Gold Is Getting Crushed—Is This The Start Of A Bigger Downturn? | Jeff Christian

Financial Freedom
10 followers
#finance
#financement
0:00 - Gold, Yields & Recession
3:53 - Recession Outlook
5:53 - Iran & Energy
7:24 - 5% Treasury Yields
11:16 - Real Rates & Risk
13:43 - Dollar vs. Gold
16:41 - Gold’s Selloff
20:21 - Central Bank Buying
27:39 - Gold Demand
31:19 - Gold Bull Market
33:01 - Fed Rate Hikes
39:10 - Economic Weakness
44:36 - Rate Hike Cycle
45:03 - What Breaks Next
AI Generated·May contain errors
We haven't seen this kind of risk, risky environment politically and economically since World War II.
So you're looking at unprecedented modern time risks and uncertainties when things are really risky.
The three assets, the two assets that people run to are the U.S. dollar and gold.
With oil prices pushing back near $100 a barrel, the U.S. 10-year and the 30-year, the long end of the yield curve have been going up.
The 10-year is now the highest since 2007. The 30-year is now the highest since 2004.
Gold has fallen 12% since the end of August.
And that has a lot of precious metals investors worried that the bull market, the secular bull market is finally at an end,
especially if the long end of the yield curve continues to go up.
Jeff Christian, managing partner of the CPM Group, is here to give us his outlook and give us an update.
Welcome back to the show, Jeff.
It's good to be back with you, David.
Importantly, the yield curve, the 10-year minus the 2-year, is flattening.
Now, the 10-year minus the 3-month is actually steepening,
but some people might look at the 10-year minus the 2-year and say,
well, that's been a pretty accurate recession indicator.
Let me just pull up this chart from the FredGraph.
So this is St. Louis Fed.
Now, like I mentioned, the 10-year minus the 3-month, which is the blue line here, is actually steepening.
The red line, however, the 10-year minus the 2-year is flattening.
Now, if you were to just look at the 10-year minus the 2-year in isolation and see this flattening pattern,
would you be worried that it's predicting a slowdown in the economy?
Because it has done so in pretty much every single instance that has flattened to zero and then subsequently inverted.
I think it's an indicator of weakening economic activity in the economy, obviously.
But I am not particularly worried, and I have been someone who has in the past cautioned folks
that just because you get a flattening of the yield curve or even a negative yield curve,
it's not necessarily a precursor of a recession.
And I was very vociferous about that in the period 2023-2024, which, as you can see on this chart,
there is a massive inverted yield curve.
And a lot of gold bugs kept saying, this is clearly a sign that we're about to go into a recession.
And three years down the road, we're still not there.
But if you look at it historically and you look at the chart, oh, yeah, it looks quite obvious.
But then you break it down into the data.
And the negative yield curve has predicted the relationship between a negative yield curve emerging and a recession
has ranged from like 24 months before that or 48 months before that and 12 months after a recession.
So it's not a particularly good predictor, despite what people say.
I know people like to find simplistic things like the yield curve flattening or going negative
or the gold-silver ratio or the 50-day moving average.
It's not that good of a predictor in reality.
But it is a clear indication that reinforces all the other data that we're seeing
that says that there are growing weaknesses in the North American economies as well as the global economies.
So it ties in with what you've seen in housing and auto sales and other sectors,
business equipment orders and things like that.
Are you still expecting a recession by 2027?
We're still expecting a recession at some point.
We've become much more cautious about it.
Obviously, the recession hasn't emerged as soon as we thought it would.
And what our view is now is that, yes, we probably will have a recession sometime between now and 2028,
so possibly emerging in 2027.
But I'll get back to that timing in a second.
And if we do see a recession, it could be less drastic and dramatic.
It could be less deep of a recession than we had earlier been predicting.
Now, the reason why we are less pessimistic about the nature of a recession
and more cautious about the timing is because it's very heavily dependent on a whole host of factors
that are present in the economy and in the financial system and the political system,
but they haven't emerged.
And it's not clear exactly how financial trends like inverting yield curves or flattening yield curves
and other factors come together to affect the real economy.
