#History#Food Sushi didn’t start as elegant nigiri or glossy salmon rolls. It started as fermented fish packed in rice, left for months, sometimes years, until it turned into something far stranger than most people would call dinner.
In this episode of Crumb Lore, we trace sushi’s full transformation: from ancient preservation methods in Southeast Asia, to Japan’s narezushi and funazushi, to Hanaya Yohei’s hand-pressed fast food in Edo, to conveyor-belt sushi, the California roll, and the global empire sushi became.
Along the way: earthquakes, barrels, beer-bottle conveyor belts, and one very smelly fish tradition that still survives near Lake Biwa.
🍣 Topics inside: • The real origin of sushi • Why the original rice was thrown away • Funazushi and fermented carp in Shiga • How nigiri was invented in Edo • The earthquake that helped spread sushi across Japan • The birth of conveyor-belt sushi • How the California roll helped sushi conquer the West
If this kind of food history is your thing, subscribe to Crumb Lore for more strange origins, forgotten dishes, and the stories behind what we eat.
Every piece of sushi you have ever eaten is a lie, or at least it is a very convincing
reinvention of something you would never put in your mouth. Because the original version
of sushi was not the delicate, fresh, beautiful food you see at restaurants in Tokyo and New York
and London, the original version was rotting fish, on purpose, packed in rice that nobody
ever intended to eat, left in wooden barrels for months, sometimes years, until the flesh
turned soft and sour, and the smell could clear a room. That is how sushi started, not as a
delicacy, as a way to keep fish from going bad in a world without refrigerators. And the wildest part
is that this version of sushi still exists. You can walk into a restaurant in central Japan today
and order it. People do. They pair it with sake the way you might pair wine with aged cheese,
because that is essentially what it is. Fermented fish that tastes like blue cheese mixed with
vinegar and a faint note of ammonia. So how did we get from that to the clean, pristine,
Instagram-worthy plates of salmon nigiri that people post photos of every day? That story
stretches back nearly 2,000 years, crosses multiple continents, survives earthquakes and wars,
and involves a man who watched beer bottles rolling through a factory and thought,
I could do that with fish on rice. The story of sushi does not begin in Japan,
it begins along the Mekong River basin, in the region that today includes Laos, Cambodia,
Thailand, and Vietnam. Sometime around the 2nd century, communities in Southeast Asia figured
out a way to preserve freshwater fish using salt and rice. The process was simple but slow.
You gutted the fish, packed it tightly with salt, then pressed it into cooked rice inside
wooden barrels or clay pots weighted down with heavy stones. Then you waited. For months,
sometimes for more than a year. What happened during that waiting period was lactic acid
fermentation. The rice broke down and produced acids that preserved the fish, keeping it edible
long after it would have spoiled under normal conditions. In a region with no ice, no
refrigeration, and a tropical climate that could spoil a catch within hours, this technique was
survival. It meant that a fisherman who had a good haul in the spring could still be eating
preserved fish in the dead of winter. When the fish was finally ready, you pulled it out,
scraped off the rice, and ate only the fish. The rice had done its job. It was a tool,
not a food. Nobody was interested in eating the slimy, fermented mush that remained.
You threw it away the same way you would throw away packing material after opening a box.
This technique eventually spread north through trade routes and cultural exchange.
By the 4th century, Chinese records were documenting a similar practice,
using the character for pickled fish with salt and rice. Han Chinese migrants in southern China
had adopted the method from the Baiyue peoples, the original non-Han inhabitants of the region
who were culturally connected to modern Southeast Asian communities.
From southern China, the method crossed the sea to the Japanese archipelago, arriving sometime
around the 8th century as wet-field rice cultivation spread through Japan during the Yayoi period.
In Japan, this preserved fish was called narazushi. The name translates roughly to
matured sushi, a nod to the long fermentation process that defined it.
The earliest Japanese legal documentation of sushi appears in the Yoro Code of 718,
an administrative document that records the taxation of fermented fish products.
So even at this early stage, narazushi was important enough to tax. It was not street
food. It was not casual. In many regions, narazushi was reserved for festivals,
feast days, and religious celebrations. It was a high-status food, partly because the
salt and rice required to make it were expensive. Producing a single batch
meant committing significant resources and then waiting a long time for the payoff.
