The Brewers are shrinking

Baseball Channel
134 followers
I have a confession to make. I am short. I am a short man. Here's a photo of me and Jeff Passen
for scale. And due to what the kids call lived experiences, I have an interesting perspective,
mostly looking up, on what it means to be short or tall. Because it is a spectrum and it really
comes down to the heights of the people around you. So here's what I think it means to be short
If you, like me, are 5'7 or below, I'm 5'6 to be exact, you are so short that it's interesting,
right? It's novel and no amount of standing on your tippy toes is going to change that. You
are short and you have to accept it. If you're 5'8 to 5'9, you are still short, but it's not
interesting. People are probably slightly disrespecting you in your day-to-day life
in a way that is somewhat imperceptible to you. You ultimately lack the jester's privilege that
interesting short people like myself have. 5'10, 5'11, you're not short, you're not tall,
but you are a liar, right? You're rounding up to 6 feet most likely, whereas I myself should not
be rounding up my height at all because all I'm going to do is put myself in a less interesting
height range. 6'2 to 6'2, you are tall, but you're not tall in an interesting way. Strangers aren't
approaching you in public regularly to ask if you play basketball. You're just taller than the
large majority of people on the planet. And then 6'3 or higher, now you are tall in an interesting
way the same way I'm short in an interesting way. I know that's not the best graphic in the world,
so here's another way of looking at it just written out. But that's just my experience
with my demographic. Of course, the spectrum shifts with the population. At 5'6, I would not
be considered short if I were a woman, or Vietnamese, or a Vietnamese woman. So when it
comes to baseball, and we're talking about professional athletes, you can imagine that
they're a little bit bigger than the general population. So we're going to have to shift that
spectrum a little bit. We're going to talk about a team that is short relative to baseball players,
the incredible shrinking short kings, the Milwaukee Brewers. But first, when it comes to money,
I've never been one to formally budget or rigorously track spending. I just try not to
waste my money on stupid stuff or develop expensive tastes. So when I signed up for
this video sponsor, Rocket Money, I didn't think it would find that many opportunities to save,
and I was wrong. First of all, its subscription management feature did find the dreaded monthly
subscription you forgot all about and you don't use. It was only one, but it was $16 a month,
and I was able to cancel that subscription within the Rocket Money app with just a few taps.
There's nothing here you can't manually do on your own, but the automation saves time,
and having it all on one screen is convenient. Within minutes of signing up, the spending
tracking feature led me to a tough insight. I actually spent slightly more on dining out
and drinks in 2025 than I did groceries. So now I have a goal, right? Rebalancing those ratios.
So head to rocketmoney.com slash foolish Bailey to start your free premium trial.
You can also scan the QR code on screen or click the link below in my description.
So of course, I've pulled up the stat head and here are all the hitters from 2025 sorted by
height. And I've determined ultimately that the top 25%, the top quartile starts around six foot
three. So I'd say at about six foot three, you are tall. That includes Milwaukee brewer, Christian
Yelich. He is tall for a hitter. Corey Seager is tall. Julio Rodriguez is tall. Gunnar Henderson
is tall. I feel okay about that. They would be in sort of the tall, but not interesting range.
And of course, at the very top, you have the guys that are tall and it is very interesting from a
baseball and real life perspective. We're talking about O'Neal Cruz, very tall, six foot seven.
Aaron Judge, same height. James Wood, same height, six foot seven. So if that top 25% of MLB hitters
by height starts at six foot three, if we're saying six foot three is where tall begins for
that population, then it would make sense that the bottom 25% or so is where short begins.
And for MLB hitters in 2025, that's right around five foot 10. So Mookie Betts, we're going to say
is short. Corbin Carroll, we're going to say is short. And that feels right. Those guys feel like
they are short relative to the population given their listed heights. And of course, as you get
to the very bottom of that list, you get to the guys who are so short that it's interesting and
you get the only player in the league with the same listed height as my height, and that is Jose
Altuve at five foot six. And we can probably just put up one of those Altuve and Judge pictures to
hammer home the point. And if you want to know who is letting those short hitters cook, right,
who is letting those players five foot 10 or shorter get at least 400 plate appearances in
the 2025 season? The answer, indisputably, the Milwaukee Brewers. Keep in mind, only 22 teams
had sort of everyday hitter short representation. So not even the whole league, but the Brewers had
five short, basically everyday hitters in 2025. Isaac Collins, William Contreras, Caleb Durbin,
Sal Freelick, Joey Ortiz, no other team had more than three. And that's beautiful to me.
Another way to talk about team height is to use the median height of the lineup. And I use the
lineup here as minimum 300 plate appearances in 2025. On average, this produced about nine hitters
per team. You can see just sort of in the middle of this graph here, a lot of it is gravitating
towards about 72 inches, so approximately six feet. And indeed, six feet is the median height
for a big league hitter. At the very top of the height spectrum, we have lineups that have a
median height of 74 inches, that is six foot two. It's the Padres, it's the Phillies, it's the
Athletics, and we'll key in on these two later, but it's the Angels and the Rockies in addition to
the Baltimore Orioles. And then at the bottom of the spectrum, I think is really where it gets
interesting, because you have two teams that have a median height of five, 10 and a half. It's the
Cincinnati Reds and the Arizona Diamondbacks. I think the Diamondbacks makes a lot of sense here,
right? If you have Corbin Carroll as your 30 homer corner outfielder, that's going to really help
skew the height down. But the Reds being down here, at least if we're measuring the median,
is interesting as well, because of course, at the top of the spectrum, they have Eli De La Cruz,
who is sort of a giraffe man. But then they do have those scrappy guys as well. They do have
TJ Friedel in the lineup. They do have Matt McClain in the lineup. So overall, this is a team that
could be considered as short despite their tall shortstop, their tallstop. But of course, there's
no lineup shorter than the Milwaukee Brewers, who have a median lineup height of five foot 10,
which we now understand is short by baseball standards. And with a median lineup height of
five foot 10, the Milwaukee Brewers may face societal challenges. They may not be able to
become president. For example, look at recent presidents in this country. They are all six
footers for the most part. You'd have to go back to Jimmy Carter at five foot nine and a half
inches to find someone below the median height of the Brewers lineup, which reminds me of that
picture where why are the Carters so small and the Bidens so big? Joe looks like he's those scenes
in Elf before Buddy leaves the North Pole. I mean, seriously, if we're talking about presidents that
are close to my height personally, we'd have to go back to William McKinley. He was five foot seven.
