44 Housing Crash in the Northeast What You Must Know

Financial Freedom
10 followers
Sales of newly built houses crashed by a massive 17.6% in January with a stunning 44% drop in the
Northeast as well as a 34% slide in the Midwest. Everyone is quick to blame the wintry weather in
January but we already saw weakening in December and it's not like we haven't been following a
macro-led housing bust this entire time. Economists don't want to admit that rate
cuts and lower interest rates are not stimulus and they didn't lead to the recovery in either
the economy or the housing market that they had predicted. But now homebuyers have another
problem on their hands another potential problem on their hands and that's volatility in interest
rates that's created by central bankers currently doing exactly what we thought they would do in
response to the oil shock. I said yesterday the economy is in a race against time and the fact
that McDonald's is cutting its prices and Dollar Tree shifting to cater to higher income shoppers
suddenly showing up in their stores those were solid signs the consumer economy was already in
rough shape not to mention almost every piece of hard data we come across on the economy but
especially jobs and incomes. Real estate is just another angle on the same view despite lower
mortgage rates the past couple of years existing home sales have gone nowhere stuck down at the
levels as the big housing bust from 15 years ago. Sales of new homes which we're going to talk about
today they had even more concern because the property sector overall is more solid evidence
pointing to the fragility the fragility of the current economy and just how much consumers have
to be struggling inside of it that's the race against time and then the time part the oil shock
it's hitting when the economy is already in bad shape so the longer that it goes the greater the
risk of pushing it right over the edge so we've got a lot of new stats to cover on the housing
market plus we also really got to get into where the oil market stands right now including a couple
of worrisome signs about how long the shock might keep up and then finally we've got to talk about
central bankers who are doing what they do best creating more unnecessary and ultimately harmful
uncertainty by having no idea how an economy even works. There have been a bunch of central bank
meetings this week including Canada and the Fed yesterday in Canada and the Fed apart from Jay
Powell of course they were actually reasonable in their responses to the oil shock over in Europe
however they are absolutely doing everything that we thought they would which complicates the story
where it comes to interest rates however there are some quirks which do apply to this discussion
about housing home prices and mortgage rates but starting with new home sales according to the
Census Bureau sales of newly built houses crashed by 17.6 percent in January from December's pace
which by the way was revised down to begin with it had originally been estimated to have declined
just 1.7 percent from the November high but is now already minus 6.8 percent and then January
comes in at minus 18. I already knew the mainstream media was going to blame the wintry weather in
January for these poor results but analysts were only expecting a small decline from December's
previously estimated rate which presumably those same analysts would have taken an account of the
snow and cold when making their predictions and sure enough sales crashed by 44 percent in the
northeast where the storms were at their worst but they were also down 34 percent in the midwest
and another 22 percent in the west where there wasn't the same kind of snow intensity even in
the south it posted a decline of eight percent in other words the weather might be responsible for
some of the setback and maybe making some of these numbers very extreme but nowhere near all
of it besides this is not some kind of outlier we've seen weakness all over real estate for years
now in defiance of conventional theories which treat lower interest rates as stimulus instead
of what they really are and that's a reflection of the same weakness that's holding housing back
but when you start out predisposed to buy the stimulus notion and any weakness that inevitably
shows up and it does inevitably show up it has to be due to some other one-off anomaly or in the
case of real estate an entire pack of lone wolf explanations sure it's wintry and winter but housing
has much bigger problems and those are in the labor market the same ones that have market rates going
lower and the fed chasing both with its rate cuts i almost never do ads and i say no to the vast
majority of those that are brought to my attention but i was thrilled to be able to work with today's
sponsor monetary metals and the reason is because they're solving a big problem one that i've been
highlighting for a very long period of time gold is a safe haven but other than sitting in a vault
it doesn't do anything monetary metals fixes that they let you earn real yield paid in physical gold
without giving up ownership it's not a fund it's not a paper claim it's your gold working for you
every month more gold gets deposited into your account it's simple it's transparent and it is
