The National Association of Home Builders' chief economist just issued a warning to the housing market: he thinks prices are going to drop on the resale market.
Home builders like Lennar and DR Horton have already cut prices significantly. In total, builders have reduced prices by 16% from their pandemic peak, and they are still dropping.
These price cuts are coming heaviest in markets like Florida, Texas, Tennessee, Arizona, and Colorado.
Meanwhile, data from Zillow and the National Association of Realtors show the prices of existing homes have not dropped at all on a national basis. Sellers with sub-4% mortgages would rather de-list their homes than sell at a loss.
However, I believe that what's happening in the builder market, where the price cuts are now approaching the same level as 2008, could eventually spread to the re-sale market as more existing mortgage holders transition to the 6% rate.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Home builders are doing something they haven't done in over 15 years, and that's cutting prices.
And these price cuts from builders are actually getting pretty big,
and almost as big as they were in the 2008-2009 housing downturn, with new homes getting cheaper
and leading economists now saying that that could force resale prices down in 2026,
with the National Association of Home Builders chief economist saying he expects home prices
to falter in much of the country as the resale market adjusts to price competition from new
builds. And what he's referring to is the fact that builders have now cut prices by 16%
from the 2022 bubble peak. Back in October 2022, the median sale price for new build homes was
$460,000. Now it's down to $387,000 in 2026, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. That 16%
drawdown over the last three and a half years is now getting close to what the drawdown was
from 2007-2010, when builders cut prices by 22% in that last downturn. And that's right, folks.
Builders have cut prices in this housing cycle almost as much as they cut prices in the last
housing downturn, 2007-2010. Not a lot of people know that, and I think that's an important data
point for you all to understand so you can see that there's an actual price correction occurring
in the market, there's an actual downturn occurring, and that more affordability is
coming to you if you live in a state where home builders are very active. However, there's a
problem, and that's the fact that the builder price reductions and the builder price cuts
are slow to translate to the existing sale market. Existing homes make up 85% of all the sales in a
given year, while builder homes only make up 15%. And so while we have 16% price cuts on 15% of the
houses from new builds, the other 85% of houses are still seeing values go up. And we're actually
seeing something historic in nature. For the first time in U.S. history, new build home prices are
consistently trending below existing home prices. This orange line is the median sale price for
existing already built houses. The blue line is that price for new houses. And you can see in
March 2026, new houses were 5.5% cheaper than existing houses, which is crazy because if you
look historically, normally new houses are much more expensive. Normally new houses from builders
are 15% more expensive than existing houses. However, we've flipped in the last year and a
half into an environment where new builds are cheaper. And that's a telling point for you guys
out there about where the market could be heading in general. You know, most of you aren't going to
buy a new build house. I think only 15% of you or so are looking into buying a new build home.
However, you should be paying attention to this data because it's relevant as to where the market
for resales could also be heading in the future, as the chief economist from the National Association
of Builders was saying. He's saying that we expect in most markets this year, resale prices are going
to go down in order to improve affordability conditions because existing homeowners now have
to do the price discovery that builders have been doing since 2022 and they haven't done it yet. So
we think that that's happening in 2026. And of course it's needed because when we look at the
home price to income ratio, this to me sums up the affordability challenge with the typical home
price being 4.9 times higher than local income, while the historical average is three times income.
But the reason that prices haven't gone down as much on the existing sale market,
and that that transition mechanism has been slow to happen, is due to the fact that a lot of
existing owners have cheaper mortgage rates. Roughly 50% of owners who have a mortgage have
a rate below 4%. And many of those owners view their cheap mortgage relative to the market
mortgage rate as a more valuable asset than the house itself. A lot of the people with a mortgage
rate less than 4 say to themselves, I'm not going to sell this house if I don't have to. I'm not
going to cut the price to the level that I need to cut the price to in order to effectuate a sale.
