in many more rooms.
Yeah, it's wild how pushing it
in this kind of studio-esque sort of vibe
completely changes it.
Because if this was a horse out in a field,
it would kind of go back to the wilderness thing.
But you put some canvas backdrop on there
if this is real or even.
Don't read, don't read.
Even if it's just cut out and put on there.
Guess how this was made.
I mean, there is a strong haloing around.
I mean, there is a, the haloing's hard
because it could just be to get the tonality.
You know, it's like a masking effect.
But I mean, I'm gonna,
I would say this was shot on a seamless,
but then you were like, hold on, wait, wait, wait.
So I'm thinking that this was generated.
No, he said he literally put this backdrop outside
and the horse was just standing in front of the backdrop
and he got it.
It's just real.
The lighting looks so, maybe it's backlit.
It does look like there's a little flash pop
behind the horse on them.
Well, that could be the dodging that they're doing.
No flash, no reflectors, nothing but ambient light.
Sun behind clouds.
Obviously straight out of camera JPEG
look completely different
as I've changed the texture of the backdrop in post
and made it way darker and added vignetting.
Oh, okay.
So it was brighter overall and he darkened the edges.
That makes sense.
So I've thought about this before
because I have a bunch of horses right behind my house here
and I'm like a little scared of horses,
especially if I don't know if they're like trained
or they're wild, you know?
I feel like I've seen those videos where they get kicked,
you know?
And so I just keep thinking,
if you were to take a backdrop,
you'd probably want to be a little further away
and you could shoot a little more telephoto,
but then this backdrop needs to be pretty big.
This is on like a C-stand with somebody like
hauling it out there, right?
And you have to not-
He says it's a two meter by one and a half meter.
So pretty small.
It was tiny.
That's not as big as I would think.
Maybe you could have those pop-up ones
that, you know, have the tension in them.
Yeah, that's probably what it is.
But, you know, it's an interesting idea
that I've thought about before
because I always think of an image that Clay Cook
has in his portfolio of like a horse
in front of a C-stand with an actual backdrop.
And it kind of gives me that vibe, but...
I really like this one too.
Ready?
Three, two, one.
I'm going for it again.
Yeah, I mean, I'm kind of thinking I could say five
if the editing was a little tighter, you know?
Okay.
What don't you like about it?
Well, I think the editing,
I think like the little halo around the face
and the hair and stuff,
it makes me think that this retouching
wasn't quite what it needs to be to be a five.
I love the hair like pulled forward.
I know.
I know he didn't style the horse,
but like the way the horse looks,
it looks like the wind is blowing from behind him.
Yeah.
And he's just got an interesting look to him.
I like that you can't really see his eyes.
He's got this really interesting, you know,
straight expression, you know, it's...
And then the color scheme,
like all of these blues and the browns,
it's just really classy.
I think this also is one of those situations though,
when you print this,
it could be really lost on a wall,
especially when the lights are low
or it's like twilight or it's nighttime, you know?
Like you might need some kind of lighting
that can do this print justice
so that it always kind of pops off the wall,
even though it's a darker sort of image.
Next up.
This has to be the most photographed locations
in all of Norway, right?
We have seen it a few times.
You went to Norway,
you didn't go to any village like this, did you?
I don't think I've been here.
I think I would have remembered
the little houses on the stilts like that
and that mountain.
I don't recognize this.
Obviously, we've done lots of pictures like this with Elia,
with our Photographing the World series.
We've, you know, been to the most crazy places on earth
taking pictures like this.
But do you want these type of pictures on your wall?
And I guess maybe the answer is yes.
I mean, you, like you said,
you kind of have gigantic over-the-top landscape pictures
on your walls in Puerto Rico.
I hope they're not over the top, but.
I mean, I took them, right?
One of them you took, but it's still very muted.
It's not like we've combined all of the blue hour shots
with like Star Trails and like Aurora.
I don't know, like I'll post the picture.
I'll take a picture of my house.
The other one is a sunrise shot,
which is very airy and bright.
It doesn't have like, it's not at the blue hour
and it's super, it's a little dramatic,
but I feel like it just looks like our marina out here.
I feel like it warms up the room
versus gives it this like really intense vibe
that some of these sometimes do, you know?
These long exposures with the stars and everything going on.
I do think these type of images look better large
because when they're small, they're great
and they capture your eye
because the color scheme looks really eye-popping.