fully insured if you believe in gold as a long-term store of value as i do this changes everything go
to monetary-metals.com slash snyder that's monetary-metals.com slash snyder for all the
details we absolutely thank them for being the sponsor of today's video and now let's get back
to it now builders have been grappling with too many homes for several years now and if you're
wondering how that could possibly be the answer is the same one that we keep finding in private
credit it's jay powell and the stock market but what i mean is the error really is the fed and
its models and to some degree equities when your views on the economy into the future are shaped by
fed models and share prices you're going to be a lot more optimistic than is appropriate
this is exactly what set private credit into its bubble period that and the rate hikes from the fed
yes the fed's rate hikes were largely responsible for blowing the private credit bubble another
example of how everyone gets interest rates completely wrong but that's a topic for another
day in fact it's a topic for today my deep dive analysis and our subscription service there
however developers back to housing they kept getting these optimistic forecasts on the economy
and therefore kept building more houses than they could possibly sell at the prices they wanted to
sell them at the weakening rather than recovering labor market kept buyers on the sidelines even as
mortgage rates started to drop as a result the inventory of unsold development soared to 2007
levels in the middle of last year and you can see right where it began to really climb the middle
of 2023 now developers and builders had cut back for a couple months and only a couple months
starting in late 2022 due to the rate hikes but in 2023 right after the bank panic and right when
the labor market started to downshift that's when home builders started to build even more why well
powell said the labor market was strong and resilient and the stock market soared on his word
and that whole ai bubble thing but it was enough to stay optimistic about the recovery and housing
long past any legitimate reason to do so with only higher and higher inventories though
home builders have had to keep offering discounts and lowering their prices so you'd think that
these basic small economics here would have fixed the imbalance like they should have
too much building not enough buying but nope again the power of the narrative everybody told
themselves it'll pick up next month because jay powell and larry young let's not forget dear
propaganda larry they keep saying conditions for home buying are getting better and better
you and dr beverage know what happened to those those errors made their way into the median sales
price has been slowly yet constantly falling going all the way back to 2022 not crashing
another forgot how to grow style of decline prices go down builders build more anyway because they
think it'll turn around soon only have to cut prices further when it doesn't happen but powell
says it will and then they start hyping rate cuts so they build a couple more houses only note bad
jobs no incomes lower rates don't help rinse and repeat before you know it you've got 2 000 levels
of inventory and prices that are going down the entire time so what we're seeing now across the
real estate market including the collapse of new home sales in january just more confirmation of
the difficult state of the labor market as well as consumers and if consumers are struggling this
badly given what we see in real estate and housing as well as mcdonald's and all the
stuff we keep talking about the data we keep getting on the labor market if they're struggling
this badly what happens when their energy costs soar and then stay there for any length of time
that's the race against time that we keep running up against so if they soar for only a couple of
weeks maybe it won't matter all that much but the longer the oil price shot goes on the greater the
chances for a much bigger consumer pullback now the crash in january home sales is another
indication pointing to a much higher degree of fragility among consumers than most people have
appreciated certainly home builders after all remember the narrative here last year's weakness
like the year before's was only going to be temporary year after year forgot how to grow
a session and each time each year they always say it's last year this year's gonna boom and it never
actually does but 2025 was all about tariffs that's what everyone decided if the labor market
finally cracked and started producing the negative months the mainstream said we'd never see
let's blame trade wars for it so if trade wars were the reason for the unexpected weakness in 2025
then by the time we get to 2026 it'll all be good again once cleared of you know tariff uncertainty
they kept talking about and the financial volatility that went along with it the labor
market was going to stop producing negative numbers and the recovery could take shape
but as we know it didn't happen we're still getting negative months in the payroll reports
the payroll reports five of the last nine in fact right up until february incomes are off as we've
