California has some of the least affordable housing in the country yet prices are not coming down. Jim Doti, economist and President Emeritus at Chapman University, has spent years building an index that tracks which cities are actually gaining ground and why. In this episode he joins us to understand what is driving that disconnect, how other markets are behaving differently, and what that contrast reveals about where California stands right now.
Timestamps: 03:47 Why Prices Aren’t Dropping 06:26 How Fed Policy Drove Home Prices 08:50 Will Mortgage Rates Fall Again? 11:34 Policy Impact on Housing Costs 14:00 Finding Real Estate Hot Zones 19:02 Case Study: Columbus Growth 21:19 New Hot Spots vs Old Tech Hubs 22:57 Using Hot Zone Data to Invest 24:58 Why People Are Leaving California 27:27 How Long Hot Zones Last 32:30 Regulation and Housing Supply
What is happening with the real estate market right now and are there a way to find out what
are the hot zones areas that could grow over the next decade? Today we sit down with Dr. Doty who
has found a correlation between the real estate market and advanced jobs and companies forming
in these regions. He's going to tell us what are the hot zones and how his research works.
When you look at the average housing there'll be an increased supply as some of these fixed
rate mortgages go away and become part of history. Supply will increase and I don't
see much appreciation but if you look at in pockets where there's more development,
more economic development, major economic factors of supply and demand will come to the fore.
Demand is increasing more rapidly than it will lead to increases in real estate values.
I'm Siamak and this is Market Insider.
Dr. Doty, it's great to have you back and welcome back.
Thank you, great to be on.
We want to talk to you about housing and the housing market. You have a specific way of
analyzing what's going on with the housing market. Can you tell us what you're seeing
right now? It's a very confusing time for people to understand what's happening in housing.
Oh on the plus side I think there's general recognition nationally and certainly in the
state of California that housing is at a price level now that excludes most workers and sadly
most young people, graduates from Chapman University. And as much as a problem as it
is nationally of course it's even worse in California. A lot of times people say when
people can't afford the price has to go down. Why is the price staying up? A number of reasons.
It's not simple Siamak. Just to give you some general numbers it's a problem that mainly
exists in California but increasingly in the rest of the nation especially urban areas
around the country. The measure that we look at in economics is called a housing affordability
index which measures what percentage of median family income is needed to purchase a median
priced home. So for example in California the median family income is around $100,000
whereas the median price home is a million. How much does it take to buy a median price home?
Well the housing affordability index in California is now at an index level of 75
as opposed to 100. 100 means that median family income is just sufficient to purchase a median
price home. So if it were 100 the average income can purchase an average home. In California the
fact that it's 75 means that median family income in California is 25 percent below what is necessary
to buy a home in California whereas in the U.S. it's 125 which means that median family income
is actually 25 percent higher than what's necessary. So obviously it's a California problem
but increasingly as indicated by the fact that just recently the senate voted on a housing bill
the first one since 1990 probably going to be passed with some changes in the house but it
points to the fact that even at the national level it's perceived as a problem. A lot of people that
don't have homes they're hoping for a crash or prices to come down. What are your thoughts on
that? Do you think there will be lower prices because of this affordability issue that you
mentioned? Yeah I really believe that housing prices are now at a high that aren't really
justified in terms of supply and demand. Population isn't increasing that much. Homes are still being
built. Prices should be dropping but the reason they aren't is because of a flaw in the system
and that is so many people living in homes have mortgages that are below market levels.
The mortgage rate now is roughly six percent for a 30-year mortgage. Many people have mortgages
locked in for a long period of time at two and a half to four percent. They took out mortgages
during COVID when interest rates were very very low. Mortgage rates were like two two and a half
percent and they're not going to sell their home and give up that below interest mortgage. If they
do they're losing all of the gain that they would otherwise get in having low interest rates. So as
a result the resale market is weaker than it's ever been. People aren't putting up their resale
homes for sale and as a result supply is limited. Demand is still high and that is keeping the
price level higher than what it ordinarily would be. In normal times the interest rate the mortgage
rate would be what it usually is around six percent. That's historically somewhere between
five and a half and six percent range. These mortgage rates that people think are so high
historically are roughly an average level. But homes aren't coming up for sale because people
don't want to give up the value. That value is significant as indicated by the fact that
when people who own a home go through a divorce that's become a major item in divorce court.
