Are Von Neumann probes coming soon? What will it take to categorize all neighboring stars? Where are the promised discoveries from Vera Rubin? And in Q&A+, which dwarf planets should we visit next?
00:00 Intro 00:32 [@HenryWarren-b6j] Are Von Neumann probes coming soon? 06:08 [@FunkyLoiso] What will it take to categorize every neighboring star? 11:17 [@PokerYoda] Where are all the Vera Rubin discoveries? 13:53 My opinions
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The video explores the technical challenges of creating self-replicating von Neumann probes, the methods used to map neighboring star systems, and the early findings from the Vera Rubin Observatory. Additionally, the speaker addresses the importance of scientific consensus regarding climate change and the necessity of transitioning to sustainable energy.
Are von Neumann probes coming soon? What will it take to categorize all neighbouring stars?
What are the promised discoveries from Vera Rubin? And in Q&A Plus,
which dwarf planets should we visit next? All this and more in this question show.
It's time for the question show, your questions, my answers. As always, wherever you are,
across my channel, if a question pops into your brain, just write it down. I'll gather them up
and I will answer them here. I am continuing to record from this quiet alley that I found
in Kyoto at six in the morning in Japan. And next time I'll be somewhere different,
but still on the road. All right, let's get into the questions.
Henry Warren, do you think von Neumann probes are coming soon? I heard about the
Blue Alchemist rovers, and I maybe think these probes could be coming soon.
So Blue Alchemist is a plan from Blue Origin to do in situ resource utilization, ISRU. And so
they're planning on scooping up regolith from the surface of the moon, and then processing it
into various useful substances, metals, oxygen, maybe make water, various volatiles, like you've
got a whole laundry list of things that they're trying to do. And this is interesting and exciting
enough to NASA that they've been funding, I think they gave them, you know, like $100 million to
continue some tests, we should be seeing some actual practical tests of the Blue Alchemist,
even on the moon in the next couple of years, which is great, really exciting.
But just digging up regolith using solar energy, turning that into little piles of iron or
titanium or magnesium out of the regular silicon is a long way from having a chip fab that allows
you to actually manufacture the chips that would be required for you to have artificial intelligence
for your spacecraft that could be then making copies of itself out of the asteroid belt,
and so on. So no, we are nowhere near close enough being able to build von Neumann probes.
But there was a, there was a paper, there's a interview that I did about two years ago, maybe,
and that this is a researcher who was sort of laying out how you might actually build
a self replicating robot factory on the surface of the moon. And the trick is that,
you know, here on earth, when we think about the chips, we think about the chips on our phone or
computers or whatever, it is built with what are essentially the most expensive machines on earth,
the chip fabs, they're, they're only designed out of this company, out of the Netherlands,
only companies in Taiwan are able to produce them at the three nanometers that they make
these things at, it's absolutely a feat of of modern engineering that you don't realize the
wondrousness of your phone of the chip that's inside your phone. But you can go back generations
to much simpler versions of microchips, wiring, transistors, things like that. And you can
actually get a certain level of intelligence and capability. And so this researcher that I had
interviewed, he was talking about how a lot of the big stuff is relatively straightforward, you can
dig up regolith, and you can turn it into solar panels that we pretty much have that we know how
to do this, like it hasn't been practically done yet. But this is the kind of test that blue
alchemists will do is can we build solar panels on the moon, for example, there's a different kind
of solar panel technology. So this is the main kind of solar panels that you're familiar with,
those are made with silicon and gallium, I think, that is very complicated required,
they're essentially kind of like microchips to build. And then there's this other technology
called perovskite. And perovskite is much simpler. The problem is, is that it's very easy to oxidize
that if you had you built perovskite solar panels in the Earth's atmosphere, the Earth's atmosphere
would wear them down, and they would become useless. But when you're on the moon, it doesn't
matter. And so you could build these perovskite solar panels on the surface of the moon out of
the regolith. And people have come up with mechanisms methodologies to be able to do that.
And so you can sort of start to make your way towards building a copy of your robot factory
on the moon. And so the researcher that I was talking to, he was proposing that you send up
the intelligence, and then it has little worker robots, and they gather material from the
surroundings and then start to form the various components that are required, solar panels,
very rudimentary chip fab, other instruments that you might want. And it's great. So I used
to work for this offshoot of the XPRIZE called HeroX. They're still operational, but I don't
work with them anymore. And it was a way to sort of let regular people crowdsource challenges.
And the challenge that I wanted to come up with is like, can we build a self-replicating robot?
Whoever can build, like, let's all gather our resources together. Let's come up with a prize,
say $100,000. And then whoever can build a robot that can make a copy of itself as well as possible
wins the prize. And then every year, you just keep running the competition,
and they just keep trying to make a robot that makes a better copy of itself.
