The Cool S of the Roman Empire: The Sator Square

Sculpted Rome
10 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
What if, 1,000 years from now, you lived in the ruins of a fallen empire?
You'd walk on the ancient roads built by those who came before you,
made with techniques that have been long forgotten about.
On your way to work, you'd see a cart of ancient statues go by,
on their way to be crushed into building material.
Passing through the market, you'd consider a charm sold by an apothecary.
You'd reach your place of work, the old sports stadium, turned into animal stables.
What if there was a symbol from the days of the empire,
that had been around for so long that everybody forgot what it originally meant?
You'd see the symbol carved into the lintel of your family's home, as a ward against fire.
You'd hear it shouted aloud as part of a Christian prayer.
And if you came down with rabies, you'd be administered the symbol as medicine,
written on a piece of bread.
What if I told you that these things already happened?
The fallen empire isn't America, but the Roman Empire.
Those roads? Roman roads, some of which are still standing today.
And it was the Colosseum, not Camping World Stadium, that served as stables.
And the fate of most Roman statues was to be crushed and roasted, to produce lime mortar.
People in the medieval era were surrounded by the infrastructure,
art, technology, even the symbols of the Roman Empire.
It was, in a certain sense, post-apocalyptic.
Only in a certain sense.
The Roman Empire declined over the course of many centuries.
There was no single world-shattering event.
To provincial folk living far from Rome,
it would have been perceived as a slow failure of public works,
a diminishing of trade routes,
and a shifting of allegiances to the local Germanic tribes.
And through it all, a symbol from the Roman Empire stuck around.
It wasn't the cool S, but it was cool, and it started with an S.
We call it the Sator Square, and it's been found everywhere the Roman Empire touched.
Here it is on a church door in France.
And here are the words of the square,
scrawled into a manuscript's margins as a charm for childbirth.
It was to be recited while crossing yourself, hence the cross.
In England, it was found scratched into a discarded pottery sherd.
Traveling further, it was found written on papyrus,
in a 4th century Egyptian amulet, as protection against evil.
It was found in Norway on a piece of wood, maybe a trencher, translated into runes.
There's a 16th century account of a French madman,
who ate three crusts of bread inscribed at the square,
before reciting Our Father five times, curing him of his insanity.
For Germans, there was an idea that it could put out fires.
An 18th century duke issued an edict for all of his towns
to manufacture Sator Square-inscribed discs as an emergency firefighting measure.
That belief went across the pond to America,
in a 19th century Pennsylvania Dutch book of folk magic called The Long Hidden Friend.
It described the Sator Square fire discs,
as well as a suggestion to write it on paper and feed it to cattle, as a ward against witchcraft.
It can even be found as far as Ethiopia,
where Christianity has been practiced since the 4th century.
There, the words of the square become the names of the five holy wounds inflicted upon Jesus.
Let's go through those words.
You can read them in any direction, backwards or forwards, in columns or rows.
There was even a theory that it was meant to be read,
ostrophedon, that is to say, back and forth, like an oxen plowing a field.
This will be more important later,
but the earliest Sator Squares are already flipped actually, in what scholars call rotos form.
Let's break it down.
First, we have Sator, meaning sower, planter, progenitor.
Literally, seeder, like those guys who give you free software.
Arepo.
What is Arepo?
No, I didn't just have a Gary Johnson moment.
No one knows what Arepo means.
It hasn't been found anywhere at all, except in reference to the Sator Square.
It's often taken to be a name,
or as a 14th century Byzantine scribe might have guessed, a Gaulish plow.
Moving on to tenet, which means he holds, sustains, masters, comprehends.
Yes, the movie Tenet is full of references to the Sator Square.
Opera, which means labor, effort, or attention.
If you're saying no, that's opera, and it's when the fat lady sings.
You're not wrong.
Just know that it was originally called
opera in musica, a work in music, before it was shortened to opera.
And finally, we end with rotos, meaning wheels.
