Start your learning journey today with Brilliant and support our channel in the process. The first 200 people to subscribe get 20% off an annual premium subscription!: https://brilliant.org/ArmchairHistorian
Kast, Bernhard, and Christoph Bergs. German Army Regulation on the Medium Tank Company H. Dv. 470/7 Mittlere Panzerkompanie from May 1941. Linz: Bernhard Kast, 2020.
Wheatley, Ben. “A Visual Examination of the Battle of Prokhorovka.” Journal of Intelligence History 18, no. 2 (2019): 115–63. https://doi.org/10.1080/16161262.2019....
Zaloga, Steven J., and Peter Sarson. IS-2 Heavy Tank 1944-73. London: Osprey, 1994.
Higgins, David R. King Tiger vs IS-2: Operation Solstice 1945. Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2011.
Zaloga, Steven J., and James Grandsen. Soviet Heavy Tanks. London: Osprey, 1991.
Music: Armchair Historian Theme by Zach Heyde Prelude Great Wars - Zach Heyde Dawn Without End - Zach Heyde The Architect - Bonnie Grace The Raid - Zach Heyde Thunder from the West - Zach Heyde The Escape Plan Activated - Grant Newman No Time Left - Jon Bjork
The Soviet tankers swelter inside of their KV-1. Until their tracks are repaired,
they're stuck in the remains of a farming village, isolated from the fight against the fascists.
As their driver clambers back into his seat, the tank is engulfed in a white cloud of smoke.
And where there's smoke, there's German armor.
Another red tank explodes as the gun carriage rocks back. The German commander can't wrap
his head around the Russians' suicidal strategy of driving their tanks straight at his dug-in
position. Suddenly, the communists pull up short, tanks scattering. Looks like they want a gun
battle. Looks like a real fight. The Soviet tank crew watches, flabbergasted, as yet another shell
whizzes harmlessly by. The Germans must be getting desperate if they're sending out crews
that can't shoot. The Soviet gunner lines up his shot, homing in on a King Tiger's glossy,
putting to the test how thick this cat's hide really is. Hi, I'm Griffin Johnson,
the armchair historian. With the success of our infantry squad videos, it seemed only fitting
that we tackle tanks as well. In today's video, we'll be viewing a set of three fictional battles
between Wehrmacht and Red Army tanks. Each battle will take place at a different stage of the war,
starting with Operation Barbarossa and ending with the Soviet invasion of Germany.
Although we've done our best to depict each vehicle accurately, it is an undeniable truth
that such matchups were unlikely to occur in reality. Both sides practiced combined arms
warfare, and even isolated tank platoons would almost certainly be accompanied by infantry or
other support. While we have tried to create reasonable scenarios for each of our battles,
please remember that our primary purpose is to match up tanks and see how they perform against
each other, not perfectly recreate historical engagements. Developing the analytical mindset
needed for research is never an easy task. Often, we have to track down old archives,
review grainy footage from the 1940s, or have foreign sources painstakingly translated into
English. Fortunately, today's sponsor, Brilliant, is a website and app designed to get you thinking
like a professional, with dozens of unique courses all designed to help you improve your
problem-solving skills and enhance your academic performance. Recently, Brilliant has been focusing
on bringing their interactive content to a new level, on both new and old courses. I recommend
their Scientific Thinking course, designed to help you gain key insight into how the physical world
works, without overloading you with complicated mathematical equations or mind-numbing technical
data. Start your journey now by visiting brilliant.org slash armchairhistorian to sign up for
free. Furthermore, the first 200 people to use the link get 20% off of an annual premium subscription.
A Russian gunner blinks the stars from his eyes, wiping a thin trickle of blood from his face.
Then a sudden hard slap brings him rudely back to his senses. It's the commander. The gunner
shakes his head, reaching for a shell as he inches back to consciousness. Next to him,
the driver strains against the control levers, poorly oiled hinges screeching their defiance.
The Valin Oblast is poor tank country, and the Ukrainian summer turns this T-26 into an
oven with a gun. The gunner slams his shell home, limp arms pulling him to his sight.
The turret traverses at a glacial pace. Finally, target acquired. The gunner wipes another bloody
trickle away as his concussed eye focuses in on a Panzer III. The commander barks the order.
The Panzer crew braces as the Russian shell whistles toward them, slamming into the Ukrainian
loam. The Panzer commander can't help but chuckle. Soviet gunnery at its finest. The German gunner
rams another shell home, focusing in on the stricken T-26. The young tanker gives his weapon
an affectionate pat. The Russians are protected by just 15mm of armor, far less than what their
50mm shell can easily penetrate. The driver scoffs as the gunner squares his shot. This isn't
war, this is sport. The gunner signals. The commander pauses for effect, then orders the shot.
