https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YqqzHwjiqQY

The Technology of Old Crossbows
4 followers
6 Video Views·May 22, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTod from Tod's Workshop analyzes the physics and rigging of an ancient Chinese siege crossbow. By testing mechanical models and examining historical drawings, he explores the complexities of pulley systems, draw length, and vector angles to determine how to maximize the weapon's force and efficiency.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Maximum efficiency, maximum draw length. That is just like a win in every single direction,
if it were true. Hi it's Tod from Tod's Workshop and Tod Cutler here and I have recently made
this Chinese crossbow trigger system but it's not for any old crossbow, it's for a siege crossbow
but the Chinese had all sorts of things and they had ordinary ones and they had crazy ones like
this and that's what I'm going to be making. But as you can see this is not a fantasy thing,
it was a real object and they lasted sort of over a lifespan of about 800 years so they must
have been really good. But the real problem is there is simply not enough information for me
to just go out and make one of these. This drawing is kind of the best I've got and so I had some
initial thoughts to it, very exciting, I've been developing those and that's what this film is
really about, explaining where my thinking is now and then if you can give me any help with it to
develop it on that would be brilliant. And this project started with some simple models to help
me understand what's going on, see the string movements and the bow movements and the draw
lengths but I was kind of pondering things and you came up with fabulous comments. I've been reading
them, digesting them, thinking about them, trying to work out what's going on and why I want to be
doing it. So I warn you this film is really about looking at the physics of the whole thing or at
least me trying to understand it. It's not yet about me building one. So let's start by going back to
this drawing which is my source material. Now clearly it's short on detail, clearly it's been
stylized. I think we can all agree on that and because it's been stylized it means that we can't
truly trust any of the detail in it. However there are some things which I think are going to be
quite clearly correct which is that you have a rear-facing bow here and the two front-facing
bows. I think we have to assume that that's right but then we come to things like the distance
between the bows. Can we trust that? Well I don't think we can. I think that is just a stylization.
So why have I jumped in and assumed that immediately? Well have a look at this eastern
style bow. It's a cheap fiberglass one but it's a recurve, the same sort of format as that. Now if I
pull that back, look how far those limb tips are coming back. That is the way it operates efficiently.
That is the way those bows are designed to operate and what you then need is a bow on this side and a
bow on that side with enough distance between them that the limb tips will clear each other
plus a little bit of distance to sort of ease your rigging. Now you might say well what you could do
is just overlap the movement of the bows and then you'll compact up your machine which is going to
be a good thing but the problem with doing that of course is that if you have a rope tied off on
this limb tip and a pulley on that limb tip once they start to curve in if they get beyond that
point they can't exert any force on each other anymore and that means that they could get to
that point which would not be in that drawing maximum draw at all and they can get no further
so there has to be a greater distance between those two bows that is shown in that stylized
drawing. So at least in my head I'm very clear that these two bows here need to be separated
further apart but then we come to the actual way that all of the string rigging is done.
Now we can agree on a few things it's short on detail, it's not very clear, it's obviously quite
complicated and I'd also say it's quite clear that it involves the sort of sliding strings
I'm going to use the word pulley if you want. So of course what's really annoying for me working
on this is that whatever detail is going on here where the strings pass is missing and they've
missed it for one of two reasons either it was there and they didn't put it in or the detail
was so simple there was no need to put it in which would mean that the strings were passing over the
bows. No pulley, no ring, no nothing, nothing to show. So if there was nothing to see or if they
just didn't show the technology what options were there? Well if there was nothing to see that means
that the string is probably going through a groove over the ends of the bow or through a hole here.
Now that might or might not give you string management issues because we're used to seeing
a bow just sort of come back and you don't think much about it but have a look at the slow motion
footage by Andreas Bickler on a composite crossbow Western European but if you don't know his work
it's extraordinary go check his channel out it's fantastic but you can see from the slow motion
footage the bow is twisting rippling moving about that may well give you string management issues
even if it doesn't pulling the cord over wood even if it's greased is going to be higher friction
than a pulley and that is why we moved away from the old traditional pulley blocks where you did
exactly that where the rope just slid over a polished wooden surface and moved towards wheels
because it works better. So I'm going to assume that the Chinese understood that things worked
better than just pulling it through a wooden groove so they might have done it through a
metal ring and again it's going to be lower friction than a wooden groove but if it's a
little metal ring and they haven't shown it that's fine but again it's going to be quite harsh on the
string it's going to wear the string faster it's going to wear the string faster than a pulley
would and they understood pulleys they knew pulleys they had them so as far as I'm concerned
that's the way I'm going to look because I think that's what they would have done.
And now a word from Todd Cutler. Our Black Friday sale has finished but don't worry we're rolling
straight into our Christmas sale as you can tell but we loved our advert so much we're showing it
to you again. There's Fridays and there's Todd Cutler Black Fridays and our prices are on fire.
