The Liberal-Washing of JK Rowling

J. K. Rowling - the writer
1 follower
1 Video View·Jun 9, 2026
How people ignore JK Rowling's bigotry.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video analyzes the ethical implications of actors like Tom Felton and Nick Frost participating in the Harry Potter franchise amidst J.K. Rowling's anti-trans views. The speaker argues that framing Rowling's bigotry as a \"Twitter controversy\" ignores the systemic harm she funds, and criticizes \"liberal washing\" where progressive actors provide a facade of inclusivity for a harmful system.
And I have not seen anything bring the world together more than Potter and she's responsible
for that so I'm incredibly grateful.
You know there is something rather sad about Tom Felton in real life turning out to be
just as spineless as Draco Malfoy.
Well done Draco, well done.
Hello interwebs I hope you are all doing well because unfortunately I am here to talk yet
again about the goddamn HBO Harry Potter show.
As many of you know I recently did a couple videos mainly focusing on actors who have
been cast in the Harry Potter show and their reaction to JK Rowling's anti-trans bigotry
mainly how they're actively ignoring it.
And I said in those videos that I didn't necessarily want to talk about this show again unless
there was something unique and interesting to talk about.
And unfortunately I do think there is because recently within the past few days we've had
two actors within the Harry Potter franchise both Tom Felton who played Draco Malfoy in
the original movies and is now back to play Draco Malfoy in the Broadway version of Harry
Potter and the Cursed Child the play as well as Nick Frost who is the actor who has been
cast to play Hegrid in the upcoming HBO adaptation.
And both of them had very distinct responses to questions around JK Rowling's anti-trans
bigotry in ways that I kind of found to be very illuminating and I think worth discussing
not just because of their own responses to JK Rowling and how they defer but how there's
been a interesting reaction to their two differing responses from within even liberal
leaning progressive spaces that I really think is interesting to discuss not just to condemn
or attack these actors or this response to it but actually more to talk about how there
has been this kind of liberal washing of the Harry Potter show that is reflective of this
trying to sort of disengage with standing in solidarity with trans people that I think
is emblematic of not only just the Harry Potter show and JK Rowling's bigotry in general but
how many progressive leaning folks tend to try to wash their hands of systemic anti-trans
harm that is kind of epitomized by these things.
And I want to kind of do that by looking at the reaction to Tom Felton and Nick Frost
like I said through two articles that were written by the progressive leaning website
The Mary Sue.
Before we get started I just wish to say right up front that while I am focusing on The Mary
Sue and these two articles written by the same author this is not necessarily to attack
this author this is not necessarily to attack The Mary Sue certainly I have criticisms as
will be very obvious but as with anything like the goal here isn't to cancel anybody
but to really look at these two distinct reactions from the same person who is working on a progressive
styling website and sort of look at what it kind of means towards responses to anti-trans
bigotry generally and JK Rowling specifically.
So let's actually get into it let's start with Tom Felton because I think he's the most
straightforward thing to discuss here.
As I already mentioned Tom Felton was recently recast as Draco Malfoy in the Harry Potter
and the Cursed Child adaptation on Broadway and he was recently asked at the red carpet
for the Tonys in which he was presenting an award about the so-called Twitterverse controversy
with JK Rowling.
So let's take a look at his response here.
How does the does the sort of Twitterverse controversy around JK Rowling's views impact
you at all or impact your work in the world at all?
No I can't say it does I'm not really that attuned to it the only thing I always remind
myself is that I've been lucky enough to travel the world here I am in New York and I have
not seen anything bring the world together more than Potter and she's responsible for
that so I'm incredibly grateful.
