#History#food This video was produced exclusively for American Food History. We created this content to provide an immersive look into America's culinary past, uncovering the forgotten recipes, survival meals, and daily dining experiences that shaped the nation throughout the decades. We are dedicated to exploring the fascinating and often overlooked chapters of American food history—from the rugged meals of the Wild West and Great Depression survival dishes to the diverse immigrant recipes that built this country's unique culinary DNA.
This account details the \"Starving Time\" of the Jamestown colony during the winter of 1609. Trapped by a Powhatan siege and deprived of relief supplies, the settlers descended into a harrowing struggle for survival, consuming livestock, pets, vermin, and non-food materials, eventually resorting to cannibalism before being saved by the timely arrival of Lord Delaware.
In the winter of 1609, a colonist named George Percy sat in a wooden fort on the James River
and watched the people around him starve to death by the dozen. When he had arrived,
there were around 300 settlers. By spring, only about 60 were left alive.
Percy wrote down what they ate to survive, and 400 years later, archaeologists pulled
proof from the Virginia clay that he had not been exaggerating. Number 14 on this list filled the
fort with a sound the survivors said they never forgot. Number three was so degrading that Percy
could barely force his pen to write the words. And number one was confirmed by a girl's skull
dug up in 2012, her bones scarred by a butcher's blade. These 25 foods kept a doomed colony
breathing through the worst winter in early American history. Hit that subscribe button
and let us count down what the first Jamestown settlers actually ate during the starving time.
Number 25. Acorns. Before the horror, there was the forest floor. When the corn ran out in the fall
of 1609, the first thing the settlers turned to was the same thing the squirrels were after.
They gathered acorns by the basketful from under the white oaks that ringed the fort,
but the English did not know what the Powhatan knew. Raw acorns are bitter with tannins that
turn the stomach and bind the gut. The native people leached them in running water for days
to make them safe. The settlers, trapped behind their palisade and afraid to walk to the river,
ate them half prepared. They ground them between stones into a coarse, gritty meal,
and boiled it into a gruel that tasted of bark and rot. It filled the belly for an hour. It
cramped it for the rest of the day. Still, an acorn was food, and in October of 1609,
food was already becoming a memory. The men who gathered them did not yet know how lucky they were.
Number 24. Walnuts and chestnuts. The Virginia woods were thick with black walnut and American
chestnut, and in a normal year, these were a windfall. Fat, oily, full of the calories a
working body craved. The settlers cracked them open with rocks and ate the meat raw,
sucking every fragment from the shell. Chestnuts they roasted in the coals when they still had
wood to spare. But nut season is short. By the time the starving time set in, the squirrels and
the deer had stripped the easy ground, and the men were too weak and too frightened to range
far from the palisade where Powhatan warriors waited. A boy might spend a whole morning
searching the leaf litter and come back with a single handful. They ate the bitter pith.
They ate the wormy ones. They learned, the way starving men always learned,
that there is no such thing as a nut too small to matter.
Number 23. Tuckahoe roots. The Powhatan thrived on a marsh plant, the English called tuckahoe,
the starchy root of the arrow arum that grew in the muddy shallows along the James.
The native women dug it, sliced it, and cured it for days to drive out the burning crystals
of calcium oxalate that make the raw root feel like swallowing ground glass. The settlers,
watching their neighbors eat it and live, assumed it was simple. It was not. Men waded into the
freezing mud, hauled up the roots, and ate them far too soon. Their mouths blistered,
their throats swelled until they could barely breathe. Some choked. Others kept eating anyway,
gambling that a swollen mouth was better than an empty stomach. Tuckahoe could have saved them if
they had only listened. Instead, it became one more lesson the colony paid for in suffering.
Knowledge, the Powhatan held, and the English were too proud and too late to learn.
Number 22. Sassafras and wild greens. The early Jamestown colony had actually shipped sassafras
root back to England as a cash crop. It was believed to cure everything from fever to the
pox, and London paid well for it. But you cannot eat money. When the starving time came, the
settlers boiled the same roots and bark into a thin, fragrant tea that warmed the hands and
quieted the stomach without ever filling it. They tore up whatever green thing pushed through the
cold ground. Chickweed. Cresses. The first sour shoots of spring that came far too late for most
of them. They ate grass. They ate the inner pulp of cattails. None of it carried enough nourishment
to keep a grown man on his feet, but the act of chewing something green felt like living.
In a fort full of the dying, the smell of sassafras tea was sometimes the only thing that
smelled like home. Number 21. Sturgeon. The abundance they lost. Here is the cruelest part.