A lot of them would just rather keep that 3% rate or 3.5% rate or 4% rate, which is why we're not
seeing the downturn play out as fast in the resale market. However, we know that there is an
expiration date on that situation. With each passing day, with each passing quarter, more and more
existing owners take on higher mortgage rates. Today in 2026, we now have more 6% plus mortgages
in the existing home market than sub 3%. And in some states like Texas, Tennessee, and Florida,
we have almost double as many as 6% plus rate owners as sub 3% rate owners. On this map,
we're looking at the states with the highest share of mortgages above 6%. This was at the
end of 2025. I suspect most of these states are even higher on this share in 2026. But you can
see it's these areas in orange. These areas and states in orange have the most higher interest
rate existing owners. Places like Alabama, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Kentucky,
Georgia, Florida, and Texas have a quarter or more. My operating theory is, and you guys can
let me know what you think about this, is that the states with the higher shares of mortgages
above 6% are going to be the ones that are going to continue to see a housing correction or more
likely to see one in the future because those existing owners are going to have a bigger
impetus to sell their house. Their payments are quite frankly too high. Foreclosures are going up.
Foreselling is going up. So these states in orange are going to be leading the way. And actually a
lot of them happen to be in areas where builders are very active. But I wanted to pause here for
a second, everyone, and show you all some historical perspective on the price of houses over
time. Because even though the builders have cut 16% in the last four years, I suspect for a lot
of you guys out there, it might not feel like a real price cut yet. And I totally get why. Because
when you look back 50 or 60 years, you could see that houses used to be much cheaper decades and
decades ago. Even 20 years ago, houses were much cheaper. And I think it's important if you're a
buyer and investor to kind of keep an eye on that historical data on how much houses used to cost
and how much they cost now, so you can make a more informed decision about if it's a good idea for
you guys to buy today. And this was an advertisement I found that I just thought was really
interesting and I wanted to show you all. Realtor.com posted it back in 2023. And it's an
advertisement for a detached home from the 1960s. And you can see that the price for the home was
$16,750. And that's crazy, right? Everyone, if you go on Zillow or Realtor.com today,
the price for these houses is $400,000, $500,000. It was $16,750 back then. It looks like the
version with the attached garage went up to $20,000 or with a carport was $18,000.
Now, an interesting question is, was this actually a good deal back then? I know it seems like a
screaming deal today, but what actually matters is what was the cost of the house compared to
incomes at the time in the 1960s. And the crazy thing is the median income back in the 1960s was
around $5,000 a year. Today, the median income is $85,000. It was $5,000 back in the 1960s.
So how does that home price to income ratio compare? Well, you can actually see it was
legitimately cheaper to buy these new build houses back in the 1960s compared to income.
The home price to income ratio for new builds in the mid-60s was around 3.5. 3.5 times income was
how much the houses cost. Fast forward to today, it's 4.7 times income. So while it's actually
gotten much more affordable to buy a new build house in the last four years, you can see the
bubble is deflating and correcting right before our eyes, it's still not as cheap as it was back
then. Interestingly, you can also see that from about 1976 to around 2000-2001, there was a period
of real stability in the cost to buy a new house relative to income. It stayed around a range of
3.7 to 4.1. Then we had the 2006 price bubble where prices surged out of control, and then
the correction when builders cut prices 22%. Then we had something I call the McMansion bubble in
the mid-2010s. The McMansion bubble is when the price to income ratio went up, not because so much
of appreciation, but because builders just kept building bigger and bigger homes. Peak builder
size of houses was actually in 2015, so the houses just got really big and the prices went up.
Then you can see the 2022 price bubble, mainly due to prices going up, that's now deflating as well.