But when it's large,
you really get the chance to go up and appreciate it.
Where an image like the horse,
I mean, you print this large
and it's gonna be impactful too,
but I don't know that as much detail
as there is in the horse, it doesn't really.
It doesn't invite you to walk up and look at everything.
Yeah, well, yeah, like I don't need to walk up
to look at all the veins in the horse,
but if you have a town or, you know,
New York or something,
I've seen these big prints in New York.
I wanna go up and look at all the apartments
and see how sharp it is and see, you know,
like far away, close up.
Like it just, there's a lot of detail
that I think encourages the viewer to, you know,
stare at it and appreciate it a little bit more.
Let's quickly talk about the prizes for this contest.
Yeah, so for this contest, it's kind of interesting.
The sponsor is LumaPrints and they are a big print lab
that, you know, allows you to print
on tons of different media, different sizes.
You can, of course, do this for your own portfolio,
for your clients.
I'm kind of hoping that the winner
that wins the $1,000 print prize
would use it to print prints for their home.
They can get anything they want,
basically just a $1,000 gift card?
Yeah, so you can get a bunch of stuff
or you could put it all into one big print.
I don't know if they have a print that's truly 1,000,
maybe like an acrylic print or something,
but yeah, $1,000 and that would, you know,
ship to your house.
So I don't know what international shipping looks like.
So maybe we have to figure that out
if the winner is not in the States or in North America,
but definitely go over to LumaPrints.
You can check out everything there.
Second place, they're gonna win a copy
of ACDC's Photo Studio Ultimate 2026
and their software, if you're not familiar with it,
does everything that the Lightroom suite
or the Photoshop suite does,
where you can get Lightroom, Photoshop,
and maybe like Bridge, all in one suite that you own.
You can kind of do everything there
for a much cheaper price and it does it really well.
Their masks and everything are as good as Lightroom.
I don't understand how Adobe has held on
to their lead for this long, you know?
I think they need people like me
that just hate learning new software
and I'm just stuck in my ways
and I have my catalog built
and I just want it.
And the other thing is like, I just like Premiere.
So I could probably edit photos in any software,
but the second that I need Premiere,
it kind of locks me into them.
But ACDC also has photo editing, video editing software.
So I've never used that.
Maybe I need to.
And third place will win a free tutorial
from fstoppers.com slash store next image.
Well, we gotta rate this.
Oh my God, let's rate it.
All right, let's rate this one.
Three, two, one.
I'm going four again.
Four, okay.
Three.
I think it's solid.
I guess I suffer with just having seen this image
and location and this style of photography so often.
It's funny.
I think the average person who's not a photographer
who hasn't seen this image a thousand times
would probably be most impressed by this.
Like, oh, you got the nighttime.
You got the Aurora.
You got the star.
You got the mountain.
You got the snow.
You know, like they would be blown away.
It's just, we've seen it before.
I'm kind of curious.
I've never been to this location.
I don't know what's possible,
but I'm kind of curious if there's a way
to frame the shot up where you're showing
more of these houses against all of this.
It would be a more telephoto shot.
Because I just keep going to this mound over here
and this like tanker on the hill.
And like, I don't know what's going on behind these houses.
I just feel like there's a bunch of stuff in here
that's not the most appealing,
but you need that if you're gonna shoot wide
from this angle.
But maybe there is another more artistic shot.
I don't say more, but like a different artistic shot.
Maybe from a boat.
What I'm suggesting is something that epitomizes
the idea of scouting a brand new location
that hasn't been photographed.
And I know so many photographers don't like to do that.
They just wanna-
I think photographers do.
Landscape photographers don't.
Landscape photographers, they like going to the same spot.
If I'm shooting a wedding or a portrait or whatever,
yeah, I like to look around and find what's working
at this very moment and maybe nobody else has done
what I'm about to do.
But with landscapes, it's like,
oh, I need to go to this side.
And once I'm over there, I'm stuck there.
The event's happening.
And this is where my favorite photographer took the picture.
I don't know.
I think there's a lot of photographers get trapped
into taking the exact same photo.
This suffers a little bit because of that for me.
Now, when I see shots like this, I mean,
is that background, are all these colors
and lighting events real?
Or is this dodged and burned and saturated
and tweaked really heavily in Photoshop?
I don't know.
My mind did not go to thinking that this was fake.
This just looks so over the top.
What's your opinion of that building?
