California voters will decide this November whether to impose a one-time wealth tax on the state's roughly 200 billionaires, a measure pitched by supporters as narrow and temporary. But some high-net-worth Californians are not waiting to see whether it passes. Several prominent founders and investors have already moved, reduced California ties, or shifted assets ahead of the proposal's Jan. 1 residency date.
Supporters say the tax would directly apply only to the wealthiest sliver of residents. Not everyone in its path is convinced the one-time label will hold.
Joshua Rauh, Ormond Family Professor of Finance at Stanford's Graduate School of Business, argues the exodus carries costs well beyond the billionaires themselves. He sits down with California Insider to explain what is written into the measure that has some of the state's wealthiest residents preparing for it as if it will not stop at one time.
00:00 - Intro 00:54 - Impact of Wealth Tax on Economy 05:07 - Proposed Use of Wealth Tax Revenue 07:45 - Economic and Philosophical Implications 13:57 - Student Perspectives and Billionaire Creation 19:27 - Impact on Publicly Traded Companies 22:09 - Proposals for Economic Prosperity 24:39 - Public Spending and Pension Funds
Wealth tax is now going to be on the ballot in California in November.
Today we sit down with Josh Rau, who's a Stanford professor.
He's gone in depth and analyzed the wealth tax and its impacts.
He's going to tell us how it would work.
You might say, well, in this case, these people are very, very wealthy,
so they can afford to give up 5% of their wealth.
But it's a very slippery slope because who is actually wealthy?
Once you start chipping away at that sacred principle
of private property, there may be no stopping it.
I'm Siamak.
Welcome to California Insider.
Josh, it's great to have you on.
Welcome.
Thank you so much, Siamak.
Great to be here.
We want to talk to you about wealth tax.
And there's new polls in May that now 54% of Californians support this wealth tax.
How do you think this will impact California if it passes?
Well, by now, probably most of your viewers have heard about the wealth tax
and what it does, but worth just briefly reviewing.
What this is, is this would be a 5% tax on the accumulated wealth
of anyone whose wealth is over a billion dollars.
So on billionaires.
And the measure is pitched as being one time,
meaning it's supposed to be a one time levy.
The way that the billionaires have been responding to this suggests
that many of them do not believe it's going to be one time.
And there's actually no real way to commit to it being one time.
This particular group of sponsors of this ballot proposition,
they may not propose in the future.
They say scouts on or we won't propose in the future,
but other groups could propose in the future or others could do it.
So what we're already seeing is that a number of the high net worth individuals
who would be targeted by this proposition have actually already left California.
As soon as the measure really gained steam in late 2025.
And as soon as it was understood that in December 31st, 2025,
that on that date, that would be the assessment date or the cutoff date.
A lot of high net worth individuals who already had maybe a toehold,
real estate in other states took the steps to change their state of residency.
And some of the really very high net worth individuals
who would be targeted by this proposition did that.
So we're already seeing billionaires leaving.
The founders of Google, Brendan Page, Mark Zuckerberg.
He left in February, 2026.
The proponents of this measure are saying that's too late.
We're still going to get him,
but I think he's probably planning a legal challenge if it comes to that.
So what it's going to do to California and its economy is that with these,
with the moving out of these individuals also moves out a lot of opportunity.
And the opportunity has to do with job creation.
Part of the reason that California has been so prosperous
over the past decades has been the jobs that these companies have created.
And so when you have people who are the job creators leaving,
that really hurts the employment economy.
It hurts the economy of California because it means that those jobs
will be created elsewhere.
And it's not only the people who are leaving and who have left,
but it's also the billionaires or the high net worth individuals
who might be created in the future by new companies that would be created.
Because a lot of those people now are the ones who are raising
Series B venture capital.
They're also thinking to themselves,
maybe California isn't the place that I want to build my company.
So people that may have a hundred million dollar company,
they might be thinking about leaving right now.
Well, exactly.
And you know, you give a very good example
because the way that a company,
you say they may have a hundred million dollar company,
the way that that valuation would have even come out
is that a venture capitalist invested money in the company.
