Building A Complete Watch Collection With Tudor.

Talking Watches.
92 followers
May 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTeddy Baldasar and Danny Milton compete to curate the ultimate three-watch collection using only Tudor timepieces. Through a strategic selection process involving a coin toss and potential \"blocks,\" both participants build sets based on different philosophies of versatility and style. A blind judge ultimately decides the winner based on wearability and overall balance.
Anything I do is at risk.
This would be my most daring pick.
Wrong choice.
Hi everyone, Teddy Baldasar here in our boutique.
And today we're going to be doing something where we're going to build a collection.
And we're going to build three wash collection for one brand.
And that brand is Tudor.
I'm not going to be doing this solo though.
We're going to make this a competition because competition is fun.
And here we have Danny Milton.
Danny, good to see you, sir.
Good to see you, Teddy.
It's my first time in the new store.
Yeah, you're here for an event.
Yeah.
What do you think?
I love it.
It's significantly bigger.
And I'm glad my first time actually gets to have some fun in here.
Yeah, so we have an event with Tudor coming up this week.
Yes, we do.
It just felt fitting because we have a stocked display.
Fully, fully stocked.
That let's do a little competition.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I'm thinking three wash collection.
But we got to add some theater to this.
Sure.
Gonna add some theater.
So flip a coin.
And with that coin flip, we will determine who gets to either go first.
There's actually a choice you can make.
Okay.
The winner.
You could either decide to go first or you can block the selection of that other person
that is going and proceeding with that actual selection.
Okay, so if I win or you win the coin toss, I can either choose to go first.
Correct.
Or I can hold in my pocket, reserve the right to block one of your picks or vice versa.
That's right.
At any point.
If you do decide to block though, you also are creating a scenario where you cannot pick
that watch either.
Okay.
So you're removing it from the field of play.
Got it.
We have three wash collection and at the end, well, of course, ask the audience what they
think and who has better collection, but we're actually going to ask one of our colleagues.
They're not seeing what we put together in our three wash collections.
They're going to see these three watches put next to one another and they will then determine
which one has the better collection without affiliating who is what collection.
All right.
I'm going to be honest.
I put zero thought into this in the best way possible and I can't wait to build it.
All right.
Coin flip.
I'll let you do the honors in deciding.
Are you a hedge or a tails guy?
I'm a tails guy.
I am too, but here we go.
It's heads, Teddy.
Okay.
You know, I'm going to be a gentleman and I'm going to let you go first.
All right.
So that means that anything I do is at risk today.
It depends on how you want to frame it.
Okay.
It depends on how you want to frame it.
I thought, you know, gentleman move would be you go, you can go first.
All right.
Right.
All right.
So what are we thinking, Danny?
And also the other thought process here too is like, how do you build a three wash collection
with this brand?
I mean, there's a lot of sports watches here.
A lot of sports watches.
But I know we both like that too.
So.
All right.
So I'm going to start with an obvious pick just to take it off the board.
It's a watch that I've wanted, haven't really made the jump to get, but I'm going to go with
the Black Bay 54 standard black 37 millimeter diver on bracelet.
You probably knew this was going to be one of your picks going into this.
It's because, you know, there are some watches that you just know
they're in the running for future watches.
You said on bracelet, right?
On bracelet.
Okay.
And I think when we both saw the blue one at the show this year, I was thinking to myself,
you know, this is cool and all, but it is not in any way taken away from the affection I have
for this watch, which is kind of a watch that shouldn't exist, but it does.
And it works so well at 37 millimeters.
So I'm taking my sort of dive choice off the board, not to give any hint as to how I'm going
to build this, but just in the most sort of obvious version of what sort of a smaller Black
Bay diver would be.
You know, I have a roughly six and a quarter interest.
I think we kind of share the same wrist size.
This is what I want to take off the board first.
On paper, I remember when this came out, you would never suspect this watch, to your point.
Like, does it have a place?
Yes.
But then you got to actually try it on and you're like, all right, I get it.
And it actually does have a different lane from the 58.
I thought initially way too much overlap, but when I'm out in public, I see a lot of
tutors on people's wrists.
