The Dive Watch That Changed The Trajectory of Tudor Forever

Talking Watches.
92 followers
Feb 24, 2026
Hi everyone, Teddy Baldessar with TeddyBaldessar.com.
And in this video, this is a big one,
not just for the watch itself,
but for a moment in this channel's history
and a moment in my career in doing this,
this is the first review as an authorized dealer of Tudor.
And why not start with the original Tudor Black Bay 58?
So if you're new to this channel,
this is where we cover watches available for purchase
on our website, TeddyBaldessar.com as an authorized dealer.
In this video, we go through all the details
and everything you need to know about the Tudor Black Bay 58,
the original version, final considerations at the end,
and also throughout the video,
you're looking to buy this watch.
Link will be in the description down below.
Without further ado, let's jump into the video,
take a closer look at this watch.
So at the time of starting our main YouTube channel
in 2017, discussing watches,
Tudor was already well on its way with hit releases
like the Black Bay and Pelagos,
with MT manufacturer Calibers
furthering the excitement around the brand.
However, if I had to identify the start of that second wave
for Tudor in the 21st century, it would be the year 2018.
At Baselworld that year,
Tudor unveiled two genre defining watches
that helped form several trends in the industry
to follow in the coming decade.
First was the rapid growth of mechanical GMTs
in that segment overall,
especially with those with an isolated local hour function
with the unveiling of the MT5652
residing inside the Black Bay GMT.
During a time when there was very little GMT Calibers
on the market from a mechanical point of view
outside of Salida and Etta, for example.
The second of the two strokes of brilliance
came by way of the mid-sized dive watch
known as the Black Bay 58.
Now, if you spent any time on YouTube,
you know how important this watch was for the community,
and it still is.
It by accident ushered in a whole move back
to mid 20th century sizing for dive watches
and developed a best-selling platform
that Tudor has bolstered substantially in recent years
with a variety of options in different dials,
case materials, and even complications with the 58 GMT.
A lot can happen in a few short years,
but likely none of it would have been possible
without the original Black Bay 58 in its retro-leaning form.
It's a modern re-imagining
of the Tudor Submariner reference 7924 from 1958
with its red bezel triangle, black and gilt no-date dial,
and big unguarded crown.
And while I've owned the blue version
since it was launched in 2020,
today we're taking a look at that original Black Bay 58
that started it all.
Of all the positive attributes of the Black Bay 58,
you could argue that the stainless steel case's dimensions
has had the most impact on its popularity with collectors.
As mentioned, it's not too far of a stretch
to suggest that its dimension set
helped push along the return of smaller cases in general.
Let's not forget that in years prior,
the prevailing wisdom was bigger is better
no matter your wrist size.
The 39-millimeter diameter
and the lug-to-lug of 47.2 millimeters
were traits many could appreciate.
It was the thickness, though,
that has become an unappreciated point.
Remember, the 41-millimeter equivalents
of the time that this piece was released
were towering at near 15 millimeters in height,
whereas the new Tudor Black Bay 58
registered just 11.7 millimeters.
Case diameter and lug-to-lug preferences
can vary by owners, but thickness, on the other hand,
I think it's a dimension that tends to be universally seen
as thinner is better
as long as there are not significant compromises
in the process.
Finishing of the Black Bay 58
has changed over the years subtly
with the original form following the tool wash correct motto
with fine brushing on the front-facing surfaces
offset by polishing on the sides and bevels
running the length of the case.
The screw-down crown is sizable, around 6.7 millimeters
with plenty of rib texture offering solid grip.
It's signed with the iconic Tudor rose
and the omission of crown guards
reinforces the vintage vibe.
A solid screwed-in case back works with the crown
to offer 200 meters of water resistance.
Now, adding to the retro feel
is the matte anodized aluminum bezel insert
complete with the historic red triangle
surrounding the applied loom pip.
As someone whose first foray into discovery with Tudor
was lusting after 1960s and 70s Submariners
with faded bezels,
I have always just loved this use of aluminum
despite it being less of a modern material than ceramic.
It offers a lot of charm and it is cool to know
that maybe with enough wear,
one day Black Bay will fade
as well as those retro Submariners.