And that is even the interest rate the fact they own a home or perhaps the interest rate mortgage
interest rate is three. The fact that it's three percent rather than paying six percent has an
imputed value in California. The value of that the discounted value of all those savings could be as
high as one million one and a half million dollars. Wow. And if couples getting divorced that has to
be calculated in the settlement because that's an asset that has to be valued that has to be given
to husband or the wife in a divorce action. So people don't want to give that up because that's
exactly so supply is limited amount of money. That problem goes back to government. And let me explain
how and why. After the financial crisis of 2007 and nine mortgage rates were around six percent.
The Federal Reserve implemented a very low interest rate environment from 2010 to about 2020.
Then COVID hit and the Federal Reserve reduced interest rates to very low levels to counteract
the negative effects of the impact of COVID on the overall economy loss of jobs the loss of incomes.
So interest rates went to very very low levels and they were already low for a period of 10 years.
So people were taking out more and more of these below historic average mortgages three percent two
percent two and a half percent because they realized that interest rates would go back to
six percent. They took out mortgages and increased the demand for housing. I want to get this this
low interest rate mortgage. They're not going to be around forever especially during COVID.
And during that time is when housing prices increased nationally not just California 30 40
percent because there were only so many homes available for sale. Everyone wanted to take out
a below market mortgage interest rate and that increase in demand with limited supply pushed up
housing prices. And people accepted those housing higher housing prices because they were getting
below interest mortgage rates. So they're looking at the payments. Yeah so so the payments didn't
increase that much because interest mortgage rates were low and they were willing to pay
the higher price for a home. Now that mortgage rates are back to six percent you have a situation
where those individuals who took out those below interest mortgages because of the Federal Reserve
because of the low interest policy results of government they don't want to and I can
well understand the economic rationale they don't want to sell those homes. Where do you think we
will go from here? Do you think if the interest rates come down do you think is a chance for this
to unlock or do you think the interest rates may not come down? What are your thoughts? I think a
mortgage rate of around six percent is a rational mortgage rate. That's what they were historically.
The only reason between 2010 and 22 they were as low as they were part of it was because of COVID
COVID and the 25 percent increase in the money supply which brought down interest rates to
practically zero short term and two and a half percent long term for mortgages. We're not going
back to those days. I think they're going to stay at around six percent which is a rational rate.
Why? If inflation is two to three percent interest rates have to cover that inflation. You also have
to cover the fact that there's a real rate of interest of around two percent because of
productivity growth. That gets you to four four and a half percent which is our 10 year bond rate
and then another two percent because of the added risk of a mortgage versus a government bond and
that gets you to six percent. So I don't see them dropping significantly maybe to five and a half
percent but certainly not back to two and a half and three percent. But what will happen is over
time many of those mortgages will be paid off. You pay off those two and a half three and a half
percent mortgages and as they're paid off the new mortgage will be around five or six percent. It
will not happen overnight. It will take a long time but over a 10 to 20 year period those low
interest mortgages will be history and that will not be part of the future. As a result
more and more mortgages will be at a competitive level of around five or six percent and those
people will not be as disinclined to sell their homes. There will be more supply that will be
coming up in the resale market and greater supply will slowly bring down home prices. I think they're
high. They're artificially high and I believe over time they will either be stable or perhaps even
experience a depreciation, housing depreciation. I believe even over this next year there
will be housing depreciation of maybe one percent and considering the fact that inflation is around
two and a half to three percent you have a real drop in housing prices of about three percent.
In the long run you see this market getting unlocked. Exactly exactly and but it will take
a while. There's more and more interest at the national level. You have a housing bill. I don't
think it's very good. It will have I don't think it will have much impact. It's basically enough
it's trying to revise the 1990 housing bill. When that housing bill was enacted
very same reason to bring down the cost of housing. Housing prices continue to increase. Do you know
what one of the major factors that's leading that will lead to higher housing prices for new homes
in the future and that will keep resale homes steady or even higher is the current tariff policy.
