AirPods Pro 3 Are They Really Worth 250

SilkRoad Technology
124 followers
#technology #highend #gadget #robot #apple #iphone #macbookpro #gaming #accessories #gears #samsung #tesla
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker compares the Apple AirPods Pro 3 to the Pro 2, highlighting updates in design, connectivity, and health tracking. While the Pro 3 introduces USB-C, improved water resistance, and heart rate monitoring, inconsistencies in microphone quality, muddy bass, and reduced total battery life lead the reviewer to conclude that the Pro 2 remains the better value for most users.
I'm testing Apple's latest AirPods Pro 3s that cost a quarter of a thousand dollars.
That's enough for an entire week of groceries,
which is a lot for a single pair of earbuds.
But when Apple announced their newest earbuds,
they basically changed almost every single thing about them,
except the way they look.
Better sound quality with more bass,
a more secure fit,
new heart rate sensors,
and more water resistance.
But they still look nearly identical to the Pro 2s.
So is this a case of Apple just repackaging their old product and going all in on marketing?
Or is this actually a real upgrade?
And more importantly,
is this just a great chance to get the Pro 2s on a discount?
So I scoured the internet watching all the reviews on the new Pro 3s,
and it seems like they truly are more awesome in every single way.
But reviews aside,
I had to try them for myself and test those claims.
So let's back it up a little because I do already have the Pro 2s,
and I've used them regularly for the past three years.
I shouldn't need an upgrade since I should be plenty happy with my old ones, right?
Well, I am for the most part.
But there are just a couple quirks about them
that make me feel like there could be better options out there,
especially the fit.
They go in the ear great,
but after a couple of minutes,
one of them will slowly slide out,
causing this annoying itchy feeling in my ear.
Is that a personal problem?
Maybe it happens to you too.
Anyways, there is a bigger problem,
and that is the lightning port.
Instead of lugging around only one cable,
a USB-C cable,
I have to lug around two.
It wasn't a big problem before when I was using my older iPhone 13 mini,
but now that most of my devices have switched over to USB-C,
it's become real apparent
that anything that needs a special cable to get charged is maddening.
And yes, I know you can always buy a separate USB-C case
for your Pro 2s that launched about a year ago.
And yes, this is a first world solution to a first world problem.
But who would spend more money on a mere case?
It made more sense to buy a wireless charging dock instead.
And so I was stuck between sticking with 5 Pro 2s
and exclusively charging them wirelessly,
or was the right decision to upgrade to the Pro 3s,
consolidate to USB-C,
and experience all the new features that the Pro 3s boasted instead.
The only way to figure this out was to test them.
So let me preface that this is not one of those videos
where I have squiggly colorful lines
indicating what the audio quality is like.
Go to Critical, one of my favorite audio creators for that, but not here.
This is a true experience of what it feels like
to buy, own, and use the new AirPods Pro 3s.
So when the Pro 3s arrived in the mail,
I almost thought they might've been fake.
The box was scuffed up
and it just didn't give me that fresh new Apple feeling.
It was bland and gray, like a blob.
When comparing it side by side with my iPhone 17 box,
which was pristine, colorful, just looked better in general,
I really did feel like I was being duped.
And to make sure, I went to Apple's website
to verify the authenticity of my AirPods.
So I bought mine from Amazon,
which means that Amazon has to tell Apple
when the product was purchased.
And if they're real,
Apple would have activated AppleCare on that date.
If not, then it wouldn't even register the product
as a valid serial number.
Well, surprisingly enough, they're real.
Thank goodness, that would have been a real hassle
if I, in fact, did have a pair of fake Pro 3s.
Although it would have been interesting,
but I'm glad I don't.
Now that that's over with, I can finally unbox them.
And like other Apple unboxings,
you don't need to search your entire house for a pocket knife.
Nope, you just use your fingertips
and pull off the tabs in the back,
which is one of the best unboxing inventions of all time.
So inside the box, there's some great reading material,
such as a quick start guide,
a bunch of warnings and regulatory papers.
Then underneath them, the AirPods case
with the earbuds inside them.
And underneath that, the new eartips with new sizes
from XXS to L with the default size on them as the mediums.
