Shen Yun is an American performing arts company that sells out venues worldwide. Before shows, bomb threats come in. Theaters get swept. Tour buses need overnight security to prevent sabotage. Incidents have been reported across the United States, including California. The question is why what investigators describe as a foreign government campaign keeps reaching an American company on American soil.
A separate but related track runs through federal court. A California-based Chinese agent was caught by the FBI attempting to bribe IRS officials into revoking Shen Yun's nonprofit status. Investigators say that the case is one documented node in a campaign our guests describe as escalating.
Steve Lance, executive producer at Sincere Pictures, and Levi Browde, executive director of the Falun Info Center, join Levi's son Lucas, a principal dancer with Shen Yun, and musician Rachel Chen to walk through what the investigation found and what the documentary "Unbroken" documents in full.
Many of you may have heard of Shen Yun,
which is a performing arts company,
and they have dances every year
that comes to LA, San Francisco, California,
which I'm a big fan of.
I've told you about it on the show.
In the last few years,
Shen Yun has faced a lot of negative reporting
from New York Times and other outlets across the country.
Today, we have a pleasure to sit down with them
to tell us what they have been going through
and what's going on with this reporting.
They also give us a behind-the-scenes look
at what's happening at Shen Yun
and what it takes to put on these performances
across the country.
I'm Siamak.
Welcome to California Insider.
Steve, Lucas, Levi, Rachel, it's great to have you on.
Thank you for coming.
Thanks for the invite.
We want to talk to you about an issue
that part of you have been part of the Shen Yun show,
and in California, we have had some major challenges
with the Chinese Communist Party.
We had a mayor, Arcadian mayor,
that actually pleaded guilty for being an agent
of the Chinese Communist Party,
and there is a lot of spies here in California
that are working with the Chinese Communist Party.
You guys have made a documentary.
Some of you are part of the Shen Yun show.
Shen Yun show itself is facing a lot of issues
with the Chinese Communist Party.
Can you tell us what the show is facing?
The level of challenge that the Shen Yun Performing Arts,
based on our investigation,
has faced from the CCP's transnational repression
is really incredible,
and you mentioned the case here in California recently
with the mayor of Arcadia.
One of the situations that we bring to light
in our investigation in the film Unbroken was John Chen.
He's a convicted, now sentenced Chinese agent,
acting as a Chinese agent,
and there happened to be a nexus, actually,
between him, somebody named Michael Sun,
and the mayor of Arcadia,
who's now been charged by the Department of Justice,
and so that's just really the tip of the iceberg,
and it's all part of the Chinese Communist Party's
United Front work department,
which is their overseas influence apparatus
that sort of blends covert influence
and really overt engagement with covert coercion,
and that's where it sort of comes together,
and this is one example that has been tried,
but from our assessment,
there's a full-spectrum campaign of this sort
where they've thrown the kitchen sink
at the Shen Yun Performing Arts
and the Falun Gong community,
and I'm sure there's a lot more that will come to light.
Levi, can you tell us about
how this investigation came about?
Because Shen Yun was part of the story.
First, Shen Yun was subject
to the Chinese Communist Party's audit.
They wanted to potentially audit Shen Yun,
their nonprofit status,
and that's how it led to the investigations in Arcadia.
Can you tell us what happened there?
Sure, well, I think it's important to understand
that from the day Shen Yun started over 20 years ago,
the Chinese Communist Party has been targeting the company
to malign it, to silence it, to sabotage it,
to destroy the whole company,
because Shen Yun is reviving the authentic culture of China,
something the Chinese Communist Party
has been trying to destroy
over decades and decades and decades
of horrific, violent campaigns.
And so them going after Shen Yun is nothing new.
What is new is the escalation over the last two years,
and a key part of that, a pillar of that,
really, is what Steve was talking about,
where the FBI actually ran a sting operation
where you had John Chen, one of his cohorts,
who are based here in California,
flying out to the area where Shen Yun has its headquarters,
and they were trying to,
they were spying, overtly spying on the company there,
and what they're really trying to do
is bribe the U.S. government
to open up an investigation on Shen Yun.