15 to 20 percent of the cost of the home is related to lumber and wood products. Much of that
wood is imported from Canada. The current tariff on Canadian wood is 50 percent. That alone will
increase. So nationally if you consider that price of wood in the home that's something like
$80,000. 50 percent of that adds 40 percent to the price of a home. $40,000. So the housing bill
if anything when I look at it will will have a negative impact because one of the things
that housing bill will do is force corporate home buyers that build homes
that build a home and then buy it and build it constructed not for the house not for resale
purposes but for rental purposes. The current bill will force them to sell that home after seven years.
All that will do is reduce the amount of corporate capital that's being allocated to
to housing. Private equity that's going to housing will not go into housing and that will make the
problem worse not better. The best thing the government can do is get out of trying to solve
the problem and look at other things that are having a more significant impact on housing
like the deficit which keep is keeping long-term rates higher than they otherwise would be to
reduce tariffs especially on those items that relate to the construction of a home and lead
to higher housing prices for a home. Dr. Doty you have been studying hot zones for real estate.
You have a methodology to recognize which areas will do well in the long run. Can you tell us
about what you're seeing in the markets and how do you do these studies? Yeah thank you for that
question. That relates to what we call the Chapman UCI Advanced Industry Index which we at Chapman
and our Anderson Center for Economic Research we do in conjunction with UCI and that's an index
that measures the strength of job growth, wages, and establishment growth in high-tech fields
like computers, software, R&D, defense-related manufacturing, pharmaceuticals. These are
generally industries that pay higher wages roughly double the median income or wages in a particular
area. So like defense jobs in Southern California they pay practically double the rate of an average
worker. So too in AI and software and computer hardware and software as well. So we track those
and we track them for 50 different metropolitan statistical areas nationally of which there are
seven in California. Areas like Sacramento, San Francisco, Santa Clara, Orange County,
Los Angeles, Inland Empire, San Diego. These are the MSAs in California but there are 50 of them
around the nation and we track those those areas. And historically California has been very strong
in this area and has led to greater economic growth but recently over the last five years
California has shown weakness while other areas around the country have shown strength
in these various areas where California had historically been a been one of the core
areas of strength in California. But that is changing and we've seen recently that growth
in California has actually in terms of the proportion of jobs in these years has dropped
in California from 18% five years ago to roughly 15% today. So we've lost a three percent market
share in all of these advanced industries. Recently we looked at what we think is the
most important leading economic indicator and that is how many establishments are being developed
not just jobs actual companies being formed and we look at them for the 50 years we grow
and we look at which years are growing most rapidly and we find we look at the top 10
of those 50 in terms of growth and we looked at what happens to home prices in these areas that
are growing most rapidly. We find that those areas like Atlanta, Salt Lake City, Lexington, Kentucky,
Las Vegas, areas like this where there's been dramatic growth we find that following the
establishment of a new business three to five years later there's an increase in housing prices
because it takes time for the housing market to respond to increased demand. So you have a
new establishment you start to add to jobs in a particular area let's say Salt Lake City
they call it now Silicon Slopes. They're increasing jobs in AI in computer related technology
and you can see the development taking place. Well now as a result of that development
first you have the number of new companies then increased jobs and then increased wages
and during that time as you recruit more workers they demand housing and initially you only have
a certain housing stock what we call in economics inelastic demand. The demand increase results in
an increase in housing that eventually will lead to home builders increasing the supply that will
bring down the price but over a five-year period you have a significant increase in housing. The
bottom line from all that as I just told my students in my class that if you want to invest
those are the areas to invest in because especially in property in commercial development residential
development because those those are the areas that will experience the most rapid increase in
in residential and commercial housing prices. So areas that have these kind of jobs these kind of
companies forming first the companies come and then the jobs come and then after the jobs are
