Movie Couple Therapy: ANYONE BUT YOU

Love Arcana - Where Love Finds Depth.
4 followers
12 Video Views·May 17, 2026
What makes a relationship last? Do you like grand romantic gestures?
Licensed therapist Jonathan Decker and filmmaker Alan Seawright are reacting to and roasting the popular romcom, Anyone But You. They talk about why Bea and Ben don’t work and why their lack of communication creates unnecessary problems throughout the movie. Jonathan rants about all of the couple’s problems and the nonsensical plot reasons that keep them apart. Alan goes along on the rant and shares his confusion over the oddly good bits in an overall turd of a movie.
AI Generated·May contain errors
You know, maybe we should do it.
Just tell everyone we're together.
We're on seventh grade.
We're all in seventh grade when it comes to this stuff.
We now have characters who are plotting to deceive the people that they care about.
Yes, we are very happy.
Happiest.
They are continually not keeping their emotions in check.
Sorry.
Yes, he's insecure.
Yes, he's hurting.
And yes, we do nonsensical things when we have strong feelings.
I can be affectionate.
I'll affectionate the ---- out of you.
Even with all of that in play, they're so mean.
Super mean.
And they're so spiteful.
There's a reason why you're alone.
No one can trust you.
Yeah, what's your reason?
Guys like you.
Understanding where a person is coming from, we can extend them grace because the fact is they both hurt each other.
Oh, maybe they want us to stop acting like assholes so we don't ruin the biggest event of their lives.
It's the day in, day out, how someone shows up for you or for themselves that show who they really are.
Hello, everyone, and welcome to Cinema Therapy.
I'm Jonathan Decker, licensed therapist who loves movies.
This is...
Alan Seawright, a professional filmmaker who needs therapy largely because I watched this movie.
Oh, my gosh.
We are going to be doing movie couples therapy on anyone but you, which, like most dumpster fire romantic comedies, was exceptionally popular.
He did not just...
Did you just say that?
Okay, to be fair...
I don't know if that's true.
No, I did that for dramatic effect.
Okay.
The fact is this is atrocious and so entertaining.
So much fun to hate.
I'm going to give you a heads up.
We are going to roast this movie, and if you're not on board with that, we got other episodes because we're not going to hold back.
Yeah.
But let's dive in to anyone but you, which we enjoyed despite ourselves.
I hate that I liked it, kind of.
Okay, so they had a wonderful meet cute with a rude barista and her having simulated intimacy with a hand dryer in the bathroom while drying her pants.
And toilet paper stuck to her shoe.
That's always funny.
I don't know this guy.
And he made her grilled cheese, and then they cuddled all night.
And she's talking to her friend.
He's...
Then she left.
And also abs.
Totally stole that from Honest Trailer.
Thanks, Honest Trailer guy.
What's up, Pete?
No way.
You cooked?
That girl you blew me off for stayed over?
He asked me out, and then I kind of asked him out, and then we just walked around the city, and we fell asleep talking.
I left before you could wake up.
I don't know why.
Why did I?
What the **** am I doing?
Okay, I love you.
Bye.
I'm so sorry I woke you up.
I didn't...
This whole thing is so new to me.
Bye.
So at this point in the movie, it doesn't make any sense.
You got cheese and bread.
You didn't miss one ingredient.
See, that's the type of stuff.
Why you got the giant wrench?
You told her about your mom, bro?
You don't tell nobody about your mom.
Dog, you in love, man.
Why does this movie have, like...
Tarantino-level F-bombs?
Scorsese-level F-bombs?
This girl's a disaster.
She's a nothing.
I do kind of love all the little quotes from Shakespeare,
because this is much ado about nothing.
It's much ado about nothing.
I don't know if you caught that.
I would much rather be watching the Joss Whedon version.
All problems with Joss Whedon aside,
that's a delightful movie.
It is a much better version of this.
The Ken Branagh one with Keanu Reeves in it.
And Denzel.
So good.
