The Car Payment Trap No One Talks About...

Entrepreneurial Edge
21 followers
In this video, I’m breaking down how car payments quietly doubled in length, why that shift benefits everyone except the buyer, and how so many people ended up stuck in long-term loans without realizing it.
⏱️ Timestamps:
0:00 - Start Here
1:01 - 3 Major Forces
5:03 - State of Current Market
6:38 - Actual Cost of Ownership
9:19 - 5 Strategies if Buying a Car
#business #entrepreneur #marketing #success #smallbusiness #motivation #money #businessowner #entrepreneurship #digitalmarketing #startup #branding #mindset #investment
AI Generated·May contain errors
Take a look at this document from the Federal Reserve back in 1963.
It's titled Automobile Installment Loans at Commercial Banks.
Back then, the majority of car loan terms were under 36 months,
with 69.5% of them being between 31 and 36 months,
and only 0.7% of car loans were over the 36-month mark.
Fast forward to today, and the average new car loan term is 69 months.
That's more than double the length of most loans back in the 60s.
Currently, 22.4% or 1 in 5 people are taking out loans with terms of 84 months,
96 months, and even 108 months on a depreciating asset.
This is the car payment trap that we as a society are falling so hard for,
but is it really our fault?
In this video, I'm going to show you exactly how we got here,
why this is the most dangerous financial trap in America right now,
and most importantly, what you can do about it
if you are thinking about buying a car this year.
So immediately upon finding this Federal Reserve data,
my brain kind of went to,
well, how did we actually go from a three-year car loan being the norm,
and now it's all of a sudden six years, seven years, or maybe eight years?
I think there are three major forces at play.
The first being wage stagnation versus car price inflation.
So in 1963, the average new car cost about $3,233 at the time.
The median household income back then was around $6,200 per year.
That means if you took the average price of a new car versus the median household income,
the average new car would represent 52% of the annual household income at that time.
Now, as of Q4 2025, the average new car price is just over $50,000.
I know that sounds crazy, but it is.
I double-checked it, and the annual household income these days is $84,000.
That means the average new car price now represents
60% of annual household income in 2026.
So cars went from taking about half your salary to taking nearly 60% of it,
but what's crazy is that adjusted for inflation,
the 1963 car should be costing about $32,000 in today's dollars.
Instead, a new car costs about $50,000,
and that's an $18,000 premium or 56% more expensive than they were back in the 60s.
Now, yes, modern cars are more advanced.
You get better safety features, fuel efficiency, and technology.
This is true, but that doesn't offset the fact that we didn't get
56% richer to match the 56% increase in car prices.
The prices of other common expenses has also increased at a faster pace
relative to income, such as rent, gas, and groceries.
So affording a car payment now is still harder than it was relatively back then.
So the car industry solution to selling a $50,000 car
to many people that can't even afford them
is to simply make the loan term six years, seven years, or eight years instead of three.
But that brings me to my second force here,
which is that banks realize that longer loan terms are way more profitable for them.
Let's simply compare a 36-month loan on $40,000 at an interest rate of 6%.
Your monthly payment is going to be $1,217 per month,
with $3,808 in total interest paid over the life of this loan.
Now, if we take the same loan, but stretch it out to six years,
you can see that the monthly payment goes down to $773 a month.
That's pretty nice, but the total interest you pay is $6,399 over the life of that loan.
By stretching out the loan, the lender receives $2,591 more dollars from you,
and you multiply this times the hundreds of thousands,
if not millions of car buyers, and you can see how lucrative this can get.
And the genius part from their perspective is that the longer that you have a loan,
the more opportunities there are going to be for, let's say, missed payments,
which means more fees, or even worse, you are underwater on your car loan,
which means that you can't refinance your car loan,
and then you may even be tempted to roll your negative equity into a new long loan.
So banks realize if they can normalize car loans to be longer,
they can make way more money for every single car sold.
But all of this wouldn't be possible without force number three today,
which is that car manufacturers and dealers realize that longer loans
help them sell more expensive cars.
In America, when you visit a car dealership,
they love to focus on what payments you can afford on a monthly basis.
If you look at all the car commercials out there, of which there are so many,
almost all of them will advertise a monthly payment at the end of those commercials.
From a dealer's perspective, pretend your customer comes in,
and they can only afford $500 a month. Here are your options for them.
They can either buy a $30,000 car with a 60-month loan,
a $35,000 car with a 72-month loan,
or a $40,000 car with an 84-month loan.