The James River was one of the richest fisheries on the continent. In the summers, Atlantic sturgeon
ran up the river so thick that John Smith claimed a man could nearly walk across their backs.
Fish the length of a man. Hundreds of pounds of pale meat and roe. The colonists had feasted on
them in better seasons, but sturgeon run in warm months, and the starving time was winter. The
great fish were gone to the deep ocean, and the settlers, weakened and besieged, lacked the boats,
the nets, and the strength to chase what little swam beneath the ice-rimmed banks.
They sat starving on the shore of one of the most abundant rivers in the world, remembering the
taste of fish they could no longer catch. Plenty was all around them, just out of reach, and that
may have been the hardest hunger of all. Number 20. Crabs, mussels, and oysters. When they dared
to creep to the river's edge, the settlers raked the mud for oysters and mussels and snatched
whatever crabs crawled in the shallows. The shellfish were there year-round, clinging to the
rocks and burrowing in the flats, and for a while they were a lifeline. But shellfish in winter are
lean, and the brackish water near the fort turned foul as the colony's own waste and dead drained
into it. The men who ate from those flats often sickened with bloody flux, fevers, and a wasting
of the bowels that finished what hunger had started. Still, they went back because a handful
of oysters pried open with a knife was a meal. And a meal was the difference between this night
and the next. They pounded the shells for the scraps, they sucked the brine, and every trip
to the water meant slipping past the warriors who were waiting for exactly that. Number 19.
The settlement's hogs. Jamestown had brought livestock from England, and pigs, hardy, and fast
breeding were supposed to be the colony's insurance against hunger. For the first weeks of the crisis,
the settlers slaughtered them one by one, salting what they could and roasting the rest over fires
they were afraid to let burn too bright. A single hog could feed the fort for days, but 300 starving
people go through a herd fast, and the Powhatan, who understood exactly how the English survived,
drove off and killed the swine that ranged outside the palisade. By midwinter, the pens were empty,
the men had eaten the breeding stock, the piglets, the very animals they should have kept alive to
rebuild. But you cannot plan for spring when you are dying in January. They boiled the bones twice,
three times, until the broth was just gray water that smelled faintly of pork,
and then they ate the bones too. Number 18. Poultry. The last hens. Hens and roosters had
crossed the Atlantic in crates, prized less for meat than for the EGGS that could feed the sick
and the children. During the starving time, that arithmetic collapsed. A laying hen is worth more
alive than dead, but a starving man cannot wait for tomorrow's egg when he might not see tomorrow.
One by one, the birds went into the pot, feathers and feet and all, nothing wasted. The bones
cracked for marrow, and the gizzards boiled soft. When the last hen was gone, so was the last egg,
and so was any hope of the flock recovering. It is a pattern that repeats all through the
starving time. Every animal they killed to live another week was an animal that could not feed
them in the spring. They were burning the seed corn, and they knew it. Number 17. The colony's
horses. The English had brought a handful of horses to Virginia, animals of enormous value
for plowing, for hauling, for the simple status of being a people who rode while others walked.
In any sane season, eating a horse would have been unthinkable. But the starving time was not
a sane season. When the corn was gone and the hogs were gone, the settlers led the horses out,
killed them, and butchered every part. Horse meat is dark and sweet and rich, and for a few days,
the fort ate something like a real meal. They rendered the fat, they boiled the hooves for
the gelatin, they split the long bones and scraped out the marrow. And when the meat was
gone, they kept the hides, because a horse, it turned out, could feed a starving colony twice.
Once with its flesh, and once, weeks later, with its skin. We will get to the skin. For now,
understand that eating the horses was the moment the settlers admitted nothing was sacred anymore.
Number 16. Dogs. Every English settlement had dogs. For hunting, for guarding, for company
on a lonely continent 3,000 miles from home. The men of Jamestown knew their dogs by name,
and in the dead of that winter, they ate them anyway. George Percy, the colony's leader through
the worst of it, recorded it plainly. When the horses were gone, they fell upon the dogs.
A dog is mostly bone and sinew, but boiled long enough it gives up a greasy broth.
The men drank it down and gnawed the legs and called it supper. There is something in eating
a working animal, an animal that has slept by your fire and followed you through the woods,
that breaks something in a person. The settlers crossed that line without much choice.
By the time the dogs were eaten, the fort had stopped pretending this was a colony.