And Emma Thompson, yeah, I get it.
I had rather hear my dog bark at a crow
than a man swear he loves me.
So this was my first indicator.
I'm like, oh, I'm going to hate these people.
She did a stupid thing, and it didn't make sense.
And he's a jerk, and it doesn't make sense.
I didn't hate her.
I was scratching my head at why she had this wonderful night
with this guy who treated her really well,
and they had this great connection,
and she just bounces.
And it's not even like a, if you'll forgive the expression,
a hit it and quit it.
They don't even have sex.
No, they didn't even hit it.
They fall asleep talking, wake up clothed, and she leaves.
And the fact is, she didn't even see
what type of breakfast sammies he was going to make.
He was going to do the same thing as last night,
but with eggs.
Goat cheese and eggs.
Yeah.
All three ingredients.
So we learn later on why she does what she does.
But with him, like, yes, I get it.
He doesn't want to look bad in front of his bro.
But if you want me to dislike a male character,
have him be an ass to or about a woman
to save face with his friends.
Yep.
And I'm like, oh, I already hate him.
If Bea and Ben want to make this whole relationship work,
they're probably going to need some couples counseling.
Yeah, and their families are probably
going to need some family therapy after all
that they put them through.
Maybe they could have used BetterHelp.
Funny you should mention that, because this episode
is sponsored by BetterHelp.
BetterHelp connects you with a licensed therapist
who is trained to listen and give you
helpful, unbiased advice.
To get started, click the link below
or go to betterhelp.com forward slash cinematherapy
to fill out the questionnaire to assess your specific needs.
You'll get matched with a therapist, in most cases,
in 48 hours or less.
And they're committed to helping you find a therapist
who's a good fit for you.
Good fit, not hot girl fit.
Not hot girl fit.
BetterHelp has a network of over 30,000 therapists
with a wide range of expertise.
So you can easily switch to a new therapist
at no additional cost if the one you're first matched with
is not a fit.
Or doesn't know how to grill a cheese sandwich.
Therapists don't need to do that.
They don't.
And you can choose a time that's convenient for you
for your therapy sessions.
And you can also choose how you want
to do your therapy sessions.
A phone call, video chat, even through messaging.
But will they sing you your serenity song?
Probably not, but never say never, I guess.
What is your serenity song, by the way?
Enter Sandman by Metallica.
Mine is Anything by Barry Manilow.
Or Tom Jones.
Over 4 million people have used BetterHelp
to start living a healthier, happier life.
And you can, too.
If you think that you might benefit from therapy,
click the link below
or go to betterhelp.com forward slash cinematherapy.
You'll get 10% off your first month of BetterHelp
so you can connect with a therapist
and see if therapy helps you.
Six months later.
This is my sister.
This is Pete, Claudia's brother.
Nice to meet you.
And Ben.
Ben!
Oh.
This is Ben.
We all grew up together.
Hey.
Yeah.
You two know each other?
Yeah, we met.
Barely.
Wow, that's so random.
I'm gonna go grab a drink.
Door's that way if you're looking to sneak out.
I know that's your thing.
Oh, yay.
I'm a disaster.
Let's go away from this.
Yeah.
Okay.
So are you a lawyer yet?
Why?
Do you need a defense attorney?
I'm just curious how you passed the class on ethics
and not bailing on people.
Sheesh.
I think it was a jerk who B got with me
when she was on her break from Jonathan.
No way.
So B's the coffee girl who ghosted him?
I thought she looked familiar,
but I don't see faces.
I just see souls.
At least he knows.
See?
Again.
Good for you.
Shouldn't work.
I'll buy you a broomstick.
I'll send you an invite.
You still live at 28 *** Boy Lane?
You do remember,
so you did mean something to you.
You'll always be my rock bottom.
The night I spent with a bitch.
Did she just call him a ***?
You think they're gonna physically fight?
Or ***?
It's a fine line.
Let's just get through tonight with them, okay?
It's not.
