Army Drill Sergeant Rates 11 Boot Camps In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider

Army Analysis
8 followers
6 Video Views·May 19, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedRetired Command Sergeant Major Lamont Christian analyzes the realism of boot camp depictions in media. He compares Hollywood tropes with actual military standards, distinguishing between genuine training methods—such as weapon proficiency and physical conditioning—and cinematic exaggerations regarding discipline, indoctrination, and the emotional portrayal of soldiering.
The DI and the drill sergeant is going to definitely dole out punishment as a mass punishment.
I'm Command Sergeant Major Retired Lamont Christian. I served about 11 years as a drill sergeant and
then as a senior leader in organizations that conducted basic combat training. Today we're
going to be looking at boot camp scenes and seeing how realistic they are. The standard for
responding to a drill sergeant is yes drill sergeant, no drill sergeant, and if it has to
have an affirmative response then the whole platoon will sound just like it. The drill sergeant was so
impressed because you know in the early part of training it's a challenge for somebody who perhaps
has not handled a weapon before what we would call weapons training to be able to take that
weapon apart put it back together and do what you saw Flores do there which was that functions check.
What your hope is as a DI or drill sergeant is that everybody in there can do it like Flores.
Shrimp and potatoes, shrimp burger. What's funny is when they're in there with them with toothbrushes
that's something of the past it was times where you know you give a recruit scissors and say go
cut the grass. They're fostering this environment of working together with over and over and over
again until you get it right. That has the same training effect that this used to have. The
approach that the drill sergeant had in here was very very common for that time period during the
Vietnam War. That's about a nine. When you look at obstacle courses usually in boot camp you'll go
through them twice. Obstacle courses are really designed to find your upper body strength and also
determine your endurance and so it may even test your fear of heights, fear of darkness and then
you get to actually experience the teamwork helping each other. You saw that a couple of
times in there and definitely that screaming and yelling. Often we call it simulating you know
battlefield conditions. This is the rabbit hole. The rabbit comes out of his hole. What is interesting
is ropes and knot tying is no longer taught in basic training. It is in ranger school though.
You're actually tested in the mountain phase as things change over time. There's certain
requirements that leaders think that people need upon finishing basic training. This is to be your
lover, your mistress, your concubine. Perhaps the only thing in life you'll ever truly love. That's
one of those things again that you get from TV and Hollywood where we place all of this level
of intimacy with our weapon. Now granted it is an intimate relationship because you really want to
be confident with that weapon so taking it apart, putting it together almost to the point you can do
it blindfolded right. Talk about it in a way that might be sexual. That's kind of a Hollywood thing
that happens. I'm sorry sergeant. I can't touch a gun. For that time period being World War II
being a conscientious objector was going to definitely be a challenge for the leadership here.
This guy particularly is Desmond Doss. He was actually a Medal of Honor recipient and he didn't
have to carry a weapon to do it. I would definitely say this was a 9 on realism. Can't think when I'm
giving you a few love taps? How the are you going to fire your rifle when grenades are going off in your face?
You know unfortunately what we wind up running into a lot of times is drill sergeants or DI's
like this one that will touch and grab by the throat. That was familiar in other you know DI
movies. Touching recruits and in training is unacceptable. Always has been. Sir I got lost on
the way to college sir. That's exactly why right there the open door that I could do even more and
it turns to him slamming the kid's head into a wall and and that's why it's unacceptable because
where do you draw the line? Them paintball bullets they hurt? Oh paintball is something as you notice
there it's pretty painful. That guy is going to learn a valuable lesson not to put himself in a
window if he's going to engage and so that's why paintball, simunitions is kind of what we call it
is very very useful in the training environment. Sounds that you are hearing are live rounds. You will get the fear out of you.
That's a trainer, a sergeant, a leader's worst nightmare is to have somebody in training
lose their life. Shooting the rounds over their head we actually do that and we also do it at
night but the conditions are totally different. The guns are raised up a whole lot higher and
it's what we call a safe surface zone so even if you stood up or jumped up and down it's almost
20 feet above the heads of the individuals and again this tragedy right here as unfortunate as
it is it does happen when those things are not adhered to. For a boot camp movie it's probably
about a five. Rusty bayonet leap guard. Now thanks to these men and their infractions every man in
the company who had a weekend pass has lost it. This is pretty neat because I actually served
as the command sergeant major for this unit for the 2nd battalion 506 parachute infantry regiment
out of the 101st airborne. This right here is easy company and their preparation for world war
two. During that time period in our military not many people were married right and everybody was
always looking for a two-day or three-day pass. The stuff that they're being inspected on like
it's parade level stuff and they're out there in combat gear I could see where he's going
but trying to instill discipline just uh I'm sure morale is not going to be too high much longer.