So I think that we are in uncharted territories to some extent.
And I think you have to be much more cautious about using historic norms to say,
oh, it's clear that this is going to happen going forward, because I think the times have changed
and the old rules may not apply as they did in the past.
I remember speaking to you at the end of 2025,
and you had said CPM Group had written that there would be a slowdown at some point, possibly in 2027.
I wonder why the Iran war has not accelerated that outlook.
I think it may have accelerated it somewhat from what we had thought in the interim between the end of 2025 and now.
The reality is that the Iran war is not as drastic as a lot of people had thought it could be or would be.
We have seen the global petroleum industry for all of the facts that we have, in fact,
lost oil and natural gas exports from the Gulf region, as well as from Russia.
We still have a global energy market and industry that is coping.
So if you go back to, say, March, people were predicting that various regions like Asia and Europe would run out of jet fuel by May.
Well, we're into the end of September, and those jets are still flying.
They've cut back some, but the jet fuel is still there.
The reality is that the energy supplies are much more distributed than they used to be.
And so there has been a greater capacity to compensate for the interruptions from the Gulf and from Russia
than you might have thought had you not realized that the energy supplies are much more diversified.
Right now, people are really concerned about the Tangier exceeding 5%.
But like you pointed out in a recent presentation on the CPM Group channel, the 5% level at the Tangier just signals normalization back to historic averages.
Probably not even a historic average level yet.
So why all the concern in the marketplace, Jeff?
Since I don't have that concern, it's hard for me to explain why people are...
Well, why aren't you concerned?
I'm not concerned in terms of high interest rates derailing the long-term secular gold bull market and silver bull markets.
I'm not so concerned because of a couple of things.
First off is that you have to understand why interest rates are rising.
Interest rates are not rising because the world is running on all cylinders and we have 85% capacity utilization in North American industry.
And interest rates are not rising because there are a lot of real economic strengths.
Interest rates are rising because we have higher inflation.
We have massive growth in not only federal debt, federal government debt in the United States, various Western European countries and other countries in Japan.
We have also massive increases in corporate debt and consumer debt.
So it's sovereign corporate and consumer debt that is rising.
And the inflationary pressures which extend beyond the Iran-US war, all of those bad things are pushing interest rates up.
And that means to us that insofar as higher interest rates might be negative for gold investment demand and investment prices and gold prices,
the factors causing the interest rates to rise are more positive for gold and far outweigh the increase in interest rates.
In addition to that, 5% nominal interest rates with 3.4% inflation is really just like 1.6% real interest rates.
That's not all that thrilling for an investor to say, whoo, I can lock in 1.4% real returns.
They typically wait to see 3% or higher real returns before they start saying, I don't need to keep buying gold.
Before we continue with the video, let's talk about a company that's building serious gold leverage for the long term.
Our sponsor today, Stellar Gold, is sitting on three major Canadian projects.
Tower and Colomac are among the largest undeveloped gold sites in the country.
The Tower project alone could be worth $2.5 billion after tax at a $3,200 gold price assumption.
And if prices go higher, so does its value.
Colomac spans over 1,000 square kilometers of greenstone deposits and could be Canada's next big gold camp.
They also have Hollinger Tailings, a cleanup project that could deliver near term cash flow.
Across all projects, they've drilled over 16 million ounces of gold, which would cost over $2 billion to replicate today.
With a seasoned team, Stellar Gold is one company to watch.
Scan the QR code here on screen or visit StellarGold.com slash David Lin to learn more.
Well, perhaps it's the direction of the real interest rate that has some gold investors spooked and caused this 12% sell off.
Do you think that this is the 10-year real interest rate here from the St. Louis Fed?
Know that it's based on expected future inflation expectations.
Actually, not an if, but what do you think is going to happen to this chart in particular?
Do you think the 10-year real yield is going to continue to go up?
Yeah, I look at the actual inflation figures when I'm calculating real interest rates,
because inflation expectations, generally speaking, are not well correlated with what actually happens to inflation.
You saw this back in 1982 when the gold price rose from $280 to $500 in about six months,
because inflation expectations were rising very sharply.