The FBI ran a sting operation, caught him, his cohort,
and as Steve mentioned, now sentenced to prison.
So he was trying to get
the nonprofit status of Shen Yun revoked?
That's right.
What was he doing?
Yeah, he thought he was bribing IRS officials,
is what he thought he was doing,
but he was bribing undercover FBI agents,
and that's also indicative of the large,
how audacious the campaign has become.
You know, in the early years of Shen Yun,
it was sort of writing nasty letters
from the embassies of the consulates,
or going and visiting theaters of local mayors
and saying, you can't have Shen Yun,
we're gonna stop this,
but it's sort of, that obviously didn't succeed.
I mean, Shen Yun has become
the fastest-growing performing arts company
in American history,
while the Chinese government is trying to silence them,
so that wasn't working.
It's this last few years
where they've gotten a lot more audacious,
and bribing the American government officials,
I think, is a key example of how audacious they've become,
and how desperate, almost, they are
to do anything and everything they can
to try and silence Shen Yun.
What are the other examples?
So you mentioned things are escalating now,
but what was it like before for you guys?
For me, I've been touring with Jane for 15 years,
and like Levi mentioned,
it's escalated in the past couple years,
but actually, we've been targeted since day one,
and we've had tire slashes,
and we do get threats sent to the theater.
The theater management always gets letters
telling them not to let Shen Yun perform,
and it's always been a security issue.
That's why we have such tight security,
both on campus, and also when we tour.
We have people watching our buses overnight, 24 hours,
to make sure that no one comes and slashes the buses,
because that's very dangerous to the company,
and also, when we're on the highway,
the vehicles around us, as well.
It's gotten to the point where it's like,
almost every city we perform at,
we get bomb threats to the theater,
and on top of that,
we see dogs always combing the seats,
almost before every show, I feel like,
and then on top of that,
I know one year, we had someone,
I think it was in Chicago, I think you were there,
we came back from Europe,
so we toured around Europe,
and then when we came back to America,
we flew to Chicago,
and they stopped some of our performers,
and some of them were Americans, even,
because we were part of Shen Yun, part of Falun Gong,
they brought them out, escorted them to a side room,
and started questioning them,
even though some of them are American citizens,
or trying to go back home,
and then also, yeah,
we do have to keep very tight security,
we have to keep looking over buses all the time,
and it's kind of just like,
we kind of have to look behind our shoulder,
a lot of times on tour, especially.
The Chicago incident was very interesting, actually,
because I remember they called me,
and I flew out there,
it was an ethnic Chinese,
essentially border officer,
but he was an ethnic Chinese,
and he was sort of,
it seemed of his own volition,
trying to galvanize some of his fellow officers
at the border to try and stop these guys,
and again, pulling several American citizens off
to question them,
telling, repeating verbatim,
Chinese government propaganda against Shen Yun
to the fellow officers,
sort of caused this little firestorm on that day,
everybody was able to get in,
but it was sort of an example
of just how far Chinese propaganda influence has reached,
it's causing people to try
and bribe U.S. government officials,
and it's causing a border agent,
who's ethnically Chinese,
and I would assume has some allegiance to Beijing,
to, I would say, violate the law,
when Shen Yun was trying to come back into Chicago.
And Steve, you have looked into this,
New York Times have done some stories on Shen Yun,
and you started investigating this,
can you tell us what you saw in your investigations?
