I Tested The 57 Samsung Ultrawide To See If It s Worth It

SilkRoad Technology
124 followers
#technology #highend #gadget #robot #apple #iphone #macbookpro #gaming #accessories #gears #samsung #tesla
Video Summary
AI Generated**Summary**
I'm upgrading my already huge 49 inch ultrawide to the largest ultrawide monitor in existence
at a whopping 57 inches, which almost sounds like it's too big.
But so many people swear that once you make the jump, 49 inches starts feeling small.
In fact, it might even be pathetically tiny.
But how can that be?
So is it true?
Is going bigger actually better?
Or is this some type of copium for trading in their nice OLED panel for a mini LED one?
But first, let's back it up.
Because you don't just suddenly decide you want to switch to a super ultrawide monitor.
It's super!
Well, super is 32 by 9.
Not the 16 by 9 that most people are used to.
A monitor like this doesn't just magically jump into your life.
No, no.
You make the decision to save up the money for months and then apprehensively go to buy one.
It's a life-altering decision.
One that you hope will completely transform your life.
Or at least that was my case.
I wanted to be more productive.
Now before this, I had a simple 124 inch monitor setup.
It was limiting.
It was so small.
And if you're talking tiny, that felt tiny.
This is my 49 inch Samsung G9 OLED ultrawide that I got last year on sale for about $900.
And I got what I wanted.
My productivity with this thing was through the roof.
I could have Discord, my calendar, my notes, browser, Notion,
even multiple file folders all open at the same time.
Just sprinkled across my monitor.
Whenever I wanted to focus on something, I would move it to the center.
No more are the days of minimizing and maximizing windows or holding alt tab
until you got to the app you wanted to use.
That was all a waste of time.
But it wasn't all fun and games.
Sure, the OLED panel looked beautiful with the inky blacks and the complete array of colors.
But it also came with the downsides of OLED too.
Burning.
Now people say it's a thing of the past.
But honestly, after spending $900 on a monitor, it almost feels like you have to baby it.
You gotta hide the taskbar, change the wallpaper regularly,
sleep your laptop, or undock it all together.
If I wanted more responsibility, I'd go and have a second child.
The OLED made me physically change my actions,
do things I wouldn't have considered before.
All because of the risk of burn-in that sat there in the back of my head.
Now if you ask me, I'll tell you I don't care.
I don't care if I get burn-in.
But truthfully, my actions say otherwise, don't they?
It was also a 1440p monitor,
which meant that all my screen recordings would have to get stretched out to 4k for our videos.
Now for normal monitor users, this isn't much of an issue.
But as a content creator who takes almost 100 screen recordings a week for videos,
it really added up.
And with OLED, the brightness also didn't get very high.
It had a maximum brightness of 400 nits,
which I was happy with.
I thought it wasn't that bad.
Until I saw the crazy brightness of the AOC Mini LED monitor we tested in another video.
Then the difference became obvious.
So despite my constant issues, I enjoyed being part of the OLED posse.
Is that what people call it?
But over time, the issues piled up one by one until it became overwhelmingly large.
So large that something had to change.
The decision then became, well, which monitor?
It had to fit a certain criteria.
The first one, it had to be 4k.
If not, then it's not really an upgrade.
So I looked around with OLED still at the forefront of my list of desires.
I love the colors too much.
I can't give up my inky blacks, you know?
I looked to see if there was a decently affordable 4k tandem OLED
that wouldn't make my wallet cry.
They're like OLED, but brighter.
It's basically taking OLEDs and just stacking them on top of each other to make them brighter.
But a quick search showed that most of these tandem OLEDs that were also 4k
were announced at CES this year.
That meant that either weren't available or they were way out of my budget.
Plus, none of these were truly super ultra wide either.
One of the other options was just to yoink the AOC Mini LED,
but I quickly realized that it was a 1440 display.
So that left the next best option.
When I bought my 49-inch monitor last year,
I saw that Samsung had an even larger monitor called the Samsung Neo G9 Odyssey
and when I looked, they were running a huge sale for $1,500 down from $2,300.
Were the monitor gods calling to me from above?
Shoving me towards the edge of jumping into the deep end?
But what's the point of this fancy new monitor
if I can't get every single 4k pixel in full quality?
So that's where today's sponsor comes in.
This is the Ugreen MaxiDock Thunderbolt 5 docking station.
Their newest in their long line of high quality Thunderbolt docks.
With Thunderbolt 5's massive up to 120 gigabits per second unidirectional bandwidth,
driving this full dual 4k panel with room to spare is no problem
and it's fast enough to transfer a 6 gigabyte 4k movie in about one second.