Inflation actually wasn't rising at that point, and actually shortly after that,
entered into this massive long-term secular decline in inflation rates that went from 1983 into about two or three years ago.
So I don't necessarily look at real rates in terms of inflation expectations.
I look at it in terms of actual inflation.
I think that there's a tremendous amount of anxiety.
I know, I'm sorry.
I know there's a tremendous amount of anxiety in financial markets,
and people are looking at risks that they haven't seen, they've never seen,
because we haven't seen this kind of risky environment politically and economically since World War II.
So you're looking at unprecedented modern-time risks and uncertainties,
and that's creating a tremendous amount of anxiety.
And those people who were talking about deflation two years ago are now talking about inflation,
and they're talking about interest rates that are going to rise.
If you do look at the actual interest rate, short rates have been relatively flat on a nominal basis,
and real rates have been rising, but they're still relatively low compared to where they were prior to 2007.
What about the argument that as interest rates rise,
capital will flow into the U.S. dollar and dollar-adjacent securities,
thus pushing up the DXY, which may be negative for gold?
The idea that money would flow into the treasuries because interest rates are rising in the United States is nothing remarkable.
I know that some people in the gold market think it's like genius.
It's actually economics 101.
The U.S. Treasury has one of the best credit ratings in the world.
It used to be considered risk-free and used as the risk-free denominator for interest rates and other financial assets.
It's not exactly risk-free, but it has some of the lowest rate.
So it's only perfectly natural that as the whole world gyrates to a period of weaker economic growth,
higher inflation, and increased financial, economic, and political uncertainty,
that money would be shifting into the least riskiest assets, which are U.S. Treasuries.
That's completely normal, and it should be expected.
Now, insofar as that shift drives the dollar up, that's also pretty much normal.
But then when you start saying, well, the dollar rising, interest rates rising, this all is negative for gold,
the answer is actually, based on theory and on empirical evidence over the last 60 years, it is potentially negative for gold.
You have seen periods of time, and perhaps the best historical view is the period 1978 to 1980,
where interest rates were rising, the dollar was rising, and gold was rising, 1979 in particular, in particular the fourth quarter.
And I know people that I was unfortunately had to deal with in 1979, 1980, who kept saying to me,
Jeff, the dollar and gold can't rise at the same time.
And my response was, yes, but they are.
So I'm less concerned about the dollar rising being a negative for investor interest in gold,
because when you get down to the basics, when things are really risky,
the two assets that people run to are the U.S. dollar and gold.
Sometimes they run just to the dollar, and gold suffers.
Sometimes they run to gold, and the dollar suffers.
And sometimes they run to both.
And I'm not surprised that over the last several years they've been running to both,
and I wouldn't be surprised if they continue to run to both over the next several years.
As we're speaking today on the 28th of September, gold is down 3.5%, which is a huge intraday move.
Whenever you see increased volatility and the size of the moves in gold pickup
and the frequency of gold moving more than 2% on the way up or on the way down pickup,
what does that tell you about the gold market?
Well, it tells you that there are a lot more players in the gold market,
that they're focusing much more on gold because they're more concerned about the risks and uncertainties that they're facing.
And as you say, it's going both ways.
And it's very ironic that, as you say, gold prices fell sharply.
They're off $150 from Friday's close as we speak,
and most of that came in Asian and European markets overnight for North American markets.
It's not just gold. It's gold, silver, platinum, palladium, copper, the stock market.
There's been a wide sell-off, and it clearly relates to, A, the rise in the 10-year yield,
expectations of further interest rate rises,
and increased expectations that the US-Iran war is not going to be settled anytime soon,
and it could grow worse, which could further negatively impact the entire economic environment globally.
So I think that coming out of UN week and listening to Mr. Trump spout at the UN,
and the give-and-take between the US, specifically Mr. Trump, and the Iranians,
and then listening to the give-and-take between rational congresspeople and administration people,
I think that it's not surprising to me that people are saying,
okay, I need to have some greater protection right now.
But there are people who are saying, oh, my God, the gold price has been falling since January.
It was $5,500, $5,600 then, and now it's $4,100.