It was a siege, and they were the besieged. Number 15. Cats. After the dogs came the cats,
the ratters that every ship and settlement carried to keep the vermin down. It was a
grim irony because the cats were the colony's only defense against the very rats the settlers
would soon be eating themselves. A cat yields almost nothing, a few stringy ounces of meat
on a small frame. But desperation does not do math. The settlers hunted down every cat in the
fort, killed them, and boiled them with whatever roots or bark they had left. And in killing the
cats, they doomed themselves to a plague of rodents, the predators gone, the rats and mice
breeding unchecked through the granary and the corpses. It was the kind of mistake that hunger
makes, solving today's emptiness by guaranteeing tomorrow's. The settlers ate their mousers in the
deep of winter and spent the following weeks overrun by exactly what the cats had been keeping
out. Here is what the history books often skip. The starving time was not a natural disaster,
it was a siege. In the fall of 1609, the colony's hard, capable leader, Captain John Smith, was
badly burned when a bag of gunpowder ignited in his lap and he sailed back to England to recover.
With Smith gone, the fragile peace he had bullied and bargained out of the Powhatan paramount chief
collapsed. Chief Powhatan, who had decided these English were a threat that would never leave,
drew his warriors in tight around James Fort and waited. He did not need to storm the walls,
he only needed to make sure no settler could leave to hunt, to fish, to trade, or to forage
without being killed. So the English starved inside their own palisade, surrounded by a
land of plenty, penned in by an enemy who understood that patience was a weapon. Everything
that follows on this list happened because 300 people were trapped in a wooden box and slowly
squeezed. Number 14. Rats. When the cats were gone, the rats took over the fort and then the
rats became dinner. They poured out of the granary and the storehouses and the spaces between the
dead fat on the colony's last spilled grain and the settlers hunted them with a desperate focus
of men who had nothing else. A rat could be roasted whole on a stick, the fur singed off
in the flames, the little body eaten down to the tail. Percy listed them among the things the
colony was reduced to. Dogs, cats, rats, and mice. Catching them was its own grim sport, the weak
chasing the quick through a fort full of corpses. The sound the survivors later remembered was the
scrabbling of rats in the walls at night, the same rats they would try to kill and eat by morning.
It was a closed loop of misery. The vermin grew fat on the dead and the living grew thin trying
to eat the vermin. Number 13. Mice. If a rat was a meal, a mouse was barely a mouthful, but the
starving do not turn down a mouthful. The settlers set crude traps and dug into nests, pulling out
the pink blind young and eating them too. A mouse offers almost nothing, a thread of meat, a few
delicate bones to crunch. But there is a cruel mathematics to starvation, where the body will
spend more energy catching a mouse than the mouse can ever return. And still, the hunger drives the
hunt. The men of Jamestown spent their last reserves of strength chasing creatures that
could not sustain them, because the alternative was to sit still and wait to die. Mice were what
was left when the rats grew scarce, and when even the mice ran out, the settlers had finally
reached the bottom of the animal kingdom and were about to start eating things that had never been
food at all. Number 12. Snakes and serpents. Spring crept toward Virginia slowly, and as the ground
warmed, snakes began to stir from their winter dens. The settlers, by now expert at eating anything
that moved, killed and ate them without hesitation. A snake at least is honest food, clean white meat
along the spine, the kind of thing even the Powhatan ate in lean times. The men roasted them over the
coals and stripped the flesh from the ribs. But snakes in early spring are few and torpid, and a
colony of starving people clears the nearby ground of reptiles in days. They ate the venomous along
with the harmless, learning to cut away the head and take the rest. By the time the serpents were
waking though, the worst of the dying had already happened. Most of the 300 were already gone.
The snakes came too late for them, and just in time for the handful who would live to tell it.
Number 11. Shoe leather. When the last animal in the fort had been eaten, the settlers turned to
the things they wore. Leather, real old-fashioned tanned hide, is not food, but it is animal, and a
starving body will try to wring something from it. The men cut their shoes into strips, boiled them
for hours, and chewed the softened leather into a paste they could swallow. It gave them almost
nothing, a trace of fat from the tanning, the faint memory of the animal it had once been. Mostly it
gave them something to do with their mouths and their stomachs, a way to feel the act of eating
even when there was nothing to eat. George Percy recorded that they ate the leather of their shoes
and boots. Picture it, men sitting barefoot in the Virginia cold, boiling their own footwear,
drinking the gray broth, and saving the chewed scraps for the next day. This is what the bottom
looks like. Number 10. Boots, jerkins, and harness. Shoes were only the beginning. Once the settlers
understood that boiled leather could be choked down, every piece of worked hide in the fort became
fair game. Leather jerkins, the tough sleeveless coats the men wore, went into the pot. So did belts,
straps, the leather buckets, and the harness and tack that had once been used for the horses they
had already eaten. Anything tanned, anything cured, anything that had ever been part of an animal,
was fuel now. The leather had to be boiled for the better part of a day to soften enough to chew,
and even then it sat in the gut like a stone. But it bought time, and time was the only currency
left. A colony that had crossed an ocean to build an empire was now eating its own clothing, item by
item, reducing itself to barefoot, half-naked skeletons huddled around fires they fed with the
furniture. Number 9. Horse hides. Remember the horses? Eaten weeks earlier, their meat long gone.
