#History#food We’re told that American food is a "melting pot," a lucky accident of different cultures coming together. The story goes that corporate brands and famous founding fathers were the masterminds behind our most iconic flavors. But that is a sanitized myth. The real recipes weren't discovered; they were stolen.
For Black America, the kitchen wasn't just a place of service; it was a laboratory of agency. While mainstream history tried to erase the architects, Black chefs were actively outsmarting the system to build the very foundation of American taste. From the man who actually invented Buffalo Wings to the culinary genius who brought fine dining to America, these are the forgotten masterminds of the kitchen.
This video challenges the myth of the natural evolution of American cuisine, arguing that it was fundamentally built upon the stolen labor and genius of Black chefs. From the French-influenced fine dining of James Hemmings to the cultural resilience embedded in soul food and the contested origins of buffalo wings, it highlights how African American innovation shaped the national palate.
We're told that American food is a melting pot, a lucky accident of different cultures coming
together. History makes it seem that the American culinary industry just naturally evolved into the
billion-dollar empire that we see today. They tell us that the founding fathers and corporate brands
were the masterminds behind some of our favorite flavors and recipes, but that is a whitewashed
myth. The real recipes weren't discovered, they were stolen from black chefs. For black America,
the kitchen isn't just a place of service, it is a laboratory of history and experimentation.
While the mainstream tried to erase the black architects, chefs like James Hemmings and John
Young were outsmarting a system to build the foundation of American foods. So join us today
for a compilation of my videos about the chefs that created American cuisine.
Thomas Jefferson was a founding father in the United States, but he was also a plantation
owner and over his lifetime owned over 600 enslaved individuals. At his peak,
he owned 140 enslaved individuals at his Monticello estate, one of these being the
Hemmings family. The intricate relationship between the Hemmings lineage and Thomas Jefferson
is predominantly traced back to Jefferson's union with Martha Wayland. This marriage brought the
Hemmings family into Jefferson's life, primarily as part of the estate that he inherited from
Martha's father, John Wayland. The connection between Martha and the Hemmings extends beyond
mere ownership. They share a common parental lineage through Elizabeth Hemmings, who was
an enslaved woman who was enslaved by Wayland and bore several of his children. This shared
ancestry ties Martha and Hemmings together through bloodlines and bondage. Within this complex
relationship, James Hemmings and Sally Hemmings stand out as central figures embodying the deeply
intertwined destinies between the Hemmings family and Thomas Jefferson. James Hemmings was born in
1765. He was one of the children of John Wayland. This familial link thus made him Jefferson's
brother-in-law when Martha was married to Jefferson. Despite the constraints of his
enslaved status, Hemmings was able to carve out a niche for himself within the hierarchical
structure of the Monticello estate, particularly through his refinement and expertise of his
culinary talent. His sister, Sally Hemmings, is the more widely recognized due to her complex
relationship with Thomas Jefferson. After Martha Jefferson's demise, there was a lot of conjecture
concerning the intimate relationship between Sally Hemmings and Thomas Jefferson. These
allegations suggested that Jefferson fathered several of Hemmings' children, and the emergence
of DNA evidence in 1998 led credence to the assertion that Jefferson likely fathered at least
one, if not all, of Sally Hemmings' children. But that's a story for another day. James Hemmings,
though, from his youth, exhibited a proficiency for illiteracy, which was rare given the prevalence
of anti-literacy statutes that prohibited the education of enslaved individuals. Thomas Jefferson
recognized Hemmings' potential and chose to cultivate it, driven not by benevolence but by a desire
to increase the value of his enslaved property. This investment exhibited his extraordinary culinary
talent and remarkable use of his acquired skills, despite the constraints of his bondage.
Jefferson recognizing his talent, when James was 19, he embarked on a significant journey
from Boston to Paris with Thomas Jefferson and his sister Sally. Following Jefferson's appointment
as America's Trade Minister in 1784, Jefferson facilitated his apprenticeship under esteemed
chefs at the Chateau de la Chantilly, a culinary establishment that was unparalleled in its
reputation during the 18th century. This apprenticeship was a privilege seldom afforded
to even the local French population, providing Hemmings with a comprehensive education in the
of French cuisines, from pastry-making to the art of sauce preparation and the nuances of kitchen
management. While in Paris, James was appointed as the chef of cuisine at Jefferson's private home,
the Hotel d'Angeac, where he supervised a kitchen team, including white servants.
