What Ended the Golden Age of Islam | Al Muqaddimah

Indian Ancestors
19 followers
21 Video ViewsยทJan 26, 2026
With the foundation of Baghdad in 762, started an era when states and empires with Islam as
their religion became powerhouses of scientific, cultural and literary development. Works from all
over the world were translated and improved upon. This era is known as the golden age of Islam
and like all good things, it came to an end. Today, we're gonna discuss why that happened.
This video is brought to you by, well, you guys. Thanks to my patrons for supporting
the channel and making these videos possible. As you can see, the videos take a long time to
research, edit and produce and it's only because of my patrons that I am able to put this kind of
time into these videos and keep them free from any kind of paywall. So, if you want to pledge
a dollar or more to support the channel, you can head over to my Patreon, link is in the description
or you can become a member right here on YouTube. There's some cool stuff that comes with it.
Back to the video. First of all, I'd like to say that I absolutely abhor the term golden age of
Islam. I have used it and I continue to use it because it's popular and it's a little bit of a
clickbait but I really don't like this term for a number of reasons. In my opinion, this term
implies the scientific, cultural and literary developments during that era as an exception to
the normal. While its scale was an exception to the normal, its mere existence was normal and
natural. The term makes you imagine an era that is out of reach and tough to recreate but that's
simply not true. Secondly, the fall of political entities and socio-political movements is always
tough to pin on a single reason. There might have been a single nail in the coffin but the
itself might have come from dozens of smaller reasons. For example, you can claim a dozen
reasons for the fall of the Ottoman Empire, from the lack of trained rulers to even the influx of
new world silver into Europe. That is an empire whose decline and fall you can write like six
volumes about. In my opinion, the reasons that you present for the fall of an entity says more about
you than it does about the entity. As a result, this video too is going to have a lot of my
opinions. Before I move on, I'd like to sort of expand on Ibn Khaldun's work and tell you about
the natural cycle of empires. A dynasty which has strong Asabiyya or cohesion rises up to conquer
an area. Then, as they consolidate control, the empire starts making money. Now, the new rulers
want prestige and a distinguished identity to give them legitimacy for which they give patronage to
scholars. By the way, you can also gain more prestige by giving patronage to al-Muqaddimah.
Anyhow, eventually, the empire declines as untrained, incapable rulers start ascending
the throne. Money dries up and so does scholarly work. Sensing their weakness, a new dynasty rises,
repeating the cycle. We see this happening on various scales all over the world. In China,
Iran, Syria, Egypt, Western Europe and even Africa and pre-1492 Americas. Stable dynasties
funded scholars. Obviously, things varied from region to region and ruler to ruler but this is
sort of the natural way an empire behaves. A stable empire will almost always fund scholars
and artisans. The scale of this funding will be based, obviously, on the revenue of the empire.
I will use the term natural again and again in this video so let me explain it here. Some regions
are gifted by geography, some aren't. Real Life Lore has a bunch of great videos on this.
Basically, if a region is gifted, it would have a more effective central government,
more natural resources such as rivers and maybe a trade route going through it. Hence,
more prosperity and more money. The more money an empire has, the more likely scholarly developments
are. These natural conditions can change though if, let's say, a river dries up or a trade route
shifts. Okay, moving on to the Golden Age of Islam. The Golden Age of Islam, for those who
don't know, refers to an era in Islamic history when Muslim and non-Muslim, Arab and non-Arab
scholars living in Islamic empires were leading the world in many fields of study. Mathematics,
medicine, astronomy, literature, philosophy, architecture, all were flourishing under the
The starting point of this era is usually considered to have been the foundation of Baghdad
in 762. Baghdad was ideally located for something like this. Most of the trade that flowed between
China, India, Europe and the Middle East flowed through the region. This brought the ideas and
gold that fuelled the birth of the Golden Age. Ideas from Iran, Egypt, India, Greece and Syria
arrived in Baghdad. Ideas that had been generated during the natural cycles of empires. Also,
Baghdad was sandwiched between two rivers. So, it was close to agricultural production
and had the food it needed to support its people. This was a gift of geography.