And the typical way that that would happen
is the venture capitalist would say,
just to give an example,
I'm going to invest 10 million dollars
in exchange for a 10% stake in the company.
And then the reported valuation of the company is a hundred million dollars.
But it's not clear at any point in time
that the company will actually be able to,
you know, achieve liquidity at a hundred million dollars.
It might not even really be worth a hundred million dollars.
On paper, that's what's implied by that funding round.
And as you say, as more funding rounds happen
and companies raise more money,
more capital as they grow,
it's actually quite natural.
We've had many, many companies that have achieved
so-called unicorn status.
They have a $1 billion valuation on paper.
But that doesn't mean that the owners of the company
are sitting on a pile of money,
like in a cartoon, you know, with a billion dollars there.
I think sometimes the proponents of the wealth tax
seem to have that idea in mind.
And in fact, they own companies that could potentially
be very, very valuable
and that have implied valuations based on venture capital
now of a billion dollars or more.
But their actual liquidity is very, very uncertain.
So what you're saying,
they're selling a piece of their company to get money,
but it's not very clear if the rest of the company
can have that kind of valuation when they need to sell it.
Exactly.
But this ballot proposition would still treat them
as being billionaires.
And so this really highlights, I think,
some of the disincentives to starting companies
in California when you have such a tax
that could potentially be imposed.
What are they planning to do with the money?
I've seen that about 90% of it is going to the healthcare
and 10% of going to education.
What are your thoughts on that?
Well, the proposition has been motivated by the proponents
as being necessary to fill in a gap in Medi-Cal.
So Medi-Cal is California's Medicaid.
Medicaid is the program for health insurance for the poor.
The claim is that the program faces a funding gap
that is the result of federal government action last year
in the House Reconciliation Bill,
the One Big Beautiful Bill Act,
which makes some changes to the way
that the federal government funds Medicare.
And in the case of California,
these changes would reduce federal funding for Medicare
by an amount of approximately $150 billion.
Now, that's over 10 years.
Half of that is the result of a work requirement
or community engagement requirement,
which says that if you want to apply for Medicaid,
you need to demonstrate that for 80 hours a month,
you're either working or engaged in school
or engaged in some kind of community activity.
And there are many, many exemptions.
So if you're a pregnant woman,
if you have a medical condition
that allows you to be described as medically frail,
if you're a disabled veteran,
there are many, many exemptions to this.
This is not a very harsh provision.
But the state of California is approaching it
from the perspective of we need to fill this in.
We want to make sure that even people
who are unable or unwilling to meet this work requirement,
that we're going to cover them as well.
And so I think the premise that this wealth tax
is necessary to fill in a funding gap
that was caused by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act,
was caused by Congress,
was caused in Washington, DC,
is just not really accurate.
I think it's a longstanding bipartisan principle
that actually underscored the welfare reforms
that Bill Clinton signed in the mid 90s.
We have a social safety net in this country
through a lot of different programs.
But if you want to have access to that,
there has to be some responsibility
on the part of the individual.
And in this case, I think these changes
that are being made to Medicaid
are actually really fairly light
and very, very reasonable.
And a lot of people who might not be on Medicaid
after the changes are made
are people who might actually choose
to say go on their spouse's employer-provided health insurance
instead of taking Medicaid from the state.
So Josh, you are actually a professor.
You teach economy.
And most Californians, a lot of Californians,
when they look at this ballot measure,
they might think, they're thinking,
this is a few billionaires
and they have a lot of money.
Why not do this one time and pay this?
How do you see that as a professor of economy?
Well, I think putting on my professor of economics hat,
may I say that the issue is the distortions
that this creates for the economy
and how it's going to harm opportunity in the future,
particularly in the form of jobs.
You know, it's nice to be able to say,
we're going to tax these people.
They can afford it.
It's only 5% of their wealth.
But what the people who are targeted
by the ballot proposition are thinking is,
this could just be the beginning.
This could be the beginning.
And if it's just the beginning,
then I want to make sure that I'm not around for the sequel.
And that's why a lot of them have left
and will be taking jobs with them.
But I'll say a couple other things now,
I guess maybe putting on maybe a more philosophical hat
than an economist hat,
which is that there is a principle here
of protecting private property.
