Does Barrel Diameter Matter Wood Baseball Bat Review

Baseball Channel
134 followers
What up, what up? Will here with the Baseball Bat Bros, and today I'm joined by JT and UH
Rainbow Warrior Ben Ziegler Nemoa, and today we are asking the age-old question,
does barrel diameter matter? And these two bats right here, if you just look at them,
look drastically different. However, they are the same wood, they are the same exact weight,
they are even the same turn model. One is the fattest legally allowed barrel that you could
ever possibly swing. This is 2.6 inches in barrel diameter, and this, same weight, same length,
same wood type and everything, is pretty much basically a skinny barrel Little League bat,
2.3 inches in barrel diameter. So basically, fat barrel, low density, tiny barrel, high density.
Let's find out which is better. So we have our massive barrel that is lower density because
it's more wood, but the same weight as this bat, our tiny barrel, which is higher density. So
basically, we're asking what matters more, surface area to hit the ball with, and just a bigger
barrel, or simply the hardest wood possible. You'll see a lot of turn models out there are marketed
as high density bats. That simply means it's a smaller barrel profile, so they use less wood,
and they can use harder, more dense wood because of that. So if I were to make this bat with this
fat of a barrel with the same hardness of birch wood as they made this bat, it would be about 34
ounces. So you have to compromise somewhere between barrel size, density, and the swing
weight of the bat. So without further ado, this is interesting. I've never seen anybody cover this.
We're going to find out which is better or if it doesn't even matter. So before we dive into our
funky bats, we're going to start with the standard version, the 2.45 inch barrel right in the medium
between the two. That should be low 90s, 95. Really good barrel, hopefully close to 100.
100.5 miles an hour. That was a good barrel. Oh, you're a 103 right there. Sweet. All right, sit on it.
Nice. Okay, 98, 385. My first home run off the mainland. Nice. Perfect barrel there. All right, really good.
102 miles an hour with a regular bat. So I'm hoping on camera you can see how
insanely different these look. Nearly half an inch difference between our big barrel and our small
barrel. We're going to start with the mega bat. Oh, it feels good. It feels like my corked bat, dude.
Okay, 102.4 with not even the hard balls yet. Everything is barrel, dude. That's crazy.
Okay, 99, 360. Sweet spot feels 10 times bigger. Actually? Actually. I'd like to weigh them.
They weigh the exact same, I promise.
They feel completely different, I'll tell you that. Oh, watch your lips. 104, 385. Yeah, that's pretty good.
Dude, honestly, I feel like I missed that low key and on that bat, wouldn't have done that.
Felt better, huh? 100%. I think that's too high here, bro. No way. Yeah, I know what you're saying, man.
98 is too high up. That's hit freaking hard. Yeah. 105.8. Is it denting? Not even that much.
This felt way better than the first bat, bro. I'm surprised. I didn't notice that it's softer,
less dense wood. It felt great. I don't know anything about exit velo difference. Feel difference?
Exit velo was about the exact same for all you guys. Feel. Let me see this. All right, this is the
Little League barrel. All right, now we got the pencil barrel right here. 2.3 inches of barrel
diameter. And what we know about this one, it should be more balanced. It should swing lighter
just because the weight is more evenly spread out throughout the bat. We don't have a big,
fat barrel on here. And because it is less wood, but the same weight, again,
it should be higher density, harder wood. It should hit the ball harder. Let's see.
All right. It's light. Whoa. It's like swinging those little training dowels. Ow. It's stiffer.
Dude, it's rigid as hell. Oh my god. It sounds good. 98. Catch a barrel.
That feel good? Yeah, that felt pretty good. All right. 96.5, 373.
There we go. Really knuckled it. 101.3. That's good. Why is the Sweet Spot that bad? 95.
That was like a little hands, but the swing felt good. Like that's peaced. I would hope
that's 102, 103. 101.7. Rain is falling in Detroit. You're swinging too fast.
Here, let's take a quick first step. It sounds right. It does sound right.
Big time off the end. Like end of the Sweet Spot. What? 96.360.
Felt a rock. 102.5. Oh man. It's not hitting harder. Was that hardball? Yes. Okay, good. I
was hitting great with this. I went to that, and I felt like I couldn't hit anymore. That was
pissing me off a little bit. Not the best review. So, dude. God, I'm disappointed in this bat. I
hate it. Watch. I'm going to hit a tank now. See, that's end. You're right. The end is money.
Crossbowly disappointing. 99.1. That said it went 371. And yeah, a higher density wood bat
should be more stiff. So, it makes sense that the lower density feels better. It's more like
hitting with select power. This is more like hitting with a wooden dowel. Go ball. Go ball.
96.345. Oh, owie. Damn. Damn. Frustrating. Like, I felt good. Let's see. 104. Yeah.
The Sweet Spot sucks. I'm so disappointed. The pop just isn't better. The pop needs to be way
better if I'm going to swing a pencil barrel, bro. Okay, let's see one here. This looks so
freaking cool. Big bat. Oh, it just crunches into it. I don't know. I don't think so. No way.
Dang, man. 98.375. It almost sounds better. 107.
105.5. Okay, last chance for this stupid bat. It's over, boys. Yeah, it's not.
I don't think it was a competition for real. 101.392. Yeah. All right, let's get you a hard
ball. Other bat. Yeah, that's back there. All right, big boy. That's not going to go,
but that felt great. That went. Dang, that's a pop up with the other bat.
That is so much more fun to hit with. 104. All right, I need to at least give this a fair shot.
God, it makes me lose confidence. All right, I'll swing as hard as I can. If I get one,
I think it'll go really far. Popped. God, holy frustrating, bro. I had the same swings that's
gone with the big barrel. That's off the skyscraper with my fat bat. I'm so disappointed. I swear to
you guys, I went into this with an open mind. My mind is not open anymore, but originally it was.
I thought that thing was going to be sick. I thought it was going to be nasty. I thought
it was going to sound so much better too. So I guess the question was, is the high density
wood noticeably hotter enough than the low density wood to where you would want to swing
this over this? I guess that's the question. Yes or no to you guys? Definitely no. There you have
it. Especially if it's birch, you can break birch bats in, get a fat barrel, low density bat. If
really strong, go ahead and get a high density bat, but get a large barrel, low density birch bat
and just break it in, hit on the same spot. And you're going to have the best of both worlds.
That's at least what we're seeing. I've seen, we were talking about this on the way here.
I've seen a study that basically claimed there was more nuance than this, but simply because
the point you're actually hitting the ball with is so small and minute that a bigger barrel
shouldn't make that much of a difference. However, I kind of, that kind of irks me because like,
if you look at a baseball being hit in slow motion, the ball kind of wraps around the bat.
So that would make me think like it really does matter. Cause like it's not just the tiny,
tiny point. The ball really kind of grabs onto the barrel. Cause right now this,
this feels harder to really square it up. Right.