Another Soviet tank falls before the mighty Panzer battalions.
His reverie is interrupted by an urgent radio call.
It is critical they surround and destroy the blind behemoth, lest it find a way out and cost
more German lives. The gunner looks at the ready rack. Their Panzergrenade 40 rounds could penetrate
the KV-1's turret, but only at point-blank range. The commander acknowledges the radio call and
after a moment's reflection, switches to the intercom band. Looks like they're going for a drive.
The gunner of the KV-1 drums on the receiver of his L-11 cannon. The metal is warm to the touch,
like everything else in the cramped turret. Clanging on the hull, the driver clambers back
into the turret, wiping grease and sweat from his face. The track has finally been repaired,
and they can try to free themselves from the ruined building now. The commander rolls his
shoulders and peeks into his optics. Suddenly, the gunner hears a shocked cry from the commander.
Bringing his own periscope round, the gunner sees nothing but a cloud of dense white smoke.
He curses, feeling the hull vibrate as the driver starts easing them out of the wreckage.
Heart-pounding, he hears the clunk of the gun breech as the loader shoves a shell into place.
Somehow, he knows it will likely be the last round his gun will ever fire, and he intends to
make it count. The torsion bar suspension provides a remarkably smooth ride over the
roughly paved road surface. Riding head-out, the German officer talks to his driver via throat
mic, warning him to avoid potholes and piles of debris. Smoke rounds from the lone Panzer IV
stationed on a nearby hill mark the enemy, while the Panzer III and 38Ts keep their attention.
There are twin T-34s in the village, but they are caught reloading, with one tungsten-cored
50mm projectile punching straight through an unlucky tank's turret ring. The other tank
attempts a riposte, and the hurried shot manages to hit home, striking the ammo rack on a Panzer
38T in a surprisingly tame explosion. Soviet fireworks. The Russians can't help but cheer
in their turret, until a Panzergrenade 40 decides to invite itself to the celebration.
The shell slams headlong into the T-34's armor, failing to penetrate but causing a cloud of
shrapnel to burst from the back of the impacted plate. The Soviet crew are shredded by this
ersatz-buckshot, killed by the very armor that should have protected them. With no unit cohesion,
the remaining Soviet tanks are little more than armored coffins, and the survivors of the German
ambush surrender the moment they realize their foes are inside the village. The greatest threat
remains, however, as the KV-1 retreats to a more favorable position. The Panzer III's boldly give
chase. One breaks through a gap between two T-34 carcasses, as the other pushes down the street
to flank. The Panzer closest engages head-on, a critical mistake. The Panzer IV atop the hill
is unable to support as its vision is obscured by foliage and smoke by the burning T-34s. The
upstart tank is left scrambling to load a new round as the enemy turret slews toward it. It's
not enough. The German commander ducks down into his turret as debris thunks against his tank.
He scrambles into the main compartment to scream at the gunner. The barrel of the 50mm gun depresses
sharply before firing, armor piercing round slicing through the exposed right track of the KV-1 and
mangling the leading road wheel. Now immobilized, the heavy tank is helpless to pursue the two
remaining Panzers. Rather than try to engage it again, the officer radios the Panzer IV to load
high explosive and bring the buildings around the metal menace down. In an instant, it's trapped
again and unable to shoot at anything beyond point-blank range. Although still dangerous,
the tank is no longer an active threat and can be safely ignored until sappers or artillery
are available to destroy it. With clear advantages in communication and leadership,
the Germans almost took the field in our first engagement. Only the superior durability of the
KV-1 prevents us from declaring this a true German victory. During the initial stage of Operation
Barbarossa, Soviet tanks were numerically superior and some were better armed and armored than their
German counterparts. But their advantages in firepower were often undermined by a crippling
lack of unit cohesion. The early T-34 models also featured such bad optics that some took dozens of
hits from German 37mm guns before even realizing that they were under attack. The few KV tanks that
were made also suffered from similar issues, while the BT-7 and T-26 models were too lightly armored
to be used in the anti-tank role. German tanks were also lightly armored but featured superb
ergonomics and intercom systems that let their crews perform far better than their Soviet
adversaries. But it was not all to be sunshine and sauerkraut, as the Germans soon discovered
a chilling fact. Even as the Russians suffered loss after loss, they were learning. It's a fine
summer day in the fields of Prokhorovka. The sun is shining, a gentle breeze shakes the barley,
T-34s are coming over the hills. T-34s are coming over the hills? A German gunner sends a round
flying from the barrel of his Panzer IV, lighting up a Soviet tank in a spectacular explosion.