This contrasted greatly with his life in America. Despite earning half of what the previous chef
made, James managed to impress everyone with his skillful blending of French and American
techniques, resulting in unique cuisine. He also used a part of his wages to hire a tutor and learn
French. James and Sally would soon discover that French law allowed slaves to seek freedom upon
stepping on French soil. Still, they didn't take advantage of this law, possibly because
they wanted to avoid being separated from their family back in the United States.
In 1789, the Hemmings siblings and Thomas Jefferson traveled from France back to America,
specifically to Jefferson's Monticello estate. While in America, Hemmings worked as Jefferson's
personal chef and received wages for his work. As the national government moved around in what
would become the United States of America, so did Jefferson and Hemmings. They lived in New York
with Hemmings running the kitchen there and Philadelphia in 1791.
Hemmings put his culinary skills to use. Using the knowledge gained in France,
Hemmings brought French culinary techniques to create uniquely American food.
It was during this time while residing in Philadelphia, a state where slavery was
abolished, that James initiated negotiations with Thomas Jefferson for his emancipation.
Recognizing his culinary prowess, Jefferson consented to his monument with a condition.
He had to pass on his cooking expertise to another enslaved individual.
Hemmings handpicked his younger brother, Peter, for this role. This choice fulfilled two desires.
First, he would finally be free, and secondly, it would help his brother, Peter,
lead a better life under the circumstances. For two years, Hemmings taught Peter everything he
knew about cooking, so Peter could continue to make meals at the Jefferson estate. In 1796,
when he was 31 years old, Jefferson finally signed his emancipation papers, and Hemmings had a chance
to start a new life. Now a free man, Hemmings faced the daunting task of making his own way
in 18th century America. He left the Jefferson estate of Monticello and settled in cities like
Philadelphia and Baltimore, where he lived among other free blacks and worked as a professional
chef. Despite his liberty and impressive culinary skills, his freedom did not shield him from the
realities of 18th century America. Unfortunately, there are only a few records to shed light
on his experiences after he was set free, but what we do know is that in a strange twist of fate,
Hemmings found himself once again in a dialogue with Thomas Jefferson. When Jefferson requested
Hemmings' service for a second time, Hemmings responded through Francis Sayers, another chef
who he had worked with in New York and Philadelphia. Hemmings indicated that he was willing
to work with Jefferson, but felt uncomfortable about the prospect of working with unfamiliar
servants. He asked Jefferson to write him directly, outlining the terms and conditions
of the job offer. While Jefferson never wrote back, Hemmings did briefly work at Monticello
for about a month and a half in the kitchen, earning about $30 before moving on.
The trajectory of Hemmings' life took a dark turn in 1801 when he died under very curious
circumstances. It is widely believed that he committed suicide. The factors that would
compel him to take his own life were completely speculative. It is postulated that his personal
adversities, possibly including being ostracized from his family and the challenges of navigating
a prejudiced society, might have overwhelmed him in his final years.