This dock is capable of up to three 4k 60hz monitors for Windows
and a single 8k 60hz for Mac.
That is a lot of pixels for one singular cable.
Enough about my insane person monitor though.
What about benefits for the normal person?
Well the box says 17 in 1 for a reason
because this dock can do basically everything but write your taxes for you.
Every single port you can find is maxed out.
You have a full 8k display port,
two Thunderbolt USB-C display outs,
2.5 gigabit ethernet port,
three 10 gigabit per second USB-A ports,
three 10 gigabit per second USB-C ports with up to 240 watts total power,
a micro SD, full SD, and three headphone jacks.
And that still wasn't all.
There's a dedicated M.2 SSD at the bottom.
Just nuts.
In real life terms, this dock can keep even heavier duty laptops fully charged,
support all your peripherals,
expand your storage,
and drive even the heaviest of monitors all through a single cable.
Even after 24-7 hours at top load, it stays cool to the touch.
If any of that sounds good to you,
be sure to check out the link in the description to get 22% off.
The sales page made it sound pretty good.
Dual 4k, which is basically two 4k screens right next to each other.
It's like having two monitors, but in one.
It's also got HDR 1000 so it goes as bright as the AOC
and 240 hertz for all the high-speed competitive work that I do on a regular basis.
But the one thing that made me question this entire decision was mini LED.
Was I ready to shed my identity of a person who happens to own an OLED display?
What would that do to my pride?
The more I thought about it,
maybe it's not a healthy thing to pair your self-identity to a random feature on a monitor.
That sounds a little bit ridiculous, doesn't it?
Plus, what if mini LED is better?
It's brighter, more vibrant, maybe.
And the biggest kicker is that it is a 4k super wide monitor.
It met all my needs.
So while teetering on the edge of decision,
the team kept pushing that it was good.
It was a good choice.
It erased a lot of the problems that we've been experiencing.
Plus, they themselves were curious about a monitor that big.
57 inches is almost as tall as I am.
It's crazy.
So I pressed add to cart and proceeded to checkout.
And whew, even on sale, it's a hefty price tag to swallow.
And what would become of my old monitor?
Well, that worry quelled quickly since our production guy,
Zach, just claimed it up as his own the moment we set it up.
And that was it.
All that was left was to wait for it to arrive and then set it up.
A couple days later, a huge box arrived.
And it sat there for at least a week before someone, aka me,
decided to push it over to my desk and announce,
we're setting this up today.
Switching at that point seemed like a hassle.
The excitement from buying it had already faded
and now it was sort of a chore.
Which isn't wrong because the setup process was a pain in the butt.
First, the box is as big as I am and the monitor is so heavy
that I needed an entire team of people to help me.
Okay, it was just me and Jake.
The others just witnessed our struggle and laughed.
The included monitor stand is massive.
It took up like 50% of my desk.
So that wasn't usable.
The next viable solution was to use a monitor arm.
But the Neo G9 weighs approximately 34 pounds without the stand.
Is there even an arm that can support it?
Luckily, I had the secret lab heavy duty monitor arm
laying around in storage that I got from my previous monitor.
But I never set it up.
So this thing can hold up to 35 pounds with a maximum screen size of 57 inches.
Now that's oddly specific, isn't it?
And to my surprise, it did hold up.
No matter how precarious the setup process ended up looking or feeling.
It's mostly Samsung's fault because the vest amount is so recessed back
that if you wanted to use a monitor arm,
you have to screw in a weird cylindrical hat thing
and their screws stripped so easily.
There was a moment of panic when we thought
what if we strip these screws all together?
Would that be it?
What if it's stuck like that forever?
Luckily, my dexterous fingers eventually got the job done
and when we removed the supporting box, it held steady.
It worked.
That was way too stressful
but even now the part sticking out the back sort of leans forward
in a way that I'm not sure if it should.
It's been a while so I think it'll be okay.
Anyways, it was time to use it.
Well, not yet since I had to plug it in still.
On the back, there's a couple ports.
More than I expected.
Surprisingly, the power cable did not include a huge power brick like the 49 inch G9
but it's a very short cable.
It has two HDMI ports, one of which goes up to 120 hertz,
a display port as well as a USB hub
and these strange square USB ports called USB type B
which lets you use two different computers as like a KVM switch.
Unfortunately, there's no USB-C
which for this price, I mean, what are you doing, Samsung?
But for me, I just ran one display port cable from the Neo G9
to my CalDigit TS5 plus dock.
This might have actually been my first mistake
since I opted to use my own cable thinking,
ah, they're all the same.
Well, they're not.
The display cable I should have used is the one that was in the box.