You know, John Locke,
whose writings formed some of the foundations
on which our founding documents
in the United States were built.
He wrote that the most important things to protect
are life, liberty, and property.
Thomas Jefferson converted that a bit into life,
liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
But the basic principle is the same.
Property is something sacred.
The idea that you protect private property
is something sacred.
And again, you might say,
well, in this case,
these people are very, very wealthy,
so they can afford to give up 5% of their wealth
or maybe more.
But it's a very slippery slope
because who is actually wealthy?
The way that the proposition is written
and the way that the text is written,
it would not be hard
for a future ballot proposition
or possibly even a legislative action
to pretty much take the text,
cross out the word billionaire,
and write the word millionaire.
So anybody who maybe has a million dollars
could be subject to a wealth tax.
It's a very slippery slope.
And so I think you have to ask the question
from a political and philosophical perspective,
would you want the same treatment?
Would I want the same treatment
as what we're doing to billionaires?
Because it may be that at some point in the future,
wealth is kind of redefined
as being something that captures
a much larger number of people.
Once you start chipping away
at that sacred principle of private property,
there may be no stopping it.
And there is another component to this.
You mentioned that some of these people are leaving
and then they're going to take the jobs with them.
What about taxes?
Because they are contributing,
these people are paying a lot of taxes to the state, right?
Well, exactly right.
And if you think about what's going on,
actually, with the California jobs economy
over the last decade,
we've actually done some interesting work on this,
looking at what I call California anchor firms,
some of the largest employers in California.
They would be the major technology companies
that everybody would be thinking of.
And we looked at 25 of the top anchor firms
and we looked at where they had their jobs
10 years ago versus today.
And a lot of these companies, you know,
have grown a lot in size overall,
but the places that they've created jobs
have not been in California.
They've been elsewhere in the United States
or they've been abroad.
So just looking at jobs that have gone to other US states,
just of these top 25 anchor firms,
we calculate around 63,000 missing jobs
just from those firms.
If you extrapolate a little more
to more than these 25 firms,
which only employ about two or 3%
of total California employed individuals,
then the number is more on the order
of a quarter of a million missing jobs.
And as you point out,
that's not only missed prosperity
and lost prosperity for people in California
who could have those jobs,
but it's also lost income for the state.
And I'll just say that, you know,
there's this tension of the way
that people think about this issue.
Some people think about the issue
from the perspective of how can we make sure
the state raises the most revenue?
What's the revenue maximizing tax policy?
I think that's an important question,
but it's also a very important question to ask,
what is the policy that actually maximizes
wellbeing in the state, prosperity in the state?
And that's a very, very different question.
As to give a very stark example of the trade-off,
I think some of the proponents of these measures
would be happy if the state brought in
an extra billion or $2 per year,
to one or $2 billion per year,
even if it led to the destruction
of 100,000 jobs or more.
To me, that's not a good trade-off.
But when you focus just very narrowly
on revenues, state revenues,
those are the kinds of trade-offs
that sometimes the proponents of this
end up being in favor of.
You mentioned somebody like Mark Zuckerberg
has left the state,
and then there's other people that have
already left, like Google founders.
Does that impact taxes in California?
Because they contribute to some
significant amount of taxes, right?
Because we get a lot of our tax revenue
when people sell their stocks.
We're getting it from the wealthiest
in California, right?
Very much so.
And this is a very important point.
Because when someone like Mark Zuckerberg leaves,
there are a couple of things going on.
Number one is the state might not be able
to collect the wealth tax from him.
So that's lost revenue for the state
from the wealth tax.
But the other point that's very important
is that these high net worth individuals
are also paying significant income taxes.
And in some research that we've done,
we try to kind of add these things up
and balance them against each other.
What's the likely net gain in state revenue
from the wealth tax measured against
the likely long-term loss
from the lost income taxes of these individuals?
And it's not a favorable calculation
for the wealth tax.
You know, once you consider the fact
that a number of people will have left
and have escaped the tax drag net,
as it were, for the wealth tax,
and then you also consider the lost income taxes
over a long period of time,
those income taxes over a long period of time
really add up very, very significantly.
