Stocks are crowded, overvalued, and increasingly difficult to justify by historical standards. In this video, GoldSilver breaks down why that matters — and why gold may continue outperforming stocks from here.
From record household exposure to equities, to extreme valuation readings, to long-term gold-vs-stock market ratios, the setup may be pointing to a major shift. Gold has already outperformed stocks in real terms over long periods — and this cycle may be far from over. In this video, you’ll learn:
Why US household stock exposure is now at a historic extreme What the Buffett Indicator may be signaling right now Why gold has already outperformed stocks in gold terms Why the next major move could favor gold over equities What the latest long-term gold-to-stock ratios may be telling us now If stocks are more crowded than ever, this is why gold deserves a closer look.
Something that keeps me awake at night? A so-called boomer panic where every heavily
leveraged American rushes for the exit due to a severe market correction. This leads to a
liquidity flush and panic capitulation on a scale we have never seen before. Never.
That tweet comes to us from Thierry from RV and he's got another tweet here.
One of the scariest charts in markets right now,
US households have 52% of their financial assets in equities. That's the highest level ever
recorded. Higher than the dot-com peak, higher than 2007, higher than any point in the last
65 years. Cash 15%, debt 14%. This is not just a portfolio choice. This is the entire American
household balance sheet levered to the stock market. Very important point. When 52% of
household wealth is in equities, a 20% market correction doesn't just hurt portfolios,
it hits consumer confidence, it hits spending, it hits the economy. The feedback loop runs both
ways. And right now the most crowded trade in history is everyone owning stocks at the same
time. So yeah, not sure if it's the most crowded trade in history. I guess it depends how you
measure it, but it's still a very crowded trade. And you can see on the chart here,
up at 52%, this is higher than any of those previous peaks. Are we in a bubble? I mean,
to me, obviously, yes, we are, but only hindsight will be able to prove it.
And you can see how low cash and debt are here. Cash is almost at the lowest level ever. I mean,
there's been a few times where it's been roughly this low. So you might say it's tied for the
lowest. And debt has been lower before, but that was a much different era back then. So
there is a downward trend in the amount of debt being held and a huge upward trend in equity.
This is just absolutely unsustainable. And when you think about it, this can, in my mind, really
only end two ways. I guess it could unwind slowly and gradually, but history shows that that is
probably not the case. It's probably going to be ugly. And there's really two ways it can go.
There can be something super unexpected that causes a massive crash and absolute chaos. I
don't think that's going to happen. I think more likely the administration, whoever the
administration is at any given time, is strongly incentivized to create more currency and make
sure they boost the nominal value of the stock market just to make it seem like it's not crashing
in nominal terms. There's a huge, huge, huge incentive to do that. And the consequence of
doing that, obviously, when you create a ton of currency, is you inflate the value of all assets,
not just the ones you're targeting. So I think all of that currency creation
will go into other asset classes like precious metals. That's what we've seen for the last 25
years. And we're about to see in just a second. But first, let me show you just how overvalued
the stock market is. We have a tweet now from Global Markets Investor. The U.S. stock market
has never been this overvalued. And we're looking at the Buffett indicator. The Buffett indicator,
which measures total corporate equities relative to GDP, rose to 232 percent, the highest level in
history. Look at this on the chart here. 232 percent. Again, the highest level in history,
even if you use this trend line sloping upward, which I find illogical and inappropriate for a
chart like this. But let's leave that aside. Let's pretend it fits and it should be there.
OK, fine. Even with an upward sloping trend line, we're still at a level that is a record
high above that trend line. So if you take the peaks here and measure just how far it
would be from the trend line, we are at an all time record high. Why is this significant?
Basically, because we're looking at the relative size of companies compared to the economy,
GDP. And you would think that as the economy grows and GDP grows, the size of companies grows
in proportion. You know, they go together. So if we look at a ratio between them, it should
oscillate within a fairly predictable range. Now, in my opinion, this range or ratio shouldn't grow
over time. Some people say that as globalization happens, of course, companies get bigger.
And I say, yeah, of course they do. But GDP also grows, right? Globalization means you're trading
with each other. GDP is growing for all the countries involved and the companies get bigger.
But as a ratio, it should stay relatively stable, oscillating within a flat range.
So even if you say, no, it should grow over time, which makes no sense to me,
we're still at an all time record high, which suggests that the valuations of companies
is overblown. It's just way too high and it should come back down even with nothing else changing.
And something very peculiar is happening with the stock market right now. We have a tweet here from
By the way, that's three alert emojis in a row. Is this like the most overused emoji? Okay,
anyways. We are in the middle of a war and the S&P 500 is about to hit a new all time high.
Yes. When the war started, the S&P 500 crashed 8.5%, wiping out over $5 trillion from its market
cap. And now from the bottom on March 31st, it is up almost 10%, adding 6 trillion back.