To the customer, it's the same monthly budget,
but selling a more expensive car might make your dealership more profit.
So if car dealers are incentivized to sell pricier cars,
and car salesmen are also benefiting because they get a higher commission,
you can see where the incentives are here and how misaligned they are.
The car industry essentially has moved the gold posts on what's considered acceptable,
and most people haven't even noticed it's happening.
Why should a six to seven-year loan feel normal?
And why is the average new car payment close to $750 per month?
This is not normal by any means, but this is where our society is.
To prove my point even further, let's just take a look at two car payment
amounts from this popular auto dealer video on TikTok.
What's the highest car payment you've seen?
$1,200.
On what?
Suburban.
Jeff, highest monthly payment you've ever seen?
$3,700.
Now, those payments are crazy, but I also want to quickly recap the state of the current market,
because I think it actually compounds this problem even further.
If you watched my last video on the car market crash last year,
you know that millions of people who bought cars during the pandemic markup era
are now deeply underwater on their loans.
But what I didn't talk about enough was that the longer loan terms
have made this situation exponentially worse.
So in that previous video, I talked about a guy who bought a Tesla Model Y for $72,000 in 2022.
However, in 2024, he still owed $52,000 on his loan, and the car was only worth $38K.
That means he was underwater on his loan by $14,000.
Now, if he had taken out a three-year or 36-month loan,
he'd almost be done paying it off, if not already paid off,
despite the depreciation and Elon repricing the Model Ys.
Of course, you could probably point out that maybe he was forced to take a five- or six-
or seven-year loan because if he made it a shorter loan in the first place,
maybe he couldn't afford it at all.
The main reason people are going underwater on car loans is that cars can depreciate
faster than the rate at which they're paying down their loan balance.
So I think that having a shorter loan term significantly reduces your risk of being underwater.
So here's an example.
On a $30,000 car with a 36-month loan,
you might owe $20,000 on the principal balance after one year,
while the car is still worth $24,000 to $25,000.
But when you have a 72-month loan after one year, you might still owe $26,000 in the car,
while the car is worth $24,000, and it's already putting you in the negative.
That's why it's always suggested to put a higher down payment
and try to combine it with a shorter loan term, even if it's harder on your budget.
But we will talk about that a little bit later in our last section today.
Now, an exercise that everyone should do in order to not fall into this payment trap
before you ever buy a car is to calculate your real costs.
Let me show you what a car actually costs when you factor in everything.
So we're going to use this Toyota Camry with a $32,000 sticker price,
and this is still far below the average new car price in America.
Let's look at a 36-month loan where you put 20% down.
Your down payment is going to be $7,000, and you're getting a loan on $25,000.
With an interest rate of 6.5%, you will have a monthly payment of $767 a month,
and the total interest paid on this loan is $2,612 over the course of this loan.
Now, here's what your monthly payment might look like after you factor in gas,
maintenance, and insurance costs, as well as your car payment.
You're looking at about $1,200 a month.
And this is pretty crazy.
You would think that if you were shelling out $1,200 a month,
you'd be able to afford something like a BMW 5 Series or something like that.
That's a huge misconception and is the exact reason why so many people you see
are driving fancy cars like lifted trucks or exotic, you know, German cars,
but they're in mountains of debt.
Realistically, $1,217 a month all in on transportation payments is going to
get you something like this Toyota Camry if you want to be within reason on your budget.
Fast forward after the payments are over,
and your monthly cost with no car payment is still $500 a month.
I did increase the maintenance cost here of $50,
since as the car gets older, you'll naturally have to spend a little bit more per month.
At year six, that means the total that you paid in payments,
insurance and maintenance and gas is $34,200.
Your total car payments totaled $27,612,
bringing your total cost of ownership to $61,812 over six years.
The car at the end of that term is still worth about $18,000.
So you want to subtract the value from your total cost of ownership,
which means that your true cost of ownership for the six years was $43,812.
Now, listen, if you get a six-year loan, the numbers are somewhat comparable.
The only difference is that you will pay roughly $2,674
more in interest over the course of that loan.
But the main kicker here is that if you opt for a three-year loan,
you will have three years with no car payments in years four, five, and six.
That's $767 a month you aren't paying during those years versus if you had a 72-month loan,
yes, you are paying a lower monthly payment of $420-ish a month,
but you are making those payments the entire time you have that car.