The billionaires in California,
they probably pay around, on average,
around $4 or $5 billion per year.
But as you point out,
it varies a great deal with capital gains realizations.
And it also, that's a number that's growing
very, very fast.
So when you consider the fact
that there's going to be a lot of leakage
in the wealth tax from the people leaving,
and then all of this lost income tax over time,
it's a very short-sighted policy.
We might get a little bit of money up front
in exchange for losing a very valuable
and growing stream of taxable income
from these individuals over a long period of time.
When you talk to your students
and you're teaching in Stanford,
how do they see this tax?
Well, it's interesting.
I think a lot of the students think
that it won't apply to them.
Particularly, a lot of the undergraduates
think that it might not apply to them.
At the business school, it's a little different.
I think many people could imagine
that someday they aspire maybe to create companies
that could potentially be worth a billion dollars.
And so I think initially,
a lot of the students come in
with this kind of cartoonish idea of,
okay, billionaires are rich people
who are sitting on piles of money.
And they don't need the money.
We can just take the money.
But then when I ask them to think through,
what is the process of raising money for a company?
Do you know people who have raised money for a company?
Have you raised money for your company?
What's the process?
How would this look if your company
were successful and grew?
What's going to happen to the valuation of the company?
And recognizing that this is actually a position
that they aspire to,
that then, I think, tends to shift thinking.
And someone once asked me in a debate,
well, okay, I understand you're against the billionaire tax,
but do you have any suggestions
for how we might otherwise reduce
the number of billionaires in the state of California?
I said, no.
I actually, I would like my students to go out
and to become billionaires
because if they become a billionaire,
it probably means that they're providing a good or service
that they've developed, invented, worked on
that is of incredible value to society.
So why would I want to reduce the number of billionaires?
We want more billionaires and we want more prosperity.
How would this get calculated?
Because you mentioned it's a wealth tax, right?
And some of these things are not really clear
if people might be billionaires,
but they might not have a pile of cash in their home.
Exactly.
Well, this is a tax on net worth.
And so that includes the value of everything
that the individual would own, including their businesses.
Now, it can be hard to place a value on a business.
And one of the ways the business would be valued
would be to look at, for example,
the last round of outside capital that came in
and what the implied valuation was there.
But that is just an implied valuation
based on a round of raising capital.
And the actual valuation of the company
could be fluctuating quite a bit
from month to month or from year to year.
And so the proposition states
that the assets would be measured
as of the end of 2026, as the end of this year,
even though the eligibility
for being subject to this tax
would be the end of 2025.
And so those valuation questions are really tricky.
How do you value an illiquid company?
The proposition suggests that the valuation
cannot be less than the last implied round
of private capital funding,
but it's going to be very challenging
to actually measure that.
And then once it's been measured,
the question is, where are founders,
entrepreneurs supposed to come up with the cash?
Because they may not have that cash.
The valuation is sitting in the private business,
the value of a private business.
Where are they going to come up with the cash?
And the answer is often that they're going to have
to sell pieces of those companies
in order to come up with the cash.
And if you have selling of companies
in order to come up with cash to pay the wealth tax,
that's actually going to drive down
the value of companies.
In some cases,
these are actually publicly traded companies,
Meta or DoorDash.
These founders would potentially be subject to this tax.
And the entrepreneurs who had founded them
would be selling in order to pay the tax.
And do they have to pay taxes on what they sell too?
They would also have to pay capital gains taxes
on what they sell.
Yes.
Another point is that the proposition as written
has provisions that suggest that the valuation
could be inflated
if the individual has a greater control of the company
than their cashflow ownership of the company.
So let me explain how that works.
So in a company like Meta,
Mark Zuckerberg, the founder,
he's raised a lot of capital
over the years for the company.
And as a result,
he owns around 13% of the value of that company.
That's the cashflow rights that he has to the company.
But he also over time wanted to ensure
that he also had some control of the company
and its decisions.
So he did something very common,
which is to issue what are called class B shares,
which have excess or additional voting rights
in the company.
So as a result,
he has 60% of the control of the company,
even though he only owns 13% of the wealth of the company.