She's your sister.
I'm sure the relationship won't last long.
She's your friend.
I question why they're even together.
Then I'm gonna get a drink
and toast to never seeing you again.
Cheers to that, bro.
Hi, this is our movie.
And at this point, I'm like,
the next hour and a half
are gonna be a freaking nightmare.
I'm not looking forward to this at all.
I'm laughing occasionally in spite of myself.
First of all,
why are they being so mean to each other?
It's been six months.
It was one night.
They didn't have sex.
They fell asleep talking.
Like, if anything,
there should be, like, mild annoyance.
Yeah, either mild annoyance or like,
hey, was this really as bad as I remember?
Or, I don't know.
She's cute.
They're so mean.
Super mean.
And they're so spiteful.
And I know, yes,
enemies to lovers
is like a time-worn rom-com trope.
But right now,
I feel a lot like Michael Clark Duncan
in The Green Mile
when he says,
Mostly I'm tired of people.
Well, then there's another thing.
The moment she says,
I am a disaster,
she reveals to him
that she overheard him.
This exact moment,
he should go,
Oh.
I'm sorry.
Like, he should be accountable?
Yeah, there should be
an accountability conversation,
an apology conversation.
I didn't mean it.
And I was being a jerk.
Which we get.
Yeah.
Later in the film.
But it should happen here.
But then we'd be deprived
of 90 minutes of Shakespeare
on Skinny Max.
Claude told me you dumped him.
To sneak out on your wedding day?
Wow, you are a child.
It's a pretty long flight.
Do you want anything
from the front of the boat?
Hot cookie, eye mask, pajamas?
Last ten years of your life?
No, thank you.
I'm all good on creatine
and small dick insecurity.
Nothing small about me.
What the f***?
That guy instantly becomes
my favorite character
in the whole movie.
He's the only one
who is responding correctly
to these ass******.
Nothing to get your audience
to root for these people
like having your male lead
class shame your female lead.
And your female lead
body shame your male lead.
Yep.
Can't wait to see
these crazy kids get together.
Oh boy, it's just
written in the stars.
You know why I think
this movie would actually
be really good on a date?
Why is that?
It's because you can't
help but feel superior
in comparison.
This is a great date movie.
Whoever you're on a date with.
Because you come out of it
no matter what.
You look at each other
and you go,
oh, we're not that bad.
Yeah, exactly.
My Black Hawk helicopter
parents have been trying
to get us back together
for the past four months.
They flew him halfway
across the world
to your sister's wedding?
That's some deep-ass
---- they came to play.
That's my parents
who think I'm
throwing my life away.
Black Hawk helicopter
parents is a line
that should be great
and it doesn't work
for some reason.
I'll see you later.
Honestly, parents meddling
on this level
in their single daughter's life
is the most believable
part of this movie.
Like, I know it sounds
horrible, but I've met
those parents.
That problem for me
and that problem for you.
So let's pretend
that we are actually in love.
Is what she says.
I don't have a problem.
You clearly want Margaret.
No, I don't.
Yes, you do.
I saw the way you looked
at her last night
and I know
she broke your heart.
She sees you're with me.
She wants what she can't have
and then bye-bye
Crocodile Jack.
There's no way
we can convince anyone
we actually like each other.
Yeah, you're right.
I know.
You know, I still think
about that night
we spent together.
Shut up.
No, I'm serious.
You know, this could
be kind of fun.
We're at a wedding
a million miles away
from home.
Who knows what could happen
under the cover of a masquerade
on that night at your place.
Doesn't matter how it ended.
It was still pretty amazing.
Convincing enough?
F*** it.
Let's do it.
That's where you drop the F-bomb.
That is the correct place for it.
Use that one.
Again, this is based on
Much Ado About Nothing.
So why don't I go after
Much Ado About Nothing?
It's equally implausible
but it's far more charming
and that's the key.
Better written
by Billy Shakes.
Weird.