So, the Muslims were carrying the baton of their predecessors. Since India and Europe were both
unstable and Baghdad was crazy rich, this era of development was huge in scale compared to
anything that came before or after in the region. Scholars from all over the world flocked to
It was unnatural. The scale of the Golden Age was much bigger than the natural capacity of
the empires of this region to fund scholars. It's kinda like how American production was on steroids
after the Second World War because the rest of the former production giants were destroyed
and didn't have the infrastructure to keep their economy up but they slowly recovered.
Then, this Golden Age movement was exported to the East and the West when scholars moved around.
Cities like Cairo, Cordoba and Fez became important centres of learning.
So, the Golden Age shouldn't be thought of as a single movement but rather,
a series of interconnected movements. Like Baghdad, all these centres were ideally located
either on a trade route or in agricultural regions. After all, you can't have a Golden Age
without gold. Eventually, though, this changed. Now, a popular idea is that Al-Ghazali along with
other orthodox Muslim clerics ended the Golden Age. Basically, the theory goes that a rise in
orthodoxy ended the Golden Age. I really, really, really hate this idea. This idea assumes that the
Golden Age actually had anything to do with religion. Obviously, Quran and Islam support
seeking knowledge but they alone weren't enough to start it and they alone weren't enough to end it.
Many things, together, started the Golden Age. Without money, ideas and the willingness of
rulers, this movement could never have been started. Religion might have influenced the
willingness of the rulers but it's not the only thing that controls it. Many things contribute
to it. Like I said, the coffin of a socio-political movement is never made from a single nail.
Also, there's a popular misconception that the Islamic world was getting more and more
conservative after the Mongol invasion but that's just not true although it's also not
the topic of this video so it's a story for another time. The Mongols sacked Baghdad in 1258.
The sack and thorough destruction of Baghdad resulted in an incredible amount of scholarly
works being destroyed. Years of research at the House of Wisdom ended up being nothing more than
ink in the Tigris. But that couldn't have been the end of the Golden Age of Islam, could it?
Ibn Battuta visited the city in 1327 and he writes great things about the city.
While the city still had some ruins from the sack, he also mentions that it had wonderful bathhouses
and some of the colleges were functional again. It didn't obviously have the prestige that it
had in its heyday but it still wasn't that bad. Baghdad was returning to its natural conditions
which was the gift of its geography. Also, like I mentioned, Baghdad wasn't the only center of
learning anymore. While this wasn't the end of the Golden Age, the Mongol invasions do mark
a watershed. The Mongols conquered all Islamic empires from Central Asia to the borders of Egypt.
The Mongol empire in the Middle East called the Ilkhanate eventually converted to Islam
and disintegrated. The time between the years 1260 and 1500s is sometimes called the era of
instability. I'm pretty much the only person who calls it that but I'm hoping it'll become popular.
This was a time of major changes in the Islamic world. During these years, everything east and
west of Egypt was in deep turmoil. First, let's look to the east of Egypt. Empires came and went
with times of peace few and far between. After the Mongol Ilkhanate, Timurids rose and after
the death of Timur, the Timurids themselves fell apart. This area, Iraq, Iran, Syria and Central
Asia had previously led the Golden Age. Where there was peace though, there was some development.
For instance, we saw the Timurids giving patronage to scholars. Hence, for around 250 years, this
whole region was mostly on the bench. To the west, the Reconquista was pushing the Muslims from
Iberia. Cordoba fell to the Christians in 1236 and from that point to 1492, when the last Muslim
kingdom in Iberia fell, there was so much instability that no one could even imagine
of funding scholars. Kings dropped like flies. Even if they could, scholars weren't willing.
Iberia had been hemorrhaging intellectuals, losing them to northwestern Africa. Losing smart people
destroys empires. Make whatever contemporary parallels you want. Northwestern Africa was on
the mouth of the salt trade route. So, it had the resources but because of the instability and
struggle in Iberia between 1250 and 1500, it had its own problems. Not only were the
locals fighting each other for control, they were also fighting against increasingly hostile
Portugal and Spain. Also, the new migrants from Al-Andalus were having problems integrating with
the locals. Certainly, they were in no condition to fund research. Cairo was prospering under the
Mamluks though who had defeated the Mongols and pushed them back. Egypt, being on an important
trade route between the Red and Mediterranean seas, was very rich and certainly in a position
to fund research. They did fund research but given that the Mamluks were slave soldiers,
most of that research was oriented towards combat. Still, it was research.