I don't love it.
I don't like it.
I don't really, I mean, can I go back to your first image
and be like, just Photoshop that out?
You know, everything that makes this image cool,
just take that out.
I don't know.
I mean, it's not the prettiest building,
but it's also super interesting to have something
so grungy looking amongst such beautiful rolling hills.
I mean, it looks like something out of a video game.
Did they mention what this is?
Like, I assume this is a farm and they're doing something
to the land that requires this type of building.
It's almost like a silo, but instead of being rounded,
it's like a, what does it say?
Growers?
Whitman County growers,
but I don't know what that really means.
Well, I mean, you see all these tracks on the grass.
So I don't know.
I mean, is it a sod farm?
I mean, it's got,
no, it doesn't say.
It's got such a pretty grass,
but there's nothing growing.
You know, what are these growers growing?
I really like this picture.
I don't know.
I don't know that I have much more to say,
but are you ready to rate it?
Yeah.
Three, two, one.
I'm going four again.
I think, have I given every picture a four?
You've been super nice.
I mean, I did pick it out.
Yeah.
I'd like to know more on the lighting.
Is this just really dappled light coming through
partial cloudy skies?
Or did you go in and, you know,
manipulate it a little bit to embellish the light
and make the brightness a little bit brighter
where it needs to be and a little bit darker elsewhere?
Composition's great.
I love the foreground like that,
that ridge and then the building sits
exactly where it should be.
And that you don't have any sky up in the top.
So, I mean, it just kind of,
the ground just goes all the way up.
Is there any part of you that wants the top part
burned in a little bit more?
Or do you like those kind of muted blacks
and that grayish sweep that kind of goes across it?
I don't know.
I don't know that really bothers me.
This image, I know we've critiqued recently.
I usually try to not put an image in twice,
but maybe this fits the print category so well.
Yeah, yeah.
This is, with my taste of art,
this is like exactly what I would want on my wall.
It's just super vague.
It doesn't call a ton of attention to itself,
but it can just kind of like set this tone in a room.
But it's not like, oh, that's obviously the beach
right down over here.
Or, oh, that's a picture of a hermit crab.
You know, it's just colors and tones.
So the obvious part to critique with this image
is gonna be the aspect ratio.
Because I can imagine if you have a huge room
and you print it this exact size,
let's just call this, could I say two by 10?
Something too tall by 10 wide.
If the room's so big and you print it in this size,
it's going to just be a sliver of an image in the room.
So would you crop this depending on...
I would crop this depending on the room
I'm going to print it on,
so that this could take up the maximum amount of space
while still being in the pano orientation.
So maybe I would crop off like 10 or 15,
20% off either side to get it to fit the room.
And I would take a picture of the room
and I would put this in Photoshop
and I'd try to tweak all that,
figure out exactly what I'm gonna print it as.
But when it's displayed this wide as it is here,
it kind of loses,
I feel like a lot of panos suffer for that.
They're so wide that they kind of lose.
I think I agree with what you're saying.
I don't know that it's so wide though.
I mean, I think it needs to be printed pretty large too.
Work.
But like you said,
I mean, he says he created this with four panoramic shots.
So you've got plenty of resolution to crop if he needs to.
I really like it the way it is though.
I don't know.
I don't know that I have that much more to say about it.
It's just like a beautiful, super simple image.
It's just my kind of shot.
Well, it's got the god rays.
Is that what you're waiting for?
I mean, but it doesn't even have...
Like sometimes god rays are like,
oh, okay, it's ridiculous over the top.
What's nice is the god rays are going through the right-hand side
with this storm coming in
and the god rays kind of get disrupted on the left-hand side
and you see the storm.
And so I don't know, there's a lot of chaos.
This looks like something like a storm chaser would find
and you wouldn't necessarily just see in your backyard,
but who knows?
Let's rate it.
Three, two, one.
I'm going to keep up these fours.
I have a little story to tell you.
I think I may have mentioned this to you before,
but I know in the last critique,
we were talking about the perils of your son's tennis coach
and how I had this crazy...
We talked about this last critique?
Yeah.
I don't know what's happened.
Maybe you know more.
I don't know anything.
In case you guys didn't watch it,
my son's tennis coach was arrested for selling fentanyl and firearms.
I think so.
Well, I was then sharing the story how I got in an Uber car,
or an Uber driver had a gun on him
and he didn't have his ID with him.