But in the context
of this universe
we now have characters
who are plotting
to deceive the people
that they care about.
He wants to steal
his ex from her
current boyfriend.
That's a great motive.
No problems with that.
She wants her parents
to back off
and stop meddling
in her love life.
I understand her better.
Yeah, her
I understand 100%.
She could also
maybe just
confront them
about it directly.
Yeah.
Yep.
I don't know.
Hey, guys.
Not cool.
Doing this at
like you're adding drama
to your daughter,
my sister's wedding
and you did this
without my consent.
Not appreciated.
Yep.
And that's how
you have that conversation
and then you decide
what to do.
Was that bull****
about your mom?
What?
The story about
the giant wrench.
I thought it might have
been a lie
and you tell all
your one night nothings.
But you guys
didn't even have sex.
You overheard that too.
Like I didn't mean
I'm sorry.
Thank you.
And it wasn't a lie.
Thanks for being so nice
to my dad.
You should probably
rinse off.
You have his
SPF a billion
on you now.
Okay.
I get so frustrated
by
things don't happen
in the story.
Why?
Because we need them
to happen later.
We need them to happen later
because plot reasons.
Like
not character reasons.
He knows that he hurt her.
He knows that she overheard.
He knows he was a jack****.
He says I'm sorry.
And he sees that she softens.
And instead of
busting his chops anymore
she says thanks for being
nice to my dad.
We have a shift in momentum.
Yeah.
Not necessarily like
romantic or sexual momentum
but like just from
we hate each other too.
Maybe we could get along
and this doesn't have to be
a miserable experience.
Yeah, let's at least
not hate each other
for the next couple of days.
And be civil.
He should keep this going.
This is the moment
for him to say hey
the things that you heard me say
I was hurt when you left
and I didn't want to look
like an idiot
in front of my friend
and that was a stupid
jerk thing for me to do
and I'm sorry.
I'm sorry that I said it.
I'm especially sorry
that you heard it
and that it hurt you.
And I was completely
out of line.
And he already knows
that if he did that
it would go well
because he just said
the words I'm sorry
and it went well.
And instead he just like
lets it be.
Why?
Because the plot
needed to happen.
And here's what I want to know
from those who watched the movie
because maybe we're missing it.
Is there a in-character
in-universe reason
for him not to follow through
and be fully accountable
right here?
Because I'm not getting it.
Can I do the line?
He's the king of the world.
You're the king of the world.
Jack, I'm flying.
Okay, we can stop there.
That was cute.
Yep.
That was cute.
Oh man.
Starting to kind of
sort of bite.
So now they're selling like
he dives in after her
and the idea is that
what he does here
shows who he truly is
and where his heart truly lies
and with whom it lies
and that's all fine and well.
But how he chooses to act
also matters?
Yeah.
And he's been a douche rocket
for an hour and a half.
Yep.
And so yeah,
we have this moment
where we see who he really is
but like that's the thing.
If we pattern our lives
after these sorts of movies
we're always waiting
for those big moments.
Right.
Yeah, you're waiting
for the grand romantic gesture.
And that the big moment
cancels out
all of the patterns of behavior.
Right.
And the difference
between real life
and romantic comedies
is in romantic comedies
you have an hour and a half
sometimes two hours
to establish drama
to create a hook
and to have a turn
that makes it
this big entertaining journey.
Sure, yeah.
Real life doesn't work like that.
Real life, it's the habits.
Yeah.
It's the day in, day out
how someone shows up for you
or for themselves
that show who they really are.
That being said
if you can manage
to figure out
how to do the occasional
grand romantic gesture
Oh yeah.
Along with your habits
of like doing
you know
the everyday stuff
that you need to
to make a relationship
that's great.
Everybody loves
a grand romantic gesture.
There's a reason
these movies make
200 million dollars.
The issue unfortunately
is I've had any number
of couples in therapy
where you have a person
who is day in, day out
selfish, self absorbed
rude, entitled, cruel
and will occasionally
show up with one of these
and occasionally
show up with a big
grand romantic gesture
and it's like
well this is how
it's supposed to be.
