The Population Collapse is Worse Than We Thought

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
#finance
#financement
0:00 Population Data
2:34 Impact of falling population
4:02 Why Fertility is Falling
9:48 Benefits Population Fall
Last year, China's fertility rate fell to 0.93 births per woman. There were fewer births in
China than back in 1776. The infamous one-child policy has been devastatingly successful.
But China is not alone. Fertility rates are falling across the world. As the United Nations
reported, the world is heading towards population decline faster than almost anybody predicted.
In the latest UN population forecast, the median projection is for the global population
to peak around the middle of this century. And on the surface, that looks fairly benign.
But the problem is that these assumptions are based on forecasts that really don't make much
sense. For example, take fertility in South Korea. It has collapsed in recent years to one of the
lowest in the world. Yet the UN assumes it will rebound in the coming years. And that would
represent one of the most unexpected demographic shifts. It is far more plausible that fertility
rates will continue to fall as they have done in previous years. As the OECD notes, once fertility
falls very low, it actually creates the conditions that keep it low. And population forecasters have
repeatedly underestimated how far fertility rates can fall. Forecasts are continually revised
downwards. And the result is that societies are being hollowed out. Schools are closing,
being converted into care homes for the elderly. Society is changing in ways we are not prepared
for. It is unprecedented. And now in the West, falling fertility is often blamed on the cost
of living crisis. And certainly the cost of housing, education, general living expenses,
makes having more children really quite expensive. And many people say they would like to have more
children, but don't want to have to have the financial cost. But the thing is, with this
argument, we have to be aware that fertility is falling in almost every country. It's a global
phenomenon, whether housing is cheap or expensive. In Western Europe, there is widespread economic
pessimism in 2026. But even in countries with quite strong economic optimism, such as China and
India, fertility has collapsed. And what does having a fertility rate of 0.8 actually mean?
In South Korea's case, it implies that a population will fall from around 50 million
to 20 million within two generations. And it's the kind of population collapse that cannot be
solved by increasing immigration or raising the retirement age to 70. What it means is schools
closing, rural areas deserted, and even small towns becoming wastelands. There are also less
obvious effects. Average costs across society will tend to rise. Take electricity or water.
In the UK, it's really quite expensive. But most of the costs are what we call fixed costs,
such as maintaining and transporting the national infrastructure. With fewer people,
these fixed costs are spread over lower demand, pushing the average cost per household. Now in
the UN's 2024 forecasts, there's also an assumption that Africa will maintain high fertility rates,
leading sub-Saharan Africa to gain a much larger share of the global population.
Now, this may happen to some extent, but I would be sceptical about that projection. Because
fertility is already falling across Africa, and demographers struggle to obtain up to date data
about what is happening in real term. Take Kenya, their fertility rate has fallen from around eight
in the late 1970s to 3.2 today. Now, one explanation for falling fertility is a spread
of smartphones and the internet. Because when people across the world have access to the same
information, entertainment, and social norms, people are facing really very similar cultural
choices. Now, if the smartphone theory of falling fertility is correct, or at least has some degree
of merit, Africa may soon face the same demographic trajectory as the rest of the world as smartphone
use increases. Given the choice, parents increasingly prefer fewer children with better
prospects. Now, one of the most striking features of a decline in fertility rates is that it spans
very different cultures. Take Turkey, a predominantly Muslim country, now has a
fertility rate of 1.48, very similar to the UK and the United States. Population researcher
Lyman Stone argues that fertility decline is not primarily economic, but cultural.
And let's go back to the smartphone generation theory. There do seem to be two significant
factors that stand out. Firstly, people spend far less time meeting in person. Young people can spend
hours on screens. For men, it tends to be playing Minecraft Call of Duty, watching YouTube videos
like this. 90% of my subscribers are men on YouTube. For women, it tends to be things like
Instagram and I don't know what else. But anyway, when it comes to internet use, it really can feel
like men are from Mars and women are from Venus. And it's not just that fertility is declining.
Alcohol consumption, drug use, sexual activity are all falling amongst young people. So much
the 1960s, it's a new cultural revolution. Dating apps were designed to encourage relationships.
