This Medieval Roman Church Shows Why The Past Is Underground

Timeless Architecture
14 followers
3 Video Views·May 1, 2026
The Basilica of San Clemente in Rome is one of the most extraordinary sites to visit in the city. What looks like a straightforward (if impressive) medieval church actually hides Roman history that goes back nearly TWO THOUSAND. And you can visit almost all of it! In this video, we explore this church and what it tells us about how the past ends up underground.
This is the Colosseum in Rome. It's probably among the most instantly recognizable places in the
world, like Stonehenge or the Pyramids of Giza. And sure, ancient Roman amphitheaters are fine,
but literally down the street from the Colosseum is a building that I think is
way more interesting. It's amazing for all sorts of reasons, but in particular for what it tells
us about how and why the past gets buried underground over the centuries. This is the
Basilica of San Clemente. It may not look like much from the outside, but this church contains
almost the entirety of Roman history, from the ancient city up to the early modern period.
Today, a full visit to this church, which is very much worth seeing if you're in Rome,
starts out roughly at ground level and then goes deep below the surface. How many layers down?
Two levels. Three. Not possible.
Very possible. You end up far underground, at the street level of ancient Rome.
How did this happen? Why do we end up with this sort of layer cake of history?
We are about to find out. Grab a shovel and let's take a visit, or at least a virtual visit, to the
San Clemente was built in honor of Pope Clement I, who was pope from 92 to 99 CE, at least per
the Vatican. Clement was also martyred. In his case, he was tied to an anchor and then thrown into the
sea, which makes staying afloat challenging. He was then made a saint by the Christian church.
The church of San Clemente doesn't date back all the way to Pope Clement's own day,
but by the fourth century, there was a church dedicated to Clement in Rome. And we know this
because the early Christian theologian Saint Jerome, writing around the year 380, mentions a
church in Rome built in Clement's honor. So we've got a very old reference to a church dedicated to
Clement in Rome, and we've got a very old church known as San Clemente that still stands in Rome
today. End of story, right? Not so fast. For centuries, people did assume that this church,
and the one mentioned by Jerome and some other early Christian writers, were one and the same.
But by about 1850, a Dominican priest named Father Joseph Mellulli began to have some
doubts about this. In his view, the topography of this part of the city, that is, the features
of the land around the church, just didn't make sense for this to be a late antique structure.
He also looked at some details in the marble furnishings inside, and they didn't seem quite
right either. Instead, Father Mellulli suspected that the original San Clemente was actually buried
somewhere nearby. Over the next several years, workers painstakingly excavated the site of San
Clemente. Father Mellulli says that some 150,000 cartloads of rubble and gravel were carried out
in baskets on the shoulders. When they were done, they found an entire other church directly below
the current one. What's even more impressive is that it was remarkably well-preserved.
It even had its original columns and the remains of extensive wall decorations.
Today, you visit this lower church by going down a set of steps just off the right or north side
of the upper church. And in case you're wondering, when they were excavating this lower church,
they also had to install some brick vaults and arches in order to support the upper church above.
So it turned out that this was the early Christian basilica from late antiquity,
a church below a church, not just of a similar size, but actually a bit wider than the one on
top. At this point, we're a little over four meters, or about 13, 14 feet below the level
of the pavement of the church above us. And actually, that upper church is already below
the modern street level. You have to go down a few steps to enter it. But hold on, now that we know
the upper church isn't the one mentioned back in the 380s by Jerome, how do we know if this lower
one is that church? What if it's just churches all the way down? Well, Father Meluli and his team
kept digging, and it just so happens that there is another level below this church. Today, you take
more stairs down to this sub-sub level. At this point, we're at the street level of ancient Rome
in the first century CE. There are two ancient buildings here, neither of which was originally a
church. One is a large rectangular building whose outer walls are big blocks of tufa, a type of
limestone. We think this building was originally a mint. Its interior walls have some amazing brickwork,
and one of the rooms even has an ancient spring of flowing water. Up until recently, you could
reach down and touch this water. It's now covered up with a plexiglass plate or something. The other
building at this level is an apartment house or insula, but what's really amazing is the space
between these two structures. In this photo, we're literally standing in an ancient alleyway as it was
nearly 2,000 years ago. Above us is all the chaos and madness of modern Rome, and down here is a
little slice of the ancient city. Just imagine all the crazy hijinks that might have happened in this
alley. But this layer has more to reveal. There is evidence down here of previous buildings that
were even older and deeper than the mint and the apartment house. So while we've gone three levels
down, there is an indication of a fourth level, though it's not really accessible in the same way.
But again, there is evidence of it. Okay, so we've made it to the deep past. How do we go from here,
way underground, to the medieval church several levels above us and the modern street level?
What's the deal with all this layering of history? For that, we need to do the return journey.
Back to the future! Or at least we need to go back to the future from the perspective of this level
nearly two millennia down. So let's consider we're currently at the lowest level that you can visit
and explore today. And as mentioned, there is some evidence that there were structures down here
built even before the mint and the apartment house. It's not clear what exactly was at that
original level, but it probably dates back to the time of the emperor Claudius or Nero,
so sometime in the first century CE. But in the year 64, there was a major fire in Rome. It burned
for several days and caused widespread destruction across the city. And here is how the past gets
buried. Before the development of modern construction and earth moving equipment, it was
generally way easier to just build on top of older ruined structures. When the dust or ashes had
settled from the great fire in 64, Romans wouldn't have bothered with clearing out all the wreckage.