So he was like,
if I get pulled over, probably going to jail
because although I can legally carry this gun,
I don't have my ID on me to prove that I can carry the gun.
Yes, I remember.
And so he was super nice.
He took me through the taco maker drive-through.
I got a bunch of food.
He told me his whole life story.
Really cool guy.
Well, three days later,
I'm scrolling through Facebook
and I see his picture pop up on a local news article
that was dated three days after my Uber ride.
And it was definitely him.
And it says he has been arrested for trying to murder by pulling a knife out.
He tried to murder his daughter.
He didn't try to murder her.
It was like he was threatening her with a knife or something, right?
I mean...
I'm not trying to take his side here.
I'm just saying there's a difference between
trying to murder somebody with a knife or brandishing a knife.
He threatened his daughter, his 20-year-old daughter.
He threatened her life with a knife
and then got arrested for a domestic dispute thing
and thrown into jail or something.
And so it's just been something I've been thinking.
I told this story the other day at the pool.
And I hadn't told my wife this, but she overheard the story.
Oh, you didn't tell her?
No, I was like, I'm not going to freak her out.
She'll never get in an Uber again.
And so I tell the story to some other guys
and my wife hears the story.
And they were just like, that's so crazy.
And I'm like, it kind of is.
You just never know who your Uber driver is.
But I don't know.
So I just wanted to give you guys a little update
that the guy that was carrying the gun
not only was carrying the gun,
but also had a large knife at his house.
But he was a responsible gun owner
when it was time to take somebody out.
He didn't pull the gun on his daughter.
He didn't pull the gun.
If he did, they didn't report that.
So it's just a little side story there.
Now, I think we've seen this shot before.
Maybe we've seen, maybe this is like that shot of Norway
or Sweden, whatever we had previously rated.
I mean, I've certainly seen this before.
I mean, this is one of these shots that's so freaking good.
That I bet you show this to anybody
and nine out of 10 people say, oh, that's AI.
Have you seen, is it Tony Northrup's new video?
He had a video the other day.
And it's like crazy to watch this video
because in some ways I kind of agree with what he's saying,
but the premise is so wild.
The premise is that AI,
I don't agree with this part of it,
but here's the idea.
That AI has been training on all of these images
that have been photographed
using all of our strobing techniques
and all of our retouching techniques
that the images coming out of AI
are kind of ultra stylized,
like we would attempt to do through real photography
five, 10, 15 years ago.
And so there is this new trend coming out
in response to these AI generated images
where people are buying old Mavica,
Sony point and shoot cameras that are three megapixels
or Polaroid or film or watching VHS tapes
or listening to a track,
like all this like old analog equipment,
some of it's digital,
but old digital is becoming popular
because people want to make sure
that their images look more flawed
because that looks more authentic
than really good photography.
And he goes into a lot of different stuff.
You can watch his video.
I didn't watch the entire thing,
but one of the things that stood out in the beginning
was the idea of, you know,
we all buy these like 85 millimeter primes
to get this blurry background,
but that is one of the things
that makes our images look so fake
because we're not used to seeing the world that way.
And so there might be this push to go back to kit lenses
and not actually use the fast ultra prime lenses
because they look like what AI is producing.
Well, and that's what's so funny to me
is that people will say stuff in the comments,
like I hate the way AI photos look
or what, you know, whatever.
And my response is always,
you hate that style of AI,
but AI can do anything already.
If you want your picture to look like
it was taken on an iPhone or with direct flash or whatever,
AI can do that.
With the right prompt.
You just have to retouch it like it looks non-retouched
or leave in some acne.
And all of a sudden it starts to look more authentic.
Yeah.
So this idea that like,
oh, we're just going to buy a crappy camera
so that my pictures don't look like AI.
Well, AI can do that too.
Yeah, you just have to prompt it the right way.
But it kind of goes back to this idea
the story about Evoto
training all of the images of headshot photographers.
It kind of goes into that too,
to where like,
do all of those images look a certain way
because they're all being trained on images
that are a very specific way?
Right.
Or if you could open it up and say,
we've trained an AI generating program
to use headshots from the 80s
before maybe the Peter Hurley style became popular,
you could get headshots that look very different
than what we're kind of accustomed to looking at.
But anyway, the point is just there could be a pushback
to where photographers might want to say,
hey, I don't want my images to look like Peter Hurley's anymore
because one, so many photographers are already doing that.
