5 Pitchers I LIKE for 2025

Baseball Channel
134 followers
Hey. You. Dummy. Pay attention. Cuz I destroyed these picks last year. Chris Sale won NLSI
Young, Shota Imanaga was an all-star, Brian Wu had a 2.89 ERA, and Ryan Walker stole the
Giants' closer job. We don't talk about Louis Varland in this household.
Heading into 2025, the Braves are giving Grant Holmes every opportunity to break
camp as part of the rotation. It must be a disorienting reversal for someone like Holmes,
who pitched for three different organizations across 10 minor league seasons before finally
earning the opportunity to make his big league debut last year. He had all but given up starting
in the minor leagues, but the Braves let both Max Fried and Charlie Morton depart this offseason
and haven't brought anyone new into the fold. With Spencer Strider's timeline trending past
opening day, there are plenty of innings and starts up for grabs.
Holmes did start 7 games for Atlanta in 2024. He averaged under 5 innings in those outings,
but was in some ways more effective in that role than coming out of the pen.
His strikeout rate as a reliever was 21%, but as a starter it was 28% with only a 6% walk rate,
similar ratios to Zach Wheeler, albeit across a much smaller sample size.
His repertoire is admittedly weird, and the pitch grading metrics like Stuff Plus aren't
exactly electrifying. Holmes offers a lot of variation in terms of vertical movement,
just not so much horizontal movement, but his foreseam slider and curveball were all
firmly positive in terms of run value last year. So, heading into 2025, why not believe this minor
journeyman can be a major league success? It would be quite the story for the 29-year-old righty.
The Braves successfully converted Reynaldo Lopez from reliever back to starter,
and I would really like it if Grant Holmes is next.
From one pitcher with opportunity to one seemingly without it, a year ago Bobby Miller
had the world at his fingertips. Coming off an electric rookie season in 2023,
he would've been a very boring pick for Pitcher I Like because, duh, he was a former highly touted
prospect, throwing triple digit fastballs for the Dodgers, and already had a good season under his
belt. But to say he struggled in 2024 would be putting it lightly. He was dreadful. Miller
started well enough, with 11 strikeouts and 6 scoreless innings in his season debut,
but after multiple injuries and demotions to AAA, he finished with an ERA of 8.52 in 13 big league
starts. By many measures, he was the worst pitcher in Major League Baseball.
And now, coming into 2025, he is on the outside looking in on the Dodgers rotation.
Tony Gonsolin and Dustin May are back from injury, and given recent acquisitions,
it's not hard to imagine a mouthwatering 6-man rotation of Otani, Snell, Yamamoto,
Glasnow, Kershaw, and Sasaki by the end of May. No room for Bobby Miller in that case,
but the Dodgers' approach to pitching is inherently risky, excluding openers 11 pitchers
started for them last year. Injuries are all but guaranteed at some point.
Injuries are also a likely explanation for Miller's struggles. He pitched through both
knee and shoulder troubles. If he's good to go this year, then his 2024 might just be the
ultimate outlier mulligan. Buy now while the stock is low. I like Bobby Miller. He's still
a 6 foot 5, 25 year old with electric stuff. He will kick down the doors and make an opportunity
for himself. These pitchers I like are brought to you by the Foolish Baseball Patreon,
where I post monthly exclusive content, and I just posted a video exclusive for patrons,
6 bonus picks for 2025. It's in the exact same format and style as the video you're watching now,
so head on over there to see that. For a $5 a month pledge, you can get access to that,
as well as work in progress updates, just everything I'm working on. Here's mine from
early February. I also do Patreon exclusive video Q&As. They're usually an hour to an hour
and a half long, and I answer questions like John Boyce or John Boy. The next one will be
in early March, so go ahead and join and pledge. Just kind of see what's on there and decide if
you want to continue supporting what I do. Thank you very much. This is the one I'm most sure about.
I've been monitoring the situation for almost two years and had this pick earmarked since
last September. 2025 will be the year of Chris Bubich. But first, let's rewind to 2023. Bubich
was entering his fourth big league season, but had never really impressed for the Royals. His
first two starts of that year were brilliant. 13 strikeouts in 11 innings and just two runs allowed.
