Introduction to Treaties | International Law

General Principles of Law
24 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 29, 2024
Welcome back everybody to Public International Law. In this video what we're going to be doing
is spending a little bit of time talking about treaties, the first source of international law
that we are going to be covering. Now I mentioned at the end of the previous lesson or at least at
parts throughout the previous lesson that arguably historically it is international custom or
customary international law which presents more of a substantive and foundational source of
international law more so than even treaties themselves. We make reference of course to the
Pacabana case from the US Supreme Court and I also made reference to some of the writings of
people such as Lasse Roppenheit who made it very clear that they believe that the principles and
the foundations and the legitimacy of treaties are derived out of principles of international
custom. However I will just say that the reason why I'm doing treaties first is because I'm going
to be doing it in reference to the various different parts of the ICJ statute. The ICJ
statute article 38.1 lists treaties as the first source of international law. So we will do treaties,
custom, general principles and then the final few elements at the bottom that are considered to
be subsidiary principles. Like I said this video is going to take a little introduction to the
concept of the treaty. Now I should also make it clear that in the future we are going to do a
series of lessons in and of itself on the law of treaties and spend a lot of time getting into the
various different details the concept of treaty reservations, the concept of the Vienna
Convention on the Law of Treaties and so this is only going to be a series of lessons maybe two or
three lessons on the concept of treaties but within the broader context of a series of videos
on general public international law. We will go into the law of treaties in more detail in some
series in the future. So in the previous lesson we introduced the subject of there being various
different sources of public international law, we looked at some of the early historical
developments, we made notes to two particular elements, we talked firstly about the Pakabana
case at the Supreme Court, the case which concerned the question of whether or not fishing
vessels could be a legitimate prize in the event of an armed conflict, and then we also talked
about the Martens Clause which is a principle within international humanitarian law which
essentially gives us this idea that where the treaties are not complete, where the treaty is
not complete in this case it was the Hague Convention of 1899, where that convention is
not complete in areas and it fails to protect people in certain areas, then general principles
of public international law and public conscience and good conscience and all this kind of stuff
fills in the gaps fundamentally, recognising the limitations of the convention itself.
And then we talked about the ITJ Charter in more detail. This lesson like I said is going to speak
on the issue of the law of treaties. Now like I said again at the start of this lesson the law
treaties is something that we're going to go into and examine in far more detail in a separate
series of lessons and provide a far more in-depth analysis of the subject, but for now we're just
going to provide an authoritative overview of the subject. So the first thing that is probably
important for us to actually work out is what actually is a treaty? How do we define a treaty?
Now what's interesting is a lot of the law and a lot of the regulation and a lot of the
definitions and principles of the treaty are actually defined in its own treaty,
the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. So we're going to be referencing the Vienna
Convention, the VCLT, at multiple stages throughout this series, specifically throughout this set of
and in fact article 2.1a defines what a treaty is in the Vienna Convention. It says that
treaty means an international agreement concluded between states in
written form and governed by international law, whether embodied in a single instrument
or in two or more instruments, whatever its particular designation. That is what a definition
of a treaty is, that's what it is defined as in article 2.1a. Now fundamentally it's quite a broad
and open-ended definition. We have here that it is just an agreement that is concluded between states,
it has to be done in written form and then once it is done and completed and ratified it is governed
by international law and then it is embodied either in a single instrument or two or more
instruments, whatever its particular designation. That is the definition of a treaty. And you
can sort of understand a treaty as a type of contract if you will. If we think back to domestic
legal systems, if you go back to for example the law of England and Wales where I'm teaching
from, you can think of a contract as an agreement between two parties, an agreement to do a
particular thing, there's often consideration involved, that is what a contract is.
And a treaty operates in a quite similar way. One can examine a treaty as a contract between
multiple states and fundamentally they have some of the characteristics of contracts, so treaties,
so contracts share some of the characteristics which are similar to that of international treaties.
But we have to be a little bit careful when thinking about treaties and thinking that they
are just contracts that are signed between states or made between states because they provide the
basis for international lawmaking as well as multilateral lawmaking in far more substantive
ways than that of simply a contract would. It does more in terms of law than a contract does.
Multilateral treaties refer to the creation of treaties between two or more states.
Now we sort of delineate colloquially in international law between regional and
multilateral. Now fundamentally a multilateral treaty is just a treaty that is not bilateral
or trilateral, it is signed between two or more states, between more than two states,
okay, between more than two states, that says two or more, it's more than two because two states
would just be a bilateral treaty between state A and state B. Multilateral treaties are multiple
different states all come together and sign treaties. Now like I said they could be regional
in nature, so it is multiple different states, but those states are confined to a specific part
of the world. So for example the Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States
from 1933 is a convention, a treaty that is multilateral, it is signed between 19 different
states but it's 19 different Latin American states across Latin America. You can have truly
multilateral treaties for example such as the Geneva Conventions or you could even have the
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, UNCLOS. UNCLOS is a multilateral
treaty because it is signed and ratified by almost every state on earth, okay. The Vienna Convention
on the Law of Treaties is multilateral, it is signed by almost every state on earth or ratified
by. One of the notable exceptions is in both of those instances is that the United States is not
a party to either of those treaties, nor is the United States a party to for example the Rome
Statute, the statute establishing the International Criminal Court. All very very interesting things
that we will make reference to throughout. Let's talk a little bit more about some of the case law
which regulates or explains or illustrates some of the principles of the treaty itself and we can
focus here on a very famous case from 1952, the Iran, the Anglo-Iranian oil company case
between United Kingdom and Iran. Fundamentally the key issue for our purposes in this case
was whether or not an oil contract which was signed between the Iranian government and a
corporation, the corporation being the Anglo-Iranian oil company, would this constitute a treaty and
therefore as a result of that be a binding piece of public international law. So could a treaty exist
between a state, in this case the Iranian government on the one hand, and a private
corporation, the Anglo-Iranian oil company on the other hand? Well this is what the court says. The
International Court of Justice in their preliminary objection state, quote, the court cannot accept
the view that the contract signed between the Iranian government and the Anglo-Persian oil
company, the Anglo-Iranian oil company, has a double character. It is nothing more than a
concessionary contract between government and a foreign corporation. So the court of justice says
no because what it does in this case, why this case is useful, is that it provides more details
to the nature of treaties as international agreements. Fundamentally one of the things
that they objected to is the fact that we were asking the question could it constitute a treaty
and therefore be binding in public international law? Well according to the
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, a treaty is defined as an agreement between
states. So the question was, well if the Vienna Convention, which hasn't been ratified at this
point in history, if we're talking temporally, but could the Vienna Convention, if a state is,
sorry, if a treaty is signed between states, can this agreement signed between a state and a private
company be considered a treaty? The answer is no, it's not a state, okay. It is nothing more
than a concessionary contract between government and foreign corporation and this gives us an
indication of limiting what can and cannot be a treaty. A treaty is signed between states.