caught we've gone over there too spending is soft mcdonald's is cutting prices dollar trees remaking
its stores to better welcome the higher income shoppers that are stopping by in droves all of
more unhealthy than it was at the beginning of 2025 and far more sickly than going back to 2024
the trend the cycle has not changed and that is the problem now we've got a growing energy shock
to contend with on top of everything else it's one that shows no signs of a quick resolution
unfortunately scanning through the world's crude oil benchmarks there's a lot of concerning
developments there's not just in terms of prices but also oil spreads i've talked about
the wti future spreads i mean something different in this video start with wti the main us oil
benchmark it's settled around 97 98 per barrel it's been as high as you know 120 for a brief
moment a couple weeks ago it was over a hundred dollars today not good obviously and it's up
sharply from february and gasoline is climbing to 315 per gallon went over that yesterday
diesel over five dollars but the comparative calm and yes it does appear calm in the u.s energy
market is somewhat of an illusion oil prices are sharply higher sharply higher and still rising
elsewhere the globally integrated marketplace is starting to break down brent crude the european
benchmark that one is at 109 110 111 a whopping 10 11 12 higher than wti normally
those two benchmarks are only a couple of bucks apart and it keeps getting worse abu dhabi's
merbin for may 2026 delivery currently sitting at 124 125 i've seen it as high as 128 today
this morning abu dhabi's main benchmark 100 moving toward 130 whereas u.s oil looks like it's less
than 100 and what all that means is desperate largely asian sources are still panic buying
crude now they've gotten all that they can from american sources and around the same region but
they're running into logistical and even fundamental roadblocks like the type of oil each
region largely uses either way the fact that panic buying isn't showing up as visibly in u.s prices
creates this impression the oil shock may be slowing down or even dissipating when that's far
from the case it is far from the case and what that ultimately means is that this is going to
as that panic buying continues it is going to revisit the u.s market and u.s prices again
here and there maybe not continuously but here and there like we're seeing in the other benchmarks
that's the time part of this global economic race the oil shock has a hold of the near-term future
and while all this is going on of course central bankers are meeting and there was a bunch of them
and while a couple of them including the fed responded reasonably to the oil shock
you knew that you knew they couldn't help themselves you knew they couldn't respond
to oil in any other way other than holy crap this is inflationary we need to start hiking rates and
largely the europeans they did not disappoint that's just what they do at best officials are
the biggest source of uncertainty at worst well like i said we've got the rate hikes in the past
in part to thank for the private credit bubble not the bust the bubble itself anyway there are
central bank meetings in australia canada the u.s sweden japan switzerland europe and england
uk england the aussies kicked everything off this week by hiking their policy rate for the second
straight meeting and that was followed by the canadians yesterday morning and the flmc in the
afternoon both of whom offered get this downright reasonable responses to the oil shock believe it
or not now we know how central bankers view energy costs they see them as highly inflationary
it doesn't matter it does not matter they never learn it doesn't matter history shows they are
not inflationary basic common sense too but central bank officials don't possess common
sense just like they don't have a printing press in fact the latter they don't have the printing
press is where the former they don't know common sense actually comes from however going back to
he sounded entirely reasonable with his take and yes i'm going to keep coming back to that word
reasonable if only compared to my own expectations for these people tiff said yesterday quote the
risk that higher energy prices quickly spread to the prices of other goods and services looks
contained now we use the word contain which has a very tortured history thanks to ben bernanke
but in this case he's got both common sense and basic economics on his side even the flmc and
they proved to be downright reasonable there weren't any rate hikes in them just a single
member and only one and only one time over the next couple of years the rest of the dots they
show that most of the flmc still expects more rate cuts ahead if not quite as many as they forecast
in december to projections they didn't change much either the flmc only raised its inflation
forecast by a couple of tenths that's it no surge in prices or interest rates to counter them but
jay powell spoke and came off hawkish with his you know flippant statement which i don't think
i think it was intentional and even if it wasn't overall canada and the fed entirely reasonable
reaction to oil but the europeans like i said they just could not help themselves especially