So, taking the Sator Square to be a sentence, and Arepo to be a name,
we can puzzle out,
The sower Arepo works the wheels with care.
But there's really all kinds of interpretations.
That 14th century Byzantine scribe was the earliest recorded person we know of
to puzzle it out into a sentence.
Next to the square, which he dutifully copied down in Greek, he wrote,
The sower holds the plow, the works, the wheels.
He translated Arepo into plow,
maybe taking it from the Gaulish word arepenis, a unit of land.
Maybe he just made it up.
It was flanked in the manuscript by sayings of the wise,
and a list of signs of the Antichrist.
This was back when every book was hand-copied, and space was at a premium,
so they'd fill up books with trivia, like Uncle John's Bathroom Reader.
It was called a miscellany.
So we can see that for the past thousand years,
the Sator Square maintained broadly Christian connotations,
showing up on church doors and stone blocks,
and being used in folk magic along with the sign of the cross.
But no one really knew what it meant.
A 19th century German historian was able to find an anagram in the square.
But don't worry, because you can also rearrange the letters into a more Christian,
Along these lines, there was a brief consensus in the 1920s.
It made such shockwaves that you'll still find people citing this as fact today.
If you rearrange the letters like so,
you can make a cross that spells the words Pater Noster.
That means Our Father, and I consider it the most important prayer in Christianity.
It's the only one that Jesus explicitly taught in the Bible.
There's a leftover set of A's and O's,
which are purported to stand for Alpha and Omega,
a title for God in the Book of Revelation.
Everybody celebrated.
This seemed like too great of a coincidence to ignore.
It provided a perfect explanation for the square,
and it affirmed its long-maintained association with Christianity.
It was a passable theory, and one people were quick to accept.
But just a few years later,
an archaeological find blew it all to bits.
That's right, the oldest Sator squares we ever found
were found in the ruins of Pompeii.
The Roman city of Pompeii was a glittering coastal jewel,
with a bustling port which made for a diverse and cosmopolitan populace.
It had an amphitheater that could seat 20,000.
It had dozens of street food spots called Thermopylia.
It had a brothel, painted with evocative murals.
Pompeii was overlooked by the lush, fertile Mount Vesuvius,
which, in reality, was a long-dormant volcano, primed to blow.
In 79 AD, it erupted, filling the air with choking fumes,
snuffing the city out over the course of a day,
and covering it with 10 to 20 feet of ash.
The entire city was left entombed in stone and largely forgotten about,
until archaeological efforts in the 20th century unearthed the ruins.
What was a cataclysmic, unexplainable tragedy,
ended up being an archaeological marvel.
It was a perfectly preserved, untouched Roman city,
like a mosquito in amber.
In Pompeii, there was a big gymnasium called the Palestra Grande.
It was here that the elite youth would learn drills
and be indoctrinated into the Roman culture.
Scratched into one of its many pillars,
was the oldest satyr square ever found.
Here's a copy of it.
Those cryptic words below,
Satranvale,
were probably a signature.
Vale is how letters were signed off,
and Satranus was a common misspelling of Saturnus,
which could be a nickname.
Another one was found in the atrium of a wealthy magistrate,
carved into the plaster.
It was just a fragment,
later reassessed as part of the square.
Remember,
the ruins were left undisturbed for nearly 2,000 years.
The satyr square was around for at least as long as 79 AD,
which is centuries earlier than anyone previously expected.
Now we know that the square didn't have Christian origins.
For one thing,
there was no evidence of Christians in Pompeii before the eruption.
The religion was only a few decades old,
and the final books of the Bible were still being penned.
That's why the paternoster theory fell apart.
God famously said he was the Alpha and Omega in the book of Revelation,
something that was written after the eruption of Mount Vesuvius.
Also, it seems unlikely in the first place
that a Latin puzzle square would rely on Greek letters like Alpha and Omega.
Then there's the supposed Christian cross that forms the central tenet of the square.
The fact is,
it took centuries for Christians to adopt the cross as a sign of their faith.