The unidirectional 60-click bezel itself
makes use of a coin edge,
perhaps not the grabbiest in terms of traction
compared to recent iterations of other Black Bays
like the Burgundy 58,
but there's no disputing that Tudor
got the action down to a science.
There are a few dive watches
that offer such a satisfying click regardless of price.
Capping off the package is the dome sapphire crystal
evoking the mid-century appearance of acrylic
while offering exceptional scratch resistance.
As for strap choices,
this Black Bay 58 is available
on a three-link bracelet with faux rivets,
a leather strap or a black fabric strap
with a single gold stripe.
The brown leather offers a vintage finish
with matching stitching and a fold-over steel buckle
while the fabric utilizes a long steel pin buckle
and steel keepers with the jacquard fabric
woven on 19th century looms
by the French family firm, Julian Farr.
The bracelet gets a proper tool wash finish
with vertical brushing on the three links
reinforcing the vintage persona of the Black Bay 58.
The middle clasp is also vertically brushed
and signed with the Tudor shield
secured by a fold-over lock.
Now this bracelet does not feature
the T-fit adjustment system
so fine adjustment does come by way
of three standard micro-adjustment holes
that require a spring bar tool.
Some collectors have issues with this
as well as the inclusion of the faux rivets
but the five-link bracelet with the T-fit
found on the newer burgundy model
is not available with the older Black Bay out of the box
and that also goes for the blue Black Bay 58 versions.
The black dial of the original Black Bay 58
sticks to the old school script
with a muted matte texture that conjures up visions
of the classic tool watches of days past.
There's just something about the pairing
of black and gold that screams vintage
and the Black Bay 58 has it in spades.
The black dial surface really allows
the warm gold detailing to pop
much more than it would on a glossier finish.
As far as the layout of the dial goes
there's a gilt minute track at the outer edge
with gilt colored applied hour indices
rectangular at the three, six, and nine
and circular at the points between.
A bold triangle marks 12 o'clock
completing the vintage sub look
which remains uninterrupted by a date window.
The golden tones of the handset
also feature classically good looks
with a pencil minute hand
and Tudor's trademark snowflake hour and seconds hand
offering superb legibility.
Superluminova fills the hands and indices
and Tudor's application offers a strong green glow.
The gilt colored dial text
includes the Tudor shield wordmark
and the Geneva below 12
with the text above six being a bit busier
with 200 meters, 660 foot depth rating,
you have chronometer
and then officially certified filling the space.
But taken as a whole
the dial offers a balanced and symmetrical presentation
with a warm vintage look
that's sure to be appreciated by lovers of the classics.
Now throughout its history
Tudor relied on outside movement providers such as ETA
but that's all changed.
The brand now claims majority ownership of Kinesi
which it uses for its movement manufacturing
for the bulk of its calibers.
Kinesi was set up as a separate entity
from the Hans Wilsdorf Foundation
that owns Tudor and Rolex
allowing for it to produce movements for other companies.
That said the Kinesi production facility
is connected to Tudor's LeLac headquarters
with the movement maker getting its own dedicated wing.
The Blackway 58 utilizes the manufacturer caliber MT5402
a COSC certified chronometer
and having the manufacturer close at hand
pays dividends in terms of consistency and quality control.
It features hacking and hand winding,
hacking stopping the seconds
when you pull the crown to the farthest position, 27 joules
and a beat rate of 28,800 vibrations per hour or four Hertz.
The MT5402 features a variable inertia balance.
You have a silicone balance spring
which improves resistance to magnetism.
And this is a true three-hand caliber too
with no date complication or ghost position on the crown.
The movement offers a healthy 70 hours of power reserve
and accuracy actually exceeds COSC specs
with the rate being minus two to plus four seconds per day
by Tudor where COSC only calls for minus four
to plus six seconds a day.
Decoration is industrial albeit nicely done
given its approach with radio brushing
and a hint of machine engraving
but given the solid case back
only your watchmaker will be able to see it.
Like the Tudor Black Bay itself,
the MT5402 sticks to the tool watch playbook
being a reliable well-made caliber
that gets the job done without a fuss.
All right, so now to unpack looking a bit further
at this Tudor Black Bay 58.