And then two, AI might be biased towards that style.
And so you're just trying to break the mold,
which I think is always good for any photographer.
Sure.
You're trying to break the mold
and set yourself apart to be very different.
It's like Mike Kelly using less strobes than ever.
So many people think of Mike Kelly
as this architectural photographer
who's popping everything.
I don't think he uses strobes hardly at all anymore,
except maybe at night.
Yeah.
And it's kind of wild that his career
has pushed him in a certain direction.
I've stolen this person's photograph here.
No, you have another one up here.
Yeah.
So what I see on this screen
is exactly what I was going to critique
with this image here.
So it's interesting that my thought process
is showing up on your screen here.
And that is with this color scheme,
I think I would have a fit
trying to get this to print out
with the perfect golden yellow light that I want.
Because I feel like your screen's
looking a little putrid green.
Yeah.
And you could get it to where
like if it's not calibrated perfectly,
it's going to go in a direction
that maybe the viewer doesn't really know.
But it would drive me crazy
if this doesn't have the right tint and color.
Yeah.
But it looks great here.
It looks great on the screen.
Yeah.
But I could see, you know, just like everything.
It looks great on an iPad.
And then the second you send it to the printer,
wow, this looks awful.
And especially with the yellow green colors,
I feel like it's a little easier for that to go,
you know, astray.
Do you like the foreground bushes down here?
Do you think it?
I think I do.
Everything adds a certain layer.
I think I do, yeah.
And just, you know, that little fog strip
you got in the background there looks incredible.
I assume that some contrast
has been brought back in the background and post,
but I don't know.
This is also another one that's just so wide.
I think like if you really print this somewhere
and install it,
you're probably going to want it a little less wide than this.
I don't know about that.
It's hard to make a general statement.
The only time I can see images that are this pano
that really work is like above your bed frame
because above the bed headboard is an area where that works.
But if you have a huge wall,
I typically don't like to, you know,
show more of the wall and have a really thin print.
Yeah.
So I don't know.
I feel like it's nice to shoot these in a panoramic format
so that you have the most options,
but very rarely would I actually print it that wide.
But I don't know.
I'm just trying to come up with another crop here
to see if people know what I'm talking about.
Maybe they all disagree with me.
Do we rate this?
If not, let's begin.
Three, two, one.
I don't, I'm in between a four and a five.
Like, again, I don't know.
There's elements of this that just look like,
oh my gosh, it's so ridiculous.
It's like a fairy tale painting or something.
This is AI.
Thomas Kinkade.
Yeah.
But then the other part of me is like,
no, it's freaking perfect.
But then another part of me is like,
is this really unforgettable?
I feel like I've seen this shot before.
I don't know if I've seen this shot.
I don't know if I've seen a thousand other photographers
standing right there.
There's your answer.
If you can't remember, it wasn't.
I do remember it though.
But I don't know if I've seen this guy's shot
or I saw somebody else standing in the same spot.
I'm in between a four and a five.
What is going on here?
So I saw this image when I first released this critique.
This is an early image that was posted
in the first week or so.
But it'd be no shock to say I love this image.
But man, does this look like a painting.
When things start looking like paintings,
they kind of start looking like AI art too.
It's just, that's the problem.
It's like when it's too good,
your mind just goes to, it's fake.
I think we're too young to know the answer to this.
Maybe you dabbled more in film than I did.
But was there a phase when things were transitioning
from film to digital where everyone was like,
that looks like digital photography?
Was that like a trend?
I don't remember.
Because with AI, it's most certainly that.
Everything now is like, everything is compared to AI.
Everything I see on Instagram and Facebook,
I just automatically think,
unless it's somebody that I know who's a photographer,
critique or somebody.
That's a real photograph.
But everything else I see,
I just kind of automatically think this is AI.
This is a fake prank video.
Everything's just made for a very specific reason.
And it's usually for an ad.
I don't know.
I feel like this the same way.
This looks so cool.
But the fact that it's got this weird filmy,
almost looks like it's a photograph
of a printed print on paper.
And doesn't that kind of look like
watercolor paper in the background?
Yeah, you're right.
Because it's got that,
and I would never see that in a real photograph,
unless you started texturing on layers of that
in Photoshop or something.
Yeah, what is that?
I don't know.
As part of some celebration,
they take out 200 bucking stock horses
and 50 trail riders are like pushing them through
and they're creating the stampede thing.