Crucifixion was a horrible act of torture and humiliation.
It was known as the slave's punishment,
and it was illegal to crucify a citizen.
Cicero wrote that the very word cross shouldn't even touch the mind of a Roman citizen.
It was such an indescribable act.
In fact, the very earliest depiction of a crucified Jesus that we have
is from a bit of mocking graffiti.
In the ruins of Rome,
in a training academy for servants known as the Pedagogium,
this was carved on the walls.
It shows a crucified figure with the head of a donkey,
along with the caption,
Alexa Menos worships his god.
It would be the fish, not the cross, that served as the actual Christian cryptogram.
The Greek word for fish served as an acronym for Jesus,
and it was easy to subtly present a fish.
It's still a popular symbol today,
and maybe if Jesus was never crucified, it would be the main symbol of the religion.
But I'll explore that later in a future video.
Now, there has been fairly recent academic support for the square as a cryptogram.
If the Sator Square truly did originate as a secret religious symbol,
it would have been a Jewish one.
It was a French scholar named Nicolas Benel who pitched its solution in a 2006 paper.
Remember, there was no evidence of any Christians in Pompeii before the eruption.
But there was strong evidence of a Jewish population.
On the walls of the dining room,
someone scrawled Sodom and Gomorrah with a piece of charcoal,
referencing a classic story from the Hebrew Bible.
They did so during the eruption,
as some sort of final message or explanation for what happened.
There were records of people there with typically Jewish names,
even a successful wine merchant called Eudikos, literally, the Jew.
So here's the solution from Benel's paper.
Looking at the square itself,
it's safe to assume that the Rotas form was the original, true version of the Sator Square.
All of the earliest squares were in Rotas form,
and the Sator form that became popular in the medieval era
could have been flipped early on to negate any pagan powers,
or just mirrored when copied from earlier designs.
So taking the first word Rotas as instructions to rotate,
you can rearrange the letters,
rotating the tenet cross around the center into this new square,
which resembles the bronze altar from Moses's tabernacle.
The tabernacle was basically a mobile temple for biblical Jews.
The altar was five by five cubits, like the square,
and it had horns at the corners.
The T's of the transformed square could be the horns.
It was three cubits tall, and this part of the square spells
Ara Area, or Altar of Bronze,
which is what it was.
It's also topped by a Serpens Area, or Snake of Bronze.
Moses famously had a bronze serpent which could heal snakebites,
just by looking at it.
Now, I don't want to disparage Benel's paper.
It offers a very satisfying and complete explanation
that fits well into the historical context.
But honestly, it just seems a little too convoluted to be true.
I've never tried to make a word puzzle,
but I just don't see how someone could have composed
the square with this solution in mind.
The original creator of the Sator Square
already had to make up a word, Arepo,
to create the square in the first place.
I don't think they were a mastermind puzzle smith
like the minute cryptic folks.
It sounds too much like old-fashioned pattern matching,
something humans can't help but do,
even when the pattern is tenuous at best.
It reminds me of another mystery from that era,
the Roman Dodecahedron.
These cast bronze sculptures were found
all around the Roman Empire,
with no explanation as to their purpose.
There's a modern theory that they were actually looms
for a kind of weird, ugly glove.
The truth is that knitting wouldn't be invented
for another thousand years,
and Romans would probably laugh at us for trying this.
I think it was just something that metalsmiths made
to show off their handiwork.
I see that as something a lot like
With no explanation or elaboration,
the human mind will go to any length to find meaning.
Can you imagine future anthropologists
with no cultural context
trying to understand 6-7 and the accompanying hand gesture?
How about the cheese touch
long after the source text has been lost?
It's undeniable that the Sator Square
was quickly co-opted as a magical charm
and vaguely Christian symbol.
But when I look at the faint scraps of evidence that we have,
I feel like I can see the square for what it truly is.
The oldest recorded meme,
and something very much like the cool S.