I know from my previous ones that mediums fit me pretty well.
So I did try small for a hot minute,
but that ended up being quite uncomfortable.
And let's not forget the lack of a USB-C cable
because Apple expects you to already have one,
which I do, but I can always use another one.
I lose them all the time.
You can also charge them with MagSafe
or Qi certified wireless chargers as well.
Ever had a great idea,
then you lose it a couple seconds later?
You know it's genius,
but you can't remember it for the life of you.
Well, this is a little tool I've enjoyed using recently.
That's the world's first AI voice recorder
that's the size of a coin.
It can record all of your ideas
with a single press of a button.
And this is the Soundcore Work.
It's perfect for business owners
who attend a lot of meetings,
content creators who have to juggle
multiple projects at once,
and students looking to take notes in class.
Inside the box is a sleek-looking
coin-shaped audio recorder
in a convenient docking station,
as well as a flexible necklace,
a magnetic ring, and a USB-A to C cable.
It's everything you need to start capturing meeting notes,
ideation sessions, and even simple reminders.
Using it is quick and easy.
All you do is press the button inwards to start recording
and then press it again to end it.
And when there's an important section you want to tag,
just double tap the front of the coin.
After that, it syncs up with the app.
Then you can look at the transcription,
and your important moment is clearly flagged
in the audio timeline
and in the AI-driven summary, too.
If you always have meetings,
the Soundcore Work can detect and label
multiple speakers within a five-meter radius.
And what's crazy is the transcriptions
are up to 97% accurate.
I've been using it constantly
during meetings and on walks.
It's so convenient.
You can clip it to your shirt,
wear it on a necklace,
or the back of your phone.
And unlike most things AI,
your data is encrypted with AES-256.
So if you're always losing your ideas
and wish you had a personal assistant
following you around taking notes,
try out the Soundcore Work using the link below.
And use code SOUNDCOREAI for $35 off,
plus six months of free pro memberships.
Thanks to Soundcore for sponsoring this segment.
So all these extra accessories,
or lack thereof, is nice and all.
But if the comfort of them are poor,
then everything else is rendered useless.
Even if it had amazing audio quality
or cool features like heart rate sensors,
who cares if you can't keep them in your ears
for a long time.
So it was finally the moment of truth.
Well, after pairing them, of course.
So I looked all around for a pair button
that I thought would be on the case,
which is where the Pro 2s had them.
Just this button here.
You just hold this button here for a bit
and it would start pairing mode.
It would light up and boom, ready to go.
But on the new case,
there are no buttons anywhere.
Not on the outside, not on the inside.
So I did what any sane human being would do.
I consulted the documentation.
Yep, I have evolved as a result of using Linux
for the past few months.
And it looks like you hold open the case
and you double tap the front to start pairing.
Sort of a weird decision.
A dedicated button just makes more sense.
Which is also weird because the new case is bigger
with less buttons.
Why? Apple, why?
But then I thought,
it's probably bigger for a reason, right?
Like a bigger battery.
That must be it.
So I went to the comparison page
between the Pro 2s and the 3s
and I was wrong.
The Pro 3s have a longer single charge
at eight hours of play time,
but only 24 total hours with the case
compared to 30 hours on the Pro 2s.
What?
So the earbuds may have more battery,
but the case has less?
I scrolled through the entire comparison page
to find a reasonable answer to my question,
but most of the features were exactly the same.
So what about the size of the earbuds themselves?
Also the same.
Okay, so let's go back to worse battery life.
That sort of stinks, doesn't it?
Sure, you can go an entire workday
with your new AirPods now,
but you have to charge your case more often.
Now, is that a trade-off you're willing to make?
But I just couldn't let this fact go.
I was bent on finding out why the new case is bigger.
And after searching the wide web,
I think I may have found my answer.
It was a way to easily locate your AirPods
when you lose them.
The case has ultra wide band tech
and it now has a better built-in speaker.
So that's fun.
Like the little scientist I am though,
I had to test this out.
My Pro 2s always got lost
in random corners of the bedroom.
Maybe the robot vacuum took it for a ride
or my daughter would play with them
and thus drop them,
resulting in them flying all over the place.
Now, hopefully the Pro 3s
will be the answer to that problem.