It was $3,960 at the end of July, but that's beside the point.
There's a proclivity on the part of short-term pontificators right now to be negative for gold,
and that's being reflected in short-term selling.
There is also a proclivity on terms of longer-term fundamental gold investors to be bullish,
saying, okay, we're down to $4,100.
We never saw $4,100 until 11 months ago.
It was October of 2025 when the gold price shot up to $4,000.
So from a fundamental longer-term perspective, the gold market is still very much in a bull market,
and if you look at it on a quarterly average basis or an annual average basis, it's at record levels.
And there are fundamentalists who are saying, okay, yeah, I'm comfortable here.
In fact, I've been waiting for $3,800 or $3,900 or $4,000 to resume my buying, right?
And those are some of the guys that we talk to, but then there are also these other people who say,
oh, my God, it's been falling for eight months now.
Clearly, the bull market's over.
I don't think that the bull market's over.
Okay.
Let's take a look at some other variables.
Central bank buying.
This is from the World Gold Council showing net flows and purchases from central banks into this year.
Now, pay special attention to the last couple of months, Jeff.
And I want to get to your outlook on central bank buying in just a minute, but let's take a look at history here.
Do we have enough data to conclude that central banks have an immediate impact on the price of gold?
If you take a look at this chart, I can't overlay them on top of each other here, but just visually look at this.
Gross sales exceeded gross purchases in March.
I guess that's one month behind, so I guess that's February, which led to, well, maybe it led to,
but it was followed by a huge downturn in the gold price in March.
I wonder if that was the direct cause of this drawdown in the price, that central banks sold more than they bought in late February.
No, it's not.
First off, you're using World Gold Council data, and it's all messed up.
And if you look at it carefully, they don't use the term central bank gold activity anymore.
They say central banks and other institutions or something like that.
So they're throwing sovereign wealth funds and other investment in there.
So the first thing is ignore that.
The second thing is if you look at that gold price decline in March, it was the day after the Fed FOMC statement said,
hey, the economy is stronger than we thought.
Inflation is much more persistent than we thought.
We're probably going to be raising interest rates a couple times over the course of the rest of this year.
And that's when the gold price fell.
The gold price fell in reaction to the FOMC, as the market reacted to the FOMC,
indicating that they were wrong last August when they said they might be cutting rates.
Instead, they were more likely to raise rates.
That's why the gold price fell.
The second thing is if you go back to the February data on central banks,
what you saw back then was massive sales by the Russian central bank because it was running low on foreign exchange,
that it needed to pay for imports, which they pay a premium for because of sanctions.
In March and April, Trump relaxed the sanctions on Russia
and eased the ability of the Russian government and central bank to increase their foreign exchange reserves.
And they actually bought back a couple million ounces of what they had sold earlier.
If you look at just the Russian central bank gold sales, purchases and sales,
they were sellers in like, I think, 13 of the last 15 or 16 months with a big sale in February.
So then you have to take them out because they're a special case and you have to say, what about other central banks?
Well, there are about 200 central banks and about 28 of them are actually active in the gold market.
So about 15 percent of the central banks actually are active in the gold market.
Sorry, what do you mean active?
Buying or selling.
I mean, if you look at the gold market activity, we put out good data in our precious metals advisory
that doesn't include sovereign wealth funds and other people.
So it's much more accurate.
And it's based on what the central banks are saying and what the central bank regulatory bodies, the IMF and BIS, are saying.
So it's much more accurate.
And if you look at that, it's 28 banks that have been buyers so far this year.
And of those, China, Turkey, Russia coming back with 2 million ounces of purchases,
and a couple of other banks have been the big buyers.
It's really just a handful of central banks.
The other 20-some-odd central banks that have been buyers this year have been buying 2 tons, 64,000 ounces, maybe 10 tons, 600,000 ounces.
That's a big buyer for central banks.
So central bank purchasing is not as large, as high and dynamic as gold promoters would like you to believe.
For those active central banks in the gold market, do you expect above $4,000, which is what the current situation is, to weigh down on their purchasing activity?
I think that they will be more active buyers at $4,100, like we have today, or if it goes down to $4,000, or if it goes down even further.
