Golder v UK (Interpretation of treaties)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jun 8, 2026
In this international law case, the court applied the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties to confirm that treaties should be interpreted in a way that has regard to both the subjective intention of the parties, and the objective meaning of the words of the treaty.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedSidney Golda, a prisoner, challenged a denial of legal access to sue for defamation after being falsely accused of attacking a guard. The European Court of Human Rights used this case to determine if the right to a fair hearing includes the right to initiate legal proceedings, ultimately ruling that access to courts is essential for the rule of law.
INTRO MUSIC
Sidney Golda was doing 15 years in jail for robbery with violence.
There was a prison riot and a guard thought Golda was one of the prisoners who attacked him.
That allegation wasn't proceeded with, but Golda was concerned that the report was on his record.
He wanted to start an action for defamation. Under British law, a prisoner could only speak
with a lawyer about general legal matters if they had special permission. Permission was denied,
and Golda challenged that denial through the European Human Rights Process.
Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights said,
or of any criminal charge against him,
The question was whether this right extended to commencing proceedings,
or whether it just ensured that people got a fair hearing if allegations were made against them.
When the European Court of Human Rights came to decide,
One said the court should ask what was intended by the countries who signed the treaty.
The other approach said that they should simply look at the words of the treaty
and read those objectively.
The court decided to be guided by what was then a brand new convention,
the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
Article 31 of the convention said,
The court said this meant they should look at both the intentions of the parties
and the meanings of the words.
They said,
They then found that the European Convention on Human Rights
was intended to advance the rule of law,
and that the rule of law was meaningless unless everyone,
including prisoners, could access the courts to bring legal claims.
Amusingly though, by the time they sorted this out,
Golda was already out on parole.
From this case we learn to interpret treaties through a combined approach,
looking at the plain meaning of the words and the intention of the parties.
you