The one that I've long since thrown away
but fear not, I purchased another one.
A display port 2.1 cable from Ugreen
and I'm waiting for that to ship right now.
The new display port 2.1 standard lets you get up to 240 hertz with 4k
while the display cable I used does not do that.
So if you get a monitor this good, you gotta do all the juice, right?
Thank goodness I won't be gaming on this thing though
so maybe I'm not that disappointed in this situation.
The first few days, every time I sat at my desk,
there was one recurring thought going through my head.
It's just too big and with my Mac that I dock daily,
I have to go through this strange ritual of zooming everything in
from 100% to 150% just to make it look normal on the monitor.
Unlike Windows, Mac doesn't have a universal scaling
where I can just bump up everything bigger.
My time in the corner, the little icons, the menu, they're all teeny tiny
and sometimes I can't tell if I'm getting older and blind
or if Mac is just dumb or not having these features.
Really, it's got to be the latter
but also it might be time for me to get new glasses
and the best part is when I undock the laptop and use it normally,
everything stays 150% zoomed in
so I reverse the ritual to get it back to 100%.
Wasting time and energy doing something that should automatically do itself.
Again, not blaming the monitor.
This is clearly a Mac issue.
So Apple, for the love of what is right,
just do a quick software update for universal scaling
for people who want to use 4K.
With that aside though, it really is a big monitor.
I hope that I would settle over the next couple weeks
and I too would end up with the conclusion
that 49 inches was laughably small.
That didn't hit quite yet.
What hit first was how bright this thing got.
It boasts a thousand nits of brightness
so I cranked it all the way up to the max
only to squint and look away.
Well, it's way too bright
so I lowered it to about 72% brightness.
Much more comfortable and even at 72%,
it still feels like more than double the brightness of my OLED monitor.
Out of the box when monitor settings were set on warm one,
which offsets how blue monitors usually are
when they're initially tuned,
the colors are vibrant and if you're not looking for it,
you won't notice a huge difference from OLED.
If you look, well, you'll see it.
We'll talk about this soon.
So it has dimming zones,
especially if they're small black areas in the image
that are smaller than the dimming zone size.
It produces this unwanted halo effect
or the blacks get a little more gray instead of being black.
But that's just when I looked at images
and really stared at the pixels
from a few inches away from the screen.
A technique I learned from my most display obsessed writer.
You would be proud.
But what about a more realistic situation
like watching HDR content?
Avatar HDR to be precise.
So my monitor newbie eyes thought,
hmm, this looks great.
Absolutely fantastic.
It's bright, it's got contrast, good color,
nothing to complain about.
But that was just me.
So I got some more experienced monitor owners on the team to take a look
and boy, they took a look.
But really, we'll never know what the movie team truly intended.
Were the scenes supposed to be more blue?
Were the dark areas supposed to be black?
Or maybe reflect the moonlight from the surrounding rocks?
The world may never know.
We played a couple videos side by side.
Fruits in 4K HDR, one of our favorites.
And between the OLED versus the new mini LED,
there were some pretty stark differences.
The color volume on the OLED is just so much vaster.
The blues get way more blue.
The reds get more red.
While the mini LED wins on brightness,
which sort of boosts your perception of saturation.
As it turns out, different levels of saturation can make
two objects with identical brightness seem way darker than each other.
And to that same end, a display with greater brightness
means the perceived saturation of colors can be boosted,
especially if the scene is bright.
Keyword, bright.
But all of this we compared in a video a couple months ago,
comparing the AOC mini LED to an OLED monitor.
So you can watch that if you want to learn more.
But what I didn't realize is that because the Neo G9 is so big,
the dimming zones themselves would also be big,
even though it has over 2,000 dimming zones.
In a dimming zone test, you'll see the blooming effect
on small and medium sized objects,
especially if the objects themselves are very bright
and surrounded by a dark background.
So it looks like it would be way worse,
but while using it, honestly, you barely notice it.
Another really awesome improvement that took me way longer
than I wish it did to notice was the letters weren't fuzzy anymore.
So because of how OLED pixels are arranged in a triangle,
the text may look fuzzy or blurry, especially when they're small.
So when I first switched to OLED, I used dark mode all the time,
but that made the letters even fuzzier.
So I switched to light mode
and now I guess I'm Stockholm syndromed into being okay with blurry text,
but apparently that actually isn't due to it being OLED,
just how the pixels are arranged in a triangular pattern
instead of a stripe, which is what LCD and LED panels use.
And on a mini LED, those issues don't exist
because the letters are clear as day.
Because it's mini LED though, that also means it's a VA panel.