The one area that people don't usually mention in the context of the Golden Age is India. By 1500,
there had been Muslim empires in India for almost 500 years but there was very little stability
because most of these empires revolved around one person, a founder or great conqueror and after his
death, the empire would decline. So, we can also count it out for the era of instability.
Once the era of instability was over, we did see improvement. By the 1550s, Iran was unified by
the Safavids. Central Asia was also coming under the control of local central powers
such as the Uzbeks. India was conquered by the Mughals and finally, the Middle East was
conquered by the Ottomans. However, the world had now changed. The Middle East was no longer
on the route of the world's most lucrative trade. Portugal, having found a way to India by going
around Africa, had cut them out. Northwestern Africa was also cut out of the salt trade as the
Ivory Coast started trading directly with Europe. Almost all of the former centers of learning had
lost their importance. Samarkand, Baghdad, Cairo and Fes. Out of these, Cairo was the only one
still prospering. The rest were just there. The world of the Arabs was gone. Persianized Turko
Mongols were the new power. The three major empires of this era were the Mughals in India,
the Safavids in Iran and the Ottomans in the Middle East, Anatolia and Eastern Europe.
All three of them funded development in technology, architecture, literature, etc.
Namely, these three empires were called the Gunpowder Empires because of their introduction,
alliance, development and transmission of gunpowder technology from China.
In fact, Indian empires such as the Bamani Sultanate were so skilled in gunpowder technology
that Alfonso de Albuquerque writes that the cannons forged in Goa are better quality than
the ones forged in Germany which was producing the highest quality cannons in Europe at the time.
So, we can say that the Golden Age or at least Golden Age light was starting to come back
but to a more natural form. However, by this time, Europe had bounced back from the Dark Ages as well.
The Italian Renaissance was funded in a fashion similar to the Golden Age at Baghdad by trade.
Specifically, its trade with Egypt and the Ottomans. Also, Europe had discovered the New
World and its silver which was fueling their empires and their ambition of expansion.
Another era of instability starts around the year 1700. Let's call it the Second
Era of Instability. Ottoman Empire was declining after having lost the siege of Vienna in 1683.
Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb died in 1707 and the Mughal Empire started declining as well.
The Safavids too were circling the drain and would die out by 1736.
A similar pattern of weakness and power vacuum was seen as the First Era of Instability. However,
this time, local powers weren't able to establish themselves. Instead,
the weakness was exploited by Europeans. By 1800, European colonization was at full steam,
kinda literally having just started the Industrial Revolution. Then, there was no
catching up to them. Resources from the colonized world were being looted and taken to Europe.
The gold and willingness of rulers required for scholarly research was gone. In return,
they gave us something called civilization but turns out you can't eat civilization so
locals died in large numbers. Now, the world we live in today is a post-colonial one and it has
its own problems which haven't allowed us to bounce back. I mean, have you looked at a map
of borders and ethnicities of the Middle East or Africa? Hence, we don't have the stability that
would allow us to make the kind of money needed to found universities and fund research. I know,
Saudi Arabia is an exception but yeah, I'm not talking about them.
So, in conclusion, the golden age which lasted from 762 till the first era of instability was
so grand because Europe was dark. This was unnatural. Then, the era of instability drained
the golden age and only a skeleton was left which I believe is the natural condition.
Regions such as Iran, India and Egypt were once again prosperous and funding research as they had
during the golden age and even before the rise of Islam, going back all the way to antiquity.
But then, the second era of instability started. In a natural setting, a similar pattern would've
repeated. After the collapse of the Ottomans, Safavids and the Mughals, new powers would've
once again stabilized and funded research till they themselves declined but colonization stopped
that from happening. All of our resources went towards that leaving nothing behind to fund
research. Now, the formerly colonized countries are starting to come back and they will once again
find their natural footing. However, that's proving difficult with the mess that the
Europeans left behind in our borders. Hopefully, without foreign intervention, we will once again
see the world of Islam along with other formerly colonized regions get stable and start funding
universities and research. See you next time. Don't forget to subscribe and press the bell icon.
On screen right now, you can see the names and tiers of the patrons. You can join them
by pledging a dollar or more to support the channel. Thank you for watching.