There's a lot of freedom to not having a car payment,
including the risk of being underwater on your loan.
You can also use the extra cash for other opportunities like investing,
where that money could be earning you 7% to 8% annually in the market.
Over those three years, for example, that could add up to over $30,000.
So I think the trap here is that a long loan term keeps you trapped in payments longer,
even if they are more technically affordable.
All right, so what should you actually do about this if you need to buy a car
this year in 2026, or maybe even next year?
There are five strategies that I'd like to share with you today.
So strategy number one, think in total cost, not the monthly payment.
You want to do this always if you can,
because the dealer is focused on the monthly payment.
You should be focused on the total cost.
The easiest framework for this is to take your monthly transportation budget,
multiply it by 36 months, or maybe even 48 months, and then subtract your down payment.
This gives you a very conservative price of a car to target.
So for example, if you know that you can spend $500 a month on transportation,
that comes out to $18,000 in payments over 36 months, or $24,000 in payments over 48 months.
You then want to subtract your down payment, which let's say for this case is $3,000.
That means the car that you should realistically target with this $500
a month budget is somewhere between $15,000 and $21,000.
This target might limit you to just use cars, which is a good thing.
It's essentially the market and your budget
telling you what you can actually afford without overextending yourself.
The second strategy is to choose a car with low maintenance costs and insurance costs,
if possible.
You can go visit Edmunds.com to check out the true cost to own
on different cars and see which ones are the easiest and cheapest to maintain.
For insurance, you can try to save some money on insurance by comparing insurance
offers across different providers, or just simply optimizing the type of
coverage you are paying for.
I will link a free insurance comparison tool down below in the description,
where you can easily check to see if you're already getting the best deal on insurance.
So you could try to save some money that way.
The third actionable item that you should be keeping in mind
as you buy a new car in 2026 is to follow the 24-10 rule.
This is still a really good benchmark rule, and it still applies today.
It states that you should put 20% down on any car that you buy,
finance the car for no more than four years,
and keep your total transportation costs under 10% of your monthly gross income.
So for example, if you make $84,000 a year, that's about $7,000 a month,
your total car costs should be under $700 a month as a simple strategy.
The fourth thing that you should keep in mind if you must buy now
is to look for a car that's between two to three years old.
That is the used car sweet spot.
Right now, because of the markup era during the pandemic,
22 to 2023 vehicles are actually really good deals relative to new cars,
because they've already had most of their depreciation paid for by somebody else.
And you can still get a really good certified pre-owned car that feels like new.
Let's use the Camry from earlier's example.
A Camry brand new will cost you $32,000,
but after three years, it might be worth $24,000.
That's $8,000 in depreciation that someone else paid for you,
just if you buy it used.
So I think that's always a good option.
Now, strategy number five has to do with,
if you're currently in a long-term loan and feeling stuck,
there are three options you can pursue if you find yourself in this situation.
The first is to make extra principal payments.
So if you're in a 72-month loan right now,
you can shave off 12 to 24 months off of that loan
if you're willing to pay an extra $100 or $200 a month in prepayments.
You want to check that your contract allows for this,
but most contracts you should be able to put down extra money
towards the principal balance of that loan.
The next is to simply drive it longer than the car loan.
So if you're willing to pay off the car in 72 months,
make sure you can at least drive it for a minimum of three to four more years
with $0 car payments.
The worst mistake here is rolling your loan into another long-term loan.
That would be falling into the payment trap today.
And the third option for you is that if you are feeling a little stuck
is to try to refinance the loan.
If your credit score has improved or interest rates drop,
you could refinance the loan to a 36-month loan.
The car payment might go up, yes,
but at least you escape the trap faster and pay less in interest overall.
In 1963, people took out three-year car loans,
paid off their cars,
and drove them for years afterwards with no payment.
It's certainly a lot harder to do that in 2026,
but if you're watching this video
and you want to compare yourself to the average American,
they never stop having a car payment.
If you can stick to a three- or four-year car loan,
you're going to be in such a better spot financially than everybody else.
And then you're going to be able to take that extra money and actually invest it.
The auto industry has conditioned us to think that
six-, seven-, and eight-year loans are normal,
but don't let them do that.
If you enjoyed this video,
you'll probably enjoy this one right here on car affordability.
I share my full formula on how to calculate how much of a car you can afford.
I'll see you guys in that video or a future one on the channel.
Thank you for being here again.