But one region of Japan took narazushi further than anywhere else.
In Shiga Prefecture, on the shores of Lake Biwa, the largest and oldest lake in Japan,
local families developed a version called funazushi. They used a species of freshwater
carp called nigurabuna, a fish found nowhere else on Earth except Lake Biwa and the rivers
surrounding it. The nigurabuna were caught in spring, gutted, packed in salt, and left for at
least a year. After the salt cure, the fish were repacked in steamed rice and left to ferment again,
sometimes for another two or three years. The end result looked nothing like what you think
of as sushi. The whole fish, head and all, was served cold on a plate, the flesh soft
and translucent, the insides replaced by a white, yogurt-like paste of fermented rice and eggs.
The bones had softened during the months of fermentation, turning almost chalky,
edible if you wanted to chew through them. People who have tried funazushi describe the smell as
stronger than natto, the notoriously pungent Japanese fermented soybean dish. The taste is
intensely sour and tangy at first, with a sharp vinegar bite, before mellowing into something
closer to a very aged, very funky cheese. Some diners compare the aroma to ammonia,
others say feet, others refuse to say anything at all and just push the plate away. The traditional
way to eat it is with hot rice and a pour of green tea over the top, a dish called ochazuke,
or you pair it with sake, the way Europeans pair wine with Roquefort. The sharpness of the
fermented fish and the warmth of the rice wine complement each other in a way that
locals have understood for centuries. And yet, funazushi is still made today.
You can buy it in supermarkets across Shiga Prefecture. Families pass down their own
recipes and fermentation techniques through generations. It is recognized as the oldest
form of sushi still in existence. During the Edo period, funazushi from the Shiga region
was even presented to the Shogun's family as a prized local specialty. This foul-smelling,
fermented carp was once considered a gift worthy of Japan's most powerful ruler.
If you told the average person eating a spicy tuna roll that their lunch shares a direct
ancestor with a fish that fermented in a barrel for three years and smelled like dairy gone wrong,
they probably would not believe you. But here is where the story starts to shift.
Because over the centuries, people got impatient. Waiting a year or more for your sushi to be ready
was not exactly convenient, and the demand for preserved fish kept growing.
So during the Muromachi period, which stretched from 1336 to 1573, something important changed.
People started eating the rice along with the fish. Instead of throwing the rice away after
fermentation, they consumed both together. This was a big deal. The rice was no longer just a
tool, it was part of the meal. Then, by the 16th century, a new variation appeared. It was called
namanara sushi, and the difference was vinegar. Instead of waiting months for natural fermentation
to produce the acids that preserved the fish, cooks began adding vinegar directly to the rice
to speed up the process. What once took a year could now be done in days or weeks. The fish was
less fermented, less funky, and the rice was firm enough to eat alongside it. This was sushi starting
to look like something you might actually recognize. But the biggest reinvention was still
coming. And it happened because of one man, in one of the most crowded cities on Earth,
trying to solve a very simple problem. How do you feed people faster? His name was Hanaya Yohei.
He was born in 1799 in what is now Fukui Prefecture, and he arrived in Edo, the city we now
call Tokyo, around 1818. Edo, in the early 1800s, was enormous. It was one of the most densely
populated cities in the world, home to over a million people, packed with merchants, laborers,
craftsmen, and samurai, all of them needing to eat. The streets were lined with food stalls
selling everything from tempura to soba noodles, and the pace of daily life was fast. People ate
standing up. They ate on the move. They needed food that was quick, portable, and satisfying.
Yohei saw an opportunity. He had been working in the food trade and was familiar with the existing
styles of sushi, particularly oshizushi, where fish was pressed into a box mold with rice.
But oshizushi still required preparation time. Yohei wanted something faster, so he developed
a completely new method. He took freshly caught fish from nearby Edo Bay, sliced it, and placed
it directly on top of small mounds of vinegared rice, pressing them together by hand. No fermentation,
no waiting, no barrels, no stones, no months of patience, just fish, rice, and the squeeze of a
And around 1824, he opened a stall in the Ryogoku district of Edo,
a bustling area near the Sumida River that sat between two popular temple grounds.