there then it would create demand for real estate. I'll give you an example as a personal example
10 years ago I invested in one of those hot areas believe it or not believe it or not in Ohio
specifically Columbus. We looked at there's a private equity company actually headed up by a
Chapman University graduate young graduate who saw the opportunities in an area where
what was formerly called the rust belt was all of a sudden because of low housing costs was
beginning to develop more companies were being formed there particularly high-tech companies in
an area around one of the large hospitals in the nation and near Ohio State University and
we invested in homes at the time that were going for 25 to 40 thousand dollars and 10 years later
those homes were sold for 300 to 400 thousand dollars. Wow so that much of it changed in that private
equity market I was one of them had an incredible rate of return. Well where are those areas in the
future look at our Chapman UCI index and that will that will lead you to the areas that will experience
similar kinds of increases in residential development. People need to to know that
you know when you look at the average and maybe on the average housing for example not experience
all that much appreciation for the very reasons I just cited mortgage rates will ultimately
there'll be an increased supply as some of these fixed rate mortgages go away and become part of
history supply will increase and I don't see much appreciation but if you look at in pockets where
there's more development more economic development major economic factors so supply and demand
will come to the fore demand is increasing more rapidly than other areas that will lead to
increases in real estate values. Is this why areas like the bay area when you look at homes in bay
areas are significantly higher priced than even the rest of California? Exactly. Because those
jobs were created in those areas? Back then but now San Francisco is experiencing just the opposite
they have 40 percent vacancy race vacancy rates in downtown San Francisco commercial property and
home values actually declining in San Francisco in the city because of the fact that there was
an overbuilding and then all of a sudden a drop in demand because those areas are not growing
like Salt Lake City like Las Vegas like Lexington like the triangle golden triangle in North
Carolina those are the hot areas now and that's where the money is to be made. And does this apply
to commercial real estate and residential? Absolutely you're into private equity in
commercial or apartment development either one you should be looking at this index because that's
where demand will be increasing most rapidly job growth population growth formation of families
families and with a limited supply of housing and commercial market space in those areas
that rapid increase in demand you see a fixed supply and that increase in demand leads to
higher prices five ten years the market will respond there will be more development but then
you have the opposite situation over development and lower property values but get it while it's
hot to find out where are those hot spots as you categorize them in your question watch this
Chapman UCI index because every year we update the five hot spots in small market areas and the five
hot spots in larger market areas. And we'll leave a link for our audience. Yeah it's included in our
Chapman economic and business review that we issued in December. From what you're seeing
both California and New York in these places are they going to stagnant for be stagnant for a while?
They will stagnate for a while and these other hot areas will grow because people are following
where there's economic development where there are jobs where housing is affordable over the last
three years California has had a negative outflow of people that is the number of people moving into
the state versus those moving out of one million half of those one million about 500,000 were lost
to Florida, Texas, Arizona, Nevada, and Idaho. Five states we've lost a half a million net flow
overall to all 50 states we lost a million people. How why did we lose a million people they were
they were moving the jobs and higher income people were moving in order to move to low
lower income tax states. And you take those five states where they're moving
no state income tax for no income tax in Texas, none in Nevada, very low in Arizona,
very low tax state income tax in Idaho. So people were voting with their feet if you will.
For people that are looking for opportunities do you recommend them to look at this index and find
jobs in these areas is it good to be in these areas like physically and working? Yes if I were
a young person again I would be looking in those areas just as I was as a newly minted PhD out of
Chicago moving to California. At that time California certainly Orange County Southern
California was a hot spot and I took advantage of those by investing in real estate buying a home
and over that time I did very well. Those times have changed now people are moving out of the
state sadly sadly mainly because of governmental policy at the national but particularly at the
state level they're moving out and the opportunities are elsewhere at these hot spots.