As the loader racks the breech and scrambles to bring a new round up from the ready rack,
the gunner scans the horizon through his optics. A seemingly endless wave of red tanks have come
to reclaim this territory for the communists. The loader gives the gunner a tap and he lines
up a shot on yet another T-34. A radio call echoes through the cupola.
Between their Panzers and incoming Tigers, the Germans might just repel this mad Soviet charge.
As he sends his shell flying, the gunner can't help but wonder,
why the hell are the Soviets just driving straight at them?
The Soviet driver jams his throttle as wide as it will go.
The commander anxiously grips his handrails, looking through his optics as the German tanks
grow closer and closer. Another shot from that Tiger, another one of his comrades literally
blown away. It seems like madness, but this reckless charge has a grim purpose. Even with
their improved 76mm guns, the T-34s have no hope of penetrating the heavy German Tiger tanks at
long range. So their orders are to close the distance as fast as possible. But as he peers
through his periscope, the commander spots something odd. The muzzle flashes are far too
dim. He focuses in on one. He's realized a mistake. The commander pulls his radio,
barking an order to the mass of T-34s around him. Those are not Tiger tanks. Disperse and
prepare to fire. The Soviet tanks peel off, breaking formation and pulling up at various
ranges along the front. So scattered, the commanders hope to buy enough time to pick
off the German tanks at medium range. It's about time the Russians pulled their heads out of their
borscht. The German commander gives his driver a chuck on the shoulder. Now this should be a fight.
The Soviets begin shooting back for the first time all day, a ragged volley shredding some
unlucky trees and carving deep holes into the Ukrainian soil. The Germans traverse their
turrets in all directions, lining up shots and picking off the now isolated T-34s.
But the Russian numbers begin to assert themselves, as the Germans' fire is answered with a near
constant, though inaccurate barrage from the T-34s. Soon each tank is bracketed like a battleship,
every German tanker knows that's the last shot fired before the end. The Soviet shells begin
hitting home, and the Germans suffer their first losses of the day. Then something comes over the
radio. A Tiger tank crests the hill behind the Panzers. As the sole member of its group that
didn't break down on the way, this Tiger will turn the tide. The Russian commander gazes in
shock at the road junction. That's the Tiger. It cannot end like this. As his sub-commanders begin
filling the airwaves with panicked requests for orders, our commander shouts to his driver.
The T-34 takes off like an armored bat out of Soviet hell, tearing across the remaining distance
and avoiding German fire through sheer luck. A handful of tanks follow suit, and as the T-34s
close to near point-blank range, the commander orders his driver to floor it. They'll dash
through the remaining Panzers and engage the Tiger in a desperate tank melee. Victory will be theirs,
and this field will be retaken for the glory of the Soviet... The commander is suddenly thrown
forward into his optics, the brass mounting knocking him out cold in one strike. The T-34s
crash spectacularly into an old anti-tank ditch hidden in the scrub just before the German
position. A ditch that retreating Soviet infantry had dug just the day before. The Tiger slowly
descends the hill, scattering what T-34s were not foolhardy enough to follow their commander
into the hole. But a couple Soviet shells slam into the thick cat's armor, and some spall goes
into the assistant gunner's eyes. Looks like someone just earned a wound badge. This field belongs to
Germany. By mid-1943, the Red Army was almost exclusively focused on the production of new T-34s.
The need to shift Soviet industry across the Urals had consumed a vast amount of time and resources,
leaving few opportunities to experiment with new designs or update existing ones. As a result, the
T-34 was completely outmatched by newer German designs like the Tiger or Panther, but maintained
superiority in numbers. Furthermore, as the tides turned against the Axis, many German tank designs
fell into enemy hands, where they were analyzed for strengths and weaknesses. With room to breathe,
the Soviets could finally come up with designs able to go toe-to-toe with the finest of German
armor. Our final battle will pit the results of these programs against Germany's own last-ditch
efforts to secure dominance in the field of armored warfare. The loud roar of engines fill
the air around the Soviet-held town of Sandomierz. As a column of eight heavy tanks bulldoze their way
out of the rubble-strewn streets and into the fields beyond. Sitting inside the turret of his IS-2,
with the radio station mere inches away, the commander listens carefully to the reports being
fed to him by reconnaissance elements in the area. The atmosphere inside the vehicle is tense,
but controlled. The four crew members all sharing a long history in the Red Army. A transmission on
the radio informs the men that the German counter-attack is imminent. T-34-85s have already
engaged a column of Panthers a few miles away, but the commander is certain that it's just a
distraction, so he's kept his heavy tanks back near the bridgehead. His suspicions are confirmed
when he peers out of his cupola and spots something moving in the trees a few hundred meters away.