Now, before we talk about some of the cons and the pros
I just want to acknowledge
that this is a really big moment for me personally
to be able to cover a watch as a Tudor retailer.
I absolutely love this brand
and I love this watch just in general.
So I just can't contain my excitement there.
I just wanted to share that
before we dive into the final thoughts here.
Now, for some of the cons and considerations on that front
a point that I would bring up is
this is going to lean more vintage heritage
than a lot of the other Tudor Black Bay 58s.
Now, this whole theme of the Tudor Black Bay 58
is all about looking to the past
but if you look at some of the other models
that now make up this collection
there is a touch of modernity
in what is being presented with some of the case materials
and other aspects of their presentation.
This one is right down the center
of being more of that vintage inspired design
and looking to the brand's archive and past.
You have the vintage looking riveted bracelets
you have the gilt markings.
So for some people out there
this might not be what they're looking for
for a modern looking dive watch.
It's going to feel like it was plucked
directly from the past.
So you have to determine where you're at
in that conversation.
In addition, this one doesn't come
with all the bells and whistles of newer 58s.
You're not going to have it out of the box
available on the five link.
You don't have the T fit adjustment in that class.
Also, this is not going to be a master chronometer.
Now, whether or not those are worth it for you
are those deal breakers?
I would say they're not.
If you like the look of this watch
as well as the navy blue version
I have a whole video on the main channel
where I talk about my five years of ownership
with the blue Black Bay 58
and how I don't think it is a deal breaker
that it doesn't have these features
but it's important to acknowledge
that this is not going to be the most buttoned up
of all the 58s and getting those bells and whistles.
Now we shift to the pros.
And I think where we go here first
is just from a sizing standpoint.
If you long for those mid 20th century dimensions
for a dive watch where Rolex and Tudor
helped establish this idea
and a 38 to a 40 millimeter case was the norm.
This is where this starts to really sing.
This watch is perfectly sized in my opinion
for a medium size wrist and below.
The 54 also can work exceptionally
but I think the 58 is going to most likely overlap
with more wrist out there.
The watch looks fantastic.
It feels as if it was pulled directly from the era
that it was aiming to represent.
Bezel action, fantastic.
The movement is no nonsense going to be accurate
with that range being even tighter than COSC.
And then the final two points that I would bring up
in favor of the Tudor Black Bay 58.
One is that this was the piece that you could talk
about the other Black Bay 58s and what they brought forth.
And there's now newer ones with new design style
new elements of the cases.
They have the master chronometer.
All of that's well and good
but it started with this watch
and it was so important in setting a new standard
for what a dive watch would be at this luxury segment
from a sizing preference standpoint
from a also representing the idea
of what a heritage dive watch should look like
and feel like in the hand and on the wrist.
And Tudor honestly owns the $5,000 price range.
If you're somebody that is looking to spend $5,000
on a luxury watch, which it feels like a good chunk
of change to put aside as a budget.
I know so many people that come to the table
looking to buy a watch for $5,000
and they wanna get the best bang for buck for their money.
If that is you, oftentimes you're looking at a Tudor.
If you're looking for a dive watch
oftentimes you're looking at a Tudor Black Bay.
And many times in that segment
you're looking at a Tudor Black Bay 58.
So in short, if you're looking to spend $5,000 on a watch
Tudor Black Bay is likely a place you're going to look
and a Tudor Black Bay 58 is a likely place
that you might add.
All right, guys, thank you again so much for watching.
If you did enjoy this one,
please give the video a thumbs up,
subscribe to the channel as that does help us out
in the future as well.
And we'll ensure that some of our new videos
will be able to reach you in your subscription inbox
every single week.
Also, if you are in the market for the watch
it is available on teddybaldister.com.
Every purchase from teddybaldister.com
comes with quick and fast fulfillment,
dedicated customer support and a full factory warranty
for all the products that we offer.
In addition to how we're able to operate as a business
and keep doing what we're doing,
releasing content every single day on our website,
on YouTube, Instagram,
all of our different social channels
is through selling watches.
So if you are in the market for a watch,
we'd absolutely love to have your business.
Allows us to keep doing what we're doing here
and we love what we do.
Guys, thank you again so much for watching.
Be well, and I'll see you all very soon.