And so it's a mixed story here. On one hand, yes, builder homes are getting more affordable, and
that is a signal of where the housing market could be heading in the future. However, it is still
objectively much more expensive on a relative basis to buy a new build home today in 2026 than
it was in the mid-1960s, and there's a variety of reasons for that. One of the main ones is the cost
of permitting and impact fees for builders. It was way easier for many of these builders to zone and
build and develop lots back in the 60s, especially in states like California and especially in states
like the Northeast. These areas used to actually be more friendly to home builders. Now they make
it very hard for builders to develop. They charge them really expensive fees up front. There's a lot
of environmental litigation up front, which increases the overall cost for these builders,
and they pass it off to the buyer. Additionally, the cost of materials and the cost of labor has
also gone up over the last 60 years, putting somewhat of a floor on how low builder prices
can go. I think there are actually a fair amount of fairly affordable builder homes on the market
right now, and what I did is I actually went to Zillow and I just applied a couple filters. I'm
looking for a new construction home, max price $300,000, with a minimum square footage of 2,000
square feet, single family. I'm sorry everyone, I don't know if you could hear the
sirens in the background, but I'm in downtown Nashville right now around 8 p.m. on a Friday,
and there's always a lot of noise. In this case, this is a new build home in Princeton, Texas for
$126 a foot, four bed, three bath, 2,300 square feet, $284,000, a $53,000 price cut. I mean,
this is a house priced kind of at 2019-2020 pricing. Princeton is a suburb outside of Dallas,
where there's a lot of inventory on the market, and you could actually buy this house with an
all-in payment less than $2,000 a month. Here's a house in Florida in Brooksville, which is about an
hour north of Tampa, four bed, three bath, 2,300 square foot, 2026 construction, $290,000. That's
$128 a foot, $2,000 a month, all-in mortgage taxes and insurance. I don't necessarily think
people should rush out and buy these homes from builders. However, I think it's important for you
guys to see what's happening in the builder market, and that there is a lot of affordability
actually showing up in different states like Florida, Texas, and South Carolina from these
builders, and that, yes, resale owners are going to have to compete with these builders on price
point, and that we are seeing these price declines from builders spill over into the resale market,
where the builder activity is highest and where inventory is highest as well.
I actually want to address something right now that bothers me. I recently saw a video on YouTube
that actually got over a million views, and this video was kind of a hit piece on home builders
and tried to blame home builders for the housing affordability crisis that we have right now. And
there were a bunch of arguments presented in this video saying that builders are not building as
many homes as they used to relative to our population, trying to claim that builders are
gouging prices in some instances, and potentially maybe doing shoddy work on homes. And while maybe
some of those claims might be true in isolation, however, I totally disagreed with the underlying
premise suggesting that builders are the problem. Builders are not the problem right now. Builders
have the most homes for sale on their lots that we've seen in 20 years. In the South, builders
have the most inventory they've ever had for sale right now. And if it weren't for the builders in
these markets, prices wouldn't be dropping as much in Florida, Texas, Arizona, Nevada, and
Tennessee. And I think it's important to get this right because we need to blame the right party
here for keeping home prices high. It's not builders. It's existing owners. Existing owners
of homes are the problem in terms of prices being high. They have not cut the price really at all
the last four years on a national basis. In some markets, they have and are continuing,
but on a national basis, they haven't on average. And the reason is because they're
clutching on to their lower rate mortgages, 3%, 4% mortgages. And many of these existing owners
would rather keep their home off the market and not cut the price to effectuate a sale.
They would rather keep the perception of what their value of their house is or what it was four
years ago than sell their home at a 20% lower price today. And that is the fundamental problem.
It's not the builders. It's the existing owners. And this is proven by the fact
that the price to income ratio for existing homes is now the same as it is for builder homes.
For builders, the price to income has actually come down below the 30-year average price to
income for builders is 4.9. Comparatively, the 30-year average price to income for existing
owners is 4.1. So the fact is existing homes are still 20% overvalued. So if someone's a policy
maker or they want to report on the housing market or they want to fix the housing market,
the main issue is this pink line, which is the price to income ratio for existing owners.