It's not.
We never fought.
Talking about her
and Jonathan.
It was just
comfortable
and he's a great guy
which means
there's no one out there
for me because
I had the best one.
What's wrong
with any of this?
Seriously.
She is describing
my relationship
with my wife
and it's awesome.
We're going to get
eaten by sharks
I had to tell somebody.
No one else knows?
I don't think
this is the weekend
to drop that bomb.
You've dropped
plenty of other bombs.
You finally did it.
What?
You know one night
you said you didn't
want to be a lawyer anyways.
You remember that?
It was a memorable night
until you
snuck out of course.
Why did you?
Because you scared
the ---- out of me.
It was the first time
in my life
that I felt fire
and I had to blow it out.
I find this framing
just deeply weird.
I know a little bit
about that.
You say those random stuff.
Like why is there
so much empty space
to her right?
Hang on,
I want to hear what they're saying.
It's not how I felt.
Look at us.
Just a couple of
f***ed up people
floating in the middle
of the harbor.
So he told her
that was she overheard.
Promise me if we
make it out alive
we'll go see that
from dry land.
He didn't mean it.
We're going to kill
her view from here.
I have no notes
on this conversation.
I actually think
this is the most beautiful
scene in the movie
of ownership
of humility
of forgiveness
of understanding
and recognizing
something that we
talk about a lot
which is
understanding
where a person
is coming from
is not the same thing
as condoning behavior.
Right.
But when we understand
where a person's coming from
we can extend them grace
because the fact is
they both hurt each other.
They both
from a place of pain
that very first interaction
that hurt them so badly
that it spread
throughout the whole movie.
Again,
my real problem
with this scene
is that it should have
happened an hour ago.
Like in real life
in real life
but then we wouldn't
have the movie
and then vulnerability
leads to connection.
I don't even know
what's real anymore.
Everything I do
just feels like a mistake.
So she says one thing
that could be taken
in a couple different ways.
He immediately jumps
to the worst possible conclusion
which is that she regrets
this night
even though
even though she's still
holding his hand
and smiling.
Yes.
And then he bounces
instead of
because he doesn't want to do this.
Hey, what did you mean
by that?
Yeah.
Which could potentially lead
to a mood-killing
awkward pixelated butt.
He doesn't want to have
the awkward conversation
for whatever reason.
Maybe he's afraid
to hear what she has to say.
He's afraid of getting hurt.
He's afraid of hurting her.
is that conversation though?
Hey, did you mean
you regret this right now?
Yeah.
Oh, no, no, no.
Oh, okay.
It's not that awkward.
Or she could say
maybe
and he could say
okay.
Do you want me to go
or do you want me to stay?
And they can have a dialogue
but like
by trying to avoid
a scenario where
he hurts her
or she hurts him
he creates a scenario
where it's guaranteed
that both are hurt.
Correct.
And he does to her
the very thing
that hurt him so badly
at the beginning
except for this time
it's right after they had sex
which feels like
more of an insult.
And this is one of the things
where okay
yes
he's insecure
yes he's hurting
and yes we do
nonsensical
idiotic things
when we have
strong feelings.
Right?
I get all of that.
Still
even with all of that
in play
like it makes more sense
for him to say
well what's that supposed to mean?
And have like
an ugly tone with her
and for her to react
to the ugly tone
and then they have a
fighting misunderstanding
and leave
that would play out
That would have been
a better way to do it.
If you want the same result.
If you want the same result
because at least
that feels real.
I don't understand why
he would just
bounce.
Here's your big romantic
gesture scene
and in fairness
as far as those
types of scenes go
it's a pretty good one.
I do
question whether or not
you can just
call Harbor Rescue
like an Uber though.
I can do Margaret.
She kissed me.
I know that's a
bull**** excuse
but it's true.
I couldn't find
a moving train.
Sorry it's the best
I could do.