James Hemmings had a profound effect on American cuisine, and one of his biggest achievements
was introducing foods like ice cream, mac and cheese, crème brûlée, and french fries to
America. He brought back many recipes from France and added his own spin using ingredients that he
could find here in the states. For example, the classic mac and cheese is linked to a similar
dish in France called macaroni pie. He then made his own version in America, and it became popular
when his brother, Peter, served it at a state dinner in 1802. Hemmings also had a knack for
making sweet treats. He used vanilla, sugar, cream, and egg yolk to make a fancy but extremely
hard to make ice cream that was a big hit at Jefferson's parties. Another French dish that
Hemmings tasted those in France, tweaked the recipe to make his own American version,
and added it to the menu in Monticello. Jefferson started promoting them, and french fries became a
popular dish all over the country. Beyond specific dishes, Hemmings' broader influence
lies in his role in blending French and culinary practices with American ingredients. This fusion
approach laid the groundwork for what is now being celebrated as American cuisine, a melting pot of
various techniques from other countries and traditions. Hemmings proved that American dishes
could possess the refinement and complexity of European cuisine while celebrating the local
ingredients and taste. Hemmings, who spoke both French and English, left behind important notes
to help us learn more about his legacy beyond his cooking skills. These documents found at the
Library of Congress include a list of kitchen tools, his own handwriting, and some recipes that he
created. They show us that Hemmings was a very talented chef and offer us a glimpse into his
fascinating life. Today, Hemmings is finally getting the recognition that he deserves with
impact on American cuisine. His influence is being showcased in his exhibits and in food events that
honor his memory and celebrate his role in shaping early American cuisine. This new understanding
goes beyond his knowledge and his cooking abilities and is a meaningful tribute to all
the enslaved individuals like Hemmings, whose contributions to American culture often go
ignored and forgotten. The buffalo wing is an iconic American food that has enjoyed a meteoric
rise since its inception in the latter half of the 20th century. Characterized by its spicy and tangy,
often served with celery sticks and blue cheese dressing, it's become a staple of American cuisine.
The history, however, is rich, varied, and cannot be attributed to a single individual or moment but
rather a cultural shift and a profound appreciation for casual, flavorful, deep-fried food. The allure
of buffalo wings can be attributed to a couple of factors, the unique flavor, the versatility,
and the communal dining experience they promote. The wings are doused in hot sauce that is both
tangy and spicy and appeals to a wide range of palates and has inspired countless variations
and adaptations across the globe, from mild to blistering hot to sweet. The savory adaptability
of the buffalo wing caters to an array of taste preferences and fosters its own widespread
popularity. Additionally, buffalo wings are celebrated for their versatility. They are
a favorite choice for various occasions, from casual gatherings at sports bars to home parties
to everything in between. The food item effortlessly crosses the boundaries between
high-end cuisine and street food, with the casual nature of eating buffalo wings often with one hand
that makes the dining experience even more engaging and informal. And lastly, another
reason for their popularity is the sense of community and camaraderie that it inspires.
Typically, they are served in large portions meant for sharing. They encourage communal eating,
making them popular choice at sporting events, family gatherings, and social outings. This aspect
of sharing togetherness taps into a fundamental human experience. When it comes to the history
of buffalo wings, it centers around the Anchor Bar, a family-owned restaurant in Buffalo, New York.
However, an equally vital but lesser-known contributor to the development of the buffalo
comes with an African-American restaurateur by the name of John Young. Chicken wings have
had its place in both restaurants and home cooking for years. In Buffalo, the oldest
establishment to serve chicken wings is the Claridon Hotel. A copy of the hotel's menu
dates back to July 1, 1857, and lists an entire entree of chicken wings fried. In addition to
this menu, Cynthia Van Ness, the director of the library and archives at Buffalo's History Museum,
also found a recipe for chicken wings that dates back to the 1894 issue of the Buffalo Commercial
Advertiser. But the common narrative around the invention of the buffalo wings is with Teresa
Bellissimo, the co-owner of the Anchor Bar. In 1964, according to the story, Teresa concocted
the dish one night as a late-night snack for her son and his friends. Finding themselves with an
access of chicken wings as this part of the chicken at the time was largely used for either
stock or thrown away, she decided to deep fry them and toss them in cayenne pepper hot sauce
that she had on hand and serve them alongside celery slices and blue cheese dressing. It was
an immediate hit and eventually became a staple at the bar and spread across the United States.
But chicken wings were not just an entree in Buffalo, New York. By the 1960s, a Washington,
D.C. restaurant named Wings and Things was serving chicken wings in mumbo sauce. The sauce
has its roots in Chicago but has since become very closely related to Washington, D.C. This
may have inspired John Young to begin serving his wings in mumbo sauce at his similarly named
restaurant Wings and Things in Buffalo. Young moved to Buffalo from Alabama and began serving
breaded chicken wings in his own special mumbo sauce around the mid-60s. His restaurant was
called John Young's Wings and Things and this was around the same time the Bellissimo family claimed
to have invented Buffalo wings. Unlike chicken wings at the Anchor Bar that were covered in
a vinegar-based cayenne hot sauce and served without breading, John Young's were different.
