A parody Re:View episode from @RedLetterMedia on the First Punic War! Mike and Rich react to watching the events of Rome and Carthage's great wars for the first time.
This video was a work of love which pays homage to some of my favorite RLM quotes from the following episodes: Best of the Worst: Hawk Jones, Winterbeast, and ROAR Best of the Worst: Twin Dragon Encounter, American Rickshaw, and Infested Half in the Bag Episode 43: The Hobbit - An Unexpected Journey Half in the Bag Episode 63: The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug Half in the Bag Episode 81: The Hobbit - The Battle of the Five Armies Half in the Bag: Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny Half in the Bag: Rogue One Half in the Bag: The 70-Minute Rise of Skywalker Review Star Trek Discovery (Pilot Episodes) - re:View Star Trek Discovery Season 1 - re:View Star Trek Discovery Season 2 - re:View Star Trek: Galaxy - re:View Star Trek: Picard Episodes 4 and 5 - re:View Star Trek: Picard Episodes 6,7, and 8 - re:View Starship Troopers - re:View The Good, The Bad and the Ugly - re:View
Two hosts review a production on the First Punic War, blending historical analysis of the conflict between Rome and Carthage with a critique of the film's quality. They explore the geopolitical clash between Rome's militarism and Carthage's mercantile empire, while humorously comparing historical consequences to the \"plot armor\" found in science fiction tropes like those in *Star Trek*.
Hello, Rich Evans, and welcome to Review.
Hello, Mike.
And today on Review, we're doing
Gremlins 2.
No, we're not.
What?
We're not. I tricked you.
The poster shows Gremlins 2.
Oh.
This is the first review
for something that doesn't exist.
Hit it, Johnny.
Normally, our review shows are about
older movies, but today we're going
to talk about something new because
Rich, you and I have
been waiting a long time.
The antiquity kind of era, like
1,000, 2,000 years ago.
The Punic Wars were a climactic
showdown between Rome and its
North African rival, Carthage.
Stretching over a century, this
conflict would be one of the most
fascinating chapters of antiquity.
We have many threads, major threads
in this storyline, and it's a lot to
wrap your brain around.
I had no idea what was happening the
whole time, and I am
to blame for that.
Partially.
I tried reading books and
I got about 50 pages in
and I got tired of reading the word
fortnight, people moving along
a map and complex details
about this map and stopping and
stopping and camping and moving
around and staying for a fortnight
here and a fortnight.
And I was like, you know,
I need to go out and
play outside.
But it's going to please
lots of bearded
fat guys because I
heard them munching on popcorn,
opening candy wrappers in my ear.
It was like being in a theater with
a bunch of perverts watching porn.
Oh, ****. Yeah.
Who is this for?
I don't understand how this is
supposed to appeal to me.
I enjoyed a lot of elements
of it. A lot of it felt overcrowded
and confusing and padded
and a little too
much happening for my
tiny pea sized brain to comprehend.
But, you know, I
would have to say I liked it
overall, but there's a lot
to discuss.
They said, oh, by the way, spoilers
from here on out.
Spoilers. Nobody's watching this
unless they've seen the movie, so
it doesn't matter.
To understand the Punic Wars,
we must first explore Rome,
Carthage and the chain of events
which led to their ultimate clash.
Rome was the younger of the two
powers founded in
753 BC.
According to legend, it had long
existed as a small backwater
village which squabbled
endlessly with its neighbors,
while greater nations dictated
the wider affairs of the
Mediterranean.
But they never investigate
how to communicate with them, how
to have a peaceful solution.
It's always it's
it's it's their society.
Their society thrives on
the need for an enemy.
They they find the diplomacy
missions kind of boring.
And then when it comes to war,
they're like, all right, let's do
this thing like.
Yet, thanks to this highly
militarized society
with near universal service
and an annual cycle of wars,
Rome would slowly but
inexorably expand across the
Italian peninsula.
It's it's a
fascist society
that just breeds is bred
for war.
There's always someone come up to
replace you in this in this
like automaton society
where you just basically serve the
state.
Yes.
And you are cannon fodder and you
are nothing. You are not not
individual.
Right.
It's a society that's brainwashed.
Totalitarian society is brainwashed
into loving violence, solving
problems through violence.
Opposite them stands Carthage,
founded as a Phoenician colony
in 814 B.C.,
it quickly expanded through
mercantile activities and
naval dominance.
The tendrils of their growing
empire reached across the
Mediterranean and Carthaginian
merchants were world renowned.
Yet encounters with these
businessmen were not always
flattering.
Many stereotypes existed
about such ambitious Punic
men.
His primary motivation
is always money.
But there's this town that's
got like two criminal factions
to it.
And he comes to town and he's
not coming to clean up the town.
He's coming to get these people to
fight each other so he can make
money off of them.
Like he comes into a troubled town
and he just makes everything
******* worse for his own
profit.
Among the most famous
Carthaginians of the era were
the navigators Himilco and
Hanno, who explored the
Atlantic shores of Britannia and
West Africa, respectively.
There was also the legendary
King Malkus, who first laid
claim to inner Libya, and
Margot, who wrote unparalleled
manuals on agriculture.