We're slashing prices. We're smashing prices. Some of our prices are even cut in half.
The Todd Cutler Black Friday sale. Do not miss it. And back to the film. So now I've decided
roughly where I'm going to position the bows on the actual machine. I've decided that I'm going
to use pulleys. I need to know how I'm going to rig the bows up. So when I started looking at this
and what I got really excited about was the opportunity to maximize the draw length. Now I
mess around with bows quite a lot and I do understand that draw length has a vast impact
on how fast and how powerful the arrow travels. So as an example I make crossbows, Western European
ones, but I make a balustrino. Tiny little bow and it's got a draw length on it about 45-50
millimeters. But it has a 200 pound bow on it. But it delivers so little energy it's almost
laughable. It was a toy. But if I then translate that to a 200 pound full-size crossbow, suddenly
you're getting something that is man-killing. Same power of bow but the power stroke, the distance
that it pushes the arrow over is very different and the end result is. So that seemed to me like
a really obvious thing to do, maximize the stroke. And you can do that by tying off the cord here at
the top, passing it down, putting it through a pulley or a ring, coming up to another pulley or ring
and suddenly you're getting very very long power strokes out of relatively small bows.
Well that is going to be exciting and I got excited. However, and correct me if I'm wrong
because I think I'm on pretty shaky ground here, my physics is very old, but I think what's going
on is that we have a two-to-one reduction on a pulley here and a two-to-one reduction here. So
two plus two is four. What that means is that you will get out of this system four times the power
stroke. That was what was getting me excited. That is, if you assume that there's a 50 centimeter
power stroke on each of these bows, multiply that by four, that is a two meter, two meter power
stroke on the arrow. So I'm like dancing in joy, this is absolutely brilliant. But the flip side
of that, of course, is there is a four-to-one reduction in the force. And so what that means
is it's not going to be, let's say, thrusting with 100 pounds of thrust all the way through
that two meter length. It's going to be doing it at 25 and that is not quite so exciting. But the
thing that was abundantly clear to me is that these bows would then need to be of different
weights. And if there's one thing we know about the Chinese, they do like to try and standardize
things as much as they can. And it would strike me as odd that this one would be a quarter weight
of this one here. So my first thoughts are beginning to become a little less exciting.
I have non-standard bows, I'm thrusting the arrow with a quarter of the force that it might
otherwise do if I rig this differently, although the draw length is longer. But then we also have
four pulleys in here. And although pulleys reduce friction, they do not eliminate it.
And so now we have four pulleys, all of which are introducing friction into the system.
So what I suddenly got excited about in that first film and thrilled about, I am now very much
doubting. And I don't think my initial thoughts about it were on the right track at all. So what
happens if we simplify the system? We remove some of the complexity out of it. Well you can
tie the bows together here and here. That means that you're losing two of the pulleys out of the
system, just leaving these two here. That reduces the friction. But you have also reduced the draw
length. But you've increased the power of the thrust on the bolt. So you're losing some things,
you're gaining some things. But I think overall what you have is a far more plausible system.
But now I also think you're beginning to be able to look at standardizing the bow weights for
having a bow weight of one, one and one. As opposed to quarters and halves. At first glance it looks
like this system should work really well. So these two bows here are tied together to create a bow
weight collectively of two. You have a bow weight of one here, that's obviously half of that. But
you have a pulley reduction system here. And so the force that it's supplying equalizes over the
two. As you draw it back, first glance they should all deflect about the same. Absolutely brilliant.
Now that is an ideal situation because what it means is all the bows are going to deflect
to the same amount. So you can keep on drawing that till they're all at maximum deflection,
maximum efficiency, maximum draw length. That is just like a win in every single direction,
if it were true. But look at this again. The front bows are flexing more than the rearward bow.
Even though they're all the same, even though in my understanding they should flex the same.
And it's not just me that's having this problem. Have a look at this video by Stephen Gardner
of his machine and look at the rear bow on it. And you'll notice that the rear bow is actually
relaxing as the front bows begin to come under tension. Once they're at full draw and they start
the stack, the rear bow starts to draw. And it gets to about 80% before I run out of stroke.
So I'm trying to wonder what the heck is going on and I can be honest with you and say that I am
totally lost. Now the first reason that I'm beginning to get really lost
is if this pulley system was tied off in a conventional pulley system way,
then I'd understand things a bit better, but it's not. Because this tying point here
is also on a bone limb tip obviously, but that means that it's flexing too.