So to test this out,
I gave my AirPods Pro 3s,
the case and everything to my production assistant
to hide in various places around the office.
And my task was to find them
using only my ears and my phone to do so.
This might be a little cruel.
He's like 5'2".
And after about 10 minutes
of aimlessly walking around the office
following my phone's instructions,
I found all the cases and the earbuds.
The Pro 3s were much easier to find.
They had a louder speaker,
especially the case.
And the earbuds gave me more to go off
on the Find My app.
But comparatively,
the Pro 2s did really good too.
You could find the case and earbuds pretty easily.
Maybe if you had a ginormous house,
then the louder speaker on the Pro 3s
actually do help.
So I'm convinced for a mere 2mm taller and wider,
it's a good addition.
Plus the new case also appears to be 7g lighter.
I guess they took that out of the battery.
And finally,
after some wireless charging,
they're at 100% and ready to go.
Now I can just put them in my ears
and leave them there for the entire day
until they need to be recharged again.
So if you think that they're just going to feel
exactly like the Pro 2s,
you're wrong.
Although they appear almost identical,
and I mean that.
You have them all on your desk just laying about,
it's pretty tough to tell which are which.
I've just spent all week annoying everyone in the office
with my constant connecting and disconnecting
from my earbuds
because I couldn't figure out which are which.
Apple has changed the angle
at which they sit at in your ears now.
The Pro 2s sit a little more shallow
with a larger portion of the body feeling a bit loose.
Of course,
everybody's ears are different.
So a lot of this is personalized
to my itty bitty and loose ears.
They're not stiff.
With the Pro 3s,
they feel like they go in a little bit deeper
and they sit where they need to.
This at first, though, felt terrible.
Like something was jabbing into my ears forward.
I thought,
there's no way I could wear this for a whole day.
You know that feeling that you get
when you're wearing your earbuds for an entire flight
and afterwards your ears feel a bit sore or worn out?
That's what the Pro 3s felt like
when I first put them on.
But I decided that I would survive
the entire week with them.
So I had a meeting that first day.
Now, I used to think that
microphone quality on earbuds were dumb
and no one should care
because no one uses them anyways.
You just hold your phone up like this and say,
hello?
Until I realized that we as humans
actually go on calls and talk like all the time.
And it's annoying to have to take off your earbuds
just to call someone.
So yeah,
microphones matter a lot more than you might think
or how I thought.
So I connected my Pro 3s to Discord
which processes everyone's audio.
So if these don't sound good on Discord,
they weren't gonna sound good anywhere.
The setup was quick and easy,
no problems,
which was nice.
Until someone said,
hey Betty,
you got a de-esser on or something?
Your S's are cutting out a lot.
And unless there's something I don't know about Discord,
I did not have a de-esser on.
I was just on my AirPods.
So I switched over to my Beacon mic
and they all complimented about
how great the audio was now.
So yeah,
that was a surprise.
Since AirPods are meant to take calls all the time,
I expected a lot more.
So I did a side-by-side comparison
of the Pro 2s versus the Pro 3s in various locations
and this is what they sound like
in those various locations.
Okay,
here is the microphone test
on the AirPods Pro 2s
in our office building
where there's not very much noise
and now there is a little bit of noise
coming from our handy-dandy server.
So same outside,
highway sound,
road sound,
trash trucks around the corner.
I don't really want to walk to the road
because it's a far walk and it's hot,
but I think you get the idea.
Okay,
this is me testing the microphones
on the AirPods Pro 3s
in a decent room in the office.
It's the break room.
It's not the most quiet room
or sound dampened room.
Now we're gonna go over to the studio
which is the best sound dampened room.
So this is the studio
where we got sound panels all around.
There's a rug on the floor
and it is the best sounding room in the office.
Okay,
there's a big 18 wheel truck to my left,
trucks to my right.
You'll see,
I see some cars zooming by.
Not a zooming road,
but it's got a lot of 18 wheelers
like that one.
Whoa.
So the Pro 3 sounds significantly better
like overall
except the part where it keeps cutting off my voice
or sounds super robot-y.
So they sound good
when it's in a good environment,
but when it's not,
man,
they don't sound so good.