Nine of the horses accidentally died
when they were spooked and ran into a fast flowing river.
The remaining 191 horses arrived at Stampede Park,
where I captured the image as the herd entered the park.
See, I saw this and thought,
if this is a stampede,
surely the horses, some horses would die,
but not from running in a river,
but being run over.
Yeah, like you see these things
where people in concerts or whatever try to get out
or there's gunmen or something
and people get trampled over and they die.
There was a documentary.
Did you see this one on Netflix?
Who was the rapper?
Some rapper in Houston, Texas or something.
Oh, yeah, I heard about that.
You just watch these and you're like,
man, it seems so impossible for that to happen,
but then when you see how it actually happens,
you're like, oh, I never would have expected
that that's how people would suffocate and die.
Same sort of thing here.
I would think one of these horses falls
and man, he's going to be destroyed and killed, right?
Yeah. All right, let's rate it.
Three, two, one.
I'm going five stars.
I mean, I just have questions and that's,
I mean, he told us how he did it,
but it's like this is such a low res image
and what's going on on that horizon line?
Why does it look so painterly?
I want to see this image sharper
because if this is truly a photograph,
if this was sharp,
I think it's like you zoom in everywhere
and you're like, wow, the detail is incredible.
If it's a painting, it's still amazing,
but it kind of goes into a different realm, you know?
But I really do like this image.
I love the image.
I love the composition.
You know, I probably wouldn't shoot this wide.
Like I just don't really like wide angle images
when I take them, but I love this.
And then the color grading afterwards, super interesting.
And I don't know if some wacky editing has been done.
Like if, you know, some sort of texture
has been placed over this
and that's what we're seeing in the background,
but at least what we can see in this low res shot.
I love it.
I saw this image and I was like,
what the heck is going on here?
Is this some infrared thing?
Do you want to guess?
I would have thought this looks like, you know,
when foliage turns white,
I immediately think it's infrared,
but I don't know infrared well enough
to know what the foreground
and the sky and everything are doing.
I would say, yeah, this is infrared.
Is this not?
Yes, it is.
It says this was taken by stitching
four by three infrared images taken
with a full spectrum Samsung NX 1100
equipped with a 680 NM infrared filter.
I don't know anything about infrared photography.
I do know that this genre of photography
seems to really had a peak in a certain period of time.
And I think it's around the early 2000s,
like 2004 to 2008.
Like in that time period,
are people still modifying their mirrorless cameras
and doing infrared the same way that they were?
Like when I see this,
I think of all those like old popular photography magazines,
like when you bought magazines to learn
and they would have this stuff on the cover.
I feel like this is a type of photography
that's kind of fallen out of fashion.
But yeah, typically I speak from back then
because I don't know what it is like now,
but typically you'd have an IR filter
on the front of your sensor
that would block the IR light
from even coming into the camera
because it's not being recorded
and it's just adding, I guess, noise.
And so you'd have your cameras modified
to where it's kind of doing the opposite.
It's blocking all the color spectrum light
and only letting in the infrared light.
And then you would put a filter on
to kind of allow that to be accentuated.
I think these were like very dark red filters.
I mean, I say all that,
I've never actually gone out and done this,
but I remember people who had those cameras.
They always got like a D70 camera
that they've converted.
And that would just be the-
Yeah, you like remove some sort of infrared filter
that's built onto the front of the sensor, right?
Yeah, the one that blocks the infrared.
Right.
Do you like the effect that it does?
I mean, yes.
The lighting in the shadows of these tree leaves,
I don't know if these are leaves, looks amazing.
It looks like you've brought out
some gigantic reflector
the size of a building
and you filled in these shadows on this tree
and maybe they just brought up the shadows.
I don't know, but something about this
looks incredible to me.
This makes me want to do a video about this
because I feel like I've seen images
like this in the past
and they always look cheesy to me.
This one looks incredible.
That'd be a fun shootout.
Like you get an infrared camera
and I see what you can create.
Yeah, look at these cameras I got right here.
I assume you bought these
and Leica didn't send them to you, right?
Because I think you just did a video
where you kind of trashed on one of Leica's,
is it like a $4,000 or $5,000, $7,000?
$7,000 50 millimeter lens
that performed horribly in my test.
I came across what may be
the most overpriced lens of all time.
The Leica 50 millimeter 1.4.