But I'm rich.
Are you out of your mind?
Yeah
because it's been
two years
since we met
and I haven't spent
every single day with you.
That's the sign
of a crazy person.
I hated you.
I didn't really
give you a choice.
And I definitely
didn't hate you
even though you
called me a b****.
I said you were
acting like a b****.
No I was a b****.
The way I handled everything.
The way I handled the first
That was funny.
The way I handled last night.
Gosh dang it.
Yeah it wasn't
really awesome.
Why did you leave?
I thought you were
going to regret it.
And I couldn't face
the idea of losing
someone else that I
I really loved.
Last night was the
first thing I haven't
regretted in a long time.
And she could have
told you that in bed.
Yep.
I love the way we fight.
I love
how smart you are.
I love
the weird way you
stick your hands
down my pants.
And I love
how you know what
you don't want.
There's a whole scene.
It's a whole bit.
And if it's not me
if I don't
check all your boxes
if I'm not the one
I get it.
That would really
really f****** suck.
There's another good use.
Yeah.
Keep it there.
That's fine.
And it's very real.
So you're going to
kiss me now?
Yeah.
I am.
Comedies serve a purpose.
True.
They're as much escapism
as anything else.
And so I'm not
going to hate on it
for that.
I do wish
we got more of
the good stuff.
Yeah, man.
It was
this movie was
really uneven
and
the relationship
was
a turd.
It was a turd.
Well, and then
they sort it out by the end.
But that's the
that's the genre, right?
That's
we want to see that arc.
We want to see that
growth and change.
But your relationships
don't need to follow
this model.
You don't need to wait
for the grand romantic
gestures to have it
proven to you.
Watch how they act
day in, day out.
And if you get
into a relationship
with somebody
and you're not
fighting,
that is not a sign
that it is boring
or this is the best
I can do.
Probably a sign
that it's working.
It's working as long
as the not fighting
is because you're
having health
It's not because
you're both avoiding.
Right.
It's because some couples
they fight and then
they get together
and it's great
and it's passionate.
Like the real thing
comes down to,
OK, do we fight?
If so, how do we fight?
Yes.
Are we mean and cruel
and petty and vindictive
with one another?
Or are we just
passionately expressing
our hurt and our anger
and our pain
and just laying it
all out there
and then sorting
through it?
Sure.
Because I've seen
couples have fights
that are actually
healthy fights.
This is the end
of the beginning
of a relationship.
That was very confusing.
Yes.
What do they do
to make a healthy relationship
going forward
that we don't get to watch
because apparently
that wouldn't be
good cinema?
They need to create
new patterns
because we've seen
outliers of healthy behavior.
We've seen outliers
Yeah, I've seen a couple
scenes that are really good.
Yeah.
Of this vulnerability
of being honest
of being open
of taking responsibility
of extending grace
and forgiveness
to one another
of seeing the real person
and letting the guard down
like all these things
but the habitual behavior
is small minded
and petty
and crotch slapping
and putting your own pain
before the well being
of everybody else
in your life.
And that type of behavior
is going to kill this
unless they turn it around.
And so what I would advise
them to do
is I'd be like
okay guys look at these
these moments
you've already seen
that you can create
something healthy together
how do we keep
that momentum going?
Right.
How do we create
new neural pathways
new habits
instead of what we saw
for most of the run time
of this.
That's what I would do.
Okay.
Well there you go.
Anyone but you.
Any movie but this one.
So until next time.
You got the cheese
and the bread bro.
You got both ingredients.
Why are you so out of breath?
You're a hot girl thing.
And.
Watch movies.
Maybe not this one.
We want to thank our patrons
for all the love and support.
If you're not on our Patreon
you're missing out
on so much exclusive
awesome stuff.
We want to thank folks
like
You've got options
with a name.
Grace.
Cozy Wazzy.
Esther.
Amy Vader.
The most terrifying
of all the Sith Lords.
Amy Vader.
We love you.
Thank you.