So, and that's how we get to von Neumann probes. So I think in the short term, we are
very far away from von Neumann probes. You know, this idea of self-replicating robots that would
go out and explore the galaxy, like we don't have the technology to explore the galaxy yet.
But this is the kind of thing that I think will be inevitable that in a couple of hundred years,
maybe sooner, we will have mastered 3D manufacturing. We will have mastered the
kind of propulsion technologies that might take you to other star systems. We will be able to
build a robot that can build a copy of itself from square one. I mean, that's what bacteria does,
right? Like we see life doing this. We must be able to figure out a way to do it ourselves.
It's time to shout out all the new $5 patrons and above.
Smashly83, Joe Deshawn, The Chicken Shrink, Jamie Newman, Earl, Tommy Moiso,
Matt Baker, Richard, Scott Barnett, and Scott Ware. Join the club at patreon.com slash universe
today. Funky Loiso, what kind of mission would we need to categorize every star system in some
radius around us? This question that you were just asking me is like a version of the question that I
always ask astronomers because, man, it would be amazing if we could look at, say, all of the star
systems within a 10 light year radius of us. I think there's 10 within 10 light years of us,
or within 100 light year radius. And then I think there's 1000 star systems in that region.
And what would it take for us to just know what's in that star system in the way that we know what's
the solar system? We know that we have the A planets plus the dwarf planets, plus the Kuiper
belt, plus the asteroid belt. We know about the moons that are going around those planets.
And the two main methods of observing exoplanets is the radial velocity method and the transit
method. And those both are, you need the star and the planet to be lined up from our perspective.
So with the radial velocity method, you've got the star, and you've got the planet,
and the planet is orbiting around the star. And it's causing the star to kind of move towards us
and away from us a little bit. And we measure that change in the speed, because essentially,
the planet is pulling at it with its gravity, it's in front, and it's pulling it away, gravity is
behind and pulling in front. And we can measure that that wobble of the star. And that tells us
the mass of the planet. But if the planet is up above, then, then you don't get that wobble back
and forth from our perspective. The transit method is even more precise, like with the radial
velocity, the planet can be a little above or a little below, as long as they're, they're roughly
aligned from our perspective, we can make those observations. The transit method, it's got to be
perfectly lined up. So the planet is moving exactly in front of the star and blocking it.
And that does not happen very often, like less than 1% of the stars in our vicinity are going
to have a planet that is perfectly lined up from our perspective. You know, we happen to get the
Proxima Centauri planets, the closest star system to us, they're actually lined up. But there are
other methodologies that will do the trick. So one is called astrometry. And this is what the
Gaia is, this is why I'm excited about the Gaia mission all the time, is that astrometry,
you are looking at the wobble, essentially, the star is going to make this little spiral in the
sky, as the planet is orbiting around it, pulling at it with its gravity, and you measure the size
of the spiral. And that tells you the mass of the planet. And if it's making a weird spiral,
then maybe, you know, sometimes it's going a little far to one side and less to the other
side, then maybe it's got two planets that are going around it. But the way that it's really
going to take is the direct observation. And this is where you just block the light of the star,
and you reveal the fainter planets that are around it. If there was no star at Alpha Centauri,
like there are two stars at Alpha Centauri, essentially, if you can block the light from
the star, so that you're able to see the reflected starlight from the planet, then we would see them.
Our telescopes are powerful enough to be able to see the reflected light off of the planets
that are orbiting around Alpha Centauri stars out to hundreds of light years away from us.
The problem is, the light from the star is overwhelming, you can't see the faint reflected
light of the planet, because the star is so bright. And it's a factor of 10 billion to one.
So the star is 10 billion times brighter than the planet. And you have to block the light from the
star to be able to reveal the fainter planets that are orbiting around it. And so this uses
a technology called a coronagraph. And there's one on James Webb, and there's one on other
telescopes. And you're essentially blocking the light of the star to reveal just the planets that
are around it. And so we would need a much better version of a coronagraph. And this is the plan for
the upcoming Habitable Worlds Observatory, and the Large Interferometer for exoplanets. These are the
two next big Earth 2.0 hunting telescopes that are going to be built, that they will have powerful
coronagraphs that block the light from the star, they will reveal the fainter planets that are
orbiting around that. But you will still be constrained to the faintest planets that you can
see, that we might be able to see the Jupiter sized planets, we will even see the Earth sized
worlds orbiting around the stars, but we won't get a proper full listing of all of the objects in that
solar system yet. But then, better coronagraphs, more powerful telescopes go into space, I would
say, you know, once we have the Habitable Worlds Observatory, once we have the Large Interferometer
for exoplanets, we will get a proper census of all of the star systems that are in our vicinity,
and all of the planets that are around those stars. So we are just a couple of telescope
generations away from that being possible. Pocriota, we discussed Virubin and all the
alerts being generated. But I haven't seen a lot of specific discoveries. Have there been any? And
if so, what are they? Yeah, there haven't been a lot of announced discoveries yet. But that's just
because astronomers work very slowly, that they are getting the alerts for the kinds of objects
that they're interested in. And then they are booking time on telescopes, they're doing fallen
observations. And then they are gathering other data from from other instruments. Then they're
writing up their papers, they're getting it peer reviewed. And so it's still fairly early, there
was like this rush of interesting discoveries made. When Virubin just came online, when they
were doing some of their engineering, first light work, we got these, like all those new asteroids
that were discovered. And there was some asteroids that were rotating much more quickly than asteroids
should. And that meant that they're probably solid, like chunks of metal or solid chunks of rock.