And the strangest thing is the war is not over. Negotiations have failed. The U.S. blockade of
Iranian ports is active. Oil is still at 93. Inflation just jumped to 3.3% in March, the
highest reading in nearly two years. The Fed cannot cut rates. So the Fed is going to be in
a bit of a pickle here. Yet the S&P 500 is just 1% away from a new all time high. By the way,
this tweet came last week and we now have made that new all time high. So looking at the chart
here, you can see that when the war started, we lost 8.5% in 31 days, but then we recovered it
in about 21 days. So if you continue this chart here from the 14 days that it has plus another
seven, we're actually up above the white line from the previous all time high. We've made a
new all time high basically at the top of the chart, right around 71.20. We're pretty much
off the chart. And this is very unusual for the stock market to recover such a loss quicker than
the loss actually occurred. Normally it goes the other way. Normally the loss has happened very
quick and then it's a slow climb up the stairs to get back to where it was. So this is a little
suspicious to say the least. I mean, I'm not pointing any figures or making accusations.
It's just weird. As I mentioned a moment ago, there is a huge incentive for the current
administration, whichever administration that is, to make sure that the price of the stock market
does not fall in nominal terms. That pretty much goes against their agenda, whatever their agenda
may be. So I don't know if that's what's going on here, but if it is, you got to keep in mind
that nobody can control all the markets all the time. So there are unintended consequences,
there are spillover effects. And even if that's not going on, even if everything is totally above
board, you can see that for the last many, many years, the stock market has not been the best
performing asset class. Precious metals have outshined dramatically. So let's look at that next.
We have a tweet here from Luke Groman. Since the bottom in the S&P 500 in the third quarter of 2002,
the S&P 500 total return in the blue line is up 1150%. But that same series priced in gold,
the red line, is down, down 17%. So look at this. So you think the S&P 500, including dividends,
is doing stellar, up 1150%. Yeah, not bad, of course. But when you price it in gold,
it's actually down, meaning gold has been better than the stock market, including dividends,
including no taxes on your dividends, since 2002. So yeah, so I don't know how much manipulation
is going on. It's not zero, right? There's some, but it's not 100%, somewhere in between zero and
100%. However much manipulation is going on in both of these markets, gold has still managed
to outperform the S&P 500. And I expect that trend to continue, which I'm about to show next.
Here is a chart of the Dow Gold Ratio, also the S&P Gold Ratio overlaid on top of it.
So Dow Gold in dark blue and S&P Gold in light blue. You can see they sit right on top of each
other. So they're basically indistinguishable when we zoom out like this. But what's nice is
we have the Dow going back even further, all the way to 1900. So we can see these oscillations up
and down when the stock market and gold take turns. So each asset outperforms the other
for decades at a time. And where we are right now, the Dow Gold Ratio is about 10, maybe 11.
So the Dow is around 49,000. Gold is around 4,900. So about 10 to 1, maybe 11 to 1.
And you can see that shortly before COVID, 2018, the Dow Gold Ratio was up at 22. So twice as high
as it is now. So in that time, in those eight years or so, gold has outperformed the stock
market by a factor of two. And this doesn't include dividends, but it still has outperformed.
And if you go back to roughly the year 2000, it's a factor of four. So gold has done extremely well
compared to the stock market. And if the past is going to repeat itself or rhyme with itself,
I'm expecting the Dow Gold Ratio and the S&P Gold Ratio to drop somewhere in this red oval,
possibly to the bottom, possibly to a ratio of one, so that the points on the Dow are the same
as the dollars per ounce in the price of gold. That's amazing, but it hasn't happened before.
In 1980, they were both 873 on the same day. It's kind of amazing. That could happen again.
So imagine if the price of gold had an extra zero on it. 4,900 becomes 49,000.
I don't think it'll go that high, but I think the Dow can come down and the price of gold can
come up and they could be the exact same price. So that could happen. It could take a few years
to get there and there's precedent for it. And even if it doesn't go quite that far,
even if it gets close, that still means that gold outperforms the stock market dramatically.
So it could be a factor of five, could be a factor of 10 over the next few years.
Our final chart before the meme of the day is a special treat for those of you who made it to
the end of the video. And you can see here that we're looking at gold versus the S&P 500,
a five-month TSI indicator. That is a true strength index. So basically this is a five-month
smooth, doubly smooth momentum oscillator. So it shows us trends and reversals and whether
anything is overbought or oversold. So we're basically comparing gold versus the stock market
as we have in other charts in this video. And you can see there's four signals here that are
the same. Basically the red line and the blue line cross over each other. And the four boxes
here are all labeled the same way. During these eras, precious metals, commodities, energy, oil
are in a bull era. And then during the white space, it inverts. So stocks do better and then
they take turns and it goes back and forth. And you can see right now we just had the fourth signal
in a hundred years. Again, precious metals, commodities, energy, oil, bull era. So in those
eras, precious metals and these others outperform stock markets each time and gain hundreds of
percent. So very big move. And this comes to us, by the way, from Kevin of North Star Bad Charts.
Thank you, Kevin. And he says, congratulations, you're living through the fourth signal in a
Don't mess it up by listening to fairytale narratives.
What might those fairytale narratives be? The economy is good. The war is over, right? Peace
talks are working. The stock market is the best place to put your money. Currency? I don't think
so. And that leads us to the meme of the day. Spongebob, imagine if the stock market really was
the best investment. Thanks for watching.