The settlers had kept the hides, and now those raw salted skins came back into the kitchen.
Hide was the most leather-like food of all, thick and stubborn, and it took endless boiling to
render it into anything a person could swallow. The men scraped off the hair, cut the hide into
squares, and simmered it until it broke down into a thick gluey jelly. It was vile. It was also, by
the standards of that February, something close to a feast, because hide at least carried some collagen,
some fat, some faint nourishment that pure leather lacked. The fact that they had saved the hides at
all tells you something. Even in the first days of the crisis, some part of them had known how bad
it might get. They had planned for the horror, and the horror had come exactly as they feared.
Number 8. Laundry starch. Here is the part that should make you angry. The starving time did not
have to happen. In 1609, England had sent a great supply fleet to Jamestown. Nine ships carrying
hundreds of new colonists, and crucially, the experienced leaders and provisions, meant to set
the colony right. But the flagship, the Sea Venture, sailed into a hurricane and wrecked on the reefs
of Bermuda. The men aboard survived. They spent 10 months building two new ships from the wreckage
and Bermuda Cedar. But the food, the leadership, and the orders were stranded with them. So while
300 people ate their boots and their dead in Virginia, the very men who could have saved them
were marooned on a green island, alive and eating wild hogs and sea turtles, with no way to send
word. When that Bermuda party finally reached Jamestown in May of 1610, they found a graveyard.
In the storehouses, the settlers found starch, the stiff white powder, to press collars and
cuffs to keep a gentleman looking like a gentleman 3,000 miles from any gentleman who cared.
It was made from wheat, which meant, technically, that it had once been food. So they ate it.
They mixed the laundry starch with water and boiled it into a thin flavorless paste, a glue
that slid down the throat and gave the brief illusion of a full stomach. There was something
almost unbearably sad in it. Men who had packed starch to look respectable were now eating it to
stay alive, swallowing the symbol of their vanity because it was all that was left. It carried a
little nourishment, the ghost of the grain it was made from. Mostly, it carried the message that the
colony had eaten everything that was food and was now eating the things that only resembled it.
Number 7. Glue and paste. When the starch ran low, the settlers went looking for anything made from
animals or grain and they found it in the glue. The paste that bound their books, the hide glue
that held their furniture and tools together, the size used in their crafts. All of it was rendered
from boiled bones and skins, which made it, in the math of starvation, edible. They scraped it from
the spines of books and the joints of chests, dissolved it in hot water and drank it. Glue is
just leather that has already been boiled down once so the body could pull a thread of protein
from it. It was perhaps the most quietly degrading meal of all, eating the very substance that had
held their civilized possessions together, dismantling their world molecule by molecule
to keep their hearts beating one more night. A colony eats its books. Remember that the next time
someone calls Jamestown a triumph. Number 6. Candle tallow. Candles in 1610 were made of tallow,
rendered animal fat, which meant the colony had been burning food for light the entire time.
When the hunger reached its peak, the settlers stopped burning their candles and started eating
them. Tallow is pure fat, and fat is exactly what a starving body screams for, so a candle was
actually one of the better things left to eat. They swallowed the soft, greasy lumps, chewed the wicks,
scraped the last smears from the holders. It would have made them sick, rancid fat tearing through an
empty gut, but it would also have kept them alive a little longer. There was a brutal logic to it.
In the dark, freezing fort, a candle was worth more in the belly than in the holder, so they
chose to starve in the dark rather than starve in the light, and they ate the flame itself.
Number 5. Tree bark and wood. By late winter, the settlers were eating the fort itself. They stripped
the inner bark from the trees inside the palisade, the soft, pale layer that holds a tree's sugars,
and boiled it or chewed it raw. They gnawed wood. They ate sawdust and shavings. Bark is a famine
food known to desperate people all over the world, from European peasants to the citizens of besieged
cities, and the Jamestown settlers found their way to it through pure animal instinct. It offered
almost no nutrition, just fiber to give the stomach something to grind against, but the gnawing
eased the pain a little. Trees were one thing the fort had plenty of, even besieged, so the men sat
among the timbers of the home they had built and ate it down to splinters, taking into their bodies
the very walls that were supposed to protect them. The line between shelter and food had dissolved
completely. Number 4. Toadstools and poison fungi. Among the most dangerous things the settlers ate
were the fungi that pushed up from the cold, wet ground and the rotting wood of the fort.