Well, there's quite a few components to it,
and the first thing that comes to mind
as we're talking about sort of the repression
that the Shen Yun folks have faced
would be a YouTuber,
he plays a significant role
in sort of what came about
with the New York Times series of articles
that they wrote targeting Shen Yun,
and his name is Yu Chao,
and there are leaked memos that we talk about
that came out of Beijing
that talk about the campaign that he was to carry out,
along with other YouTubers,
to sort of set the stage
for what happened with the New York Times,
which whether you call them a victim
or an accomplice in carrying out
Beijing's messaging campaign against this group,
we'll let the viewers ultimately decide that,
but one thing that I'd like to point out
in our investigation is that
we entered sort of this process with an open mind,
and I think that the New York Times,
when it comes to deciding to take on this project,
if you will,
it's not to say that Shen Yun should be exempt
from criticism or being looked into,
but the standard at which the New York Times
should hold themselves to,
to, in their own words,
in their own words, in their articles,
to a group that has been brutally cracked down upon
by the Chinese Communist Party,
should be extremely high,
and what do I mean by that?
When we entered this project to kind of analyze
their reporting and their editorial process,
it didn't take us long to find out
that their sources,
their key sources that they used in their reporting
were directly connected to the Beijing Dance Academy.
These are their key sources,
and there are a plethora of other flaws.
They try to minimize the persecution
after saying, yeah, acknowledging it,
and then one of the most egregious crimes
is the forced organ harvesting
that has taken place against Falun Gong practitioners.
They use an example or an expert
in their reporting who has ties
to the Chinese government indirectly,
and there's a lot of things like this
that were extremely concerning
that we were able to kind of uncover
and find throughout the process.
So you think there were a few performers
that were picked, handpicked to create these stories
from what it looks like to you?
Well, it goes back to the YouTuber,
and he, prior to the series of articles
that were released, I think it was in August of 2024
when they started, in January of 2024,
this YouTuber was bragging and boasting online
that he had connected the New York Times
with a series of disgruntled former Shen Yun dancers,
and this sort of tracks back
and traces with the leaked memo
that we were able to find and corroborate
that was directing him and others
to sort of do this type of operation,
and the connection between him
and these dancers, it's very alarming.
And Levi, what was it like for you,
because you have your kids performing at...
Well, it was interesting.
I've been volunteering for Chinese human rights
for a quarter of a century,
but it's always been sort of,
and of course, a lot of the stuff that happens
has been to close friends and family of close friends,
so it's always been a personal matter,
but it wasn't until about two years ago,
two and a half years ago,
where it was directly now affecting my family.
We were getting bomb threats to kill my whole family,
death threats to kill my whole family.
The theaters that Lucas and his brother are going to
are getting bomb threats,
and so it all became enormously personal
in a much bigger way over the last two years
with the way and the manners
in which they've targeted Shen Yun.
And what was it like when you saw the articles?
What was your reaction?
Well, if I'm honest, I was a little bit angry,
because the New York Times has been in my household
since the late 40s.
My grandfather read it every day.
My father reads it every day.
It was something that was on my kitchen table growing up.
It is something that a lot of Americans look to
to actually understand the truth of the world
and what's happening.
I had a little bit of background with New York Times.
They've had some significant journalistic failures
when it comes to covering the persecution of Falun Gong.
I was well aware of that
in terms of taking on Beijing's narrative,
in terms of downplaying the persecution.
You know, this goes back 25 years,
but then when they took up the Shen Yun story
and did upwards of, I think, a dozen articles at this point,
it was an immediate red flag
that suddenly this persecuted the Falun Gong group,
the Falun Gong group, the people who'd started Shen Yun,
that ran Shen Yun, they've ignored that for so long.
And now suddenly, at the exact same time
that these leaked memos coming out of Beijing are saying
we need a campaign in the West to strike at Shen Yun
and sabotage it and take it down,
exactly the same time Beijing is calling for that,
along come these New York Times articles
that are implementing that.
And again, we have no idea why they're making those decisions
in the back rooms of the New York Times,
but the point is that shouldn't matter.
Willingly or not, they are carrying out Beijing's objectives
to silence the Falun Gong community and to sabotage Shen Yun.
And that was abundantly clear from the very first time
I took a look at those articles.
So it was clear it was something we needed to look into
and I'm glad Steve and his team jumped on it
and did this whole investigation.
Now, Lucas, what was it like for you guys and Rachel?