I think there will be more active buyers at these levels than they were at $4,500, $4,700 in August.
Is there a precedent for central banks chasing momentum?
The retail crowd does it over and over again.
At $5,000, there was a lot of FOMO buying.
Was there any evidence of a lot of buying at $5,000 earlier in the year?
Historically, central banks are value investors, and they don't chase the price higher.
And when I say historically, I mean like the last five years.
But no, it's actually the last 50, 60 years.
But if you go back to 2019 to 2023, look at that period.
And from 2019 to 2021, central banks were stepping up some of their buying, not because they were chasing the price higher, but they were increasing their threshold.
Their threshold where they wanted to buy had been like $1,200 or $1,300 or $1,350.
When the price went over that, they pulled back their purchases.
And the price went to $1,600, and they pulled back from their purchases.
Then it went in early 2022 when Russia invaded Ukraine.
It went to $2,060.
It went over $2,000 for the first time.
And central banks really pulled back, and some of them were selling.
And they didn't start buying.
If you look at the Bank of China, People's Bank of China did not buy gold at that time.
They waited until November of 2022 when the price got to $1,680.
So the gold price had fallen.
That's 20% from $2,000 to $1,600.
That's 20% decline.
That's when the People's Bank of China came back in, as well as a host of other buyers, both private and other central banks.
So they have tended to be value investors.
We'll buy on the dips.
And when the price gets pushed higher, as it was in August, we'll just stand aside.
Going forward, do you expect central banks to remain a primary actor in your bullish thesis?
In other words, who do you think will drive the price higher if you're assuming that investment demand will still drive prices higher?
We see the primary actor pushing gold prices higher as private investors.
Ranging from individuals to large institutions, sovereign wealth funds, pension funds, and others.
We see them as having been the primary actors pushing gold prices up over the last quarter century,
and likely to be the primary factor pushing gold prices up in the next quarter century.
Central banks are important, and they represent at times half or a third of the stock demand, the rest being private buying.
These days, right now, central banks are probably one-sixth or one-seventh of the purchases of gold as gold as an investment or a long-term holding.
So central banks will continue to be important.
They'll represent 14% of the market or so, but they're not going to be the primary driver.
When you see large, this is just something that a lot of, where some commenters have asked me to ask.
When you see large Wall Street institutions turn bullish on gold, is that a contrarian indicator for you?
Take JP Morgan, for example.
They've been hated on by the retail crowd for all sorts of various reasons, which I don't really want to get into today.
But the key is that early in the year, they had a 6,000 year end target.
That's probably not going to happen since we're already in October.
Then later in the summer, they cut their forecast by 25%.
Now they're saying average gold price of $4,300 in the third quarter, $4,500 by Q4,
which is a significant reduction in scale reported by Who Finance here.
Anyway, what does JP Morgan turning really bullish on gold tell you?
Not just JP Morgan, by the way.
It's also Bank of America, Societe Generale, and this goes on.
My old colleagues at Goldman Sachs were doing the same thing.
These guys, generally speaking, their forecasts, generally speaking, are based on current price trends and what the charts are showing.
When the price is pointing higher, they're bullish.
When the price is pointing down, they're bearish.
We don't pay a lot of attention to their forecasts.
It's interesting when we pay attention to what they're saying, but we don't see that as particularly insightful for what's really going on in the market.
Because these guys, generally speaking, are trend followers.
When I started in the business in the 70s and 80s, you had real research departments at a number of banks and brokerage houses.
Today, they basically get their data from marketing groups like the World Gold Council that are always trying to paint a bullish picture because that's what their members want them to do, and what they read on the screen.
What they read on the screen is the self-fulfilling trend following because it's them and their colleagues at other institutions talking about, oh, yeah, the gold price is rising, therefore, it's going to get to 6,000.
Oh, wait, the gold price is falling, therefore, it's going to fall.
It's just they're trend followers.
What would change your bullish thesis?
It would have to be a massive improvement in governance.
Political governance on a global basis in the United States, in various European countries, in Russia, and in other places.
I just don't see that emerging anytime soon, so we maintain our bullishness.