Most lenses with these specs are around $500.
This one cost $7,000.
But I have good news.
It just went on sale.
It's $1,000 off right now.
You can get this lens for just $6,000.
And in today's video,
we're going to be comparing this $7,000 lens
to all of these 50 millimeter lenses,
including this one that's just $200.
Can it possibly compete?
Let's find out.
So I believe this is a $7,000 Leica camera
that I'm trying to understand
why people love these things.
And then this is Sony's $5,000 competitor here.
These both have fixed lenses.
Yeah.
You cannot change the lenses.
$7,000.
$7,000, $5,000.
Like I just, I don't understand it.
I don't understand it.
I'm trying to learn though.
So there is a part of me that has a desire
to have a camera like this.
That's not $7,000.
That's just floating around my house
that I could somehow like take pictures
of my family with
in like cool, intimate, fun moments
of like my kids growing up.
Kind of like that.
I feel like the iPhone isn't stylized enough.
Like it does weird stuff
where like it's doing the processing of the image.
Like I'll see a photo on my screen.
Maybe you can explain this to me
because I don't understand it.
I will be taking a picture and be like,
oh, my daughter looks great there.
And then I take the picture
and the resulting image,
it's got this like computational edit to it
that I hate.
And I'm like, maybe I can go in
and remove that and do more with it.
But I feel like the iPhone is just,
I don't know.
I don't like the look of the images from it.
And so I think if I could have
like a 35 millimeter 1.8,
something that looks classy
and I don't even know if,
I guess it's one of these type of cameras,
but just having something floating around
to where I'm also not worried
if my kids pick it up.
It's the opposite of this.
But you know what I'm saying?
Like a camera that could just float around
that would have a fixed lens
that would be fast.
It could work in low light.
The TV could be the key light.
Why do you want it to be a fixed lens?
Like why not a zoom lens?
Because I just feel like
I want that fast aperture.
Okay.
I guess they do have zoom.
These just aren't the fastest lenses.
Is this not faster than 2.8?
What is this?
This is a,
all right, this is a 1.7
and this is a F2.
Okay.
Yeah.
I mean, this is the direction
that like Fujifilm went.
Kind of.
They have other options.
Yeah.
I just,
I find it really hard to like give up,
you know,
a lens that zooms
and interchangeable lens and everything
for professional use.
Maybe for travel,
people like that.
But I don't want to travel
with a camera that says Leica on it.
Like that's the first way to get.
But how else are you going to flex
on everybody else who's on vacation?
You know, you got to.
So I won't name names,
but we have a friend here who's a,
she's become a photographer in the community
and she was at our place in Charleston.
She was like,
yeah, I really want to get one of those.
Is it called like Leica?
And I was like,
if you don't know how to say the name,
why do you,
why do you want it?
Because it's expensive.
She's like there,
but they're really expensive.
And I was like,
oh my gosh.
I mean.
The Leicas.
Yeah.
I mean, there's obviously something to it.
You just put a high price tag on it
and all of a sudden people want it.
They don't even know why.
Yeah.
All right.
Have we rated it?
No.
Three, two, one.
Three.
I'm going four.
I like it.
I think the trees look amazing.
I love the color and the white and all that,
but an ocean and everything,
it just looks like there's no real good foreground.
It just kind of looks like a snapshot
that's got really cool coloring going on
because of the infrared look.
Yeah.
If this was a color photograph,
like a normal shot,
we'd be like,
this is a two, right?
Yeah.
Absolutely.
So then it brings up the question for our rating system
is if you have an infrared camera,
does that immediately knock it up one star?
An extra star immediately because it's white?
I don't know.
Hopefully that's not the way our rating works,
but this particular image,
I like the way this looks.
Next up, final image.
I'm going, where are you going to guess?
Is this like Iceland or I would say Hawaii.
Oh man.
I just realized this is the same dude
who took the horse picture.
Wow.
Totally different vibes.
I've always wanted to experience this
and we were in Hawaii once doing something
and I really wanted this to happen,
but it wasn't
because you can take boats out and stuff and see it.
It's pretty gnarly to be like
standing on the ledge with it right now.
Yeah, right there.
I always feel like I would get like stuck,
like you turn around and,
oh my gosh, the lava is coming up from behind me.
What are you going to do?
Yeah.
Or you make some dumb decision,
I'm going to jump over it
and then you like,
I don't know.