While the Pro 2s have less of like a quality peak,
it's more consistent
and performs better everywhere.
It's disappointing that the microphone quality
wasn't what I expected,
especially after the meeting and the various tests.
But surprisingly,
I had realized how comfortable they were too
at no point during the meeting.
And this is like a two hour meeting.
Did I try to like switch them out for something else?
Like how I do with my over the ear Sony XM4s
that give me a sore spot
right at the top of my head.
So yeah,
they're a lot more comfortable than they appear
and they also didn't slide out
and I didn't find myself taking it out
and itching on my ear.
But after about a week of testing,
I realized that was just a lucky day.
Some days they start sliding out,
others they're firmly in there.
Now I'm starting to seriously think
this is a user issue on my part.
However,
there's another test the Pro 3s need to pass
if they want to prove
that they can be the end-all be-all,
only pair you own earbuds.
And that's transparency mode
and noise cancellation.
For a long time,
I stopped wearing my Pro 2s
because I constantly talk to people
all the time,
every day.
They'd be like,
hey Betty,
I need you for this.
And the Pro 2s,
they got in the way of that.
Usually I can't hear someone,
so they have to go tap me on the shoulders,
wait for me to take out my earbuds
and then say,
what'd you say?
But then they'd already forgotten
and we all just wasted a bunch of time.
So I stopped wearing them
and replaced them with either no earbuds
or the nothing ear opens,
which let me hear all of my surroundings
all the time.
It's a bit annoying,
but it solved my problem too.
And that's where we're at now.
The Pro 2s have transparency mode,
but it felt suffocating after about an hour.
Like there's a plunger in my ears
and it felt pressurized.
Plus it didn't feel natural.
You knew you were in transparency mode.
Everything just felt louder.
And that puts the Pro 3s in a tough spot.
A transparency mode that feels natural
with no static and no pressure
is a lot to ask for.
But is it really?
I mean, these earbuds cost a quarter of a thousand dollars.
I should expect them to have top level transparency
and noise cancellation.
I did notice a floor of static,
but it was quiet.
If I had music playing,
even at a low volume,
I didn't hear the static anymore.
But when nothing was playing,
there it was again.
So a few Google searches told me
I had to clean the microphone grill,
but these are brand new.
So I think that's just something I have to deal with,
which leads me to the next state of affairs.
Active noise cancellation.
In a quiet room,
there is a bit of static
when the earbuds aren't playing anything through them.
But let's go to a real challenge.
To the most nefarious place for extra unwanted noise.
The gym.
Where treadmills go to scream
because people are stomping on them.
The gym also has dumbbells and barbells
clanging against each other.
And most of all,
the people.
In fact, there's a dude that moans in the corner
every time he completes a rep on bench press.
These are the kinds of noises I need not hear
when I myself am trying to work out.
At the gym,
when you turn on noise cancellation,
it really does minimize a lot of sounds.
Sure, you hear the rumble in the back,
similar to how it sounds on a plane,
but it's a lot better than without them in your ears.
But regarding the weights clanging or moaning man,
unfortunately, those sounds permeate through the matrix.
They're high pitched and noise canceling works way better
with low pitched consistent sounds,
like unwanted humming or highway sounds.
With loud noises that are high pitched,
like boxes ripping,
it almost feels like these amplify those sounds
in an even more uncomfortable way.
So if someone dropped something around me the other day
and it shocked me,
like where I almost jumped out of my chair.
Compared to my Sony XM4 over the ears,
the Pro 3s have this uncanny active noise cancellation.
So the Pro 3s are a bit inconsistent too,
since they rely on a good seal to work properly,
while the Pro 2s feel even,
like there's zero baseline static
with noise cancellation turned on.
So noise cancellation feels more natural on the Pro 2s,
but the Pro 3s delete more sound.
Now for the fun part,
the newest feature that Apple has unveiled,
heart rate sensors in your earbuds.
Most people probably think this feature is weird
or some strange gimmick,
but actually it could be super useful,
especially to people that work out often
or rely on their heart rate
to dictate how hard or how easy to work out that day.
And to be transparent,
I'm one of those people.
I wear a Garmin watch when I train,
just so I know my heart rate.