Well, to quickly add on to what he was saying,
what's scary is this actually does have an impact
on the people reading it
because it's the only side they see.
They don't really get to see our side, not yet at least.
And I think the past couple of years
we've been getting phone calls from our grandparents
or uncles or aunts really worried about us
because if you kind of read
what the articles portray about us,
it makes it seem like we're getting abused,
we're not getting treated properly.
But then they call asking us, are you guys okay?
What's going on over there?
We're completely fine.
We're being treated completely like
as best as they can treat us.
And so I feel like it's had quite an impact
and it's kind of like we need to get this story out.
We need to show them our side
because when you kind of see an issue in society,
if you only see one side,
how could you make a decision on what's right or wrong?
You need to see both sides.
And our side, our story of Shen Yun
has not been told to the public yet.
And we're hoping through the documentary,
through everything, these interviews, everything,
we're able to kind of put our side onto the table.
And that way everyone can have,
they decide what's right or wrong,
how they view this issue, yeah.
And for me, since I've been with Shen Yun for so many years
and also in the past couple of years,
like Lucas can tell like every show we have bomb threats,
we have police coming with their dogs
to come and make sure that it's okay for us to perform,
it's okay, it's safe for the audience as well.
But, and then we've normalized it in a way that
it seems like, oh, it's just part of the schedule,
but actually that's not very normal.
And also, if I think about it,
all these years that we've received all these threats
and all these bomb threats,
we've always treated in a way like
we wanna make sure that our company
and our audience members are safe.
That's our first and foremost.
And we've never gone back and like sent an email saying,
no, we're gonna bomb you.
Like, it's always been a peaceful,
we wanna make sure that we're safe,
the audience members are safe.
And that's something I think is also reflected really well
in the documentary.
And it's something that I rarely think about as a musician,
because I'm just focused on like getting ready for the show
and working on my craft that I forget
that there's so many things that are,
like that we've faced over the years
and it's never been documented before.
So I think I'm really grateful for the documentary
because it really does show,
and it's also for us artists,
reflection of like, oh, how much we've gone through
and how proud we should be of how much we've accomplished.
It's also, it's really hard for us
to give our voice sometimes,
because our job is to let's say play an instrument
to dance on stage.
But then behind the scenes, it's like,
sometimes we always wonder like,
what can we do to help out?
And then through this documentary especially,
we're able to tell our side.
And it's been pretty special.
And I thank everyone who's been involved in the
helping out with this issue
and kind of saying our side of the story.
Now, Lukas, how is it like to be in Shen Yun
and why are you so passionate about telling this story?
So I can probably start from the beginning
of how I started dancing, I guess I can say.
Growing up, my parents took me to see
the Shen Yun show every year.
So it became kind of like a yearly thing,
kind of like, you know,
if you go to watch Broadway every year,
like the Lion King or something.
But some of the time he'd sit still, some of the time.
I wouldn't whine and complain, but anyways,
it intrigued me because something about the show
seemed different than every other show I've seen.
And I was too young to kind of comprehend at the time,
but as I got older and understood more,
and then slowly, I don't know,
life just brought me on the path of dance.
I didn't really want to dance.
It's just, I joined an art summer camp.
Next thing I know, I was enrolled in an art school
and I started dancing.
And so life kind of flowed.
And as I progressed as a dancer,
I progressed as a person as well.
And I understood the show more and more.
And then I could feel this,
whenever I watched the show,
not only would I be able to understand the dance,
but the energy, the passion of the dancers
and the values portrayed and the meaning behind the show,
all of it struck a chord deep inside me.
And it's like wanting to become a Shen Yun dancer
and now being able to tour with Shen Yun,
you know, it's kind of like a dream come true.
But at the same time, it's like,
yeah, it's pretty surreal.
And that's why I'm very passionate about it
and want to voice their side as well.
I remember a moment.
Remember when you guys came back from the last tour?
Because we normally, they come back from tour,
we haven't seen them for four months.
So there's this big family reunion.
You came back and we sat around the kitchen table
because something really struck me
because we were talking about how they're doing.