I'd be looking at Salt Lake City which is a beautiful area to live and ski a great education
system great public resources. People should consider moving to those hot spots and benefit
from what just as I moved from Chicago to California back 50 years ago now if I were here
just getting a PhD I hate to say it but I'd be moving to some other hot spot and taking advantage
of a state that offers its services better services at a lower cost lower overall taxes
moving out of the state that's ranked 48th highest in state and local taxes to a state like
Utah which is in the lowest 10 and that's where I know that economic development will take place
I would do what Dave Wilson the trustee at university he gave me this tip good friend
trustee when he was a young man beginning to develop his automobile dealerships he would go
from city to city where the job growth was greatest because they would be buying automobiles
he would lease a helicopter and pilot and he'd fly over the development areas and find out where
the development was taking place and then buy land out in the periphery right in the path of
development because he knew that the development ultimately lead to his plot of acreage that he
bought from you know agricultural land pennies on the dollar for these hot zones how long do they
last is their time frame or how risky are they they're all different because it depends on what
happens in the state governmental policy how quickly people move into those areas but it was
on average a window of 10 years in terms of population and housing is there any correlations
with when people move from one state to another state that's a great question we did a massive
study five years ago but I believe it still applies today we looked at 120 metropolitan
statistical areas to see could we find what variables explain housing prices in each of
these areas and there was a huge range huge what statisticians would call dispersion you know
California being a million dollars while other areas in the nation three and four hundred thousand
dollars so a huge what explains that so we did a study and we found that the principal factor
was income higher incomes in an area lead to higher price homes for a number of reasons
but principally because you have more income there's economists call elasticity if higher
incomes you devote a greater proportion of your income to housing you like a bigger home more
amenities in that home better appliances more square footage so that's one factor the other
is we looked at the amenities in each state in terms of climate proximity to water like oceans
and amenities explain not as much as income but a large share so in California California will
always have higher home prices than the rest of the nation because we have higher income median
family income is higher in California and secondly we live in a beautiful state particularly southern
California the amenities climate proximity to the ocean it's a wonderful place to live
but when we put those two factors in all of these 50 areas it explained most of the differentiation
but not all of it there was some portion of housing that was unexplained like in California
housing for even after considering higher income considering amenities home prices were higher in
California and the reason for that but this is the difficult part to measure is that housing
restrictions the other factor is population growth more population higher housing prices
this window that I'm talking about in 10 years where you have these hot areas as more and more
people move to those areas because of economic factors like jobs and so on population will
increase and as population increases home prices will increase the economy expands and becomes a
more vibrant place well what's happening in California in population for a long time when
I came to California 50 years ago population was growing much more rapidly in California
because many more people I wasn't a genius many more people saw California as you know the gold
the golden state the place to go but it's not that place anymore because mainly I see of
inept governmental public policy but what's happened to population why people are voting
with their feet in 2025 while the nation was growing at a historically low rate of a half a
percent we're still growing half a percent growth in a population of three and a half 350 million
people California was actually beginning to decline it actually dropped almost zero growth
slight decline but we see in the future further declines in population because people are still
moving out of the state immigration is falling off a cliff because of the immigration policy
and the natural birth rate births minus deaths is dropping because there are more deaths as baby
boomers age and the birth rate is lower so for all of those reasons population will be declining
in California what does that say about housing you have statewide housing goals of absurd the
governor would like to build 300,000 additional apartment and single family homes per year we're
currently building 100,000 and in all likelihood because of declining population it'll be going
down it's not going to be dropping from 100,000 not going towards 300,000 so we're not going to
need as much housing in California because of the population decline that will be that decline will
be worsening in future years you mentioned areas that have restrictions on housing what about these
kind of areas can you give examples and thoughts yeah they're probably the most significant
restriction that applied exclusively to California was the California Environmental Quality Act
the acronym is CEQA basically it's very involved a huge law many pages but comes down to this
if you want to build an apartment commercial structure or build a home and your neighbors
whatever they might be don't like that they could easily go to a court with a small low filing fee
obstruct that development for at least two years maybe longer and whenever you hold off construction
over a period of two years investors don't want to get involved in that kind of delay time is money
and if they have to wait around two three years before they can begin or start construction
and it adds that much to the construction timetable they're not going to build and that
led to a significant restriction of housing and of course that limitation of supply led to higher
appreciation and real estate whether it be commercial industrial or real estate
thankfully one good thing and I applaud the state for it in March of last year CEQA was put on hold
I hope it can be totally eliminated but it's been put on hold and there aren't many loopholes in
that it pretty much will keep CEQA from being used by NIMBY they're not in my backyard people don't
want to see development it will keep them away so it will limit their ability to restrict
construction so that was a very I think positive development but like and since then since March
we haven't seen any significant increase in construction but I believe it will have the
impact the positive impact will be a long run not a short run so we have to stick with it
that's why it just can't be a temporary hold on CEQA it has to be a permanent hold hopefully
abolishing it and then over time we'll see the market respond housing is it's a good it takes
it's not like chewing gum or automobiles it takes a long time for the market to respond
CEQA was taking even longer. Dr. Doty, professor at Chapman University and President Emeritus,
it was great to have you on Market Insider. Thank you, it's always great to be on your show
Siamak and you ask great questions. What do you think about Dr. Doty's methodology to find out
hot zones in the real estate space? Let us know your thoughts. I'm Siamak, this is Market Insider,
we'll see you next time.