Records list the deeds of many
more great individuals.
Hannibal, Hasdrubal, Adabal,
Asdrubal, Sakabal, Barakbal.
I can't say these nonsense names
that all sound the same.
Jat Vash.
Sure.
On the planet Vashti.
The villainous Vashjabi.
Oh my God.
We're looking for Daj and Soji Aj.
We're not even capable of having
a coherent discussion about it
anymore.
Anyways.
In the years leading up to the
Punic Wars, both the
Carthaginians and Greeks had
found themselves locked in a
tug of war over the
strategically important island
of Sicily.
There has been lots of violence,
as this collection of clips
will show you.
Each of these conflicts proved
increasingly costly and yielded
an ever more destabilizing
geopolitical situation.
The most recent of these would be
the Pyrrhic War, which saw a
Greek general launch a campaign
of supposed liberation, which
cut through both Roman and
Carthaginian spheres of
influence.
The power vacuum of his
eventual withdrawal drew the two
powers ever closer to
colliding.
Indeed, as the king sailed away
with his army, he is said to have
remarked, quote,
Oh, what a wrestling ground we
have left for the Carthaginians
and Romans.
They were like, bye, saddle
up, get involved in this now.
All of those people are scumbags.
It's just a bunch of scumbags.
The inciting incident for the
first Punic War proved to be a
revolt among the Mamatines
against Syracuse, the latter of
which called for foreign
assistance.
Naturally, both Rome and
Carthage jumped at the
opportunity to dispatch military
forces to the island.
But Rome seems intent on
escalating the matter, greedily
eyeing the prospects of
plundering Sicily themselves.
Is there no place for the
diplomatic, ethical problem
where this, this faction wants
this and this faction wants
that? That was all just war!
I'm going to stab you in the
******* face!
With Rome taking the initiative,
it rallied an army, marched it
to southern Italy and prepared to
make the crossing to Sicily.
However, Carthage and its
superior navy established a
blockade of the island.
Their admiral reportedly boasted,
quote, I will not allow them to
even bathe their hands in the
sea.
He thought that was the most
badass line he ever wrote.
It's so ******* badass.
I started crying.
Yet the Roman commander was able
to easily bypass the blockade,
ferrying his troops over under
cover of night.
For this monumental failure, the
Carthaginian admiral was recalled
and crucified.
How embarrassing.
With the legions making landfall,
Carthage and Syracuse put aside
their differences and formed a
hasty alliance to stop these
outsiders.
But the Romans marched inexorably
south, defeating both armies in
turn.
As they approached Syracuse, the
Greek city-state came to the
negotiating table, ultimately
switching sides and agreeing to
provide logistical support in
exchange for guarantees of their
continued autonomy.
With one opponent thus
neutralized, Rome turned its
sights back on Carthage.
In 262 BC, the legions marched
west, defeating a Punic field
army and managing to capture the
vital city of Agrigentum.
Such victories convinced the
Senate to expand the scope of the
war.
Carthage was not just to be
checked.
They were to be evicted from the
island entirely.
Yet victory could only be
achieved by wrestling control of
the seas from Carthage.
Challenging the top naval power
of the Western Mediterranean
would have been a tall order for
even the most esteemed fleets at
the time.
But there was just one problem.
Rome had never conducted an
overseas campaign before.
In fact, it didn't even have a
navy to speak of.
Such matters had never really
been a requirement when the brute
force smashing of legions into
neighbors had thus far won Rome
its victories in Italy.
This, this, this warrior race
culture is very good.
That hates science.
Science is for fools and
weaklings.
We have the most sophisticated and
advanced technology ever invented
in the universe.
Now let's headbutt each other and
eat raw meat.
Yet, despite a complete lack of
maritime experience, Rome would
assemble a vast fleet of 120
warships in the span of just a
few months.
Who built them?
There's, there's, there's 10,000
of them.
Who is building them and how does
this go unnoticed?
To build this fleet, Rome had to
seek outside help.
This primarily came down to
leveraging the maritime skill of
their Greek subjects and allies.
I like to believe that somewhere
like underground and some, some
like secret place, they're just
doing work.
They're just in charge of
everything.
The warrior guys that kind of
look the other way.
And they get absolutely no
respect.
They get absolutely no respect,
but they provide all the warriors
with the tools they need to, to
kill and murder and create mayhem
and terror in the universe.
Yeah.
They even have time to design and
present the new battlecruiser.
They have something much better,
which is a ship 500 times as big
as a decent battlecruiser.
Okay.
I'm fine.
I'm fine with, I'm, I'm fine with
that.
With its new fleet, the Romans now
set out to finally challenge the
Carthaginians at sea.
The novel Corvus boarding bridge
proved decisive in transforming
naval engagements from dynamic
skirmishes into simple boarding
actions, which favored the
legions.
However, for every victory won
thanks to the Corvus, it seems
that Rome lost an even greater
number of their ships to storms.
Meanwhile, on land, progress
proved fleeting due to the
difficulty of Sicilian terrain
and its fragmented settlements.