Because this is like the second tour
where they're getting a lot of bomb threats,
but this one was pretty severe,
more severe than the prior year.
I mean, you have to understand that Shen Yun is,
the level of artistry is world-class.
It's among the very, very best.
And it takes an enormous amount of effort and focus.
I mean, just like anybody who's gonna become
the world best at what they do.
And so it is very difficult.
The training is rigorous.
It's a tough program.
And so when normally I come back from tour,
we sit around the table
and it was sort of like a nice reunion.
And this time I could just see the weight of,
because the first thing you asked me was,
did grandpa read the articles, right?
And so they're carrying the weight
of trying to be the very best at what they do,
which is already a very elite program and very demanding.
And on top of that, they're sitting there thinking about
who might be reading these articles,
who might be consuming this sort of campaign
and lining up against this,
and that's bearing down on them.
And I think people have to think about what that means,
having to both become an elite and be an elite performer
and have all the pressure that would normally have.
And at the same time,
seeing these kind of dark forces aligned against you
and kind of weighing you down,
I think that was the first time that that,
the reason I mentioned the kitchen table there
is because that was the first time it was kind of,
for me at least, I don't know how it was for you,
kind of a depressing experience.
Normally it's very joyous.
They're back from tour,
mom's in the kitchen cooking
and we're sort of this celebration,
but it was really sort of like,
Lucas asked me, has grandpa read the articles?
And it was, the pressure is very palatable and it's real.
And I think it has a very real effect on their lives.
At least I saw it around the dinner table.
Now they have a way of sort of,
when you guys get together,
there's a great camaraderie in the company.
And so they're able to sort of shake things off
because of that.
So you guys are with the company
and a lot of people are with the company
and you guys are doing good performances.
With the accusations, does that impact you guys?
I mean, of course it impacts us.
It kind of lets,
sometimes makes us reflect on what we're actually doing.
But then on the other side,
it gives us more motivation to do better for the show,
to show them who we really are
and what The Shining Show really is.
And so sometimes it's like,
we hear all this stuff getting thrown at us
and when it gets to showtime, we're like, you know what?
Clear it all out.
We're going to give you the pure, untainted Shining Show
and let you decide what you see.
And Steve, when was the moment
you decided to make this documentary?
I just wanted to piggyback off of what Lucas
and Levi were saying,
which is one thing that sort of struck me in the process
was being backstage with the dancers
and watching their process and how they prep
and how they train.
For anybody who's a fan of sports,
whether it's baseball, basketball, football, hockey,
whatever your sport is,
you always hear the term mental toughness, right?
It takes a certain level of mental toughness to prepare.
The way that these folks train
are literally like Olympians, right?
The way their diet is, they're focused.
And then to Levi's point,
seeing them walk into a theater,
it's hard enough to stay in shape and to be ready
and to get up for that moment on stage,
but to walk into a bomb threat
and then in Washington, D.C.,
where we were the day that it happened,
where they got one,
everybody had to evacuate in freezing cold weather.
It's hard enough to maintain your diet
and your mental focus
and then you're dealing with these bomb threats.
And it's really, I think, a testament.
You see how they're reacting here,
water off a duck's back to a certain degree.
But to your question about when we decided to do it,
when we first saw these New York Times articles roll out,
we saw one, then we saw two, then we saw three,
and it was right around the article three or four
where you start to say to yourself,
this is getting a little bit weird.
For anybody who's an avid reader of the news,
you know that once you get into the two, three,
four, five articles,
it has to really justify the attention.
And on one company,
because I've heard from a lot of people saying
that this is very odd,
these many articles on one company.
It's very odd.
And at one point,
one of the articles was sort of,
it was almost like they were speaking,
trying to speak directly to Shen Yun or Levi
or whoever, somebody,
and they were almost threatening and bullying.
It was almost like a bullying tactic.
Like, don't worry, more's coming.
It was really a bizarre sequence.