The location was smart. Foot traffic was constant, and Yohei set up right near one of the few bridges
that crossed the river, guaranteeing a steady stream of hungry customers. The sushi Yohei
served looked different from what you see today. Each piece was roughly two to three times the
size of a modern nigiri roll, about the size of a small child's palm. It was designed to fill you up,
not to be dainty. Customers stood at his stall, watched him prepare each piece,
and ate with their hands. There were no chopsticks, no ceramic plates, no reservations.
This was fast food in the purest sense. And it took off. The workers and merchants of Edo
loved it. It was cheap, it was filling, and the flavor of fresh fish paired with tangy
vinegared rice was completely different from the heavy, sour taste of traditional fermented sushi.
Yohei's stall became famous. He built a reputation first on Kohada, a small silver-skinned fish
firmed up by soaking in vinegar, which he sold from portable wooden carrying boxes in the night
streets. Then he added fresh shrimp, sweet conger eel, and shirao. By the time he opened a full
restaurant in Ryogoku, people were coming specifically for his shrimp sushi and tamagoyaki,
a sweet rolled omelette that became one of the signatures of Edo-style sushi.
His style spread through the city fast. Other chefs copied his method. And within a decade,
nigiri sushi stalls were everywhere in Edo. When night fell, the streets of Ryogoku and Asakusa
were thick with sushi vendors, each offering their own take on the format. Woodblock prints
from that era, like the ones in Kitagawa Utamaro's 18th century illustrations of Edo street life,
show these stalls side by side with tempura vendors, lanterns glowing, customers standing
elbow to elbow, reaching for their next piece. Yohei had taken a food that required a year of
rotting and turned it into something you could eat in 30 seconds. He did not just reinvent sushi,
he accidentally invented fast food. But nigiri sushi stayed mostly regional for nearly a century.
It was an Edo thing. Other parts of Japan had their own sushi traditions,
their own preservation methods, their own local fish. Osaka had oshizushi. Shiga had funazushi.
Kyoto used mackerel in pressed sushi. The country was full of regional variations,
and there was no particular reason for Edo-style nigiri to go national.
Then, on September 1st, 1923, the ground shook. The Great Kanto Earthquake was one of the worst
natural disasters in Japanese history. It struck the Tokyo-Yokohama region with a magnitude of
roughly 7.9, and it hit at lunchtime, when cooking fires were burning across the city.
The earthquake itself was devastating, but the fires that followed were catastrophic.
Winds from a nearby typhoon fanned the flames through Tokyo's wooden buildings,
and the city burned for two days. Roughly 60% of Tokyo's buildings were destroyed.
In Yokohama, the number was closer to 80%. The death toll reached an estimated 140,000 people.
Over one and a half million were left homeless. In the aftermath, something unexpected happened
to sushi. Trained sushi chefs, who had built their careers in Tokyo, lost everything. Their stalls
were gone. Their neighborhoods flattened. Many of them fled the capital and scattered across Japan,
settling in cities and towns that had never seen Edo-style sushi before.
They brought their techniques with them. For the first time, nigiri sushi was being prepared and
sold far beyond Tokyo. At the same time, the destruction drove real estate prices down across
the devastated capital. Properties that would have been far too expensive before the earthquake
were suddenly affordable. Chefs who had been running outdoor stalls on the streets of Tokyo
for years could now rent indoor space with actual walls and a roof. This shift changed everything
about how sushi was experienced. The stalls were gone. In their place came small, intimate
restaurants, where a counter separated the chef from the customer by just a few feet.
The format evolved with the setting. Pieces got smaller and more refined. Presentation became
more deliberate. The rice was shaped with greater care. The fish was sliced with more precision.
By the 1950s, sushi in Tokyo had moved almost entirely indoors, and the standing, grab-and-go
style of Hanaya Yohei's era gave way to a seated, counter-service experience that felt closer to a
performance than a meal. Customers watched every cut, every squeeze, every placement of fish on
rice. The chef became the show. An earthquake killed 140,000 people and destroyed two cities,
and one of its side effects was turning a regional street food into a national cuisine.