So numerous things already that we can discuss here first off let's criticize the reporter
here this is not the Mary Sue this is someone else but the reporter kind of frames things
as Twitterverse controversy and this is the kind of the problem that I always have with
a lot of people who discuss JK Rowling it's always framed that her bigotry here anti-trans
hate is just a thing that's in the Twitter sphere on social media ignoring that she is
actively causing anti-trans harm to people I mean most obviously she is using her platform
be it Twitter be it elsewhere to promote anti-trans hate at a time where trans people
are under attack she has been doing this continually for years and years and years at this point
but even more demonstrably recently she has been actively funding anti-trans legislation
like she donated to the group that sued in the United Kingdom successfully tried to get
the definition of woman changed to be exclusionary to trans people which has demonstrably harmed
rights protections within the UK so she has had a tangible effect financially there and
most recently she has announced that she is going to be helping to fund a group that will
be actively pushing legislation against trans people in the United Kingdom so she is directly
harming transgender people it is not some social media controversy certainly a lot of
her anti-trans bigotry takes place on there but to silo it solely as just that to minimize
it solely as that de-escalates the very real harm that she is causing at a time where trans
people are directly being attacked and being systematically harmed both in the United Kingdom
and the United States and around the globe. So right away the question is not great but
Tom Felton's response to it is frankly even worse because he basically is almost honest
to a fault because he quite literally says I can't say it impacts me I'm not really attuned
to it and it speaks to his privilege right he's a fairly well-off cis dude who is able to not
have to worry about these things like I don't even know Tom Felton's overall politics be they
progressive or conservative who the hell knows it doesn't really matter at this point it's more that
he doesn't have to look at it it's not something that bothers him he can sort of cast it off as
just a social media thing I'm not really worried about it but then he goes on to defend JK Rowling
saying I've not seen anything more that wouldn't has brought this world together than Harry Potter
she's responsible for that so I'm incredibly grateful so it's again sort of positioning JK
Rowling as this progressive figure that sort of she has been become in pop culture generally and
sort of playing into that narrative around her while ignoring the demonstrable harm that she
has caused and it's again just speaking to his privilege that he can sort of look away from this
and prop her up within the narrative that she is always generally propped up as is like a progressive
leaning feminist figure that she is wielding to harm trans people and this brings me to the first
article from the Mary Sue which goes right into this exact thing the author basically says exactly
what I just said it is a point of privilege to act as if what JK Rowling says and does with her money
doesn't affect you when you're working on a project first that's what Tom Felton has I'm assuming she
meant done there people need to proofread these sites too and he used it while on the red carpet
for the Tonys I'm not gonna read the whole article here but it basically goes into exactly what I
said here recently she said she would donate money she made from the show to the same organization
that just got a bill passed in the UK that is going to end up hurting trans men and women and
their rights as well as non-binary people it should be said but Felton's response to that
question was just as disappointing as the question itself obviously the author also
acknowledged the same problem I had with the question how it's framed and also the fact that
there was no follow-up if you want to start in a Harry Potter project you have to unfortunately
feel these questions you can take it up with Rowling she's the one who has made it her business
to constantly attack trans people simply existing so if anything you should be aware of what's
going on and know that people still want to know what you how you can be a part of the Harry Potter
franchise if you want the money say that I'd respect you more if you just openly said I wanted
money into work and I'll be using the platform it gives to help me support trans lives so here's
where I already want to start acknowledging something because she is saying if you want
the money say that I'd respect you more if you openly said that which you know I don't necessarily
agree with but you can already see that she's kind of already presupposing that Tom Felton
here wants to support trans people there's already kind of a slant within this article of like
wanting to like actually wanting to believe the best of Tom Felton that he is trans supportive
and I understand that I understand the like there's a place of wanting to assume the best
about people here and I get that I do but when you look at someone like Tom Felton who is actively
not listening and actually not saying anything and then you look at someone like his co-stars
in Harry Potter like Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson um who have openly spoken up for trans
people um even a soft way like some of them have been like none of them I don't think any of them
like have been overtly like J.K. Rowling sucks they've said they disappointed in her
but they they have already like gone out of their way to speak up about trans people
Tom Felton hasn't done that he hasn't shown that and again I want to believe the best of him
but like already here there's a assumption that that is kind of what he would want to do
regardless but we don't know that but it's already presupposed assumption here which is something
that I want to kind of bring up because it'll tie into our discussion about Nick Frost later on
but on the whole as this article ends pretending like what Rowling does with her platform money
doesn't affect the Harry Potter franchise and is foolish and it is time for Tom Felton to educate
himself on it I agree with that ending statement right like I I ultimately agree with this article
overall there is a presumption that Tom Felton is telling the truth when he says he does not know
what is going on with J.K. Rowling that may be true but as someone who is cast in a project I
am sure he has his managers telling him like this is what you're going to be stepping into and they
probably told him to give this response of like I don't know they probably did the cost benefit
analysis say like well it's probably better for you to be in this project if you're going to do
it's probably better for your career because you haven't been cast in anything else you might as
well get that boost of like replaying a character that you that people know you in and the best
thing to do is try to just ignore the controversy and come out as unscathed as you can while getting
the attention and fame and money that you can get from the project so there is a presumption of uh
just taking him at his word within this article that he does not know um but if we are going to
his word on that then I agree completely with this article that like it is he does need to educate
himself on that and he is only able to not educate himself on that because of his privilege I would
question whether or not he does but uh he has he does not know but you know taking him at his word
this is the correct tact here this though stands in sharp contrast and I'm going to directly read
the entirety of this next article it's rather short and it's very telling uh this author's
same response that was actually posted on the same day as this article two hours later about
Nick Frost being asked a question about J.K. Rowling's transphobia a very similar question
so the article headline here reads they just don't align in any way shape or form Nick Frost
opens up about J.K. Rowling's views in this Harry Potter casting so again we're going to go right
through this article it's rather short so it'll also give you all the information that we needed
to talk about Nick Frost in particular but I also want to talk about the this article's framing
the new HBO adaptation of Harry Potter has been causing quite a stir and for good reason J.K.