And then the fumes too,
like another part of it
is we were going to take a helicopter
and see some of the lava fields,
but they were like,
today the fumes are too strong to wear.
How do you know that?
How do you know today's fumes are bad?
Tomorrow's fumes are going to be safe.
How do you know?
They have like the index scores for like the sun.
Today's a bad day to be out.
How do you know that stuff?
I don't know.
Well, that just seems like cloud, cloud cover.
What do you think about this
from a photography standpoint?
I like it.
I think, you know,
there's something with the framing,
with the bottom that might be,
I mean, I like the colors.
I like that.
I assume you don't like this.
I like it okay.
I kind of want to see like,
I hate that the rock on the right hand side
is blocking the view of the closest.
Yes.
Lava.
Yes.
I feel the same way.
I've also seen some pretty amazing
lava shots like this
where lava is like exploding
and you get these little like
fireworks of lava going into the ocean
and this is kind of missing that.
It seems like maybe
there's a little bit of it on the right,
but I don't know that I need that though.
I kind of like it where it's just oozing out.
Like sometimes when things are exploding it.
It's too much.
Yeah, it kind of becomes a little too much.
I think I want a little bit more foreground.
Like the camera tilted down
or just widened
or stepped back just a little bit.
Or maybe I want none of it.
I don't know.
I can't really crop on the iPad
without also cropping the left hand.
I'm wondering if I would prefer it
zoomed in like that.
Because this black that we have
on the bottom right is like,
it's just a little awkward to me.
I like that better.
I don't know.
There's also kind of some artifacting.
I don't know if this is like the edit.
This one feels kind of heavily retouched to me.
And so it feels fake to me.
Whereas that horse picture
may have been heavily edited,
but it seemed more stylized.
This just feels like
we're gonna bump up the contrast on the lava
and make it glow more.
And it seems a little too heavy handed.
I do love the exposure choice.
I feel like the water isn't too long of an exposure.
There's some really nice detail.
It's like in that three to five second length
as opposed to like 30 seconds
where everything gets too flat.
And then I love the lava
reflecting the warmth in the waves too.
Especially the hottest one.
The hottest lava point in the middle
could be toned down a little bit.
But I love that line that comes towards you
where you're seeing the reflection
in the water there.
I think that's pretty cool.
Ready to rate it?
Yeah.
Three, two, one.
Three, this is my lowest rated one of the critique.
Still cool.
I feel like I gave a lot of threes in this.
So it's always challenging to remember
which ones I like the most
when it comes time to pick the winner.
All right guys, we have deliberated.
Third place.
We are giving it to Timu
with the horse picture.
It's kind of sad for me to give this third place
because I do love it so much.
But we just got awesome shots for this critique.
So third place.
Send me, Lee Morris, a private message on fstoppers.com.
Let me know which tutorial you would like.
And second place.
We have the winner of ACDC's 2026.
We're giving it to Robert Henderson
with the two lions here.
Such an amazing shot
to get these two lions that close together
and such a cool pose and expression
on both their faces.
And first place.
We both agreed that we're giving it to Ken McCurdy here.
This horse stampede is such a wild shot.
And like you said,
it kind of just feels like a painting.
I love photographs that look like a painting.
I mean, this looks like you're in the Smithsonian Art Gallery.
And like that is,
it looks like George Washington should be overlooked.
Like it just has such a vibe.
Yeah.
It's so cool.
So Ken, you have just won a $1,000 print credit.
I'm sure whatever you decide to print is going to be amazing,
but I kind of hope it's this picture.
And I want to see what you decide to print.
So make sure,
send me all your information.
Lee Morris on fstoppers.com.
Just send me a private message.
And once you get your prize and everything,
send me another message with pictures of it
wherever you're hanging up
because I want to see what you've chosen.
This is just incredible looking.
And guys, remember that we're doing that 50% off
the entire fstoppers store.
You can go to fstoppers.com slash store
and use the coupon code CTC,
Critique the Community, 50.
And you can save 50% for the next 30 days
while we're running this next critique.
And if you'd like to join,
we're just doing emotion.
Any picture that shows emotion
and you can sign up 100% for free
at fstoppers.com slash contest.
And first, second, and third place
is going to win a free tutorial from the fstoppers store.
And if you buy one right now and you happen to win,
you can either get another one
or we'll give you your money back.
You decide.
So we'll see you at fstoppers.com slash contest.