Well, the provision is written
would offer the state tax authorities
the option to potentially up-value the company
as though Mark Zuckerberg owned 60% of the company,
not 13% of the company.
And that would be a major, major tax for him,
one that he would feel much more
than just say the way people think of a 5% tax
on some pile of money
that somebody would be sitting on,
because he would actually have to sell
pretty significant portions of Meta stock to them.
That's going to drive down the value of stock
in people's 401ks who own Meta.
I think DoorDash is another company
where it's even more extreme example,
where the amount of stock that he would have to sell
would result in loss of control of the company
and would exert very significant downward pressure
on the value of that company.
What about the jobs?
When we talk to people in the legislature
and California politicians,
there's a lot of confidence
that people have to be in California.
This is a great market.
People will come here and it doesn't matter
they have to pay a little bit more
or they have to deal with this type of issues.
This is such a great place that people have to be here.
What are your thoughts on that?
Well, we have been living through a time
where California has what we like to call
terrific agglomerations.
California has terrific agglomerations of employment.
An agglomeration means that, you know,
because you're here, I'm here,
and people just want to come here.
They want to come here to start companies.
They want to employ people here.
And the thesis behind what you're saying
is that they're willing to put up with a lot
in order to do that.
Because it's worth it.
Because you're going to get the money back
or because it's a big market or you have good talent here.
And you get all these positive externalities
of having all these other people around.
But there are limits to that.
And we're seeing that in California
is we're seeing how people, individuals are responding
to a lot of the heavy regulation we have in California
and the heavy taxation in California.
These agglomerations are fragile.
You know, we do have a lot of great natural resources
here as well.
So some of the comparisons to other places
that have had agglomeration economies
sometimes seem unfavorable.
But if you think about, you know, Detroit in the 1950s,
that was the place.
It would be impossible for anyone
who was in Detroit in the 1950s
to imagine what would become of Detroit
as those agglomerations that they had
built around the automobile industry
would eventually dissipate.
And while in California, you know, it's hard to imagine,
I think because we have a lot of natural beauty around here.
We walk around, we say everything's nice
and the sun is always shining.
Nonetheless, these agglomerations
are still very, very fragile.
You know, the weather can only hold you together
for so long when government is passing policies
that are driving people and businesses out of the state.
And this research that we've done
on where are California anchor firms
actually creating jobs.
You know, if we go back to 2015,
if we held the share of jobs
that these anchor firms had 10 years ago,
11 years ago, if we held that share constant,
we imagined, you know, what would happen
if they had done as much employment creation
in California as they have had,
as they've been doing in other parts of the United States.
California would have an additional quarter million jobs,
250,000 more jobs for people.
And they would be higher paying.
And these policies that the state makes
to drive companies out,
these really damage prosperity for individuals.
And so, you know, the sort of populist idea,
oh, the high net worth individuals,
billionaires, they can afford it.
We'll just, we're just asking them to,
you know, to-
Dip in a little bit.
Yeah, exactly. Put in a little bit.
You know, you could think of it that way,
but the problem is they're not accepting that
and they're leaving and going to other places.
And so then the reality is, you know,
you can feel good because you exported billionaires
out of California, but in reality,
you're just really exporting jobs,
high paying jobs, prosperity.
You mentioned about, you had thoughts about
unleashing prosperity in California.
Can you tell us how?
Well, I think we need to go back to a system
that has much lower tax rates and a broader base.
There's actually, I should mention,
there's a proposition on the ballot
that's not getting much attention.
It's going to be on the ballot in November.
It's not getting much attention
because the wealth tax is getting,
is drawing so much of that,
of the attention about the ballot.
But there is one to renew our top bracket
income taxes in California,
which are 13.3% at the top bracket.
And this rate applies to a lot of business owners
who structure their companies as past revenues
and pay tax under this individual income tax regime.
And so, you know, that was put in place originally
as a temporary measure in 2012.
And then it was extended in 2015 through to 2030.
And now on the ballot, there's another proposition
to basically make it permanent.
This has been very damaging.
This has driven a lot of companies and individuals
out of California.
I have research that documents this.