The King Tiger's transmission audibly grinds with the effort of pushing the gigantic vehicle
through the thick undergrowth. The German officer can't help but wince at every tortured sound the
engine makes as his inexperienced driver fumbles with the stiff controls. Taking his platoon
through the woodland was an enormous gamble, but it appears to have paid off so far. Now with the
engine struggling to push them to their top speed of about 10 miles an hour, the King Tigers finally
rumble into the open, ready to bombard Saint-Domierge until reinforcements can arrive. But luck, like so
many other things, is not on his side. As soon as the Tigers emerge from the forest, the officer
sees a formation of Soviet tanks already rolling out to meet him. Seeing he is faced with IS-2s,
the officer makes a snap decision. Charge. He doesn't trust his rookie crews to win a long-range
duel, and the huge 122mm Soviet guns require special two-piece ammunition that makes them
much slower to reload than the German 88mm counterparts. The two vehicles on the flanks
launch smoke grenades for cover, while the others make ranging shots with high-explosive rounds.
The accuracy of his inexperienced gunners leaves more to be desired at the best of times,
much less on the move, and the Soviet tanks react remarkably fast. None hit, but the shock waves are
felt through the holes of every vehicle. The sight of five Tiger IIs emerging from the treeline
briefly shocks the Soviet platoon commander. It's an unexpected play, but years of fighting
the cunning Germans has made him quick to adapt. Fully expecting his first salvo to miss, he takes
precautions by ordering his gunner to wait for the smoke of the volley to clear, then adjust his aim
accordingly. Now the enormous gun breach violently flings itself back towards him,
the 122mm shell landing just two feet from its intended target. Luckily it was a high-explosive
round, and the 3.6kg warhead turns the left track of a King Tiger into metal confetti.
The enemy formation collapses, the other tanks either grinding to a halt or swerving to avoid
further aimed fire. Only the two leading vehicles stay together, presenting their sloped 150mm
thick frontal plates toward the enemy. Now the Soviets must endure the fury of the German KWK
43s while their crews scramble to reload. The near-instant immobilization of one of his tanks
only serves to further dishearten our German officer, but the Soldat draws upon his last
reserves of resolve and begins shouting his formation back into order. His gunner's hands
shake as they align the sights on target, and the first armor-piercing round falls hopelessly short
as a result. As the loader slams the next round into the breach, the gunner takes a deep breath
and aims more carefully. This time, the projectile strikes true, striking an IS-2 in the turret
facing and cleaving straight into the armor. The sight seems to inspire the other crews,
and soon the Tigers are firing in a steady rhythm, easily managing three or four shots
every one sent in return. In moments, another IS-2 is destroyed, then another, and for a few minutes
it seems as if the tide has turned. But then, two 122mm shells strike a Tiger II in its upper glossy
plate. The armor holds, but the welding points don't, and the entire plate slumps downward almost
6 inches, leaving a giant gap. It's the last straw for the rookies, and the two undamaged Tigers both
start to reverse back toward the treeline. But one unlucky Tiger begins to shake violently,
belching acrid smoke as its engine gives its last metallic wail. Cursing his terrible luck,
the German officer tries to rally his men, but is interrupted by a new message.
The Panthers, acting as a distraction a few miles away, have been overwhelmed and forced to withdraw.
Reinforcements have not arrived, and now several dozen T-34-85s are racing toward his position.
Isolated and outnumbered, at least 5 to 1, his gambit has clearly failed. All that's left
is to go down fighting. Towards the end of the war, German forces were constantly on the defensive.
However, their tanks were ill-suited to such operations, and heavy crew losses meant that
many of Germany's most advanced war machines were being operated by raw recruits. Meanwhile, the Red
Army had developed its own corps of battle-hardened veterans who had learned from their mistakes and
The adoption of new guns, such as the 122mm for the IS-2 and the 85mm for the T-34,
also gave Soviet crews a fighting chance against even the heaviest German armor.
German tankers were constantly tasked with near-suicidal missions, while shortages of
critical alloys meant that inferior substitutes were often used in the construction of their
heaviest vehicles. Huge lumbering tanks like the King Tiger also lacked mobility, preventing their
commanders from engaging in the fast, adaptive tactical maneuvers that had defined their
successes during the earlier phases of the war. In the end, Germany was simply outnumbered,
outgunned, and outthought on every level.