You see, the Sator Square
wasn't the only word square found in Pompeii.
Scratching to a wall facing a public street
was this smaller 4x4 square.
Milo is a real name,
and the words, if not really a sentence,
still conjure a bit of imagery,
especially if you were living in the Roman Empire at the time.
A few of these Roma squares have been found,
but it never really caught on like the Sator Square,
probably because its meaning and intention is more clear.
I see the Sator Square as an attempt
to outdo or improve on the Roma Square,
but doing so was an almost impossible feat
and required making up a word, arepo.
It's telling that no one has ever made
a 6x6 or larger palindromic board square,
in any language.
So here's how I think the Sator Square was created.
I'm trying to create the ultimate palindrome square.
I'll start with rotos,
which I know makes Sator.
Rotos, rotate, feels thematic.
Okay, now it's just one word filled in.
We only have nine letters left.
And that middle word has to start and end with a T
and be a palindrome itself
in order to make the whole thing work.
Praise Saturn for Tenet.
Now, let's see.
O blank E blank A.
That could be opera.
And that creates arepo.
Not a word, but it's pronounceable at least.
I don't think the Sator Square was created
with any hidden, colder message at all.
I think it was made to satisfy the requirements
of a 5x5 word square
and any meaning it had was prescribed afterwards.
But what did it mean to the ancient Romans?
Well, I don't see why it had to mean
anything specific at all.
It's possible they just saw the square
as an amusing piece of child lore.
Let's take another look at the oldest squares.
In Pompeii, one was found on a pillar
in a training grounds for imperial youth.
It was also found on the walls
of the atrium in someone's house.
Both were in places that you'd expect
young Romans to leave graffiti in.
And what happens to young Romans
when they grow up?
Well, they become adults
who go on to lead troops,
who serve as clerks, scribes, and aides
in far-off corners of the empire,
spreading their knowledge, beliefs, and superstitions.
It was found painted on the wall
inside a Roman military office
in a border town in Syria.
Not just graffiti, but something done with care
and a decorative flourish.
And so far from the heart of the empire,
I can very easily imagine the Sator Square
being a welcome reminder of home,
in the same way the Kill Royals Here graffiti
functioned for US troops during World War II.
As the centuries went on,
you can imagine how the Sator Square's origins
were quickly forgotten about
and it took on a life of its own.
So, sorry to get all Rian Johnson on you
and subvert your expectations,
but often the most elegant solution
to the convoluted mystery
is that there is no mystery.
The Sator Square, with those 25 letters
that form those five enigmatic words,
provided plenty of material
for people to interpret
and incorporate into their own culture,
even when completely removed
from its original context.
So my question for the comments is this.
What things from life today
will totally confuse people
a thousand years from now?
It could be concepts like racism
and the family unit.
Odds are those will still be around
and it's going to be those dog poop bag dispensers
that no one will understand.
This is my first video
since I hit 100,000 subscribers.
I just know that silver play button
will look great on my wall.
No!
I wish I didn't drop my play button,
but what's done is done.
Or as Caesar once said,
the die is cast.
He was referring to a six-sided game die,
but right now I want to talk about
the die of a coin.
If you join my Patreon at any tier,
I will send you a goblin quarter.
I had the stamp made on Alibaba
and I'm using the cheapest hydraulic press
I could find to deface US coinage.
I've already sent out over 50 of them
all around the world.
There's also a Minecraft server
for Patreon supporters.
I've always dreamt of hosting a Minecraft server
because it's like a little microcosm of reality.
Come and build with me.
I want to issue a sincere thank you
to everyone who enjoys my content
and helped me get to where I am today.
But this is only the beginning.
As the world's deepest man,
Herbert Mitch, once said,
each time I think I've reached a limit,
a door opens and the limit is gone.
That's why my next video is going to be
a true blockbuster,
optimizing DC supervillains.
Thank you again to my
credits-tier Patreon supporters,
or as I call them here,
producers and executive producers.
Your support literally means more to me
than I can express.