And I think when you look at it,
to follow up on what Levi said earlier as well,
we don't know who's in the back room
and what their reasons for doing anything might be.
But what we do know is the executive editor,
Joseph Kahn of the New York Times,
made his chops as the Beijing bureau chief
in the early 2000s.
What we do know is that Nicole Hong,
one of the co-writers of the series of articles,
her father, George Hong,
is directly tied to the CCP's United Front Work Department
through various organizations.
I think that this is worth a serious discussion
because when you look at the net impact
or sort of the net outcome of the New York Times
12 hit pieces and counting,
hopefully they've moved on,
you could see that they're directly in line.
Every narrative that they come at Shen Yun
is exactly what the Chinese Communist Party has parroted
or what they have created.
And they're parroting the CCP's narrative.
And Chinese Communist Party,
they are very good at creating propaganda
and they get people to believe it.
A lot of the people,
they believe it and they don't really know
they are following the Chinese Communist propaganda.
A lot of times people might not even know
they're doing that.
And because they have influence
in a lot of media organizations across the globe.
And what was it like for you to look into Shen Yun?
It was actually very eye-opening for me
to watch their process.
And of course, as a journalist, as a human being,
you see these accusations.
And so you start to be concerned and questioning.
Things don't quite add up,
but of course you want to get to the bottom of it.
Asking Shen Yun for access to the shows
and to see their process, their training facilities,
and to see how the sausage is made, if you will,
was very eye-opening.
And I still remember a time
we actually had an outside consultant
who was helping us with the film,
wasn't exposed to Shen Yun before,
didn't really know anything about the group.
And he took a tour of the campus with us
as we were doing some interviews.
And we just happened to stumble upon,
I think you and your brother,
and there wasn't a plan to do it.
It was like, oh, hey.
And you see these young, vibrant souls
with just glowing with a smile.
And then we walked away and he's like,
you can't fake that smile
in terms of the abuse allegations.
And so for me to be able to see the process
and Shen Yun really opened up a lot of information to us
in terms of medical records,
medical treatment, which you can see in the film.
We're grateful for the opportunity
to be able to do it and tell the story.
When I talk to people about Shen Yun,
a lot of people are wondering
why would the Chinese government wants to shut down
or bother this performing arts show?
There's not even performing in China.
I mean, for Shen Yun,
our mission is to revive traditional Chinese culture
and the CCP at its heart is atheist.
And then in the show, we have a lot of divine elements.
And also since we were started up
by Falun Gong practitioners,
we're also spreading awareness of the persecution in China,
the organ harvesting, and that's all because of the CCP,
the CCP's persecution of us.
And so internationally, we're well-recognized
and a lot of people are understanding more about the CCP
and also our story.
And I think that's what the CCP is afraid of.
So that's why they've been targeting us since day one.
And Levi, was that obvious to you?
Because you've been involved with this for many years.
When you saw those articles,
you felt like there might be a connection to China.
Yeah, I mean, again, the first thing
that's abundantly obvious and objectively clear
is that they're achieving the goals
of the Beijing's propaganda.
So the question now is why and how.
And that was sort of, I think,
what was so intriguing about your investigation.
Some of the reports that my nonprofit have been doing
on this topic was really trying to expose the why and how.
I would think if I were in charge of the New York Times
and I just run a series of articles
that did a better job at achieving propaganda goals
of Beijing than Beijing has ever done themselves,
I would hope that's a serious moment of introspection,
audit, how did we get here, folks?
So that was to try and dig into it
and find out the how and why.
And it was really the impetus of looking at this.
And as Steve said, there are red flags all over the place.
Undisclosed ties to China,
using very compromised sources,
ignoring evidence that Shen Yan had brought forward
that would counter their negative narratives,
using the one individual sort of almost on the planet
who would deny the existence
of forced organ harvesting atrocity,
and meanwhile ignoring the literally scores
of published experts on the topic.
I mean, the list goes on and on and on.
And so there is some serious deficiencies
and serious journalistic failures at the New York Times.
And I think the question is, do they realize this?