This is a useful feature during a workout.
But as someone who currently doesn't own an Apple Watch,
is it still useful?
Without an Apple Watch,
you have to keep your phone unlocked on your fitness app
to see your heart rate while you're working out.
Now maybe this is just an excuse
for Apple to suck you farther into their ecosystem.
I've already got the phone,
the laptop,
the earbuds,
but now they're trying to get me to convert to the watch as well.
So to get your heart rate to appear,
you need to have the fitness app on your phone.
And after trying some simple exercises,
jumping jacks,
jogging around the block,
and comparing my heart rate,
the in-ear sensors react a bit faster
than my wrist-based sensor on my Garmin watch.
Now apparently,
wrist-based trackers aren't as good
because you're bouncing up and down.
Most heart rate sensors are worn around your chest
for more accuracy,
followed by at the bicep.
And your ear has some pretty good blood vessels
to take a heart rate reading from.
Now, despite what I said earlier,
the real-life test showed that the in-ear sensors
and the wrist-based sensors were virtually identical.
In fact, my Pro 3s lost my heart rate a couple of times
in my workout.
But when it did get back,
it was all sorts of wrong
before bouncing back up to correct itself.
So it looks like Garmin is still reigning supreme here,
but they also cost an arm and a leg.
A PolarStrap, which is a good alternative,
goes for $110,
while Garmin's go for $300 on the lower-end models.
Anyways, a couple beats off here and there
isn't gonna hurt anyone.
As you may know,
I've been doing triathlon training,
which means I swim, bike, and run.
The Pro 3s have a huge upgrade of water resistance
up to IP57.
This means they can be submerged in water
up to one meter deep.
That's like three feet,
for up to 30 minutes.
So in theory,
you can swim in these at a shallow depth
for half an hour.
But Apple strongly advises that you don't.
You can't shower in them,
you can't swim in them,
even though feature-wise,
they should be able to withstand it.
Comparatively,
the Pro 2s were only splash resistant.
You could sweat and walk around in the rain
and they would be fine.
Another channel, DC Rainmaker,
who I go to for reviews
on anything fitness tracker related,
actually took his Pro 3s into open water
and swam with them.
He could have lost them forever,
but they were fine.
Sure, they don't play music through them
while you're swimming,
but Apple was right when they specified
that they have an IP57 rating.
So I was about to say that the Pro 3s are worth it
with all the extra features,
but then I realized I forgot a crucial change
they made from the Pro 2s.
The sound quality and the increased bass response.
That means, finally,
Apple might satisfy the listening needs
of bass heads all over the world,
which is great.
But is the bass clean or is it muddy?
So I put on my default bass tester,
without me, by Eminem,
on the Pro 2s and the Pro 3s,
back and forth and back and forth.
And to my surprise,
the Pro 3s performed worse.
The bass was intense,
but not in a good way.
The bass on the Pro 2s are clean and crisp,
where the 3s sound like someone has a subwoofer
in their raised truck
and they're blasting music way too loud.
At that point,
I actually thought I was gonna return them.
If they can't do music right,
what's the point of all these other features?
But if you're not a bass head,
other types of music actually sound pretty good.
The volume on the Pro 3s get much louder.
The highs and trebles are crispier.
It has more of a V shape.
Although after about an hour of listening,
I get tired of the intense treble.
But this could be a personal problem,
where I'm just more sensitive to high treble.
So despite starting out on a rocky path
and seriously questioning
whether I should have returned these in the first place,
they're pretty good.
Not perfect, but pretty good.
But are they $250 good?
With the new release of the Pro 3s,
the Pro 2s are down to $199.
And honestly,
I think they've been at that price
for the past few months already.
As someone who had a couple problems with the Pro 2s,
I did come into this looking for a solution
to the sliding earbuds and the lightning port.
And after testing the new Pro 3s,
I can say they've solved those problems
and offered more on top of that.
But they aren't good for their top priority,
which is listening to music.
So no, I don't think they're $250 good.
For most casual music listeners
or those who just want earbuds
that pair well with other Apple products,
the Pro 2s are still crazy good.
And if you also want a great iPhone to go with that,
check out this video right here.
Bye!