Rowling will benefit from the show and she has already said that the money she earns will go
to her organization that seeks to harm trans rights correct it has made some casting that
I would otherwise be excited about tainted one such casting is Nick Frost as Rubeus Hegrid
to me this is perfect but then I had to think about the situation why any adult would put
themselves in the series when they know that Rowling has used her platform to attack trans
rights time and again it made me originally upset with Frost okay a few things already here
the author clearly has a love still of Harry Potter and I get that this is something that I
struggled with several years ago I love Harry Potter it was a franchise that meant a lot to
me but I'm seeing JK Rowling attack people attack me attack trans people attack even other people
doing holocaust like there's this plethora of things have been going on for years now
and I came to the point of like I I grieved the loss of this thing that meant a lot to me
and I put it aside and is no longer a thing that I'm dealing with this author is very clearly still
like I want to be excited about Harry Potter and I think that that's important there's this idea
that like this person has still trying to preserve and hold on to Harry Potter as a franchise and
again I have a level of sympathy for that in the sense that I went through that but we are at a
point given where the world is generally for trans people just the fascism rising generally speaking
that like I feel like we should have moved past this this element but again being fair this is
where a lot of even progressive styling folks are still at there's still a lot of people that are
like I don't know about JK Rowling's transphobia but I still love Harry Potter and uh also denote
the word originally I've loved Frost in his career since I was 12 and found Shaun of the Dead his
work has made me happy for over two decades and I don't didn't like the idea that he'd be hateful
and harmful towards the trans community so it pleased me to see a new interview he did with
the observer that explained his thoughts on Haggard and Rowling so want to acknowledge here
I was also very disappointed in Nick Frost Nick Frost was an actor that I've really loved
for numerous years um he appeared in like I said Shaun of the Dead which was a very formative movie
for me as a kid not just as a genre science fiction but as a filmmaker that movie is uh
is I think a really great piece of filmmaking in a genre that I love and was very informative
in terms of like tackling the tropes of zombie fiction being very funny sort of less like
interesting breakdown of it interesting filmmaking like those runners in that movie so it's like a
movie that I've loved and he's been in that and numerous other films that I've really liked so
he's an actor that I looked up to in his casting in this uh show I think more than any other actor
that has been cast in this show so far has been the one that's actually disappointed me the most
to see him in he is the probably the perfect embodiment of that John Lithgow I've always
liked but Nick Frost was kind of like someone that I have loved since I was a kid Lithgow
someone who I've enjoyed I think he's a really great actor but that's not not one that I've been
like super attached to as much as I would say Nick Frost for example that's me personally
your mileage may vary on that which leads to this he thinks she's entitled to her opinion
he just doesn't agree with her on it it is similar to new Severus Snape actor Papa Isidou signing an
open letter for film and television to protect trans rights after a new bill in the UK was passed
that Rowling's support helped get through it all led to me to thinking this why not take the
paycheck and use a lot of it to counteract what Rowling is doing with her portion of the profit
we'll come back to that I'm gonna put a pin in that but I have thoughts heavy thoughts on that
but we're gonna put a pin in it for right now um and we'll also talk about Papa Isidou in just a
little bit as well but just to give context there what she is referring to is he uh recently signed
a letter in support of trans people and even JK Rowling acknowledged uh him doing this by saying
I don't have the power to sack an actor from the series and I wouldn't exercise it if I did
I don't believe in taking away people's jobs or livelihoods because they hold legally protected
beliefs that differ from mine yeah you just believe in taking away trans people's jobs and
livelihoods and rights I don't believe for a second that she doesn't want to fire him she
just knows that she can't um she has been known to attack actors uh that have been in her franchise
namely uh Emma Watson and Daniel Radcliffe she has very clearly alluded to that previously
so I I very much don't buy her response to this I just think she can't and so this is the face
that she can put on it but regardless she has addressed that we'll come back to that as well
um because it's very similar to my feelings on Nick Frost here but the article continues one of
the fascinating parts of his interview with the Observer came with Frost talking about Rowling's
anti-trans take at the start of the interview he pointed out he was constantly working and
starring in things not because he loved the game because he needed to as he pointed out people