And you know what they did to him? You know what they did to him? Cuz he was short. I mean,
everyone was shorter in McKinley's day. Look at the 1898 Boston Bean Eaters lineup. These are
the champions of the National League. They were all short, at least by today's standards.
They had to be really. They weren't supposed to be playing professional baseball back then.
They were supposed to be hunched over in the mines. Oh, did you know Marty Bergen? Yeah,
I know. Shut up. But back to the Brewers now, because this offseason, I thought they were
betraying the short king cause. It started with the trade of Isaac Collins, who is listed at five
foot eight. He was their left fielder in 2025, where he finished fourth in rookie of the year
voting. And I felt like letting go of this type of player was a betrayal of all things short
and scrappy and high motor. And I know this video is about hitters, but I also felt like
trading Freddie Peralta showed they weren't down for the cause either, because I do think Freddie
is on the short side for a pitcher. You can see this picture right here. It's him and Jacob
Mizorowski and Trevor McGill. Of course, those guys are giants, right? But I mean,
Freddie, he looks like one of us, at least with this visual. But when they traded Freddie Peralta
to the Mets, do you know what they did? They got shorter because one of the prospects they got back
in that deal was jet freaking Williams listed at five foot seven one 75. He makes Isaac Collins
look like some sort of circus freak. Jet Williams is a prospect I've always found interesting
because even though he's short, he's never really been overlooked. The Mets made him their first
round draft pick back in 2022. Like Caleb Durbin, for example, who is also listed at five foot seven
is a 14th round draft pick from a D3 school. That's not jet Williams. And Williams does
have some pop to his game. He hit 17 home runs in the upper levels of the minors last year.
The only hitters his height or shorter who have done that in the majors that are still active
are Ozzie Albies and of course, Jose Altuve. There have been six draft classes this decade,
and yet only nine players under five foot ten have been drafted in the first round.
Five foot nine Slade Caldwell in 2024, five foot nine Tommy Troy in 2023,
five eight Tamar Johnson, five seven jet Williams and five nine Drew Gilbert in 2022,
five eight Sal Freelick, five nine Khalil Watson, five nine Matt McClain in 2021,
and five nine Nick Gonzalez in 2020. And of course, Williams is the shortest of that group.
You would have to go back to 2018 Nick Madrigal to find someone his height drafted in the first
round. On the brewers side of things, I would also hate to overlook the midseason acquisition
of Andrew Vaughn. He is listed at five foot ten, which may not seem that remarkable,
but he is a first baseman and he's one of only six active major league first baseman listed
five foot ten or shorter. So I think that has also brought a lack of height to the brewers game.
Height is definitely going to be a subject in the big leagues in 2026, just because of the
introduction of the automatic ball strike challenge system, which uses height as the
basis of a bespoke strike zone for everyone. A few years ago on this very channel, I theorized
that this change would benefit players on the extreme ends of the height spectrum. So it should
help Aaron judge, but it should also help Jose Altuve. When these systems were introduced to
the minor leagues in 2023, of course, what was needed was updated, fully accurate height
measurements. And so as a result, the listed height of some of these prospects changed
significantly. This data is from Eric Langenhagen at Fangraphs. I will put the link down in the
description below, but you can see Jorge Barrosa shrunk four inches, right? He was listed at 5'9",
and then listed at 5'5". He was masquerading as 5'9", but then he became interesting short,
like me. No, Jorge Barrosa, you are my height. And then some grew, right? And in some cases,
that made sense. Ethan Salas, of course, the catching prospect for the Padres was only 17
at the time. So for him to gain three inches of height, I mean, that could have very well
just been him growing still. Because that challenge system was brought to spring training
2025, that also means some of the measurements at the big league level had to change as well.
Most notably, they affected Gavin Lux, who went from 6'2 to 5'11", Connor Wong, who went from
6'1 to 5'10", and Tucker Barnhart, who went from 5'11 to 5'8". But that's good. They should want
that. That is effectively shrinking the size of their challenge strike zone. So in a new baseball
frontier, where you now have a fully height-based, challengeable strike zone, the Milwaukee Brewers
may very well enjoy themselves. They are tiny brewers. They have tiny strike zones. To wrap
things up, I do want to go back to this guy. And I did point out when we last looked at it,
the Brewers are the shortest team, and among the tallest teams are the Rockies and the Angels.
And it got me thinking about contact, right? Taller players tend to make less contact but
hit for more power, and it's kind of the inverse for the short guys. The Brewers, of course,
are a scrappy, contact-heavy team. And so when I looked at the swinging strike rates from 2025,
I wasn't too shocked with the outcome. The Brewers had the lowest swinging strike rate in the league
at 9.2%, and the worst? Well, that was the Angels, and that was the Rockies. In conclusion, when I
sit down in a cramped airplane seat, I still have a lot of leg room.