And it's the fact that it's still more or less at the highest level on record and has not come
back down to what it was before the pandemic in this range of around 4X. And one housing market
that is actually legitimately crashing right now alongside the correction in builders is a housing
market in another country that I actually want to key you guys in on because I was doing a little
research on this housing market in another country and was surprised to see actually that home prices
in this country are down almost 20% in the last four years. The correction there is looking very
much like the correction in the builder market in the U.S. And in some cities in this country,
prices are down 25%. And I believe that the price action in this country could also be a useful
indicator of what could happen in the U.S. going forward. And the area, of course, I'm talking about
is Canada. In Canada, home prices are down nearly 20% from peak at the peak in 2022. And according
to the Royal Bank of Canada, March 2026 marks the fourth year of declining home prices in Canada in
a row. You can see here the house resales in Canada have dropped off significantly from the
pandemic peak and are near their lowest level in the last 20 years, with higher inventory causing
prices to drop 7.4% from a year ago in Toronto and 6.8% in Vancouver. Toronto is down about 25%
from peak. It's the biggest housing market correction in North America next to Austin,
Texas, Toronto, Ontario. Additionally, values are down in Kitchener, Barrie, Hamilton, London,
Ontario and Fraser Valley, while prices are actually still going up in Regina, Saskatoon,
Winnipeg, Montreal and Quebec City, where prices are up 10% year over year. So interestingly, Canada,
similar to the U.S., has a bifurcated market where values are still going up a lot in certain
pockets of Canada, just like they're going up in the Northeast and Midwest in the U.S.
Now, Canada's mortgage market is very different from the U.S. mortgage market. In Canada, most people
have variable rate mortgages with five-year terms, as opposed to the 30-year fixed rate
mortgages in the U.S. So Canada's owners and sellers are more quickly adjusting to the higher
interest rate environment, which is why more of them are inclined to cut the price and liquidate
the property because their payments are higher. And I think that's just another preview of what
we could see in the U.S. as more and more U.S. mortgage holders transition to the higher mortgage
rates as well. But home values have dropped in a lot of U.S. markets. I don't want to lose sight of
that. Resale values especially have gone down in a lot of different markets in the U.S., and
we should understand that there is a heavy price correction playing out in a lot of different
markets. Affordability is returning to a lot of buyers in a lot of different markets, and that
a lot of sellers are cutting the price, right? So while the broad-based national metrics on the U.S.
resale market still say we're in a price bubble, that bubble is correcting in a lot of different
cities, and it's also already corrected for builders and continues to correct, and it's
already corrected in an area like Canada. So there are a lot of examples of prices dropping.
Since the 2022 peak in the U.S., values in Austin are down 25%. Values in Punta Gorda,
Florida are down 22%. In Cape Coral, they're down 16%. In North Port, Sarasota, Florida,
values are down 14%. In New Orleans, they're down 12%. So we have double-digit price corrections
in five large metro areas in the U.S. since the bubble peak in 2022. Additionally, San Francisco
is down almost 10% from peak, although it's starting to rebound. Phoenix is down 9%. Boulder's
down 9%. Naples is down 9% from peak. San Antonio is down 8%. Boise is down 8%. Sacramento, Colorado
Springs, Dallas, along with many other markets, and that's good news for you guys as a buyer.
The trick is understanding how much more prices could drop into 2027, and if it's a good time to
buy in your market from a valuation perspective. And we came up actually with two distinct data
points to help you guys do that. You know, it's my mission here on this channel to make sure every
home buyer in the U.S. is informed before they go to buy a house. And I want to make sure every buyer
looks at the 2027 price forecast and the overvaluation rate to know if it's a good
time to buy. And if you do want to buy this year, how much you should offer. What you can do to
access that data is go to reventure.app and then type in your zip code. First thing you want to do
is check out that one-year price forecast. You can see for this zip code in Nashville, we expect
prices to drop 7% in the next year. When you see this type of negative forecast, it means actually
good news for you as a buyer negotiating opportunities. However, this area is still 10%
overvalued, and other areas of Nashville are as much as 37% overvalued. So if you buy into an
overvalued market, there's greater risk that prices could drop in the future, greater risk of stagnation
in the future. Certain zip codes now towards the center of Nashville are undervalued. So you're going
to want to see in your city where the undervalued areas, where the overvalued areas, how much your
price is going to drop or go up over the next 12 months. To access that data, sign up for a
ReVenture premium plan for only $33 a month if you sign up for the annual pass. This annual pass is
going to allow you to access the data for the next 12 months so you can see how your market is shifting
and so you can make more informed offers, get ahead of the market, and potentially save a lot
of money on your purchase. Go to www.reventure.app, upgrade today to unlock that price forecast and
overvaluation rate for your area. You're going to need that data.