Now that may mean nothing to you
or it makes you want to cross this thing off your future purchase list.
VA panels don't look good from every angle,
just a few degrees off axis or up or down
and it starts to look washed out.
So you would think that a monitor this wide would look bad,
but if you're at the center, looks really good.
So they added more curvature from the previous monitor
to account for this added size and the fact it's a VA panel,
which means if you're the one sitting in the center of the desk
and it's curving around you, it looks great.
Even the blooming pattern doesn't look that bad if you're looking at it head on.
Now I know what you're thinking, Betty.
Only using a MacBook on this thing isn't doing it justice.
Well, I agree.
HDR on Macs stinks.
It makes everything dim and bleak.
It's so much better on Windows 11
where they have an auto HDR feature that goes from SDR to HDR
depending on your content.
It seriously sounds like I may just have a problem with my MacBook.
Uh, yeah.
They're made to work within the Apple ecosystem,
but there's zero chance I'll be getting myself a studio display anytime soon.
So there's so many people that can't even imagine
switching to something smaller than this
and I too hoped that it would become my new norm.
You know, when you first move into a place and you don't like it
because it's new, it's different,
but eventually it becomes your beloved home.
That's what I need to happen to me.
But in the depths of the internet,
I also saw conversations about color calibration,
optimizing your Neo G9 to look its best.
Was that something I had to do as well?
I hadn't messed with any of the settings except brightness
and set it to custom mode,
but really there weren't that many settings to play around with.
It seemed like the biggest thing that mattered
was turning local dimming to high.
That's supposed to increase the contrast
between your whites and your blacks.
So I did.
That's nice.
So with how big the monitor is,
you have the option to do a picture-in-picture or a picture-by-picture.
And what that means is you can use the display
as if they're two completely separate monitors,
but they just happen to be on the same panel.
I attempted it since it's a really cool idea, right?
But to do that,
you have to connect an HDMI display cable to the monitor
alongside a DisplayPort cable or two HDMI,
neither of which my dog has.
So I did have to buy USB-C to HDMI,
but then the problem became,
there's still the separation in the middle.
I much rather prefer a seamless one screen experience.
You could also do three.
Then you need a DisplayPort and two HDMI
and that's a lot of work.
Speaking of work,
the biggest problem with having one seamless monitor like this
is when you want to stream or record your entire monitor.
Just looks so bad in its 32 by 9 form factor.
You have to be intentional of which screens or areas you record
instead of going for the entire display all at once.
And this is good and bad.
For the good, you get 4K recording,
no matter where you're at,
no matter what you do.
But it's bad since you're recording one window
and if you happen to jump to the next,
you have to remember to go into OBS to change that setting.
Otherwise, it's messed up and you got to do it again.
So it's different workflow,
but once you get used to it, it's not too bad.
I've already learned the workflow on my previous G9,
so it wasn't anything new.
But to anyone who's never used a 32 by 9 monitor,
it's quite an adjustment the first time around.
So remember how I thought I threw my special DisplayPort cable away?
Well, I didn't.
In fact, I popped open the plastic and there was a thick display cable.
So I looked around and apparently,
MacBooks just cannot support 4K 60Hz monitors.
They can only do three,
which means it's missing that one extra one to run a dual 4K monitor at 240Hz.
It's a little complicated,
but once you read the specs,
you start understanding that to make 4K 60Hz to go to 240Hz,
you have to multiply it many times over.
And that is a lot of data.
So days pass and then weeks and every day,
I get to work,
I dock my laptop,
just have all my programs already open to where they need to be.
It was pretty cool.
It feels like you have a lot more room to play with compared to the 49-inch monitor.
Almost half of my entire monitor is just dedicated to just windows floating there
so that when I do need it,
I can drag it and then move it back when I'm done.
So the real question is,
compared to the 49-inch monitor,
is the 57-inch monitor that much bigger?
And I would say yes.
And I think that's because of the 4K aspect.
It gives you so much more room to play with.
But the Neo G9 ultimately makes my life simpler.
Lighter.
I don't have to worry about OLED burning.
It's bright.
It's big.
Improves my workflow.
And once you have it set up,
it really is a great monitor.
Except for maybe the flaw where all the ports are covered by a piece of curved plastic.
But you can forego that completely.
After all,
no one's looking at the back of your monitor.
Speaking of the back though,
it has a really round,
cool RGB thing just like the G9.
But again,
not something I ever look at.
So I think it's off right now.
So if I really had to choose,
I think the Mini LED fits my lifestyle a bit more.
It's great for work with its 4K resolution.
And it reduces any future anxiety about burning.
With all that though,
which one would you pick?