But you have to see a much more responsible and intelligent governance on the part of governments around the world.
I think that is what it would take, and that then filters through.
So you see a reduction in wars.
You see an increase in international cooperation.
You see an increase in domestic political cooperation.
You need to see a reduction in debt, deficit spending, and in debt, a rational approach to economic development and to other factors.
And again, it would take a sea change in governance, and I just don't see how that emerges, at least for the next few years.
Yeah, so basically much lower geopolitical volatility.
What about the Fed?
Just going back to interest rates, but we were talking about the bond market.
Let's just zero in on the Fed funds rate.
I must recall, and I've been speaking to you for quite some time, 2022.
Let's jot our memory back to 2022.
It wasn't a good year for anything.
Stocks were down 30% in 2022.
How far did gold drop that year?
I can't remember.
Let me just…
It dropped 20%.
Yeah, about 20% as well.
If the Fed is singularly focused on fighting inflation right now, which Kevin Walsh has indicated he is, price stability remains its primary target.
He said this over and over again.
We will see the Fed funds rate probably go up even more, probably again in October.
How aggressively is the Fed going to fight this inflation?
And that's one question.
I think the second part of the question, a separate question, is if we do see more aggressive Fed, would that change your outlook on gold?
I do think that the Fed will continue to try to fight inflation.
I'm not sure how aggressive it will be over the course of the medium term.
And by that, I mean the next six months to 18 months to 24 months.
Right now, they've increased the Fed funds rate once for the first time in several years.
They increased it 25 bps.
And the financial markets have said, oh, this is the beginning of a long-term trend that's going to lead to…
…four more interest rate increases yet this year, which didn't make sense and it didn't look like it was a rational projection.
They've scaled it back ever since.
We think that the Fed will raise interest rates at least one more time, maybe two more times.
But it's going to be wholly dependent on what's happening in the economy.
And as I said earlier, you're seeing increased signs of economic weakness.
These could be exacerbated over the next six months by two political factors.
One, you're starting to see emerge now.
And that is all of those cuts in government payouts for social entitlements and other government services,
All of those cuts in the big beautiful bill were geared to come into being in the fourth quarter of 2026 and early 2027 after the congressional elections.
Now, you're starting to see some of those cutbacks now.
But over the next six to nine months, you're going to see a massive reduction in government spending in the United States.
That's going to have a major negative impact on economic activity in the United States.
That's the one factor.
The second thing is the congressional elections themselves.
And I don't see how the congressional elections, either outcome, three outcomes are possible,
and none of them look like they are going to lead to a more responsible governance.
If the Republicans win and retain control of the House and the Senate,
you're going to have more of the same problems that you've had over the last 15 months.
But you're going to have an even more intense part of it.
If the Democrats win, you're going to have investigations into virtually every Republican politician and donor.
You're going to have all kinds of regulatory investigations.
You're going to have congressional investigation as to whether or not Amazon should be broken up into two pieces.
You're probably going to have an impeachment hearings and process against the president
and possibly impeachment hearings against various other cabinet members.
They're already talking about and they've already drafted a call for impeachment investigation for Hegseth, for example.
So if the Democrats take control of the House and Senate, I think you're going to have bad governance.
If the Republicans retain control, you're going to have bad governance.
And if it remains sort of like it is now, where it is an uneasy, almost balanced situation,
you're going to have a stalemated government the way you've been having over the last 15 months.
So I don't see that the congressional elections are going to be good for the economy.
In addition to which, the Republicans have made it clear that they're going to fight tooth and nail
and they're going to push the boundaries of the Constitution beyond the boundaries of the Constitution in order to retain control.
So Speaker Johnson has said, hey, if the Democrats win majority stake in the House,
I just won't swear in the new congressional Congress people.
I don't have to swear them in.
You know, he did that with Gravalta in Arizona for like 18 months or something because he didn't want her voting.
And he said publicly, I'm going to do this. I can do this.
You know, other people have said, well, that's not constitutionally kosher.
And he said, yeah, well, you know, the Constitution is not kosher.
It's Christian. So we can cheat.