think because you made Shaun of the Dead you're a billionaire that's what led me to my to my new
kind of hope for adults joining the Harry Potter series if you want to get that paycheck I understand
it but I'd also love if every one of them in turn spoke out against Rowling and what she is doing
Frost went on to talk about how Rowling could have her opinion but that it didn't align
quote-unquote with his own quote she allowed her opinion I'm allowed mine they just don't align in
any way shape or form he told the publication he was then asked if he was quote worried that the
pushback against Rowling would hurt the series quote I don't know he said but then said something
that made me have a lot more respect for Frost more than I already did but maybe it shouldn't
blow over we shouldn't just hope it will go away because it makes it easier maybe we should educate
ourselves okay so that's the end of the article and there's quite a lot that I want to break down
here both in terms of Nick Frost's response and what this article is sort of alluding to and what
its kind of end goal is let's start though with Nick Frost as I've said numerous times Nick Frost
is framing what JK Rowling's views as an opinion that he can defer on and that speaks a lot to his
presence because what JK Rowling is is fundamentally a bigot she is saying trans people do not exist
and specifically overtly attacking trans women as well as erasing trans men and calling them just
confused little girls or whatever that whole bullshit that is targeted at trans men she is
fundamentally saying though that trans people don't exist but it is fundamentally a way to try
to attack and harm and try to erase a actual marginalized living group of people trans people
like I am that is not just an opinion that you can have that you can be like oh we can just we
can agree to disagree place this in the context of black people right if JK Rowling was saying
this about black people or about another minority um or you know a religious minority jewish people
muslim people like we would understand instantaneously though this isn't just opinion
that we can accept but when it's trans people people can say like oh yeah it's just a difference
of opinion so already while Nick Frost is aligning himself with uh saying you know he stands by trans
people he's still underplaying the bigotry that JK Rowling is portraying here by just saying it's a
reasonable people can disagree reasonable people cannot disagree here reasonable people would look
at what JK Rowling is doing and understand it as bigotry and saying it is unacceptable
not just a difference of opinion but that's the sort of more like capital l liberal progressive
mindset that is oh it's just difference opinion we can disagree on these things but no she is
actively causing harm and again she is using her platform to be able to not only promote
anti-trans ideas but fund them as well the Harry Potter empire the Harry Potter franchise that is
continually generating money and cultural relevancy towards JK Rowling is being used to attack trans
people directly and Nick Frost appearing in this show actively lends his weight right weight and
credence and credibility to it is saying oh I as the actor Nick Frost say it is okay with people
for people like me to be in this show so what he is ultimately doing is actively harmful in that he
is giving this progressive face to say like hey those of you who still stand by trans people it
is okay for you to like the Harry Potter show it is okay for you to say oh it is it is fine and like
progressive people you can still like this show you can still enjoy it because hey it's you can
just have a difference of opinion with JK Rowling without acknowledging the underlying harm that
you are both you know giving cultural relevancy continue cultural relevancy and active money to
and giving some level of permission to people who are progressive by your words but saying it's just
difference opinion to still engage with and ultimately that is of what a lot of progressive
minded people who believe that they are standing by trans people are looking for it's a similar
thing that we saw going on with the Harry Potter video game right people just looking for a way to
from the harm that is happening here that is that this is funding because we can sort of like say
well it's it's we're extrapolated away like Harry Potter is a different thing there are billions of
people working out we can you know it's gonna it's gonna help get payment to the actors like
Nick Frost he needs the money it's gonna give payment to workers at Warner Brothers who are
gonna work on the show it's going to you know fund all these people without acknowledging that money
could go elsewhere that money could be made on different things all of these other different
it's sort of like well we're just going to keep on going along with what this is
quite frankly it would be much better if only anti-trans bigots were cast in this Harry Potter
show because it would reveal the vileness that goes on here it would reveal how ultimately like
how vile and despicable that like J.K. Rowling's views are she should only be accepted by people
who share her bigoted views like everyone else should shun her and should not work with her