Do not help that man. Do not help that man. We ran this mountain a couple of times. Currahee
mountain. Yeah it's no joke uh what I noticed here though you know he was telling them to leave that
guy not leaving uh our fallen comrade you know that was part of the warrior ethos and never
quitting so when you tie that together in today's modern military uh leaving somebody behind would
be something that we wouldn't do. That would be a 10 for running up that hill and for world war
two uh it'd probably be about an eight in realism. Hey no drill sergeant do I make myself clear?
You get them in the barber chair spin them around they had no hair like that's even part of like a
military cadence sometimes or males anyway are getting their hair cut where they cut it all the
way down. Female recruits are not required and believe it or not it's a health and hygiene issue
right because you get people that come from all walks of life and so you don't know necessarily
if they have like headlights or any other type of issues underneath all the hair. Next we got about
100 shots. You just get shots until you get all the way to the end and you're completely inoculated
against every disease known to man right. Execute.
The difference that I can see so far in this scene is they have them all taking their clothes off
like in an open room or an open bay. It wouldn't be done that way at the what they call a military
entrance processing station or the MEPS. All military members go through there and there's
no drill sergeants there right it's it's just a staff of military personnel, administrators,
doctors, counselors because what they're doing is they're determining whether or not you're fit
to train. Had to strip down to our underwear and duck walk the circuit of a big room.
Oh yeah duck walking. I remember the first time I did that I was like what in the world.
They have you walk from one side of the room to the other and the doctor is looking for your bone
structure, your musculoskeletal development, if you're flat-footed, also just your mobility and
agility but yeah you definitely wouldn't be in a room like that full of other people,
be hard to assess. I would have to say it's about a four right because that's not necessarily how
that whole indoctrination process would happen with the drill sergeants.
So far this is looking pretty good. In the DI's in the Marine Corps they actually have a script
they say you sit up straight and look at me. So while the difference in the titles the drill
instructors was tied into the Marine Corps, drill sergeants became into play for the Army
and the interaction in the first part of boot camp is always going to be what we call total control.
Everywhere you look there's going to be some DI or drill sergeant ensuring
that the training that has been given is being reinforced and so when you see
R. Lee Ermey walking around in the bay he's doing exactly what a DI would do. He actually
was a drill sergeant as a matter of fact. He served several years during the Vietnam War as a DI.
If you notice the DI is constantly yelling and it's not because they like yelling at individuals
it's just that they don't have to repeat the same commands over and over. So if you have a
recruit on one end of the bay he or she is going to hear the instructions all the way on the other
end of the bay. Another thing that you often see in these movies and TV shows is the DI or the
drill sergeant doing a lot of cursing and swearing. Cursing and swearing is not something that is
acceptable but it does happen. For that Vietnam era that's pretty realistic. Now you have people
who are deciding to you know serve their country and it's a different view. I was part of the
committee that created the change what we call shock and awe commonly called a shock attack
as opposed to this fallacy which was we have to break them down in order to build them up
and focus more on the teamwork and so that's what the 100 yards was designed to do. Day one
part of that indoctrination when the DI comes in is the wellness of the trainees or the recruits
and so they have to inspect the feet and inspect the hands and make sure that there's no open sore.
We've gone away from foot lockers and modulized most of the equipment in the bay so you wouldn't
necessarily have a foot locker in the bay and they definitely wouldn't be standing on the
equipment like that. They have this term in the army they call toe the line and that's where they
actually stand next to the line so that they can do that inspection. Especially in the beginning
phases of boot camp the DI and the drill sergeant is going to definitely dole out punishment as a
mass punishment. Even though one person may mess up this opportunity for somebody to have looked
and held Pyle accountable for that donut was missed and that's what the DI is reinforcing
we'll hold each other accountable. I would have to say it was probably about a nine for that era
if we're talking in today's terms it'd probably be about a seven in realism. We are going to win
this war because we have the best men. When they were standing in formation and the leader stopped
and kind of looked at this guy and he looks like a middle middle school kid there was actually a guy
named Laherty this guy was four feet nine inches and they called him the giant killer because of
all the different exploits that he did during Vietnam and he was smaller than Rogers was right.