I think of any brand, when somebody said they follow the channel, like tutors were one of
the leading brands for when I'm like connecting with people and out in public.
And this is near the top of watches that are on people's wrists.
Like I, cause I get to see the bezel.
Like it makes a lot of, it makes sense.
I kind of envy it when I see it.
It's got a thinner profile.
It just kind of works.
It's just sort of like a great everyday watch.
It's a great pick, but I think we could do even better.
Let's see.
I probably should pick the watch that I think is going to be my next watch.
Like this is legitimately going to probably be the next watch that I purchase.
So I probably should go here.
I'm going to go Black Bay, 58, burgundy, 5-link.
5-link.
It's a great choice.
I've always liked the burgundy like design.
58, it works really well with the 5-link too.
Cause I've been a long, a fan of the 58.
The now discontinued blue 58.
Yeah, I know.
I know.
Very, very sad day.
Pour one out.
Exactly.
But this, it brings it all together.
5-link design, update with the hands, the case.
It's a little more refined.
And then it goes back to that 1990s prototype as well in the process.
Yeah, you and I were lucky enough to see that at the Tudor HQ a couple of years back.
And you know what I like about this watch?
A, I've heard you talking about it as a potential next watch purchase.
So a legitimate pick in the game.
But also it's the first watch that has been the next evolution of the Black Bay 58.
Not just in new bracelet, but in, like you said, new hands, new bezel design,
slightly slimmer format, a smaller crown.
Just overall a refinement of one of the seminal watches in the Black Bay collection
in a killer colorway.
I mentioned with Cole too, because 2018 we saw the Black Bay 58 collection come out.
And now we're seeing this second iteration on the design where there's like these two
existing ideas where you had the traditional 3-link.
And then you have now like this 5-link with some of the case updates.
Kind of marks the second generation now.
There's like two generations of 58.
Now with this going away, that's at least my interpretation of it.
So that's my pick.
Black Bay, Black Bay.
Which there's going to probably be more Black Bay as we continue.
Without question.
But after you, sir, now you get to go again.
We said the word Black Bay a lot.
And I'm going to move away from Black Bay for a second.
Okay.
For my second pick, you know.
Going for a Tudor Royal?
I'm tempted.
I'm tempted by Royal, but not with my second pick.
Okay.
Not my second pick.
My second pick I want to go 36 millimeter Ranger.
Black?
Black.
Okay.
Tell me more.
So here's, you know, a bit who I am as a collector.
As much as I am tempted by the shiny new thing.
And in the case of the Ranger, it would be sort of the Dune colorway.
I am a sucker for a classic.
And as much as I enjoyed the larger Ranger format, this was sort of the other new thing.
When they introduced the black dial alongside the Dune in 36 millimeter,
it kind of touched my explorer loving heart in Tudor form.
You're going small cases, 37 and 36.
I love a small case.
Not because it's small, because it just fits my wrist for everyday use.
I just really enjoy a watch that feels like I'm wearing it.
And it's not wearing me for the most part.
I mean, I'm saying that while I'm wearing a 42 millimeter watch on my wrist.
But you know, as I'm a watch guy.
You're upholding your watch media credentials here.
These are very watch media credential picks.
But they're true.
They're actually true.
They're true.
For a long time, I wore a Rolex Explorer.
Eventually, I gave it to my wife when she graduated from her master's program.
Nice.
But I still have an affinity for this sort of explorer style watch.
And this one, unlike what the BlackBerry 54 did, where it introduced a satin dial,
you still have this like matte finish, these painted numerals.
It's like very classic tool watch.
And I love how instead of having sort of a faux patina,
it has kind of this like Luma Nova coloration to it.
This green that kind of just protrudes from there that's just always ever present.
And it kind of is like this striking a balance between retro and modern in a very cool way.
And I've been talking dollars.
I mean, we did see the Royal II now start to be at that entry point for the MT calibers,
now being introduced this past year.
But this still sits like right at a nice sweet spot.
And you know, we said this was not a price competition.
But I'm still somebody who, even if you gave me an unlimited budget,
I'm going to pick something that I'm legitimately going to wear.