Are they doing anything about it?
Someone needs to get to the bottom of that
inside that company.
In terms of this documentary,
I watched it and it's well done.
You're showing what the Chinese Communist Party is doing.
Are you not afraid?
Because there might be a safety element in this.
How do you guys feel about being in this documentary
that's going against one of the most powerful countries
in the world?
Well, to be frank, through the process of doing this film,
of course, there are security concerns
and we take every precaution that we can.
But it was actually one of my big takeaways
from learning more about Shen Yan on a much deeper level
and the people involved.
Rachel's told the story many times now,
is that Shen Yan, you could sort of draw parallels
to the people who established Shen Yan and the pilgrims
that actually established our country
and everything that we're founded upon.
And our founders and in our heritage
sort of paved the way for Shen Yan
in terms of fleeing communist China
under religious persecution,
seeking a better life to practice their religious beliefs.
And so the bravery that they have
under much more pressure than I do,
it's really the least we can do
is just sort of project their voice and tell their story.
They have far more to lose than we do here in this country.
And Lucas, do you have any thoughts for our audience,
how they can help you guys?
This documentary, I feel like,
even though it's such a complicated narrative
and such a confusing story to get your head around,
I think they portrayed it very well.
And I think, make sure to check out the documentary
because it's a very clear path
and a clear storyline to follow and understand.
And just get the word out,
kind of help everyone around you
understand more about the situation,
understand more about the story
and get to really know us.
If you really have any questions or like hesitant
about what the Shen Yan situation is like,
just watch the show.
That's us, there's nothing else.
If you watch the show, that's who we really are.
Also, like the documentary,
I mean, there's only a few people in the documentary
like me and Lucas,
but there's actually so many people behind the scenes
that have been working hard at making sure
that we are able to perform every year
and we're able to put on a whole new show.
And there's like the school and everyone involved.
And I think that the movie actually really depicts
the spirit of Shen Yan and how we try to strive
towards our goal and our mission,
how focused we are on making sure
that our mission comes through.
And I think there's one thing
I think is important about the movie is that
in a way it's not about Shen Yan.
Shen Yan is a litmus test in many respects
for whether we can in this country
stand up to the full scope and scale
of Beijing's transnational repression
against one of our companies, one of our organizations,
one of our communities right here on US soil.
And whether we can do that,
I mean, yeah, the story,
the story of the movie really follows Shen Yan,
but really it's, I feel in many ways it's about that,
is can we, do we have the courage?
Do we have the political will?
Do we have the economic will?
Do we have the moral fiber to stand up to Beijing
when it's targeting someone on US soil and say, no.
It's a lot harder to do than we might imagine,
but it's worthwhile.
And I think the movie kind of makes that clear.
Levi, why is it that the Communist Party,
you've been at this for many years,
you're involved with Shen Yan.
Why is it that the Communist Party is coming after Shen Yan?
The Communist Party goes after Shen Yan
because Shen Yan is depicting authentic Chinese culture,
which is very divine in its origin on the world stage.
And by doing that,
demonstrating that the Chinese regime
is not the true shepherd of China,
its culture or its people.
In other words, it's a fraud.
But there's another element that I think most people miss.
They go after Shen Yan
because it started by Falun Gong practitioners.
So Falun Gong is this Buddhist-based spiritual practice
that what most people don't know
was widely popular in China in the 1990s.
One out of every 13 people
were practicing Falun Gong in China
by the turn of the century.
That was so many people,
it worried one or two leaders in the top echelon of the CCP
and they decided to crush it.
And so for the last 25 years,
there's been a horrific persecution,
rampant detention, rampant torture,
death by torture, forced organ harvesting,
absolutely horrific atrocities
against this Buddhist-based spiritual practice.
The media has been largely missing.
And so this persecution started in 1999.
And so after a few years, the media went silent.
There was a group of artists that came together in New York,
Falun Gong practitioners.
They realized this persecution is not just about us.
This is the death knell for Chinese culture more broadly.