You know, I'm sorry. It just doesn't make sense.
The Republican National Committee has already prepared filings in all 50 states challenging the election outcomes.
So if they don't like the outcomes, they're going to challenge them.
And it's going to go into this extended period of navel gazing and fighting and arguing.
And that person doesn't know how to count or that person is counting in a democratic way.
So it's just going to be a nasty political environment.
And a nasty political environment is not good for the economy.
You've made an excellent case for why the economy is going to see headwinds.
Yeah. I mean, yeah. Stop growing.
I let the Fed funds rate just to illustrate the point of what they've done before in prior hiking cycles.
Let's take 2022 as an example, 500 basis points.
I think when Yellen was at the Fed, they raised by 200 basis points.
In 2003, it was from 1.1, another 450 basis points.
And so I think the question is why they've tried, why they felt it was necessary to raise by several percentage points in past rate hike cycles.
Was that what the Fed has historically determined is enough to, quote, unquote, make a difference?
And if so, then one could argue, well, they need to do the same thing again this time.
Otherwise, what's 25 basis points or even 50 basis points going to do to anything?
Well, I think you have to take it into the context of what was going on in the economy in each of those periods of time.
In 1921, 2020, in 2021, 2022, when they raised the Fed funds rate 5 percent or whatever it was.
Yeah.
You had 9 percent inflation.
You had this massive reduction in economic activity during 2020 COVID lockdown.
Then you had this massive government spending, like 1.8 trillion dollars pumped into the economy to compensate for the lost incomes during the COVID lockdown.
That then led to this massive spurt of buying, which pushed inflation up to 9 percent.
And the government at the time did absolutely nothing to counter that on a fiscal basis.
And in fact, they fueled it further.
So the Fed was sitting there saying, hey, inflation comes from fiscal policies.
Our job is supposed to be to try to balance money supply economically between inflation and employment.
But we get co-opted into this.
And as Alan Greenspan very active, aggressively said repeatedly in his Humphrey Hawkins talks, the Fed cannot fix fiscal imbalances.
The Fed can only apply Band-Aids to the bleeding that the Congress and administration caused.
Right.
So you got that.
That was that one.
In the period 2016, 2018, you had the post Great Recession financial problems that had led to this extended period of time from 2009 to 2015 of zero interest rates.
And that led to a lot of imbalances in the financial system.
And that led to, I'm trying to think of the right term to use, inappropriate expenditures on the part of large financial institutions.
Sorry to interrupt.
Do you remember in 2017?
Back in 2003, 2007, you were talking about also a large period of a speculative bubble.
So the Fed gets co-opted into setting aside its charter and saying, we have to provide the liquidity to save the economy from the ill consequences, high inflation and deflationary and recessionary or depressionary economic contractions.
We have to set aside our charter and we have to intervene on a monetary basis to try to stanch the bleeding that the fiscal inappropriate behavior causes.
And that's what happened in each of those periods of time.
If the fiscal job was being done by Congress and the administration, the Fed could focus on its charter.
That hasn't happened in a long, long time.
I recall in 2016 when the Fed started raising rates under Yellen, inflation was not very high.
In fact, cost of living was not as much of a concern in the mainstream press as it is now.
Do you remember what the Fed was looking at that prompted them to say, hey, we need to raise by 200?
The Fed was looking at very sharp increases in financial asset prices.
And if you recall back at that time, there were people who were inflation hawks who were saying, okay, inflation is not showing up in prices of goods and services.
It's showing up in the financial markets.
And again, stop and take a deep breath.
Long term interest rates are the primary factor affecting consumer spending and business investment.
Short term rates are much more of a financial instrument.
So it was that long period of time of zero or effectively zero Fed funds rates that had caused inflationary pressures in the financial markets.
And the Fed was trying to correct for that.
Bottom line, then, you don't think this is going to be another 200 basis point or 300 or 500 basis point hiking cycle?
It's possible.
I think anything is possible at this point.
Like I said, the amount of uncertainty and risk in the financial markets, in the global economy, domestic economies, and politically is greater now than it has been for 80 plus years.
Yeah, very difficult to make predictions in this environment.