And so going back to a time
where we had lower tax rates, a broader base,
and where we actually held public services accountable
for delivering results,
as opposed to just kind of, you know,
throwing money at things, right?
We've grown public spending in California
very, very dramatically by around 70% just since 2019.
And if you-
70%?
70% just since 2019.
If you walk around and talk to people,
do you think your services are 70% better
than they were in 2019?
You know, nobody would say that they are.
And so in order to get back
to a more prosperous California,
to make sure that our future
is one of growth and prosperity,
we need to return to a regime
that has a more rational approach to public services,
to school and healthcare in particular,
to ensuring that these entities
are actually delivering on services
that are serving the people.
Going along with that to reduce taxes.
Also, there's a lot of regulatory burden on companies here,
what they can do, what they can't do,
and regulatory burdens on things
like the construction of housing.
You know, we all know housing is very, very expensive.
Sometimes people like to scapegoat
the billionaires for that too.
I'm sorry, you know,
they're actually not responsible for that.
The people responsible for that
are the state and local government entities
that make it so that it is very, very prohibitive,
prohibitively expensive and problematic
to build new housing in this state.
You mentioned that the spending,
the government spending is up 70%.
The population hasn't grown in California.
Where is the money going?
Well, the money, a lot of it has actually gone to Medi-Cal,
so California's version of Medicaid,
and going to public education as well.
So even though the spending on these things
has grown a lot,
the populations that are being served by them
have not grown nearly as much.
Under Medi-Cal, the population that is being served
has actually increased.
You know, we're covering more people under Medicaid
than we were before 2019,
but we're also spending a lot more,
not only because of medical cost inflation,
we're also spending just above and beyond
per enrollee in Medicaid.
And it's unclear where exactly the costs are going.
There've been a lot of investigative journalists
who have been uncovering fraud in these programs.
I think that probably plays a very large role.
And as for education,
you know, we're seeing more and more money
going towards education,
but we're not seeing greater satisfaction
with education or better educational outcomes.
In fact, we're seeing worse educational outcomes
on testing.
We're seeing a lot of money
going to actually plug gaps
in pension promises to public employees.
You know, that's a topic that's a big deal.
School employees, teachers,
and other school employees are promised pensions,
monthly retirement checks when they retire.
Not enough money was set aside in the past
to cover those.
So a lot of the additional money
that we're spending is actually money
that's being contributed to those pension funds.
Is it fixed now?
Do we have enough money for the pensions?
Unfortunately, it's not fixed.
We seem to keep shoveling more in,
but it's a problem that sort of keeps
running farther and farther away from us.
The challenge is that the way that we budget for this
sort of automatically builds in
a lot of growth in both asset values
and in public resources that we're going to have.
And so we've been able to do that due to,
you know, the stock market's been going up a lot
and there have been increases in revenue
at the state levels.
We've been able to continue to contribute more and more,
but the system is such that if that growth
slows down or stops, we're in deep, deep trouble.
In terms of the pensions,
the reason it's difficult,
it's because they're guaranteed, right?
And you have to give guaranteed money out,
but then when you're investing,
you're not sure you're going to get
that amount of return, right?
Is that how it works?
Exactly.
Let's take our big step back
and just compare this arrangement
that public employees have
to those that, you know,
most of your viewers will have,
which is the standard 401k type of arrangement
defined contribution plan,
where, you know,
you put money into a retirement account,
your employer puts money into a retirement account,
you know, the individual is in charge
of investing that money.
And then, you know, when they retire,
they take distributions from that retirement account
or they can buy an annuity with the funds
and that's how they fund their retirement.
Okay, state and local government employees
are operating in a totally different system.
And the way that system works
is that the state or local government
that employs them promises them
a monthly retirement check
when they retire at a given retirement age.
And these retirement ages
are still in some places pretty young,
like in the early 50s,
but many state and local governments
have moved towards more normal retirement ages
that are more closely aligned
with social security, you know,
early 60s or mid 60s.
Social security is now 67.
So monthly retirement checks.
Now, if the government didn't plan at all,
didn't budget at all for that,
then they would be in deep, deep trouble
when the person retired
because the person will retire and they say,
well, where are we going to get the money?