But sushi was still expensive. Making it well required years of training, fresh ingredients,
and skilled hands. It was not the kind of food a working family could afford every week.
That changed because of a man named Yoshiaki Shiraishi and a trip to a beer factory.
Shiraishi ran a small standing sushi shop in Osaka called Genroku, which he had opened in 1947,
just two years after the end of World War II. Business was decent, but he had a problem.
He could not find enough staff. Sushi preparation was labor-intensive, and trained workers were hard
to come by. Customers waited too long, lines built up, and Shiraishi knew he was leaving money
on the table. Then one day, he visited an Asahi brewery. He watched beer bottles rolling smoothly
along a conveyor belt, moving from one station to the next without a single person having to
carry them. And in that moment, an idea landed. What if he could do the same thing with sushi?
What if he could put plates of sushi on a moving belt that circled the restaurant,
letting customers grab whatever they wanted as it passed by?
He spent the next five years building the system. It was not easy. He had to figure out how to make
the belt turn corners without jamming. He had to switch from traditional rectangular sushi dishes
to round plates, which moved more smoothly. And he had to determine the right speed.
Too fast, and customers could not grab their food. Too slow, and the sushi would go stale on the belt.
He eventually settled on 8 centimeters per second as the ideal pace. In 1958, Shiraishi opened
Mawaru Genroku Sushi in Higashi, Osaka. It was the first conveyor belt sushi restaurant in the world.
The concept was an instant hit. Customers loved the novelty, the speed, and most importantly,
the price. Because conveyor belt sushi needed fewer servers and less overhead,
Shiraishi could sell sushi at a fraction of what traditional restaurants charged.
A food that had been moving toward refinement and exclusivity was suddenly accessible to ordinary
families again. Shiraishi patented his conveyor system and started franchising the concept locally.
Then, in 1970, he did something brilliant. He brought a pop-up version of his Kaiten Sushi
restaurant to the Osaka World Expo, a massive international event that drew tens of millions
of visitors from around the world. People who had never seen sushi before, let alone sushi on a
moving belt, were suddenly sitting at a counter in Osaka watching plates of fish and rice glide
past them at 8cm per second. The spectacle was irresistible. The combination of novelty,
efficiency, and affordability spoke directly to the post-war Japanese obsession with technology
and progress. It arrived at the exact moment when western fast food chains like McDonald's
were beginning to enter the Japanese market, and Shiraishi's conveyor belt sushi offered a
homegrown alternative that felt just as modern. At its peak, his Mawaru Genroku chain operated 250
outlets across Japan. When his patent expired in the mid-1970s, competitors flooded the market,
and conveyor belt sushi became a permanent fixture of Japanese dining culture. Chains like Sushiro
and Kura Sushi eventually grew even larger, adding touchscreen ordering, bullet train-themed
plate delivery systems, and digital games you could play between bites. While all of this was
happening inside Japan, sushi was about to make a much bigger jump. Across the Pacific Ocean,
in a neighborhood of Los Angeles called Little Tokyo, a restaurant named Kawafuku opened what
is widely considered the first traditional sushi counter in the United States. The year was around
1961, and the operation was small, expensive, and catered almost exclusively to Japanese
businessmen and expats. Most Americans in the early 1960s had no interest in eating raw fish.
The idea was, to put it mildly, a tough sell. The average American diet at the time revolved
around meat, potatoes, and cheese. Seaweed was something you stepped on at the beach,
not something you wrapped around your dinner. But sushi had a secret weapon,
and it came in the form of a single roll. The California roll is one of the most disputed
inventions in food history, with at least three different chefs claiming credit. The most commonly
told version involves a chef named Ichiro Mashita at a Los Angeles restaurant called Tokyo Kaikan.
According to this story, Mashita was struggling with the inconsistent availability of quality
tuna in Los Angeles, so he made a substitution. He used avocado instead of toro, the fatty tuna
belly, because it had a similar creamy texture and richness. He added real crab meat for the
seafood flavor. And then he did something that broke every rule of traditional Japanese sushi.