His version of chicken wings were larger, breaded and coated in a thick tomato-based sauce. This
was Young's own special concoction and he referred to his wings as mumbo wings and served them at
his restaurant on Jefferson Avenue in Buffalo, New York. Now it's unclear when exactly Young
opened his restaurant in Buffalo. Although he applied for a restaurant license for Wings and
Things in 1966, interviews with Young and former customers indicate that he most likely was selling
food under that name long before he applied for a license to do so. In any case, Young's restaurant
became known for serving breaded whole wings in mumbo sauce. Early media coverage around Buffalo
wings predominantly featured Frank and Teresa Bellissimo. In 1972, the Buffalo Evening News
published an article highlighting Buffalo wings served by the couple, propelling them into the
national spotlight. This exposure led to a feature in an Associated Press article, a cooking show,
and most notably a 1980 article in the New Yorker by Calvin Trillin. Trillin's piece, however,
introduced a counter-argument by John Young, who had challenged Bellissimo's claim to the invention
of the Buffalo wings. Young had relocated to Illinois in 1970. When he came back almost a
decade later to Buffalo, he was shocked by the proliferation and marketing of Buffalo wings.
Specifically, he was surprised by the Anchor Bar claiming to have invented the dish when he believed
that Frank Bellissimo had been inspired by him. Young stated, I was selling 5,000 pounds of chicken
wings in 1962 and Mr. Bellissimo used to come to my place and eat my wings. Young's assertion of
his pioneering role in the Buffalo wing led to some recognition for him being the inventor of
the Buffalo wing, but the damage was mostly done. By the 1970s, restaurants in Buffalo began to
which adhered to the Anchor Bar's recipe of frying the wings, breaking them into drumlets,
and tossing them in hot sauce. Commonly, these wings were accompanied by sides,
such as blue cheese dressing or celery sticks, but nevertheless some establishments sought to
innovate how they served these wings. Some places would serve them with pizza. By the 1980s,
Buffalo-style wings began to permeate restaurant menus outside of Buffalo, New York,
marking their ascension to American cuisine. The inception of Buffalo Wild Wings,
initially called Buffalo Wild Wings and Rec, in 1982 in Columbus, Ohio, would underscore
this expansion. As Buffalo wings continued to proliferate nationwide, they became increasingly
synonymous with American sports culture, especially football and the Super Bowl in particular,
solidifying their status as the quintessential game day food. John Young would pass away in
2020. His daughter, Linda Brown Young, began to serve his father's chicken wing recipe on Buffalo
Bike Tour's historical wing ride, which honors John Young as the King of Wings. There have been
some recent efforts sought to amend this historical oversight by acknowledging Young's contribution.
Culinary historians and food writers, along with the Buffalo community, have aimed to ensure that
Young's legacy is preserved. This includes coverage and articles and documentaries that
highlight Young's innovative role in the significance of Buffalo Wings and bringing
mumble sauce to local cuisine. Community leaders and historians in Buffalo have advocated for Young's
deserved recognition, emphasizing the varied origins of the Buffalo Wings and celebrating
the diversity of their contributions. These acknowledgements not only honor Young's legacy,
but also enrich the local narrative of the Buffalo Wing, acknowledging the diverse origins
and the contributions of African-Americans to the national culinary landscape.
In the heart of African-American culinary traditions lies a rich tapestry,
woven with flavors, history, and resilience. It's a cuisine born from struggle and survival and
tells a story far deeper than its delicious dishes. It's a story that stretches across
continents and centuries, from bustling markets of West Africa to sprawling plantations of
the American South. So join us today while we chronicle the history and legacy of soul food.
And if you like stories like this, you can find more stories like this at onemikehistory.com.