Yet paradoxically, people are dating far less and marriage rates are falling very rapidly.
Social media promotes idealised images of relationships, making reality feel disappointing
by comparison. And this is reflected in the sharp decline in marriage rates and rise in single
person households. And it's one of the defining features of our age and actually a very significant
factor feeding into the housing crisis. Now, pick up a textbook from the 1980s or 1990s,
and you will find stark warnings about overpopulation. We can't cope with all the
people. And it does seem that we seem to swing from one panic to another. But if fertility rates
keep falling below one, we will start to see population figures that look a lot more like this.
And once the decline sets in, it becomes very hard to reverse it. And the truth is that this is now
a realistic outcome. So how will this affect the economy? Well, initially, with a fall in fertility
rates, there can actually be a demographic dividend because you get a smaller number of children,
but a larger working age population. And that supports higher savings, higher investment and
growth. And this has helped much of Southeast Asia in recent years. But this demographic dividend
then turns into a liability. Because when that population bulge reaches retirement age,
old age dependency suddenly rises very sharply. And at that point, governments must spend more
money simply to stand still. Pensions and health care spending will all rise whilst public
investment is squeezed and reduced. At the same time, debt and taxes have to go up. Ageing societies
tend to experience lower economic growth, weaker productivity and less innovation. And you can see
here that as the share of a population over 60 rises, growth slows down. And this is a recipe
for political dissatisfaction. Taxes rise, public services deteriorate and living standards
stagnate. And of course, older people become a powerful voting bloc. They're more numerous and
also more likely to vote. Take this example of in London, over 65s receive free public transport,
despite the fact that the average pensioner couple have more wealth and around 4,000 a year more
disposable income than, say, a young couple with three children. Now, you might think that a
rational response to this population crisis is to subsidise child rearing, subsidise people to have
more births. And in recent years, many countries are now trying pro-natal policies. But to a large
extent, the results have been really very disappointing. Hungary spent heavily with
very little effect. South Korea offered up to $700 a month, yet fertility remains below 0.8.
Cultural forces appear stronger than modest financial incentives. Limestone suggested
achieving a replacement fertility rate of 2.1 might require additional child benefits
of $10,000 to $20,000 per year. But how do you fund that kind of child benefits when pension
spending is rising, growth is slowing, and taxes are going up already? Low fertility also reinforces
itself. Large families were once the norm, having no children once carried social stigma. But today,
childlessness is common, and large families seem really quite unusual. Once, people feared missing
out by not having children. But now, children are often seen as an obstacle to career or even
basic financial survival. Now, as you know, with technology's help, we always try to look
on the bright side. And a falling population does have potential benefits. In theory, housing and
land should become cheaper over time. It will take a while to get there. Also, very important,
environmental pressures will ease, reducing the stress on fossil fuel consumption and reducing
stress on water supplies, land use and ecosystems. But the adjustment is always going to be uneven.
In Italy, population decline has coincided with people fleeing rural areas for cities. You might
be able to buy a house for one euro in a ghost town, but few people actually want to live there.
Now, a smaller population might reduce pressure to build on green land and give people more space.
Will technology ride to the rescue? Automation, drones and AI may replace some of the low skilled
jobs and free labour for care work. But for all the potential technology, it can't repopulate
schools or revive ghost towns. And AI is not a cure to the social fragmentation that has been
occurring in recent years. What about immigration? Well, it can always act as a temporary buffer.
But with fertility falling globally, the pool of potential migrants will shrink. And of course,
immigrants themselves tend to adopt the same low fertility patterns over time and will age
just like native born people, causing a similar ageing population. In the UK, population decline
will be slow at first, but we will have to face this ageing population. People will have to work
longer. Retirement may become shorter than in the past. But the direction of travel is clear.
And if we start to follow what's happening in other countries and fertility rates continue to
fall, the shock may be even greater. And even with the population still modestly rising,
the economy is still struggling. And this makes it hard to fund more investment in trying to
change the trajectory that we're all on. This video looks into some of the economic problems
that we face this year. Thanks for watching. And let me know what you think in the comments below.