A mushroom is food until it is poison, and a starving man in 1610 had no way to tell the
difference. They ate toadstools that cramped their guts and clouded their minds. Fungi that may well
have killed some of them faster than the hunger would have. When you have eaten your dogs and your
boots and the bark off the trees, a strange mushroom looks like a gift, and the gamble looks worth it.
Some won the gamble and got a meal. Some lost it and died in the corner of the fort. There was no
one left with the strength or the knowledge to warn them and no time to be cautious. The settlers
played a deadly game with the forest floor because the alternative, eating nothing, was a death they
could already feel coming. Here is how we know all of this is true and not just legend. For centuries
some historians dismissed the worst accounts of the starving time as exaggeration, propaganda,
or the ravings of broken men. George Percy's own writings, with their descriptions of eating the
dead, were treated as too horrible to be literal. Then, in 2012, archaeologists from Jamestown
Rediscovery and forensic scientists from the Smithsonian were digging in a cellar inside the
old fort, in a lair of trash dated precisely to that terrible winter. There, among the butchered
bones of horses and dogs, they found the skull and shinbone of a teenage English girl. They named her
Jane, and her bones told a story no one could deny. The cut marks of a blade, the chops and
scrapes of someone trying to reach the brain and the flesh. The forensic evidence was unmistakable.
Percy had not exaggerated. The last entries on this list are not folklore, they are fact,
written in the bone. Number three, the unspeakable. George Percy, struggling to describe the depths
the colony reached, wrote that the settlers ate things that seemed incredible, things he could
barely commit to the page. Among them, by his own account and others, were the foulest leavings of
the fort, rotting scraps, refuse, and in the most degraded cases, their own waste. Starvation does
monstrous things to the body and the mind, stripping away every barrier of disgust until
nothing is too vile to put in the mouth. The men ate filth that would have killed them slowly,
even if the hunger did not. Percy was a gentleman and an officer, not a man given to sensationalism
and the fact that he recorded these things at all, that he forced his pen to write what he had seen
his own people do, tells you how completely the ordinary rules of human life had broken down
inside that fort, and it was still not the bottom. Number two, the dead. When the leather and the
starch and the vermin were gone, and the dying outnumbered the living, the settlers began to eat
the corpses. The fort was full of them. People died faster than the survivors could bury them,
and shallow graves dotted the ground inside the palisade. George Percy recorded that some of the
living dug up the dead from their graves and ate them. They took the recently buried, the still
fresh, and butchered them in secret and in the open, beyond shame, beyond horror, driven by a hunger
that had erased everything that made them people. The girl called Jane was almost certainly one of
these, not murdered, but eaten after death. Her body used to keep someone else alive a few more days.
It is the kind of fact that does not fit into a triumphant story of America's founding, which is
exactly why it stayed buried in the ground and in the history books for 400 years. Number one, a man
and his wife. The single most infamous act of the starving time was not the eating of the already
dead, it was murder. George Percy recorded the case of a colonist who killed his own pregnant wife,
then salted her body and ate it piece by piece to survive. When the crime was discovered,
the man was arrested. He confessed under torture. Percy had him strung up by his thumbs with weights
on his feet until he admitted what he had done, and he was executed for it. It is the darkest
single story in the founding of English America, and Percy told it plainly because he had been there
because he was the leader who ordered the man's death. One human being killed another and their
unborn child and consumed them inside a wooden fort on the James River, while England's relief
fleet sat marooned in Bermuda. This is the true bottom of the starving time. This is what survival
cost. By the time the survivors from Bermuda sailed up the James in May of 1610, only about 60
of the 300 were still alive, and they were so far gone that the new arrivals decided the colony could
not be saved. They loaded the survivors onto ships and actually abandoned Jamestown, and were sailing
back down the river to go home when they met the new governor, Lord Delaware, coming up the river
with fresh men and supplies. Jamestown survived by a matter of hours. The next time someone tells
you the clean story of how America began, remember the fort on the river, the boiled boots, the empty
graves, and the girl named Jane. They ate their dogs, their boots, their dead, and worse, and a
handful of them lived. Tell me in the comments which of these shocked you most.