You know the smallest guy right in the formation wound up coming up with the plan of success.
In a basic training environment you probably wouldn't have that type of situation placed
on a trainee or recruit. That's some special missions type unit stuff that's going on there
where an assessment is being done right because they want to know if you have a special skill set.
What they were actually doing in the training would not necessarily be something that you
would see in recruit training so I'm gonna give it a five. Yeah that's the campaign hat
the famous drill sergeant hat. I just happen to have mine with me and it is distinct take here
that is worn by the male drill sergeants in the army but then also by the male and female
DI's in the marines. What's unique is while all the branches except the navy has some form of a
the army still has a separate hat for the female drill sergeant it's called a bush hat.
That part where the one character starts singing that you know diddy bop
it's interesting that most cadences that's actually where they come from
right popular tunes R&B music I mean even nursery rhymes even my own voice
has been tapped into a cadence and the Gatorade commercial singing the hard work cadence.
So these guys they're just you know jumping on the bandwagon throwing in the diddy bop in there
the same time. Yeah that ain't happening. However in the army in what we call the advanced
individual training which those periods of training go from six weeks to six months maybe
even a year drilling ceremony competitions are usually used to continue to motivate
those individuals that have the longer periods of training but not as likely in a basic combat
training because we're focusing on shooting moving communicating and treating yourself
and others on the battlefield. I'd have to say a four. Locate a wounded soldier represented by a
dummy you must then transport him to the emergency field hospital. There's a lot going on there so
far when it started out it definitely was something that you would see in recruit training
you know a lot of female leaders now are in positions of senior leadership that's something
that hadn't occurred over many years until the military had started really opening up the ranks
of the infantry to our female leaders. An aggressor team will be trying to stop you
they are all awaiting ranger training and can't wait to capture. Based on what the information
and the instructions they were given is actually an advanced individual training you know medical
training they're not going to be as complex with a mission that would go that deep and that was
evident when I saw them in the river there because the risk for you know perhaps somebody drowning or
you know something else with all that equipment on and not too many people are going to want to
put a recruit in that type of environment. Again the risk factors wouldn't be something that you'd
see in recruit training but definitely something very similar challenging wise as far as the
military is concerned you know marines have a crucible and the army has this thing called the
forge very similar in the final test of all of the training that they receive during the recruit
training and the medical lanes where they might have to treat a casualty or transport a casualty
like you saw here to really see if all of the training has actually reached the point where
they are confident that these individuals can leave and go to their next assignment. I have to
give that a five as far as realism. Hazing is something that again has never been accepted
but it happens. This is depicting an environment where it's still initial entry training or initial
military training but it's officer candidate school. Typically officer candidates are a little
bit more mature have either been in the military for quite some time and reached enlisted ranks.
There's levels of hazing that may be more acceptable in that environment versus in the
recruit training. So there was a mandate that provided leadership across all of the branches
to come up with you know progressive ways if you would in order to attack and get in front of hazing
and so whether it was reporting such as in the army you know not in my squad to place
accountability not just on leadership but on each other.
There's about two or three layers of checks and balances so that you don't have that rogue
DI or rogue drill sergeant who might take something personal like it looks like in this clip
because of the flexibility and the things that take place in the officer candidate school versus
what happens in recruit training for initial entry training. I would say that it's probably
about a seven. Weight training has always been something that's important in the military to be
able to carry your body weight and in some cases you might have to lift or carry or drag somebody
else. The sand buckets and them using them for weights a lot less expensive than buying weights
for every marine but then they get the same physical exercise out of it.
You know they were doing combatives right with the pugils and and then the drill instructor was
showing them with the knife close quarter combat because every marine, every soldier, every person
that joins the military is is a fighter first right and so pugil strength training is one of
those ways that that confidence is instilled in the individual in their ability to stand their
ground and it's also fun to look at. I would say it's a about a seven. My favorite drill instructor
was Jack Webb and the movie The DI. It actually shows both sides of the drill instructor's life.
What does he do in the evenings after he's away from the base squad?
If you enjoyed this video why not click on this video above.