The mass engagements of the early
war now devolved into a running
series of small actions between
raiders and garrison troops.
There's a lot of, a lot of scenes
that don't really move the story
forward.
Also just kind of highlighting
the, just like the pointlessness
of the, the, like the lives that
are being lost over nothing.
Like every day they carry a
bunch of bodies back home.
They do it all again.
It's interesting.
It's a, how do you mold this pile
of clay into something?
You've got a premise, you've got
a location, you've got some
random characters.
How do you put these pieces
around differently to make
something that's actually
workable?
So it's fun in that regard where
you watch it and you kind of go
like, Ooh, that was bad.
Oh, that kind of worked.
They could have done this.
They couldn't.
You say that.
I think it was a desperate
attempt to stretch running time.
Eventually Rome once more decided
that the best way to break the
impasse was to expand the scope
of the war, summoning a grand
fleet and army.
They now planned to take the
fight to Africa.
Sensing this danger, the
Carthaginians massed their own
fleet to intercept them.
The resulting battle of Egnomus
was one of the largest naval
battles in history, featuring
nearly 700 warships and 300,000
crewmen.
The Corvus once again proved
decisive in the chaos of battle
and the Romans emerged victorious.
Absolute schlock.
And I loved every second.
That was the best thing.
That's what we need.
With free reign, they now made
the crossing to Africa.
In 256 BC, Roman legions set
foot on foreign soil.
They quickly set about raiding
the lands and put down yet
another Punic army set against
them.
At this point, a demoralized
Carthage sues for peace.
But the Roman commander lays out
such humiliating terms that they
have no choice but to continue to
fight.
Pure ego and id on that man.
To make matters worse, Carthage
recruited the help of a Spartan
officer who retrains their army
and advises them on battle
tactics.
When the campaign season resumes,
Rome's commander throws caution
to the wind and rushes to engage
them immediately.
I don't give a ----.
It is criminally negligent
and it is the most amazing
******* thing I've ever seen.
The Carthaginians sweep down upon
them with nearly 10 times as many
cavalry, which quickly outflank
the legions while a battle line of
100 elephants smashes into them
from the front.
The results are disastrous.
The docile, gentle giant elephant
also just destroys their boat.
They ******* hate boats.
All told, some 10,000 Romans were
killed and shortly thereafter,
nearly 100,000 men are lost in
storms at sea.
The dual losses of this failed
invasion dash Roman hopes for a
quick victory.
Instead, they now resign
themselves to slowly choking out
the last remaining Punic
strongholds on Sicily.
Eventually, Rome pushes Carthage
back to the Western fringes of
Sicily, laying siege to the major
city of Liliban.
In an attempt to further cripple
the enemy, a Roman admiral attempts
a surprise attack on their naval
base at Drapana.
Yet on the eve of the mission, the
augurs consult the sacred chickens.
They are refusing to eat.
It's a bad omen for the battle
ahead.
But rather than rethink his plans,
the admiral exclaims that quote,
if they are not hungry, then perhaps
they are thirsty and throws them
overboard.
Admirals always like once you, once
you ascend from the captaincy to
admiral, then it's like, Oh, I'm
going to do dirty ---- to save the
Federation.
Now, now I'm not a captain.
I can do, I can do nasty, nasty
----.
The resulting engagement was a
devastating defeat for the Romans.
For this failure, the admiral was
recalled to face trial yet because
of his high status, he received a
mere slap on the wrist.
Speaking of Star Trek cliches, you
got the evil admiral who does
sketchy things and no matter
committing a crime, mutiny, stealing
the starship, you know, sabotage,
whatever.
As long as you save the day in the
end, as long as you save the
Federation, it's okay.
Yes.
He didn't get the little trial like
Kirk had and the voyage home.
You're charged of all these *******
crimes, but because you figured
out that whales needed to talk to a
space sausage, your rank is fully
reinstated.
Well, technically not fully
reinstated.
He was an admiral.
He was reduced in rank.
That's what he wanted though.
That's all he wanted.
For eight more years, the war
dragged on.
Though Carthage would continue to
score a few wins, which bloodied
its rival, they nonetheless slowly
lost ground.
In a final bid to end the war, both
sides now rebuilt their armies and
fleets for a climactic battle.
The showdown would occur in 241 BC
at the battle of the Agates
Islands.
There was nothing clever.
It was just like, let's, let's, uh,
let's have everything fight each
other.
Ultimately, the Romans came out on
top.
This was the straw which broke the
camel's back.
Carthage now sued for peace,
agreeing to abandon Sicily, return
all prisoners of war and pay a
huge indemnity over 10 years.
After 23 long years, the war was
finally over.
But how long would such a peace
last?
It's meant to hook you and kind of
throw out a lot of what, what's
going to happen.
Keep you tuned in every week until
it ends.
And then they're going to pull the
rug out from under you and say,
thanks for watching sucker.
Hold up, hold up that bias, hold
up that bias.
We don't know.
And we're going through this like
everybody else.
There is a non, there is a non
zero chance that will be
brilliant.
Okay.
Is that your scientific opinion?
That's my scientific opinion.
There is a non zero chance that it
will be brilliant.