That was really interesting. But yeah, I haven't heard a lot of news coming out of Virubin yet.
But it just feels like it's the calm before the storm that astronomers have only been able to work
with the data from this telescope for a couple of months now, they're still learning how to do it.
Typically, a science paper will take an astronomer like the better part of a year to produce.
When astronomers do observations with James Webb, they have a year of embargo and information. So
they do their observations, they get access to the data, they get to sit on the data for
a year to get their paper together before they do their announcement. So I would expect that we'll
really start to see the flush of papers coming out towards the end of 2026. So stay tuned.
Did you know that you can watch the same video with no ads and get a bonus question over on
Patreon completely for free? We'll call it Q&A Plus. This week's bonus question,
which dwarf planet should we visit next? I'll put a link in the show notes.
All right, those are all the questions that we had this episode. Thank you, everyone,
who put your questions into the YouTube comments, everybody who joined me for the live show,
the last one I did before I left for Japan. I'm going to respond to a comment that I got about
climate change. But first, I'd like to thank our patrons. Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Progetti,
Brian Bode, Cara Doyle, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Balak, Darkfinger, Dave Gilton, David Mattson,
Enthraller Reading and Math for Toddlers, Eric Lindstrom, Evan Dot Pro, Jane Clark, Jeremy
Madden, Jayden Burke, Jordan Young, Josh Schultz, Marcel Sitz, Michael Purcell,
please follow my nephew at vbrick6994, Ray Kaidu, Richard Williams, Sean Sardin, Stephen
Feathermoney, Team49, TeleslopesCanada, FlagshipBoy, Wolfgang Klotz, and ZeldaWorldGalacticDefender,
who'd support us at the Master of the Universe level, and all our patrons. All your support
means the universe to us. So I got this question from Akamite.
You've had no difficulty in the past on several occasions giving your opinion on climate change,
aka global warming. Talk about a theory failing to make predictions. Here's some news you might
spread, which would not be bad science. Global warming, oops I mean climate change, world
champion Al Gore is now touring with warnings of a failure of the Gulf Stream, causing an ice age.
So the thing that I say at the beginning of every live stream question show, and I mention this
quite a lot, is that I'm not a scientist, I am a journalist. And so my job is not, you know,
I have no opinions about the various topics in space and astronomy. If you want to ask me,
what are the holes that I find in some certain version of inflation or whatever, I cannot provide
you any information. I am just a journalist. What I do is I provide you the scientific consensus,
and I am consistent on this. So I provide you the scientific consensus on space and astronomy news,
and I also provide you the scientific consensus on global warming, climate change, and what
is happening to our planet. Now, I don't cover it very much because it's not my beat.
I read a lot about it, and I'm really interested in what's going on out there.
But anytime I mention climate change, I promise you, I am referencing the scientific consensus,
the thing that almost every single scientist agrees upon, and that there are people who are
funded by oil companies who are looking to try to put off the consequences of climate change,
or try to put off the consequences of having to pay for the costs of climate change as long as
they can. And they have tons and tons of money, and they're doing a very effective job of trying
to muddy the water as best they can. But reality, nature is the ultimate arbiter, and we are
experiencing it every day. I am in Kyoto right now, and they broke a temperature record. I left
home, and they broke a temperature record. We're seeing temperature records broken. Anyway, I don't
need to justify it, right? Obviously, the scientific consensus is in, and that is a very urgent thing
that we need to take action on. And we see what's happening with the Strait of Hormuz, how dependent
the world is on what is essentially an archaic form of energy production, and it's time to move
to the age of electrification. Now, I'm going to use this opportunity to pitch and promote a bunch
of other channels that I think are doing just a fantastic job of explaining the scientific
consensus in ways that I just can't do it. So check out Just Have a Think, fantastic channel.
Simon Clark, who is a climate change researcher. Professor Dave Explains does a beautiful job of
debunking people who have specious arguments about climate change. And then Potholer54, again,
fantastic debunker of climate change nonsense. So if you want the scientific consensus on things,
if you are consistent, intellectually consistent, then you should continue watching the channel.
But if you want to pick and choose what you think is the scientific consensus, that's not how the
scientific consensus works. And so you probably don't want to watch my channel. All right, we'll
see you next time.