That's a lot of work. Instead, they often just filled in the ruins and began constructing on
this new layer of the ground. And it was on this ground, atop the ruins of the great fire of Rome,
that the mint and the house were built, sometime around the end of the first century or at the
start of the second century. About a hundred years after the house was completed, a religious group
decided to add a worship space to the building's central courtyard. This was a small but growing
religion that featured sacred meals, a supernatural divine birth, and initiation rites for its
members. I'm talking, of course, about Mithraism. This was one of several religious mystery cults
that popped up in the ancient Roman world. Christianity was not the only game in town.
We can't get too deep into Mithraism, but it was popular among Roman soldiers from the first to
fourth century. If you're curious to learn more, let me know in the comments and I'll see if I can
put together something on the mystery cult of Mithras. Anyway, back to San Clemente. Here's
where the timeline of construction gets a little fuzzy, so I'm just going to go with what I think
is the likely scenario. Just keep in mind that there's some disagreement among scholars on the
Sometime in the middle of the third century, the upper floors of the Tufa building, the mint,
were demolished and the lowest level was filled in. That would have further raised the ground
level. At this point, a private house was built on this new level. The house probably served as
a gathering space for Christians. And eventually, sometime in the late fourth or early fifth
century, that private worship space was renovated and transformed into a public worship space.
It became the lower church of San Clemente. Its form is pretty much the standard early Christian
basilica shape. It's got a nave, two side aisles, and apse, and originally had a rectangular atrium
in front. Again, all built atop the ruins of the previous structures, the mint and the apartment
house. This early Christian basilica was used for hundreds of years. Over the centuries, it was
restored and renovated several times, as you'd expect for something so old. The last of these
renovations took place in the 11th century and included a number of new frescoes or wall paintings.
We won't go into detail on them, but I do want to point something out in one image that I think
is really fascinating. This painting, which shows a story from the life of Saint Clement, features
some of the earliest written Italian that survives anywhere. Maybe not surprisingly, it has
someone yelling and cursing. This guy over here has been fooled into thinking his servants are
dragging Clement to prison. In reality, they're just pulling a stone column. He's shouting at them,
in early Italian, Fili delle putte, traite, which means, pull you sons of bitches, along with a few
other lines. And just like in modern comics, the words are next to the speaker. Back to Saint Clement
itself. Very soon after these renovations and frescoes in the late 11th century, this lower
church was replaced with the upper church. It's not exactly clear why. This meant that any openings
in the walls of the lower church were filled in, the colonnades were blocked up, and then the lower
church was completely filled with rubble and dirt. This became the foundation for the new church,
which was built directly on top of the old one, from about 1100 to 1120. If you look at the plans
of the two churches, you can see just how closely the upper one follows the old. The south aisle
wall is built directly on top of the older south aisle wall. The south colonnade is on top of the
lower south colonnade. But then they built the north colonnade on a new foundation, and the north
wall is on top of the old north colonnade. What this means is that the new church is a bit narrower
than the lower one. But in general, its form is the same. A central nave, two side aisles, a
semicircular apse, and an atrium with a courtyard. So we're back in the Middle Ages, the future from
the point of ancient Rome, where we just were all those layers down. Or are we? See these columns in
the upper church? Every single one of them has a shaft that dates back to ancient Rome, and almost
all the bases of the columns are ancient as well. The capitals date to the 18th century, but before
then it seems that the original ones were also ancient. So we haven't gotten away from ancient
Rome after all. This reuse of old columns and building materials is not unique to San Clemente.
Lots of medieval churches in Rome and elsewhere reused older materials. And why wouldn't you? The
city was filled with building materials. Repurposing them was much easier than doing all the hard work
of quarrying new stone, transporting it, and then carving it into the desired shape. But it's more
than just reusing old building materials. At San Clemente, the form of the church itself is a
throwback to late antiquity and the early days of the Christian church. The same is true for many of
the original decorations, like this apse mosaic that calls back to early Christian decorative
elements. There are many reasons to make these sorts of formal decisions, but a lot of it probably
has to do with highlighting the deep history of Christianity in Rome. We see similar throwback
decisions being made in other churches around the city from about the same time. What is unique to
San Clemente is just how much of its physical history is preserved and accessible to us today.
That's what makes visiting it so amazing. You can very literally walk down into the past step by
step, layer by layer. The reality is that Rome, like many cities, has millennia of material culture
buried everywhere beneath its surface. Most of it stays hidden unless someone excavates it. This can
be the result of things like the ground level rising due to the erosion of nearby hills or
sediment deposits from flooding, but it's generally due to the nature of ancient construction practices.
The rubble of old buildings makes a great foundation for new buildings, and it's much easier
to build on top of wreckage than it is to clear it out. So if you're someone who loathes cleaning up
a mess, take heart. You are part of a long tradition of construction history, all the way back to the
ancient craftsmen who built not one, but two churches of San Clemente that have stood for
centuries. Thanks for watching. If you enjoyed this video, give it a like and leave a comment
to let me know. If you've been to San Clemente, I'd love to hear about it in the comments.
For more videos about art and history, subscribe to the channel. And if you want a transcript and
a link to all my sources and image credits, check out the links in the description.