So the good news is that they do some planning
and the planning is that they contribute money
to a big pension fund.
It's a big account.
They're contributing money to a big fund
like CalPERS,
the California Public Employee Retirement System.
And that money,
which is very substantial, by the way,
I mean, CalPERS is over half a trillion dollars.
That money is invested in stocks and bonds
and private equity with the target
or the hope of having enough money
to pay the pension when the school teacher
or the public safety official retires.
So that's basically how it works.
Now, the budgeting for this is done in such a way
that they ask themselves,
all right, well, how much do we have to set aside today?
And the way that they do that is they say,
we're going to assume that the money
that we're going to set aside
will earn a return of usually around
seven and a half percent per year.
That means it will double roughly every nine years.
And we're going to budget based on that assumption.
We're going to put enough money into the pension fund
so that if it does that,
then we'll be in good shape.
We'll have enough money.
So what could possibly go wrong?
Well, what could go wrong would be
that they might not achieve the seven and a half percent return.
That's one thing.
Or they might not contribute enough money to the fund.
That's the other thing that could go wrong.
A third thing that could go wrong,
and it actually happened in California,
is that they could look at the pension fund
and think based on this assumption
of seven and a half percent return,
we think we're doing pretty well.
And so we're going to increase the benefits even more.
And so all of those problems and challenges
have kind of intersected.
We've actually had a pretty great 15 years
in the stock market.
The stock market is up by over seven times
over the last 15 years.
What's remarkable is that the financial condition
of the pension funds hasn't really improved that much.
Many of them are still very, very underfunded.
They don't have enough resources even under this.
It's because they were starting from a point
where they weren't well-funded.
They also granted additional benefits
and they didn't continue to make contributions
in a very steady or stable way.
Despite the fact that the markets
have gone up significantly.
Despite the fact that the markets
have gone up significantly,
the condition of these funds is still not strong enough.
And other factors, the benefits have just grown
more quickly than the actuaries,
the sort of insurance mathematicians
who do the calculations and projections
of how much the pensions are going to be on.
They've increased more than those people had thought,
in part because people have been living longer,
you have more longevity,
so that makes it more expensive.
And so all of these things together,
what do they mean?
What does this actually mean?
The implication and the conclusion
is that we now have to come up
with ever more money every year
to sort of shovel into the pension funds.
And that's money that could be used for other things.
It could be used to return money to taxpayers,
could be used to-
For services.
For services, for health or for schools.
Josh, you've been studying a lot of numbers in the state.
What do you want to tell Californians?
Where are the areas that Californians
need to pay attention to
in terms of the spendings of the cities
and the communities?
What are the things you would point them to see?
Well, I would encourage all of your viewers
who are interested in these issues
to get involved at the local level,
first of all, particularly in school districts,
to look at where the money is actually going,
where it's actually being spent,
and whether it's, in fact,
improving educational outcomes
and how to make sure
that the money is actually being directed
in ways that improve outcomes.
The only way to do that
is to have accountability
at all levels of government.
But the place that people can start,
if your viewers are sitting at home asking,
what can I do?
The place to start is actually
your local school board,
your local city council
is another very important place
because those local city councils,
they do a lot of the determination
of what housing is going to get built,
what, you know,
what new building is going to occur,
what businesses are allowed to open,
and to really think about,
you know, gee, in the long run,
what is important for our state's prosperity?
It's that we have plentiful housing.
It's that we have businesses
who want to be here.
It's not that we think about
how can we find ways to,
you know, extract a few more dollars
from billionaires
who will leave the state anyway.
And so I would say
those are the places to really look
and also to ask seriously,
whether, you know,
given the increase in spending
that we've had at the state level
on Medi-Cal,
on the state-provided Medicaid
for lower-income individuals,
you know, is this really going
to improving outcomes for people?
Or is the story that I'm being told
one that's actually not really accurate?
Josh Rao,
Professor of Economics at Stanford.
It was great to have you
on California Insider.
Thank you.
Thank you, CIMAC.
Great to be on the show.
Tell us what you think about wealth tax
in California.
Make sure to email us
at cimac.californiasider.com
or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm CIMAC Korami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.