And so the whole two to one ratio thing that I was trying to work this out on
just is no longer true. So what I'm thinking in fact, is that actually this probably isn't
operating on a two to one, it's probably operating on a one to one. It's just increasing the draw
length, that's all it's doing. But remember these two bows collectively together are twice
the weight of this one. So in my head now I'm thinking that this, but these two bows should
flex half as much as the rear one and that's not the case. But if that wasn't enough to muddy the
waters, there's another aspect which does. So this central bow here is being drawn with vector angles
on the string here, so basically like a conventional bow would be drawn. But the front bow and the
rearward facing bow are going with the zero vector angle on the string, they are being pulled directly
and that is not how bows are weighed. So what that means is that these two outer bows will
inevitably be operating in a different way, they are operating in a different way to this central
one. So they might all be 100 pound bows, but it doesn't mean that they would all exert 100 pounds
into the system. Vector pull, bringing the limb tips in. Straight pull, pulling them straight down.
They are different things. We're going to try a little experiment now to show the importance of
vector angles and how that changes everything. So this bow here is, oh I don't know, 15 maybe 20
kilos in draw weight, something like that. I'm going to mount it in the vice and I'm going to draw it
using a crane scale, a measuring scale, from the center of the bow here. Tomash is going to come in
and he's just going to measure a distance, limb tip to limb tip, and I'm going to repeat the
experiment again, but doing a straight draw where there is zero vector angle. Tomash, come on down.
So big crane scale, it's going to come into the middle. I'm just drawing that now. So we have got
88 centimeters and that's 13 and a half kilos. So 13 and a half kilo draw and it's 88 centimeters
tip to tip. Let's do that with zero vector angle. So we're repeating the experiment now
with a straight draw on it. So I'm just going to load it up. There we go, 13.5 and what's the distance?
113. So previously at 13 and a half kilo draw it was 88 centimeters and this time it was 113.
That is a huge difference. That shows the importance of vector angles. It shows the way
bows are designed to work. So suddenly now what we're going to be doing is using two bows, the
forward and the reverse, in a totally different way. So the fact that all three bows are the same
draw weight actually doesn't matter because they're not operating with the same draw weight.
So that's all very interesting I'm sure, but what does it actually mean to my triple bow Chinese
siege engine crossbow thing, the oxbow? Well fundamentally it means that however much I may
want these bows to be exactly the same, I do not envisage that at all. I cannot see it because you
have now, as far as I'm concerned, two different bow weights. These ones have to be different to that
and you have three different positions for all of these bow weights and that's just assuming that
the rigging is done correctly. So there's an awful lot of variables in here, none of which we know
and I haven't got years and years to work all this through. I haven't got generations of craftsmen to
work it all through. So where does it leave me? Well simply put, it leaves me out of my depth.
I don't really know what's going on here because I seem to have conflicting information, conflicting
logic. I don't have enough information from making it. There are too many variables. So this is,
as far as I'm concerned, even if we can put it through some sort of engineering finite analysis
type bit of software, there is so much research work for me to do because, you know, force distance
curves are not constant on these bows, that I can't even just hand it over to an engineer and
ask them to solve the problem for me. So I have got two choices and the first one is go back to
university, do a PhD and spend three years studying this thing. The second one is buy some bows and
just make it work and I think you all know me well enough to know which option I'm going to take
because that's not going to be a PhD. So if you have suggestions, if you have ideas, please throw
them out there because there is some really weird stuff going on here I don't get. But the other
thing of course is clearly I'm going to need a little bit of a variety of bows to do this. So if
you're a bow shop, if you're a bow manufacturer and you want to sponsor me doing this, bring it on, I am
going to talk to you because I've got a few bows to buy and I have got a really exciting, really
interesting project to do with them. But before we go, you may have noticed that I'm wearing an Arrows
vs Armour 3 t-shirt. This is just a reminder to you that it is coming soon. So for those of you
who are not familiar with the Arrows vs Armour series, go check them out and just, you know,
bookmark the page, do whatever it is you need to do, but make sure you watch those films when they
come out. It's not going to be long now. And then the other thing as well is just to say if you like
this kind of content, we have fantastic websites that you are going to be interested in. Everything
we sell on them is going to be of interest to you. And then of course finally I have got my second
YouTube channel, Todd Cutler, and our Patreon page which is enormously useful, especially if I can't
find a bow sponsor. So anyway, bring it on. I hope you've enjoyed it. It's been a talky one this, but
there's been a lot to go through and a lot on my mind with this. Join me. Come and make it happen.
Work it out for me. I don't know, just help, whatever. Anyway, I hope you've enjoyed it and I'll see you again.
Sorry, I've had to come back again to show you this. I was thinking last night, I rigged it up
again this morning and check this out. All the bows bend the same. So I've worked out how to
balance the bows and to make that work, I actually have a formula for it. Methodology. Still don't
fully understand what's going on with pulleys and things, but anyway, what it does mean is that
there's going to be a part three where I explain my methodology and that gives me the information
to go and buy the bows.
