Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties | International Law

General Principles of Law
24 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 29, 2024
Welcome back everybody to Public International Law. In this video what we're going to do is spend some time talking about the
sources of international law,
continuing our discussion of the sources by looking at the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
The reason why this is a very important and really merits its own lesson, as we are doing here,
is because the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties is one of the main instruments that we use and we think about when we
look to regulate the law of treaties.
So treaties, being one of the major sources of public international law, are
regulated by the Vienna Convention and as a result of which it is pertinent that we spend some time examining this convention as a major
source of international law.
Itself being a treaty, the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties represents one of the most significant elements of international law.
A great number of many provisions of the Vienna Convention, in fact, actually amounts to
the forming of customary principles of international law to this very day.
So, of course, this is a very important treaty which regulates the law of treaties.
It is a treaty about treaties, fundamentally. Now, I'm going to cite a number of different articles of the Vienna Convention.
We've already cited what a definition of a treaty is as per the Vienna Convention itself,
which is found in Article 2, and so the result of this is that we are going to be just spending some time thinking about the
Vienna Convention, thinking about some of the things that relate to treaties, and we will be citing the Vienna Convention, in fact, at multiple stages.
Not only in our discussion on the law of treaties, which is what we're doing here,
but also in relation to other parts of international law as well.
When we talk about reservations in the next lesson, for example, or treaties and their relationship with third parties in the video afterwards,
these are all going to be very important elements of public international law that the Vienna Convention has a number of
different points of authority over.
Article 3 says the following. It says, quote,
the fact that the present convention does not apply to international agreement concluded between states and other subjects of international law, or
between other sub-subjects of
international law, or to international agreements
not in written form, shall not affect the legal force of such agreements, the
application to them of any of the rules set forth in the present convention to which they would be subject under international law
independently of the convention.
Thirdly, the application of the convention in relation to states as between themselves under international agreements to which other subjects of international law are
also parties,
all of which are very important elements. This provision essentially tells us and
provides quite a lot of importance and pertinence to the view that
international treaties are particularly
state-centric, okay, the nature of state centricity in relation to public international law.
Now, this is a view that will be challenged when we look at the concept of international legal personality in future lessons time,
because there are certain elements that
challenge this view of public international law being at least entirely state centric.
There is, of course, a lot of literature and a lot of
a lot of scholarly debate about the relationship in international law between
international institutions and also non-state parties to various elements of
international law.
But Article 3 does present a very state centric interpretation of at least the law of treaties,
okay, of international treaties.
Modern international law, of course, recognizes international institutions as being key actors in the subject as well.
Subsequently, for example, in 1986 we see another Vienna Convention on the law of treaties, this one being a lot less
famous, and it being one that codifies
far more explicitly the relationship between states and
international organizations.
So, this is one that is important because it includes the idea of other international institutions as being part of, or at least formerly,
part of, international law in terms of its relationship to treaties. Now,
we also get in this 1986 Vienna Convention
the specification of the power of international organizations when it comes to the conclusion of international treaties, the extent to which
international organizations are pertinent, relevant, important in the creation of international treaties.
This is known as the Vienna Convention on the law of treaties between states and international organizations, and Article 2a
IA, sorry, says the following.
They define a treaty as an international agreement governed by international law and concluded in written form
between one or more states and one or more international organizations or
between international organizations.
This takes away a little bit of this sort of state-centricity
view of public international law and
includes and adds into the fold the idea of international organizations being a very, very key player in
under the remit of public international law.
Like I've said previously, we have a number of lessons that we're going to do in the future
relating to the concept of international legal personality and statehood, and we'll talk about
international organizations as being recognized by international law as
fundamentally very key players that have legal personality within public international law itself.
And we will talk about some very early advisory opinions and very early
ICJ contentious jurisdiction cases that really illustrate this point.
One of the things that I want to finish on is this principle of Pactus and Survanda, which is a
maxim of international law that relates specifically to the obligations of states under
treaties and treaty obligations more specifically.
It is actually this principle, or this and a multitude of other principles, that really leads people like
Lasse Roppenheim to conclude that it is in fact the
the existence of customary international law that gives
authority to the existence of treaties, rather than it being anything the other way around.
It is one of, if not the most important rules for the law of treaties.
The rule is codified in Article 26 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties,
and it says fundamentally that, quote,
every treaty in force is binding upon the parties to it, and must be performed by them in good faith.
The principle itself refers to this binding authority being done in good faith.
It is a good faith principle. It is essentially still binding to those states who are not party to the Vienna Convention,
seeing as this particular element of the VCLT is simply citing
provisional customary international law. In fact, the principle of Pactus and Survanda is actually a principle that is
very well established in history prior to the Vienna Convention, and so as a result of which,
a result of the fact that it is a general practice that is done under the view of states as being an obligation,
it is therefore, as a result of that, customary international law as well.
And we'll get to the relationship between treaties and customary international law in future lessons time,
when we start to talk about the nature of international custom in more detail.
But this is a very fundamental principle of treaties.
It is that, fundamentally, if you have a treaty that is in force, and it is
acting upon the parties who have signed and ratified the treaties,
then those parties must perform the obligations in that treaty in good faith.