but by accepting the casting in this show Nick Frost has basically given that permission and
he's continued to given that permission by downplaying it and by him saying things like
well we can let's sit in the discomfort we've been sitting in the discomfort by sitting in
the discomfort you're allowing trans people to continue getting harmed we are sitting in the
discomfort right now we need to be fighting back against that discomfort the time to sit in the
discomfort was years ago when J.K. Rowling was still like have evolving these views and getting
more and more radicalized into anti-trans and fascist viewpoints there were numerous people
at that time myself included who wrote articles people who knew her who reached out like Daniel
Radcliffe Emma Watson who tried to take her out of this radicalizing path and that's a point where
you can be like all right let's let's have a conversation let's talk about this let's try to
this but right now she is had numerous chances to escape this we've had numerous chances to have
this conversation and right now harm is being caused that J.K. Rowling is actively contributing
to this is a point where we fight back this is a point where we say this is unacceptable and again
I wanted to talk about this not just as a element of just Harry Potter but this is something we're
seeing across the board right where we're seeing people like Gavin Newsom giving a platform to
******* right-wing assholes and saying like yeah I agree with your anti-trans views like I am just
like basically trying to give himself a progressive like he's being more opportunistic in the sense
that he's trying to make himself more appealing to conservatives which isn't necessarily what Nick
Ross was doing but it is one of those things that like generally we are seeing the more progressive
like capital L liberal leaning space like Democrats and such trying to do is being like well we we
stand by trans people but we're not we're going to ignore the systemic harm or we're not going to
stand by stopping the systemic harm or even in some cases help continue the systemic harms this
is Gavin Newsom passing stuff that like limits trans people's ability to participate in sports
for example while sort of like saying oh well we still support trans people we need to stop making
us such a big deal out of it or stop platforming it and basically people going along with it because
they they want to be able to say they stand by trans people but are unwilling to recognize the
systemic harm that they are that they are funding and J.K. Rowling is kind of a perfect example of
this because it is probably it is generally systemic harm because you get the sense of like
look they're part of a Harry Potter franchise empire that is feeding money to something bigger
that is ultimately being used to harm trans people they're not directly harming trans people
but they are leading to the funding of all this whole thing but it is probably the shortest
pipeline version of that and the most overt pipeline version of that of like the money you
are making for Harry Potter is going directly into J.K. Rowling's pocket in a large amount
and she is using that to fund trans people it's like one of the most direct versions of that
everything else after that gets much more complicated for sure but it's still very a
similar sort of pipeline and this is I like talking about Harry Potter in that way because
it is such a poor example of it and this kind of brings me back to this article because you have
this writer saying here that's what led me to my new kind of hope for adults joining the Harry
Potter series if you want to get that paycheck I understand it but I love if every one of them in
turn spoke out against the Rowling and what she was doing and she's basically giving herself a
kind of that pass here right it's like well I can feel okay with having respect more respect even
for Nick Frost and feeling okay to watch this Harry Potter show because look there's someone
who aligns quote-unquote with my views here and uh you know I can sort of like say like oh look
it's not completely a betrayal of my views to watch the Harry Potter show because now I have
some level of permission to be able to watch it because now like oh look there's there's a con
there's we're sitting with the discomfort within the conversation of the show we're ignoring the
larger harm and she's also saying like well what if the he donated some of his paychecks to support
transgender people several things with this a as a hypothetical the amount of money that Nick Frost
could give from his paycheck to be able to uh try to help trans people would not offset the amount
of money that he would help generate for JK Rowling who would give be giving more money to
harm trans people so there is in no way an offset analysis here you can and it's like one of those
weird things where it's like oh look well some people might get harmed here but we might benefit
some people here it's like no maybe don't benefit the harm either way but even if it like that's if
it was equal but it's not going to be equal and then on top of that this is a hypothetical Nick
Frost has not said a damn thing about donating some of his paycheck to support trans people and
see this author has done this both with Tom Felton and Nick Frost is sort of like what if and again