If you like audio only episodes, you can find my podcast wherever you get your podcast. But
without further ado, let's get started. Soul food is more than a type of cooking. It is a
symbol of black culture. This cuisine traces its roots back to the agriculture and culinary
traditions of enslaved Africans in the American South. It includes dishes like fried chicken,
collard greens, cornbread, black-eyed peas, known for their comfort and rich flavors. Soul food is
not only about providing nourishment, but it's a symbol of community, cultural pride, and identity
over generations. But beyond this taste, soul food has played a crucial role in American cuisine,
influencing dining habits and spotlighting black heritage. The recipes and techniques
have been passed down through generations, each telling a story of adaptation and perseverance.
As soul food spread from its southern origins, it became a cherished part of America's diverse
culinary scene, inspiring chefs and food lovers everywhere. Let's start at the beginning.
Born from West African culinary traditions, the staples of West African farming societies
included grains, yams, legumes, vegetables, and some meat elements that are closely aligned
to soul food's basics. Western African regions had preferences for different starches,
including rice, millet, sorghum, and yams. Fishing was crucial along the coast and interior rivers,
contributing significantly to their diet. Traditional West African cooking methods
included frying, smoking, baking with ash, roasting over a fire, and boiling in water,
many of which are staples of soul food today. Seasoning pastes were commonly used to enhance
the flavor and color of meats and showcase the shared culinary practice between Western Africa
and the Americas. Culinary knowledge was passed down orally since there were no written
cookbooks before European contact, and the Columbian Exchange, which brought Europe and Asia
and new world crops like maize and plantains to Western Africa, were skillfully incorporated
to their already rich cuisine. So, during the transatlantic slave trade, enslaved Africans
would bring their culinary traditions with them to the Americas, laying the groundwork for what
would become soul food. Their culinary framework was centered around savory sauces and stews
served on top or with a starch, imbibing a resilient and adaptive approach to cooking
despite their harsh conditions. The basic diet of the enslaved was extremely limited. It often
consisted of the three Ms, meat, meal, or molasses, with corn serving as a staple crop.
They creatively used the ingredients they had to produce nourishing meals, such as sweetening
cornbread with molasses, which they would call long-sweetened. And despite these limited rations
and being provided the least desirable cuts of meat, the enslaved demonstrated resourcefulness
by transforming their least desirable cuts into flavorful dishes. They mastered slow-cooking
techniques and used flavors like onions, garlic, and peppers to tenderize tough cuts of meat
while infusing them with rich flavors. This fusion of African culinary traditions with
available ingredients and cooking methods from the Americas led to unique dishes reflective
of their diverse cultural influences. For example, gumbo from southern Louisiana showcases African,
French, Spanish, and Native American elements, with okra serving as a thickening agent akin to
its use in western Africa. The enslaved would often supplement their meager diets by foraging,
hunting, and tending to small gardens. Leafy green vegetables like collards and turnip greens
provided essential nourishment, while black-eyed peas served as a crucial protein source. They also
would introduce hot and spicy sauces and oils that would add depth and complexity to their meager
meals. After the Civil War, newly emancipated African Americans adapted their traditional diets
to the changing post-emancipation landscape. Many became sharecroppers and rent farmers,
cornmeal became a staple used in cornbread and hushpuppies and often paired with collard greens.
And again, with limited economic resources, they relied on inexpensive ingredients and less
desirable cuts, such as those of chitlins and ham hocks. Pork would grow in prominence and become a
mainstay through farming and hog butchering practices. This post-war period allowed African
Americans to reclaim their culinary heritage with black-eyed peas, collards, and pork dishes
becoming emblematic of their culture. As economic opportunities changed, it gradually led to the
diversification of available food, and the black church would emerge as a central community hub
where church gatherings and suppers became important social events where culinary skills
were showcased and reinforcing traditions and strengthening communal ties. As black folks
migrated out of the south, they carried their southern cooking traditions nationwide,
contributing to the establishment of a diverse range of culinary offerings. African Americans
also started open restaurants and food businesses utilizing their skills that they had developed
during enslavement. They specialized in barbecue, fried chicken, and fried fish, which would solidify
their place in African American culture. This movement sparked an evolution of soul food as
these migrants adapted traditional soul food dishes to their new urban environments. Fish
fries became popular in an area abundant with freshwater fish like the Great Lakes, while
interactions with different ethnic groups introduced new techniques and new ingredients
to the cuisine. The urban influence led to the development of down-home cooking,
a culinary expression that helped African Americans maintain their connection to their roots.