And that's where I've been so far.
Okay.
Oh, this is tough.
This is tough.
I was going back and forth between like what I was thinking.
I was going to go here first.
But then I'm like, I should be authentic to self
and recognize that that was going to be likely my next watch purchase.
I'm going to go Pelagos.
Oh, I like this.
I'm going 39 millimeter Pelagos.
I like this.
I'm sorry for all of those individuals out there that like the larger sizes.
I am not selecting this based off of whether or not 39 is better.
I'm selecting it based off of what works for me.
And this is what works for me.
The 42 millimeter Pelagos is fantastic.
You can go for the FXDs.
I thought about it.
But being true to self, I'm going for the Pelagos 39.
I always liked the Pelagos before the back in like 2016, 17 era.
I actually liked the Pelagos more than the Black Bay.
Yeah.
Because once you started that transition into the new manufacturer calibers for the Black Bay,
I actually liked the way that those original Pelagos wore
just because of the titanium construction.
It had the on-the-fly adjustment in a time when Black Bay didn't have that.
I also just, I always position the Pelagos as the watch that
if you had like the Marine Nationale identity of those watches,
modern day, what would they create?
It would be that.
And it was funny too because they came out with that FXD
and then there's all that Marine Nationale affiliation.
Those original dials were some of the coolest evolutions of a classic dive watch style.
I know that the 39 doesn't continue that,
but it still has these fully loomed like solid blocks on the dial.
But no, the Pelagos is truly the modern version of everything you're talking about.
And just the fact that the Marine Nationale connection actually came to be
is just like the perfect, you know, endpoint for that idea.
And I'm playing around with some different materials.
So I have titanium, I have ceramic.
As you mentioned, you're not getting maybe all the touches of the 42.
Like you don't have the re-hot.
You also have more of like the sunburst pattern on the dial.
But I'm going to dive heavy.
I'm going to dive heavy.
So now we can decide on what your last picks are.
So I still have my block, by the way.
I could just be a mean person and just decide to use it.
And the thing about the block is if I pick something that you wouldn't want anyway,
the block is totally valid.
So this is where you can strategically use the block against the person that has the block.
I could also fake you out and go for a watch just trying to bait you in.
But then I can walk you into that decision
and then it might not be what you ultimately want.
I like this block.
I like the block.
I'm legitimately scared of two things.
One is this is a competition.
It's a competition where I can feel good about this.
Our judge sitting in the back with noise canceling headphones on.
She's in the back.
She cannot hear anything.
There's that component.
And then there's what, you know, I remember the comment section in some of these videos,
you know, Teddy wipe the floor with you on this one, Danny, whatever.
I'm also conscious of that, but I'm not going to let it deter me.
Because we did a video, it was at the previous store.
It was a $10,000 collection.
Yeah, I think it was.
I think it was five or ten.
Yeah, something like yes, maybe right in the middle.
OK, and I still think I won.
But, you know, you have to let the people decide.
We have the jury in the comments and we also have the judge in the back.
So we'll figure it out.
All right.
Here's what I'm going to do.
I was going to go for a royal, but I'm not.
OK, I'm going Black Bay Pro Black Dial.
I'm going to complete block.
All right, folks, see where we've ended up here.
And I want to I want to be honest for everybody at home.
I did not bait Teddy into that.
That was my legitimate choice.
OK, OK, OK.
So moving on, moving on.
So you want a royal now?
So the royal I was going to go with,
you and I actually got to see these up close together at our Tudor meeting.
I'm going to go where you don't think I'm going.
I'm going 36 again just to finish my collection.
Oh, OK.
And I'm going two medals.
I'm going Steel and Gold with the Champagne Dial.
Oh.
For me, this is sort of Tudor's riff on a classic format,
which is whether you want to call it the classic Datejust look
or the old sort of Oysterquartz look.
It's that integrated bracelet format that I think
for my sort of tool watch heavy selection here,
it's a great third watch to have.
And it's one that in the face of all the other colors that were released,
you saw that there's the blue, there's the green,
there's the larger size, which is a Day-Date.
Here, you're just getting the classic date format.