it's one of those like well what if you have that conversation it's like no we shouldn't have that
conversation it's a non-starter as a conversation but it's where you want to try and push the
conversation to every single time and but it's not even happening so it's like a hypothetical
to sort of change the conversation to there and then also it's like not a thing that even if we
did ultimately have that happen if actors did give their paycheck or even all of their paycheck
to trans people it would still not offset the harm generally being done both culturally and
financially through J.K. Rowling and the continued relevancy of her platform and ultimately this
writer's trying to saying like oh I have more respect for Nick Frost no I have less I have
less because it shows how spineless his position is that he is like I acknowledge that trans people
are being harmed by J.K. Rowling's views I'm aware of it and yet I'm still going to try and take this
paycheck anyways I'm going to get mine because I want the money I want the fame and I'll just
say like oh well at least we can have the conversation it's like you're being honest
at least about like I want the fame I want the money but it's a spineless position showing you
have no values when it comes to trans people you're not going to stick by those values
and I get it it's a rough time right now people need money I understand there is no perfectly
ethical consumption under capitalism but there are certainly more ethical consumptions under
capitalism than others and in doing so you are directly trying to liberal wash the harm here
and you can see it quite literally how that is effective in the response through this article
that this writer is giving who is very clearly buying into that exact line of like I just want
permission to engage in Harry Potter in these things and say that I'm standing by trans people
yet ultimately not willing to do the work or even not even willing to give up a Harry Potter show
like again I had a love a huge love for I am someone who lives in pop culture look at everything
that I do on my channel that is my identity in many many ways I'm a filmmaker I'm a director
I'm a youtuber talking about pop culture regularly at the end of the day like we need to be able to
be willing to give this stuff up and there are numerous other books and franchises that you can
engage with yet people aren't willing to do that and they aren't willing to do the work to actually
and this is the thing I keep reiterating to people and again this is not just applying to
Harry Potter but the thing that we need to keep reiterating is being an ally means losing
something standing to lose something whether it be money you're you know putting yourself in harm's
way you know being willing to like lose a show if you aren't even willing to lose a Harry Potter show
then what are like how can I expect you to stand by me oh quick addition here uh before I wrap up
he's very similar to Nick Frost right in the sense that he is like trying to be like I can
benefit from having this platform within the Harry Potter show but still stand by trans people
if you're going to stand by trans people if you're going to sign that letter and go up
against JK Rowling you shouldn't be part of the series you should not lend your weight and
credence to it because it's showing like yeah I understand the harm happening to trans people but
I still want the fame and I still want the paycheck and I still want the the platform
that this is going to give me why not instead go and support a trans made project and it's
actually even more egregious in Nick Frost's case because he is actually starring in a trans
written and led series so it's like again he's in community with trans people and yet he's still
doing this uh so it's very upsetting in both of their cases and I still say they should leave the
show and give more promotion to their trans folks that they are in community with so criticism both
them uh Isidou is is actually an interesting more complicated case too because he is a black man
being cast in a in the role of Snape so he's also going to be facing and has already been facing a
lot of racism coming at him um that happens to any uh person of color cast in a big franchise
especially a person of color who is cast in a role that has typically been played by a uh white
person so I have certainly criticism of them casting him as Snape uh the villain of the piece
casting a black man as that character in specific but even beyond that just the general optics of
it he's going to be attacked by the anti-woke brigade so certainly he is going to be facing
that bullshit and I don't expect the woman who literally wrote uh a character named Kingsley
Shacklebolt to necessarily be sensitive to the racism that he is going to be facing
big corporations like WB and Disney has certainly not done that and I don't see them doing that for
him here J.K. Rowling certainly doing that and now that he has signed this anti-trans or sorry
trans signed transportive letter I don't see J.K. Rowling doing any work if in fact possibly even
stoking some of the racism either indirectly or directly uh against him certainly J.K. Rowling
has stoked racism against stuff like um people like Iman Khalif as we saw at the Olympics and
still doing that over a ******* year later so certainly there is a lot of racism and J.K.