He turned the roll inside out, putting the rice on the outside and hiding the nori seaweed on
the inside, because American diners found the dark, chewy seaweed unappetizing. Another strong
claim comes from Hidekazu Tojo, a Japanese chef working in Vancouver, Canada, who says he developed
a similar inside-out roll to coax Canadian diners into trying sushi. Tojo even attempted to trademark
the concept in the early 1990s. A third candidate is Ken Sousa, a sushi chef in Los Angeles who was
known for creative adaptations aimed at American tastes. Whoever actually invented it, the California
roll did something no traditional sushi had been able to do. It made sushi approachable for people
who were terrified of raw fish. The avocado was familiar, the crab was cooked, the seaweed was
hidden. It was a Trojan horse, a way of getting Western diners to sit at a sushi counter without
realizing they were being eased into one of the world's most sophisticated culinary traditions.
And it worked. Through the 1970s and into the 80s, sushi restaurants spread across the United States.
The California roll opened the door, and once people were comfortable at the counter,
they started reaching for the salmon, the tuna, the yellowtail. Each step felt like a small act
of courage for diners who had grown up on burgers and meatloaf, but the progression was steady.
The California roll became the gateway. It inspired other American inventions, too.
The Philadelphia roll added cream cheese and salmon. The New York roll used shrimp. None of
them would have passed muster in a traditional Tokyo sushi bar, but that was never the point.
The point was getting people to the counter. Japanese food expert Hiroko Shimbo once said that
the California roll is not Japanese sushi because it was created for the convenience of American
diners. She called it another dish entirely. But whether purists accept it or not, the California
roll is the reason millions of people ate their first piece of sushi, and most of them came back
for more. From there, the expansion was relentless. Sushi jumped from the coasts of the United States
to the interior, from major cities to suburbs, from restaurants to grocery store delis. Then,
it crossed the Atlantic. Conveyor belt restaurants opened in London and Sydney.
Supermarkets in Paris and Berlin started stocking pre-packaged sushi in their refrigerated aisles,
right next to the sandwiches. Travelers returning from Tokyo wanted the food they had eaten abroad,
and entrepreneurs were happy to supply it. High-end omakase counters appeared in New York
and Hong Kong, where a chef would serve you a personally curated sequence of 15 to 20 courses,
and the bill at the end could easily run several hundred dollars per person.
At the other end of the spectrum, convenience stores across Japan were selling onigiri and
sushi bento boxes for a few hundred yen, affordable enough for a student's daily lunch.
Sushi had split into two completely different products, occupying two completely different
worlds, and both were thriving. The range is staggering. Today, the global sushi restaurant
market is valued at over $20 billion. There are more than 55,000 sushi restaurants operating
worldwide, with roughly 23,000 of them in Japan alone. The United States has nearly 4,000.
The food that started as rotting fish in a barrel along the Mekong River is now one of the most
recognized and consumed cuisines on the planet. And through all of that, through nearly 2,000
years of reinvention, the core idea has never really changed. Every version of sushi, from the
ancient narazushi that fermented for years in Lake Biwa to the salmon avocado roll you can order on
your phone right now, is still a version of the same concept. Fish and rice combined in a way that
makes both better. The method changed. The speed changed. The presentation changed. But the pairing
at the center of it never did. What changed was everything around it. The people who ate it, the
places it traveled, the accidents, the earthquakes, the stubborn chefs who refused to accept that
Western diners would never eat raw fish. The man who watched beer bottles on a conveyor belt and
thought, that could work for tuna. The families in Shiga Prefecture who still ferment carp the way
their great-grandparents did, even though the world moved on. Funazushi is still there, on the
shelves of local shops near Lake Biwa. It still smells the way it always has. And if you walk
into one of those shops, pick up a package, and take a bite, you are eating the same food that was
taxed in Japanese law over 1,300 years ago. You are tasting the ancestor of everything a global
industry now produces. The most popular cuisine on Earth started as a preservation hack that made
fish rot on purpose. The rice was garbage. The smell could knock you sideways. And somehow,
over centuries of impatience, innovation, and happy accidents, it became the food that conquered the
world. If you made it this far, drop a comment telling us whether you would actually try
Funazushi, the original fermented sushi that smells like blue cheese and ammonia.
Hit subscribe so you do not miss the next one, and smash that like button on your way out.