Now, I'm going to be honest.
There's one thing I would change on this watch
that actually isn't present in this exact model in this size.
I prefer stick markers here than the Roman numerals.
This one is not going to win me this competition.
I know that.
However, I'm going to be true to self.
And I think this is just a really interesting three watches to have.
If I was to build a collection here,
I've got sort of an everyday field style watch.
I've got a classically, if not vintage size dive style watch.
And I've got something a little bit dressier.
And if we're being honest, you know,
as much as the watch media would not agree with me, by the way, on this one.
Yeah, you're now separated from that general stereotype.
But in sort of like the everyday experience of wearing watches,
like the two-tone is where people are like,
oh, that's a nice watch.
But that's not why I'm doing it.
I happen to really enjoy that format.
I do have, in my own collection,
a two-tone Datejust with a similar champagne dial.
And I'm just really into that format.
Okay, all right.
So I used my black.
I would have gone for that Black Fate Pro.
That would have been my black dial sport watch triumvirate.
I can't pocket the block.
I need to use the block.
Lost my GMT.
Royal did inspire me to maybe be a little daring.
Yeah.
I have it narrowed down to three watches.
Should I explain what those three watches are?
Because there's no risk.
I can explain this to you.
I can guess one of them, I think.
Okay, guess.
I'm going to guess one of them is the Monarch.
One of them is the Monarch.
One of them is the Black Bay 58 GMT.
It's not that one, but it's a GMT.
Okay.
Black Bay Pro with the opaline dial.
This would be my most daring pick, I would say.
But to complement the collection, it might be the most complete.
But I want people to think at home.
I want you to go on this journey with me.
These are my thought process.
I was thinking maybe GMT.
I don't have a white dial yet.
It would actually be really a nice complement.
It's very sport heavy.
Yes.
It's very sport heavy.
And I don't know.
And then also, you could say this is dressy, but a red burgundy dial,
I don't know if that would actually get me everywhere.
So I have to recognize that.
This is my other pick.
I was thinking 1926, the moon phase.
That is a very underrated watch.
It is.
I've actually, this is my first time seeing it up close.
It'd be a little bit out of place in the three watches,
but it'd be a very, very interesting pick.
No matter what I do now, someone's going to say I made the wrong choice.
Totally.
Because I exposed myself here.
You've allowed people into the thought process.
Which is never good on the internet.
Never.
Never good.
Here we go.
I'm going.
I knew it.
I'm going back.
It makes the most sense though.
Also, just like from looking at three watches next to each other,
very pleasing to the eye.
White, red, and black.
The only point I could probably be docked is that
someone might look at this and think I'm all accomplishing the same thing with these watches,
but I don't know if I would agree with that.
These are all the same size.
That's true too?
Yeah.
Same size.
But okay.
This is my thought process.
Five link.
Burgundy.
A design and a look that is part of the Black Bay DNA.
I have my titanium.
That also, I probably don't give enough credit for how versatile this watch is.
I know the Pelagos is always seen as the tool launch,
but you could wear that in a variety of environments.
And then I have my GMT at a 39 millimeter size.
I know some people would probably go for 58,
but I just felt like I was starting to go a little too,
like that felt like it'd have some overlap with the burgundy if I went 58 GMT.
So I wanted to complement with something with a different dial,
different design approach.
So those are my three.
I like them.
You know what's interesting about both of ours?
We each, in a way, each took three different bracelets.
Because if you think about it,
you've got the rivet style three link,
you've got the Pelagos style three link,
and you've got the five link.
This is rivetless on the Ranger.
Riveted on the 54.
And then you've got the integrated style bracelet on the Tudor Royal.
Okay.
So just to unpack, you have Royal 36.
54.
Ranger at 36 black dial.
I have Pelagos 39.
Burgundy five link.
Black Bay 58.
And the Black Bay Pro with an opaline dial.
Not a white dial, an opaline dial.
As I have learned when speaking with Cole,
calling that a white is not a good move.
It is opaline.
Okay.
So with this, Danny,
I think we should put all these to the side.
Okay.
And we're going to introduce our judge.