the brits now remember i talked about this last week the ecb raised its policy rate in july of
2008 let me say that again because most people who aren't aware of this would think that's just
absolutely crazy the ecb raised hiked its policy rate in july 2008 several months after bear
stearns and only a couple of months before lehman brothers and the meltdown and why did they do that
because they were focused on the what they thought was the inflationary impact of oil prices
not the banking crisis not the deepening recession oh no crude oil driven higher by a supply shock
so today the ecb and christine lagarde played right into the same trap lagarde said quote
if persistent higher energy prices may lead to a broader increase in inflation through
indirect and second round effects it's a situation which requires close monitoring nope that's not
how this works this is stupid expectations theory and it's nonsense and it's exactly why her
will be remembered for raising rates in 2008 and again in 2011 by the way just before i mean just
before yet another major deflationary shock slammed europe into a recession not inflation
into a deflationary recession but as bad as lagarde statement was the bank of england outdid her
at first its statement sounded like lagarde had written the damn thing
quote monetary policy cannot influence global energy prices which is true but aims to ensure
that the economic adjustment to them occurs in a way that achieves the two percent target
sustainably the npc or monetary policy committee at the bank of england is alert to the increased
risk of domestic inflationary pressures through again lagarde here second round effects and wage
and price setting the risk of which will be greater the longer higher energy prices persist
and that's just garbage but that's not all i mean the minutes from the bank of england's meeting
showed a clear hawkish shift on top of everything else including one of the typical doves one of
the dependable doves on the committee who now says they're considering rate hikes too so the market
response is to price a very good chance the bank of england raises its policy rate as soon as next
month next month and the front end of the yield curve not just in the uk but all across the entire
global bond market reacted back to repricing these official mistakes after you know the more
muted response yesterday to the mostly reasonable takes here in north america even in the u.s
treasury market let's go there the u.s treasury market has seen the two-year rate jump to now
a high of around 3.86 that's the market taking central banks as a group in repricing the overall
potential for the near-term path of policy rates as a group as an idea there's more ecb 2008 in
that group than there should be stupidity using expectations theory which is why the two-year
is reacting but that also explains why long-term rates have done almost nothing especially here in
u.s treasuries the treasury tenure by contrast has gone almost nowhere the yield was up earlier in
the day sure but it's right back to where it's been yesterday the twos are up sharply the tens
not much at all same for the 30-year long bond the market is repricing the fed not inflation and
not necessarily the fed just the higher chances the group think which is already running wild in
europe may eventually pressure some u.s officials and maybe enough u.s officials to follow them into
committing the same mistake as 2008 jean-claude trichet lives and he's at the front end of the
yield curve right now for beleaguered real estate there's a small silver lining here as we know
central banks don't set mortgage rates the market does and the spot on the yield curve which
determines mortgages is more like the 10-year than the two-year in the short run so long as long-term
rates remain settled mortgages and mortgage rates aren't going to chase after the oil inflation
foolishness that central bankers are themselves addicted to but that's a very small positive to
take out of everything that we just went over the far greater problem and the risk has nothing to do
with interest rates except how those interest rates eventually going to react to reality in these
conditions so the latest housing data just further confirms weak economy in a fragile state what's
happening across the oil patch shows the shock is showing no signs of slowing down or disappearing
they are on a collision course that's the race against time so forget central bankers and their
rate hikes and their inflation theories and expectations though they're going to make a lot
of noise in the short run it's about the housing market and the oil shock the oil spreads and the
dollar shock that's developing we didn't even get a chance to talk about the liquidations in metals
today the economics behind everything is relatively simple if at times very brutal we know what the
data says and what it looks like when we see these companies these big names respond to what the data
implies it offers highly compelling corroboration i went over some of that in the video link below
as always thank you very much for joining me huge thank you
you're at all university members and subscribers and until next time take care