Street vendors and black-owned restaurants played an essential role in providing familiar southern
favorites, helping nurture a sense of community, while grocery stores began stocking southern foods.
So as we move forward into the civil rights movement, this is where you would see the emergence
of the term soul food, infusing traditional southern cooking with racial pride and political
significance. This new label symbolized a step away from original descriptors like southern
or down-home cooking and instead fostered a sense of black solidarity. Soul food connected
African American heritage to a broader culinary identity, and dishes like neck bones and chitlins
and turnip greens and fried chicken not only became culinary staples but icons of black pride
and unity. Eating these foods became a form of edible black power that celebrated and affirmed
black culture. However, soul food was not without its criticism and challenges. Class divisions
shaped the reception of soul food as some wealthier black individuals often regarded
soul food as merely a fad, referring to traditional terms such as down-home cooking.
Black Panther Eldridge Cleaver criticized the idea of soul food being empowering,
suggesting that it instead serves as a mocking slogan of the black bourgeoisie.
Health concerns also arose due to the cuisine's high-fat, high-sugar, high-salt content,
often linking it to poverty. Additionally, the commercialization and co-opting of soul food
posed additional challenges. The innovation of African American fine dining has sometimes
mischaracterized it as inauthentic. While other restaurants that don't serve soul food staples
are criticized, media portrayals often confiscate the different aspects of black cuisine with its
legacy of being a slave food, raising questions of whether or not it perpetuates stereotypes.
Soul food spread was also resisted by some conservative whites who saw it as the domain
of black people or black people food. Yet, despite these challenges, the rise of soul
food symbolizes cultural identity, pride, and resistance. Today, soul food stands at
a bit of a crossroads, balancing its preservation with its rich heritage with the need to address
modern health concerns. Its journey echoes the complex history and cultural identity of
African Americans, reflecting a connection to both its past and a vision for the future.
The contemporary soul food scene is marked by a simultaneous celebration of tradition
and innovation. This movement emerges where upscale dining establishments reinterpret
traditional African American dishes, blending nostalgia with modern culinary trends and health
concerns. The health-conscious approach is increasingly prevalent as chefs and home cooks
aim to reduce the fat and salt content found in soul food. Some establishments have even moved
away from the soul food label, opting to return to down home with things like Down Home Healthy
or even Vegan Soul to highlight their healthier options. The rise of vegetarian and vegan soul
food further expands the accessibility of the cuisine while aligning it with broader
plant-based diets. Contemporary soul food also embraces global influence and fusion cuisines.
As Americans become more culturally diverse, chefs have incorporated flavors and techniques
from other regions while honoring the spirit of soul food. Additionally, there is an emphasis on
fresh local and seasonal ingredients and moving away from processed foods and inexpensive cuts
that characterize earlier versions of these dishes. Soul food remains a powerful staple
of the black community and continues to showcase our ability to adapt and stay resilient,
and in that way, mimics the African American story as a whole.
Thank you, this has been One My Black History. I'm your host, Country Boy.
If you like stories like this, you can find more stories like this at OneMyBlackHistory.com.
If you like audio-only episodes, you can find my podcast wherever you get your podcast. I'd
like to thank all my financial contributors. Without you, none of this could be possible.
I love you all. Thank you, this has been One My Black History. I'm your host, Country Boy,
and this is the story of the black chefs that shaped American cuisine. I like this compilation
album. I've amassed a bunch of videos, and I think it's nice to sometimes mash them together
so that you can kind of see a total picture. I hope that you appreciate this. Of course,
you know, I'm still working on new videos. I'd like to thank all my financial contributors,
all my day ones, everybody that supports me. I love you all. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
Check out my sub stack. I create new content every single week, and peace.