Rowling stuff that I think uh you see do I have a certain level of empathy for for the ---- that
he's going to face but it even makes it more egregious of like you're willing to go through
all ******* that and uh like still understand what's happening to trans people and yet you're
still going to end up wanting the the platform first which sucks it sucks and it speaks to
how much still people desire the platform um no matter how much doesn't cost them personally
mentally or it's going to cost other people because our society ultimately values fame
and fortune over anything else no matter what it costs for your community for yourself
for your own self-worth which sucks and so I have a level of empathy for the racism that he
is already facing is going to face even more I'm sure in the future but it does not negate
uh the criticism I have for him uh as a person who is staying in Harry Potter so two things can
be true at once I guess and again the turn that's going to happen here as I am sure we're going to
see it's the same thing that happened with the um Harry Potter video game which is trans people are
going to be made the villains here we're going to be made the villains for like oh look you're
attacking John Lithgow or attacking Nick Frost these people who are uh they're good people they
do care about trans people and why are you attacking them I'm not trying to attack them
I want them to do the right thing I want them to I I have a lot of respect I had a lot of respect
I should say for these people so I'm not trying to attack them I'm not trying to
cancel them quote unquote but I'm pointing out what they are doing but ultimately I can guarantee
you either in response to these comments or in a few months when the Harry Potter show does
end up premiering and people start watching it and people start having this conversation even
louder than it already is because this is just casting announcements this isn't the like thing
that most people are paying attention to um when this becomes more of a relevant cultural conversation
like the Harry Potter video game was we're going to see that same thing where trans people are
going to be made the villains we're going to be attacked we're going to be seen as the ones that
are causing the problem because we're asking people to be uncomfortable and to actually you
know not support these things they want to do anyways that they're trying to find permission
venues and have found and now are eliciting permission to do anyways um and now are going
to use that permission they have given themselves to be able to then attack trans people what they
have now said like oh it's okay if I do this so if I'm okay I'm a good person why are you telling me
that I'm not a good person you must be wrong they're going we're just going to be made the
villains that's why I ultimately and I'll end on this note it's why ultimately as I said with
a Harry Potter video game I don't necessarily believe in calls for boycotts you know people
kept talking about like me saying like I want to say boycott the Harry Potter video game I mean
ultimately in the day I'm asking people not to buy things but I don't call for like an active
call for a boycott because ultimately that just becomes a losing proposition right like
the progressive leaning space is much less uh unified when it comes to talking about these
things I mean you can look at something like the right wing when they boycotted Bud Light because
of anti-trans bigotry with Dylan Mulvaney like they were much more willing to all get behind
their bigotry at that point like the right wing has many infighting but they all kind of get
behind their ---- when it comes to the people that they ******* hate but here within left-wing spaces
it's kind of harder to create that consensus and so I sort of consent that I don't know I said it
that way consensus and so it's why I'm like we shouldn't be calling for an active boycott what
I'm trying to do here is trying to educate and try to point out how these things systemically
harm people and how you actually stand in solid area trans people so I'm using this more as a way
to educate what we should be doing how you out there should not try to fall into this trap and
how you stand by trans people and not overtly trying to attack people like Nick Frost or even
this writer for the Mary Sue even though I have a lot of problems with them and certainly have
my criticisms but the goal is more to be like my goal is not to cancel these people but to use
this opportunity to try to educate you out there of the larger conversation that we can be having
what you can do I think that's a much more useful proposition of our time not trying to take down
these you know main conglomerates and you know JK Rowling's like we should we should go after
JK Rowling specifically to be fair but more to be like how do we build solidarity how do we build
community here what's what's the right action going forward rather than focusing on anti-something
again you shouldn't be supporting Harry Potter you should be uh you know going after JK Rowling
calling out her arm tainting things like Harry Potter and the conversation around it and always
but those are just things that was natural like part of the for the course like we should be doing
those things but let's actually focus on even more important and the harder work of how do we build up
community and I think that's the conversation we need to be having here so ultimately hopefully
that was very helpful I again this wasn't to attack Nick Frost or anybody in the Harry Potter
franchise whatever I have certainly had my ******* issues and I don't I'm not happy with them but the
larger goal is to have that bigger conversation uh and using Harry Potter's name. Anyways that's my
thoughts I hope you're all taking care of yourselves and I hope you as always live long and prosper.