We need to start a company
that not only reclaims this culture,
puts it on the stage so the world can see it,
but also tell the story of what's happening to Falun Gong
because that's the story of modern China.
And so when you see a Shen Yan show,
it's like thousands of years of Chinese history,
including modern China.
And so it was started at a time
when everybody started, Shen Yan at that time,
Falun Gong practitioners, they had a brother,
a family member, a friend,
who's literally being tortured or killed
or in prison in China.
It was a really, really horrific time.
And this show, putting Shen Yan together,
was an attempt to say, we need to tell the story,
not just the story,
we need to tell the real history of the CCP,
what real Chinese culture is,
how what a precious gem it is that they've almost lost,
and tell the story of Falun Gong.
And so that's how Shen Yan was formed.
It was all formed by Falun Gong practitioners.
So that comes to the second main reason
the CCP goes after it,
because they've spent the last 26, 27 years
trying to convince the world
that something's wrong with Falun Gong
in order to justify their persecution.
They're weird, they're a cult, they're this, they're that.
Along comes Shen Yan and shows that Falun Gong people
are capable of telling such a beautiful,
moving, inspiring story.
People shedding tears in the audience
of how glorious China was before communism.
And it completely shatters the billions of dollars
they've spent trying to demonize Falun Gong
on the world stage.
I think something that like, for me,
growing up in America that I don't realize
is actually the persecution of Falun Gong
is not just of the persecution in China,
it's very close to our hearts
because there's a lot of members in Shen Yan
who have family member until this day
still being persecuted in China.
So it's very much our story.
And for me, actually,
I learn more and more about this every day.
I like the stories in the documentary as well,
when they said there's 94 current Shen Yan members
who have family being persecuted in China.
Those are people all around me that I don't know
because every time you see them,
they're smiling, they're happy,
they're working, they're dancing,
they're playing music,
and they're trying really hard
to make sure that our show goes well
and they're telling our story.
So I think that's something that's very important
that I tend to forget as well,
that the persecution of China and Falun Gong
is the Shen Yan story as well.
Can you give me an example of this persecution?
Do you guys feel these challenges you're seeing?
Well, for me, I didn't feel it for many years
until there was one time I was performing
and we were performing in Holland
and our Erhu player was a Chinese instrument.
She made eye contact with a lady in the audience.
It was during intermission
and they just acknowledged each other
and I felt like there was a lot of meaning
in that acknowledgement.
And so I asked her,
well, who is she?
And she responded,
we were in the same labor camp together.
Wow.
So in that moment,
I just felt like what we're doing,
our mission is very real and it's happening to us.
And we were able to tell the story of Falun Gong
and the practitioners in China,
they're unable to tell their own stories.
Basically, with all these threats,
all these attacks,
all these accusations coming towards us,
of course, we get hesitant
and we kind of have to think like,
what really are we doing?
It makes us kind of reflect on ourselves.
But I know when times get really hard,
it's actually the audience members that keep me going.
Especially, I watched the documentary a few times.
The most recent time I watched it,
I got really touched.
When at the end of the documentary,
they're playing audience members
who watched the show outside Lincoln Center.
They're saying,
these guys are brave.
These guys are courageous.
Keep going.
You guys are the light in this world.
Like all those types of comments,
that kind of refreshes me
and keeps me aware that what I'm doing
is needed in this world.
That the show is really needed
and that it spreads beauty and hope to the world.
And that's actually like you guys,
the people who watch the show keep us going as well.
And so it's like we help the audience out,
but at the same time,
the audience helps us out and keeps us going.
And it's very hard to tell as an audience
when you watch the show
to know you guys are going through all of this
to put on this show
because the performance is amazing.
So we encourage everybody to watch the show
and also watch the documentary.
I was personally surprised
by what these performers go through to put on Shen Yun.
Tell us what you think about this episode.
We also will leave you a link
to the documentary Unbroken
so you can watch the documentary.
You can always email us at siamak.californiainsider.com
or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Ghorami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.