So the final question would be, what indicator would you look at that would confirm that monetary policy needs to tighten a lot more or there needs to be a lot more fiscal intervention?
Or if neither of those happened, the bond market is going to step in and intervene on their own.
Yeah, I think it's a combination of factors that we're watching because it's not going to be a single factor that breaks the system.
It's not going to be a single factor that fixes the system.
So I will be watching economic activity, especially business investments, housing starts, housing prices, housing sales.
You can build all the houses you want, but if no one's buying them, that's a bad sign.
So I'm going to be looking at major sectors of the economy.
I'm also going to be looking at political international factors.
We do have this U.S.-Iran war, and it's not clear how it will be prosecuted and come to a termination or when.
I mean, it has all of the makings of the Afghan and the Iraqi incursions that the U.S. had.
This could be a very long-term negative factor for the economy.
I'm going to be watching that to see what happens.
Obviously, the congressional elections are going to be extremely important, as will be the post-election bickering and how the court system comes down.
I mean, we've seen lower courts impose the Constitution.
We've seen the administration ignore those lower court rulings.
And we've seen the Supreme Court reverse those constitutionally supported lower court rulings.
It all comes down to the Supreme Court, which clearly has been stacked by people.
And Trump has said in public, I can't believe that this guy, I appointed him and he voted against me on this.
Why did I appoint him?
So I think it's going to be a very nasty season, but it's a whole range of factors that are going to come to play.
Somebody talked about what intuition is, and they studied firefighters.
And veteran firefighters can be in a house or a building on fire, and all of a sudden they say to their colleagues, get out.
This thing's going to blow.
And they get out, and they say, what made you realize that?
We need to train the junior people.
And the guys can't verbalize it.
There's just a combination of factors, and you say, oh my God, this is it.
And I think that seasoned economists have to be in that same kind of position.
You're not going to see one indicator that you're going to come in one morning and you're going to open your screens and you're going to say, oh, that's it.
Rates are going up.
It's going to be a combination of factors that come together, and you say, gee, this looks a lot like 2002, or this looks a lot like 2005.
It wouldn't just be as simple as, OK, the Iran war has reached a stalemate, and oil is not coming down below 90, or hasn't been for the last couple of months, hypothetically.
That could be one of the factors.
I don't think that in and of itself does it.
OK, very good.
You have all these people in the United States arguing about diesel supply right now, and they're completely ignorant of what's going on in the diesel market.
And you see politicians arguing about why diesel prices are so high, and they're ignoring the fact that many diesel distilleries, refineries, have been closed in the United States.
And they say, oh, well, we're exporting diesel.
We have to ban diesel exports.
But if you look at the diesel market, the exports aren't the cause for the low supplies and high prices of diesel fuel in the US market right now.
You see similar things there.
Today at 2 o'clock, as we're speaking, Trump is going to announce a multibillion-dollar program with an Indian steel company to build a steel mill in Iowa.
And it's going to be online by 2030.
Well, they don't even know where they're going to put it.
They say that it's going to cost a couple billion dollars.
The US Import-Export Bank has already given a $10 billion loan guarantee for the $2.5 billion mine.
It's just a total mess, and it has nothing to do with economic rationality.
And that's where we're at.
Yeah, that's the story.
Yeah.
Being built in Minnesota-based company owned by India's Essar Group.
Interesting.
$15 billion steel promised to be the nation's biggest.
And it's going to be built in Iowa because the Republicans who have had control of Iowa for a few decades are at risk of losing it.
Iowa used to be a perfect purple state, and it's been red for a couple decades now.
And Iowans are sort of saying, you know, you really haven't helped us in the farming industry.
Okay, let's see how that transpires.
Jeff, appreciate your insights as always.
Where do we follow you?
You follow us at www.cpmgroup.com, and we do free videos twice a week on YouTube.
Okay, we'll put the links down below, so make sure to follow the CPM Group there.
Thanks a lot, Jeff.
We look forward to it.
Thank you.
It's always a pleasure.
Thanks for watching.
Please do like and subscribe.
Follow Jeff and the CPM Group.
Links down below.