And they are going to make a decision on which one of these is the better collection.
I know our judge and I'm nervous.
Okay.
She doesn't know.
No, no, she doesn't know, but I'm nervous.
Unless there was some collusion.
Unless you guys had a little exchange in the back.
You had mentioned there might be collusion earlier.
I don't trust these people.
Zero collusion.
There's been zero collusion.
I think they're going to team up on this.
No collusion.
Okay.
I mean, we would, but we didn't.
Okay.
So we have to introduce Nicole.
Nicole has been a member of the team for what?
Three, four years now?
Three and a half years.
Well, now you have the distinct honor of being able to decide what collection is better.
So we're not going to tell you.
Who's is whose.
You can't ask any questions.
You can just experience the watches.
And at the end, you will decide who has the better collection.
And this is just one opinion, but I think it helps in getting some balance.
Okay.
I'm going to.
Please analyze.
Turn this one first.
And you're not allowed to guess whose collection belongs to who
until after you make your decision.
So with this one, I like that there's a little variety here,
even with just like the bracelet type.
So we have a five link and then we have three links.
So there's a little bit of diversity.
This is a solid choice.
So 10 out of 10 on that one.
I feel like this one gives a little bit more like depth to what's going on here,
because I feel like these are a little bit more classic.
So this one gives a little bit of some diversity here.
And then this one's a lighter watch, obviously.
So I think it wears a little bit more casually.
So I think this one's like pretty well-rounded.
Okay.
The other collection.
Okay.
I love this watch.
I prefer the June dial way, but I love this watch.
I think this is just something that's so different
and it's not something that you see a lot of people on wearing.
I feel like this with the gold tone on the dial
gives you a little bit more of like a pop
and it's not like the classic watch that you see.
So it gives classic, but then it's got a little bit of difference to it,
which makes it stand out a little bit more.
This is a hard sell for me.
This is just like a little too much flash for me, I think.
But I think if these are a little bit more understated,
this gives you the special dressier,
a little bit different than what else you have in the collection.
So now the decision.
You've now taken a look at the watches.
If you had to pick one, make your selection and why?
Honestly, it's kind of tough
because I feel like this one is a little bit more well-rounded,
but this one's got the Ranger in it.
But I feel like I would reach for the watches in this collection
more frequently than I would reach for all three of these, right?
The Ranger would probably be like a daily wear,
but I don't know that I would ever pick this one up.
Interesting.
So I feel like...
So what's your choice?
Are you getting over there?
I don't know.
Yeah, I think I have to go with this one.
Even though the Ranger's in this one,
I feel like I would go with this one
because I feel like I would get more wear out of all of the watches
rather than getting wear out of one or two watches
and then having something sit in a watch box.
So now that you've chosen that one,
whose collection do you think that was?
Your winning collection.
I think this is Teddy's collection
and I think this is Dani's collection.
Why?
Not giving anything away.
Just want to know why you think that.
I don't know that I would ever see Teddy wearing this watch.
Yeah, two-tone is more Dani.
Look, it just came up literally in the background.
That's how she was talking.
This does not give Teddy at all,
but I definitely think...
Your check will be in the mail, Nicole.
Thank you very much for talking to me.
Thank you so much.
I think she made a faster choice, personally.
I know that was the right choice.
But it was great.
It was good work.
It was great.
You know, at the end of the day,
I had her favorite watch of all the watches,
even if my collection lost.
I think that's something that should be said to that.
Sounds like a participation trophy.
Yeah, but you know what?
I have a lot of those.
Thank you for doing this.
That was a lot of fun.
But that's just one opinion.
There might be a different opinion in the comments.
So if you guys think that maybe Dani fared better
than what maybe...
I think that the two-tone Royal
might be the nail in the coffin,
but I stand by it.
But you know what?
At the same time we're asking for all these opinions,
it don't matter.
No.
If you like your collection,
that's all that matters.
And it goes to show
that you can pick out a pretty good variety.
People talk about a lot of Black Bay,
a lot of Black Bay,
but there's more than that with Tudor, if you will.
Guys, thank you so much for watching.
Be well and see you again soon.
Thanks, guys.