He looked like a completely different pitcher. But, his velocity was down in his third start,
and that ended up being his final appearance of the year as he underwent Tommy John surgery.
When he returned last July, he thankfully looked like the Bubich that was dealing before his
breakout was rudely interrupted. The Royals rotation was both effective and healthy all
throughout 2024, so Bubich came out of the bullpen, even though he was rehabbing as a
starter in the minors. He was one of the most effective relievers of the second half. He had
best XFIP of any pitcher with at least 30 innings that year, a product of his 32% K rate, 4% walk
rate, and 56% ground ball rate. The Brady Singer for Jonathan India trade has freed up a rotation
spot for an organization that suddenly appears to know exactly what they're doing when it comes to
starting pitching. Guys like Alec Marsh, Kyle Wright, and Daniel Lynch will vie for that spot,
but let's be real, it's Chris Bubich's to lose. If he's ready to go, it should be his.
And with that comes a perfect storm, the Royals' success with starters combined with Bubich's
smooth progression from Tommy John to bullpen to back in the rotation. Like, any bozo can pick
flashy prospects, but who's gonna be bold enough to tell you a 41-year-old coming off a season
shortened by back, arm, and hamstring issues is gonna surprise people? Full transparency,
Max Scherzer won't be 41 until the end of July, so this is technically his age 40 season. And
although he did lose over a tick of velocity on his fastball between 2023 and 2024, the fact that
he's a hyper-competitive future first ballot hall of famer certainly cushions the blow of picking
him for 2025. The Blue Jays certainly liked him enough to offer a $15 million one-year deal,
but he's not just going there to be the sage old veteran presence mentoring guys like Bowden
Francis, no, he's there to pitch too. Considering how brutal his 2024 season with the Rangers was,
it speaks to his still intact abilities that he finished with an ERA under 4 in 9 games started.
He had a late start due to off-season back surgery after toughing it out in the playoffs,
then dealt with thumb issues upon his return, followed by shoulder fatigue before a hamstring
strain ended his season early. And yet, some of his offerings were still as Scherzer-y as ever.
His swinging strike rate on his slider was 27%, putting him in the 98th percentile. His penchant
for pitchability remained as well, locating 48% of his pitches in the strike zone shadow,
one of the best marks among starters. It really is a good situation for Scherzer. The Blue Jays
have a solid rotation with or without him, and they've just upgraded their defense up the middle
by acquiring Andres Jimenez. I like Max Scherzer for 2025, I think he has more in the tank than
people are giving him credit for. Wait, so the Rangers traded their first baseman Nathaniel Lowe
for a reliever with a 4.22 ERA last year? It helps when that reliever in question,
Robert Garcia, has 5 years of team control left while Lowe has 2. And with a FIP of 2.38
to his 4.22 ERA, Garcia had the 6th largest differential in MLB last season among pitchers
with at least 50 innings. For Garcia, the move is appealing because he transitions from being
a 7th inning guy in Washington to a potential 9th inning role in Texas. His main competition
appears to be Chris Martin, another excellent strike-throwing reliever, but Garcia may fit the
prototypical closer role more, with his higher swinging strike rate. What I like about Garcia
is that he's able to get swings and misses in the zone, while coaxing hitters to chase
outside of it. His best performing pitch last year was his chain jump, which he threw 295 times to
righties and 0 times to lefties, though he didn't produce major splits, as both lefties and righties
had around a 600 OPS against him in 2024. His repertoire is rounded out by his 4 seam fastball
and slider, so he has a legit 3 pitch mix. And although the pitch data doesn't reveal anything
remarkable about his stuff, the video shows a deceptive delivery as Garcia keeps the ball
hidden from the batter's view for longer than most. I like Garcia to succeed in a higher leverage
role with the Rangers in 2025. Not saying he's going to be the closer right away, but there will
be save opportunities for him that might not have been there with the Nats. So there you have it,
5 pitchers I like for 2025. Bet your entire life savings on these guys doing well. This
is gambling advice. This is gambling advice, and you should lose all your life savings and blame
me.
